Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “Comparative Analysis”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 19 records
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
DOE OSTI2022

Comparative Analysis of Corrinoid Profiles across Host-Associated and Environmental Samples

Vitamin B 12 (the cyanated form of cobalamin cofactors) is best known for its essential role in human health. In addition to its function in human metabolism, cobalamin also plays important roles in microbial metabolism and can impact microbial community function. Cobalamin is a member of the structurally diverse family of cofactors known as cobamides that are produced exclusively by certain prokaryotes. Cobamides are considered shared nutrients in microbial communities because the majority of bacteria that possess cobamide-dependent enzymes cannot synthesize cobamides de novo. Furthermore, different microbes have evolved metabolic specificity for particular cobamides, and therefore, the availability of cobamides in the environment is important for cobamide-dependent microbes. Determining the cobamides present in an environment of interest is essential for understanding microbial metabolic interactions. By examining the abundances of different cobamides in diverse environments, including 10 obtained in this study, we find that, contrary to its preeminence in human metabolism, cobalamin is relatively rare in many microbial habitats. Comparison of cobamide profiles of mammalian gastrointestinal samples and wood-feeding insects reveals that host-associated cobamide abundances vary and that fecal cobamide profiles differ from those of their host gastrointestinal tracts. Environmental cobamide profiles obtained from aquatic, soil, and contaminated groundwater samples reveal that the cobamide compositions of environmental samples are highly variable. As the only commercially available cobamide, cobalamin is routinely supplied during microbial culturing efforts. Furthermore, these findings suggest that cobamides specific to a given microbiome may yield greater insight into nutrient utilization and physiological processes that occur in these habitats.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2015

Comparative analysis for various redox flow batteries chemistries using a cost performance model

A robust performance-based cost model is developed for all-vanadium, iron-vanadium and iron chromium redox flow batteries. Systems aspects such as shunt current losses, pumping losses and thermal management are accounted for. The objective function, set to minimize system cost, allows determination of stack design and operating parameters such as current density, flow rate and depth of discharge (DOD). Component costs obtained from vendors are used to calculate system costs for various time frames. A 2 kW stack data was used to estimate unit energy costs and compared with model estimates for the same size electrodes. The tool has been shared with the redox flow battery community to both validate their stack data and guide future direction.

electrolyte↗
DOE OSTI2018

Comparative Analysis of Soft-Error Detection Strategies: A Case Study with Iterative Methods

Undetected soft errors caused by transient bit flips can lead to silent data corruption (SDC), an undesirable outcome where invalid results pass for valid ones. This has motivated the design of soft error detectors to minimize SDCs. However, the detectors have been studied under different contexts, making comparative evaluation difficult. In this paper, we present the first comprehensive evaluation of four online soft error detection techniques in detecting the adverse impact of soