SEARCH · Search NASA
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Life cycle assessment of suspended algal cultures in outdoor open pond systems: investigating carbon utilization efficiency and CO2 sourcing
This project developed a process to convert industrial carbon dioxide (CO 2 ) emissions into high-value, sustainable products through genetically engineered algae cultivation. While traditional microalgae cultivation depends on sparging CO 2 gas through water, this method is often inefficient because much of the gas escapes into the atmosphere before the algae can consume it. To overcome this challenge, the project designed an integrated system that first uses a CO 2 to formic acid electrolyzer to convert CO 2 into water-soluble formic acid/formate, then introduces formic acid/formate into the algae pond for cultivation, which allows the algae to access and utilize nearly all of the provided carbon, greatly increasing the efficiency of carbon utilization. The project team has successfully scaled up the CO 2 to formic acid electrolyzer from lab-scale to 1000 cm² and demonstrated industrially relevant current densities with the scaled-up electrolyzers using a CO 2 source that simulates industrial CO 2 waste.
The Marine Algae Industrialization Consortium (MAGIC) works to solve pressing challenges in the commercialization of sustainable microalgae production as a feedstock for biofuel and other bioproducts.
Microalgae are often cultivated at near-neutral pH to optimize growth. However, this results in significant CO 2 loss through outgassing in open-pond cultivation systems, leading to low CO 2 utilization efficiency and higher biomass production costs. One potential solution is algal cultivation at air-CO 2 equilibrium pH, which minimizes CO 2 outgassing but may inhibit growth due to stresses at higher pH levels. In this study, we evaluated the viability of this approach by growing Picochlorum celeri and Tetraselmis striata under outdoor relevant conditions at equilibrium pH. Compared to pH 7 cultures, biomass productivity declined by 35 % for P. celeri and 57 % for T. striata. Although CO 2 outgassing could be minimized, the significant loss in productivity led to a higher overall minimum biomass selling price (MBSP). Increased ammonia toxicity at the higher pH was found to be one of the growth-limiting factors and was mitigated by reducing ammonium fertilizer concentration. This adjustment resulted in a more moderate productivity decline of 13 % (instead of 35 %) for T. striata, and consequently, a lower MBSP was achieved. These findings suggest that equilibrium pH cultivation may be a viable method for reducing CO 2 loss without significantly compromising biomass productivity. Depending on the strain, strategies to mitigate stressors, such as ammonia toxicity, may be necessary.
Membrane carbonation, the delivery of CO 2 by diffusion through non-porous hollow fiber membranes, was successfully integrated into outdoor raceways (5.6 m 2 , 900 L) and operated continuously for up to 45 days. Biomass productivity associated with membrane carbonation was similar to using traditional sparging, but the average carbon utilization efficiencies for membrane carbonation was 3-fold higher than for sparging when 100% CO 2 was delivered to both systems. Here, when the pH setpoint was 8.5, growth on ammonium bicarbonate using membrane carbonation achieved a carbon utilization efficiency of 106 ± 45% due to uptake of some carbon from bicarbonate. Using nitrate as the N source had a 78 ± 55% carbon utilization efficiency, due to dissolved inorganic carbon accumulation as the medium alkalinity increased. Lowering the pH setpoint to 8.0 created a carbon-rich environment that decreased the carbon utilization efficiency to 51 ± 27% due to CO 2 off-gassing, but it still was 3-fold higher than with sparging.
The economic viability of microalgal biofuels relies on increasing productivity in a cost-effective manner. As microalgal biomass contains > 50% carbon, a high rate of CO 2 delivery is required for high productivity, and inefficient CO 2 delivery amplifies operating costs. Membrane carbonation using non-porous hollow fiber membranes can ideally deliver CO 2 without bubble formation and high carbon transfer efficiency. Because CO 2 streams from industrial resources are not 100% CO 2 , the buildup of inert gasses can significantly lower the CO 2 delivery rate when the distal end of the membrane is closed. To overcome the buildup of inert gases, we managed the distal end of the membranes with three different approaches: fully open end, restricted bleed valve, and restricted bleed valve with pH-actuated venting. For all approaches, CO 2 was delivered to membranes ondemand based on a pH set point. Evaluating a wide range of CO 2 concentrations (10% to 100%), we found that all approaches eliminated the buildup of inert gases, could maintain target pH values and gave the same biomass productivities and carbon distributions. However, carbon transfer efficiency depended on the operation of the distal end. Fully open-end operation gave a poor carbon transfer efficiency because of excessive loss of CO 2 from the distal end. However, restricting the exit flow rate to ≤4 cm 3 /min mitigated the problems of excessive CO 2 loss, but without incurring a large loss of CO 2 -delivery flux. For the continuous cultivation, combining a restricted bleed valve with pH-actuated venting improved the carbon-transfer efficiency and -utilization efficiencies up to 85% and 67%, respectively, with a sufficient CO 2 delivery flux.
This report describes the overall findings of the research project “Integrating an Industrial Source and Commercial Algae Farm with Innovative CO 2 Transfer Membrane and Improved Strain Technologies”. The motivation and goal for this project were to increase the carbon utilization efficiency (CUE) and areal productivity for algal cultivations, thereby reducing CO 2 costs to cultivation operations and improving economics. This was achieved through a combination of enhanced delivery of inorganic carbon and improved strains of Nannochloropsis oceanica capable of higher rates of bicarbonate uptake and metabolism. The project succeeded in these goals. First, a bubble-free, membrane-based technology was developed for delivering CO 2 to cultivations, which increased the CUE from the 15-20% that is standard in the industry to more than 65%. In addition, N. oceanica was modified to express a bicarbonate transporter protein, BicA, which enabled the cells to grow more quickly. In addition, advances were made in the protein engineering of carbonic anhydrase (CA) for enhanced stability and catalytic performance, the computational fluid dynamics modeling of algal cultivation systems, and in the life-cycle assessment and technoeconomic analysis of algal production. Together, these outcomes contribute to advancing algal cultivation as an economically viable platform for production of fuels, materials, and other chemical products. The project results aid in addressing the dual challenges of reducing atmospheric CO 2 levels and achieving green energy solutions.
Abstract Oil has long been the dominant feedstock for producing fuels and chemicals, but coal, natural gas and biomass are increasingly explored alternatives 1–3 . Their conversion first generates syngas, a mixture of CO and H 2 , which is then processed further using Fischer–Tropsch (FT) chemistry. However, although commercial FT technology for fuel production is established, using it to access valuable chemicals remains challenging. A case in point is linear α-olefins (LAOs), which are important chemical intermediates obtained by ethylene oligomerization at present 4–8 . The commercial high-temperature FT process and the FT-to-olefin process under development at present both convert syngas directly to LAOs, but also generate much CO 2 waste that leads to a low carbon utilization efficiency 9–14 . The efficiency is further compromised by substantially fewer of the converted carbon atoms ending up as valuable C 5 –C 10 LAOs than are found in the C 2 –C 4 olefins that dominate the product mixtures 9–14 . Here we show that the use of the original phase-pure χ-iron carbide can minimize these syngas conversion problems: tailored and optimized for the process of FT to LAOs, this catalyst exhibits an activity at 290 °C that is 1–2 orders higher than dedicated FT-to-olefin catalysts can achieve above 320 °C (refs. 12–15 ), is stable for 200 h, and produces desired C 2 –C 10 LAOs and unwanted CO 2 with carbon-based selectivities of 51% and 9% under industrially relevant conditions. This higher catalytic performance, persisting over a wide temperature range (250–320 °C), demonstrates the potential of the system for developing a practically relevant technology.
Gas sparging is the most commonly used method for delivering CO2 to algal cultures in Open Raceway Ponds (ORPs). While this method is well-tested and effective, these systems experience large amounts of outgassing to the surrounding atmosphere and often achieve carbon utilization efficiencies (CUE) lower than 30%. With such large losses, system are overdesigned to provide CO2 gas in extreme excess, resulting in increased capital and operational expenses. This research is focused on the development, testing, and implementation of a hydrogel membrane seeded with the enzyme carbonic anhydrase and designed to convert gaseous CO2 into aqueous bicarbonate and deliver this inorganic carbon (iC) directly to the algae pond. Despite increased capital expenses for the module, bicarbonate storage tank, and added pumps and infrastructure, preliminary results suggest that the membrane module has the potential to reduce the minimum biomass selling price by 35% by significantly reducing the operational expenditure for CO2.
The goal of this project was to increase the efficiency of carbon utilization by a Synechocystis biofuel production strain in a photobioreactor system by at least 50% using a multi-pronged approach that combined the best features of both biological and physicochemical CO 2 capture technologies to: 1) increase rates and extent of CO 2 absorption into the culture medium by addition of biocompatible amine solvents and a nanobubble gas delivery system, and 2) increase cellular rates of inorganic carbon uptake and carbon fixation through genetic engineering. In addition, the project plan included evaluating the use of fermentation effluent gases as a CO 2 source and demonstrating performance under outdoor conditions in closed-pond photobioreactor systems. These combined efforts would be guided by integrated technoeconomic and life-cycle analyses. Both physicochemical CO 2 capture technologies explored proved to be successful. The amine solvent monoethanolamine (MEA) was found to be biocompatible with a Synechocystis laurate production strain. Using an adaptive evolution strategy, an MEA-tolerant laurate production strain was developed that showed significantly increased carbon utilization over the parent strain. To our knowledge this was the first time nanobubble (NB) technology had been used as a carbon delivery system for algae production and it also proved quite successful as a proof of concept. Solutions containing CO 2 nanobubbles (Nano-BG11) at concentrations significantly higher than the aqueous CO 2 concentrations achieved with gas sparging were successfully generated and characterized with regard to bubble size (nm), concentration (NB/L), and pH stability as per project plan. Growth studies proved challenging. However, once the source of a puzzling growth defect was found and remedied Synechocystis was able to grow somewhat better in Nano-BG11 than in standard BG11 medium.
The goal of this project was to develop a novel integrated direct biomass liquefaction process with improved hydrogen utilization and better carbon efficiency compared to other thermochemical conversion technologies for advanced biofuels production. Reactive catalytic fast pyrolysis, or RCFP, combines a robust hydrodeoxygenation catalyst for in situ pyrolysis in an excess of hydrogen at atmospheric (low) pressure. RCFP was developed to leverage advantages from catalytic fast pyrolysis (process simplicity and improved bio-crude quality) and biomass hydropyrolysis (enhanced hydrodeoxygenation) to produce a thermally-stable, low oxygen containing bio-crude intermediate that can be upgraded in a single conventional hydroprocessing step to produce gasoline- and diesel-range hydrocarbons. In parallel, carbon lost to the aqueous phase was recovered as renewable methane from anaerobic digestion to offset fossil carbon required to meet the hydrogen demand of the integrated process.
This study presents a comprehensive pipeline network modeling framework to estimate the CO 2 delivery cost for CO 2 utilization and geologic CO 2 storage across the United States. We developed a Python-based CO 2 pipeline transportation cost model leveraging Argonne National Laboratory’s pipeline engineering expertise and detailed natural gas transmission pipeline cost data across U.S. regions. Using existing road corridors as practical routing guides, the model designs pipeline networks that aggregate CO 2 from one or multiple sources and deliver it to selected destinations. It then minimizes the total transportation cost by optimizing pipeline diameters and incorporating booster pumps. A key contribution is the incorporation of up-to-date, region-specific cost factors with itemized components for materials, labor, miscellaneous construction expenses, and right-of-way acquisition. Results emphasize that regional variation and economies of scale associated with CO 2 pipeline costs are significant and should be explicitly accounted for in screening and planning studies. By combining realistic routing constraints with regionalized cost inputs, the model provides transparent design methodology and location-specific insights into source–destination delivery costs, including the effects of routing complexity along existing road networks. We demonstrate the model with two illustrative case studies – one for CO 2 storage and one for CO 2 utilization – in which the model designs pipeline networks spanning hundreds of miles across the states, collecting CO 2 from multiple sources and delivering it to designated endpoints while minimizing levelized cost of delivery via diameter and compression optimization. The model offers a practical, scalable approach for alternative design option screening and early-stage CO 2 transportation planning.
Global demand for methanol as both a chemical precursor and a fuel additive is rising. At the same time, numerous renewable methanol production pathways are under development, which, if commercialized, could provide significant environmental benefits over traditional methanol synthesis pathways. However, it is difficult to compare technologies at different maturity levels, with differing feedstocks, and with significant differences in overall process design. Thus, there is a need to harmonize the analyses of renewable pathways using a consistent techno-economic approach to evaluate the potential for commercialization of various pathways. This analysis uses a novel cross-comparison method to assess near-term and long-term viability of both low- and high-maturity level technologies. Furthermore, the techno-economic assessment considers cost factors critical to market acceptance combined with carbon- and energy-efficiency assessments of three renewable pathways compared with a commercial baseline. We find that biomass gasification to methanol represents a near-term viable pathway with a high technology readiness level and commercially competitive market price. If cost-reducing technological improvements can be realized and scaled up in the CO 2 electrolysis pathways, the potential for higher carbon efficiencies may help drive market adoption of these more modular, direct conversion pathways in future markets as they present an opportunity to better support global decarbonization efforts through efficient waste carbon utilization.
ABSTRACT Global transcription factors (TFs) control metabolic processes in bacteria to efficiently utilize available carbon. The orderCaldicellulosiruptoraleshas drawn interest due to the ability of its members to degrade components of lignocellulosic biomass. Regulatory reconstruction ofAnaerocellum (f. Caldicellulosiruptor) besciiidentified two major global transcription factors for xylan utilization, XynR and XylR, and the corresponding putative transcription factor binding sites. Recombinant versions of XynR (LacI family) and XylR (ROK family) were subjected to fluorescence polarization (FP) and biolayer interferometry (BLI) analysis to confirm the predicted binding sites. Four XynR sites and two XylR sites were validated, accounting for 20 of 26 genes regulated by XynR and six of seven genes regulated by XylR. Bioinformatic analysis of the individual genes controlled by the two regulators showed an inter-dependent scheme for xylan conversion; the transport of xylooligosaccharides (XOS) is dependent on XylR, while enzymes responsible for hydrolysis are controlled by both regulators. For xylose catabolism by the xylose isomerase-xylulose kinase pathway, regulation is also split, with XylR controlling xylose isomerase and XynR controlling xylokinase. The XynR/XylR regulator pair withinA. besciiis conserved in all sequenced species ofCaldicellulosiruptorales, suggesting similarities in regulating linear xylan conversion. In other xylanolytic thermophiles, XylR homologs control xylan degradation, compared to just 6 out of 26 genes forA. bescii. These results show that two separate regulatory schemes (dual repression) are coordinated byA. besciito effectively regulate the hemicellulose inventory and xylan catabolism. IMPORTANCE To take full advantage of extreme thermophiles as platform metabolic engineering microorganisms, the tools for genetic manipulation must be further developed, and strategies that exploit a better understanding of metabolic regulation need to be discerned.Anaerocellum bescii, the most studied of the extremely thermophilic fermentative anaerobic bacteria that can utilize microcrystalline cellulose, can degrade microcrystalline cellulose and hemicellulose and has been metabolically engineered to convert the resulting sugars to products such as ethanol and acetone. For xylan, in particular, two major global transcription factors (TFs), XynR and XylR, play a role in sugar metabolism, although their predicted regulatory interdependence from bioinformatics analysis has not been elucidated experimentally. Here, fluorescence polarization (FP) and biolayer interferometry (BLI) were used to explore this issue to support metabolic engineering efforts aimed at improving carbohydrate processing to industrial chemicals.
High long-term soil moisture may either stimulate or inhibit soil organic carbon (SOC) losses through changes to mineral and chemical composition, and resultant organo-mineral interactions. Yet, the trade-off between mineralization and accrual of SOC under long-term variation in unsaturated soil moisture remains uncertain. We tested the underexplored relationships between long-term soil moisture and organo-mineral chemical composition and its implications for SOC persistence in an experimental field in New York, USA, with differences in long-term mean soil volumetric water content (0–0.15 m depth) ranging from 0.40 to 0.63 (v/v) during the growing season. Long-term soil moisture across 20 subplots on four fallow plots were positively correlated with SOC (R 2 = 0.23; P = 0.019, n = 20), mineral-associated organic matter (MAOM) content (g fraction/g soil) (R 2 = 0.44; P = 0.001; n = 20) and occluded particulate organic matter (oPOM) content (R 2 = 0.18; P = 0.033; n = 20). Higher long-term soil moisture was associated with a decrease in the relative content of sodium pyrophosphate extractable Fe (R 2 = 0.33; P < 0.005; n = 20), an increase in sodium dithionite extractable Fe (R 2 = 0.44; P < 0.001; n = 20), and an increase in SOC retention by non-crystalline Al pools (R 2 = 0.51; P = 0.0002 for sodium pyrophosphate extracts, R 2 = 0.41; P = 0.0014 for hydroxylamine hydrochloride extracts; n = 20 for both). Increasing long-term soil moisture was associated with a four-fold increase in microbial biomass C (per unit SOC) and lower metabolic quotient (R 2 = 0.56, P < 0.001). MAOM fractions of high-moisture soils had lower C:N (from C:N 9.5 to 9.0, R 2 = 0.27, P = 0.011, n = 20). Consistent with decreasing C:N, increasing decomposition with increasing moisture was reflected by a 15% and 10% greater proportion of oxidized carboxylic-C to aromatic-C and O-alkyl C, respectively, as measured with 13 C NMR, and a more pronounced FTIR signature of N-containing proteinaceous compounds in high-moisture MAOM fractions, indicative of microbial metabolites and transformation products. A partial least squares regression showed that SOC content increased with greater long-term moisture (P = 0.019), pyrophosphate-extractable Al (P = 0.0001), and exchangeable Ca (P = 0.013). Here our results show that higher long-term soil moisture resulted in SOC accrual by enhancing conversion of plant inputs into microbial biomass that interacts with reactive minerals.
Abstract Background Efficient utilization of all available carbons from lignocellulosic biomass is critical for economic efficiency of a bioconversion process to produce renewable bioproducts. However, the metabolic responses that enable Pseudomonas putida to utilize mixed carbon sources to generate reducing power and polyhydroxyalkanoate (PHA) remain unclear. Previous research has mainly focused on different fermentation strategies, including the sequential feeding of xylose as the growth stage substrate and octanoic acid as the PHA-producing substrate, feeding glycerol as the sole carbon substrate, and co-feeding of lignin and glucose. This study developed a new strategy—co-feeding glycerol and lignin derivatives such as benzoate, vanillin, and vanillic acid in Pseudomonas putida KT2440—for the first time, which simultaneously improved both cell biomass and PHA production. Results Co-feeding lignin derivatives (i.e. benzoate, vanillin, and vanillic acid) and glycerol to P. putida KT2440 was shown for the first time to simultaneously increase cell dry weight (CDW) by 9.4–16.1% and PHA content by 29.0–63.2%, respectively, compared with feeding glycerol alone. GC–MS results revealed that the addition of lignin derivatives to glycerol decreased the distribution of long-chain monomers (C10 and C12) by 0.4–4.4% and increased the distribution of short-chain monomers (C6 and C8) by 0.8–3.5%. The 1 H– 13 C HMBC, 1 H– 13 C HSQC, and 1 H– 1 H COSY NMR analysis confirmed that the PHA monomers (C6–C14) were produced when glycerol was fed to the bacteria alone or together with lignin derivatives. Moreover, investigation of the glycerol/benzoate/nitrogen ratios showed that benzoate acted as an independent factor in PHA synthesis. Furthermore, 1 H, 13 C and 31 P NMR metabolite analysis and mass spectrometry-based quantitative proteomics measurements suggested that the addition of benzoate stimulated oxidative-stress responses, enhanced glycerol consumption, and altered the intracellular NAD + /NADH and NADPH/NADP + ratios by up-regulating the proteins involved in energy generation and storage processes, including the Entner–Doudoroff (ED) pathway, the reductive TCA route, trehalose degradation, fatty acid β -oxidation, and PHA biosynthesis. Conclusions This work demonstrated an effective co-carbon feeding strategy to improve PHA content/yield and convert lignin derivatives into value-added products in P. putida KT2440. Co-feeding lignin break-down products with other carbon sources, such as glycerol, has been demonstrated as an efficient way to utilize biomass to increase PHA production in P. putida KT2440. Moreover, the involvement of aromatic degradation favours further lignin utilization, and the combination of proteomics and metabolomics with NMR sheds light on the metabolic and regulatory mechanisms for cellular redox balance and potential genetic targets for a higher biomass carbon conversion efficiency.
Efficient carbon capture and utilization require strategies that minimize energy penalties of CO 2 regeneration and compression. Reactive capture and conversion (RCC) address this challenge by integrating capture with direct electrochemical conversion. Here, we show an NH3-mediated tandem RCC system that couples capture of CO 2 from simulated flue gas (10% v/v CO 2 in N 2 ) with electroreduction of NH 4 HCO 3 to CO over a Ni single-atom catalyst (Ni-SAC). Speciation modeling and capture experiments revealed that a deep CO 2 capture with C/N ratio of 0.65 was achieved using 2.5 M NH 3 from simulated flue gas. Electrolysis of the resulting NH 4 HCO 3 on the Ni- SAC delivered an 85% CO Faradaic efficiency at 100 mA/cm 2 with excellent tolerance to NH 3 /NH 4 + as confirmed by DFT calculations and ab initio molecular dynamics (AIMD) simulations. Further, the technoeconomic analysis established a levelized total cost of CO manufacturing of $25.43/kmol, gauging the practical viability. Overall, this study holds great potential to decarbonize the chemical manufacturing industry while reducing synthetic production costs.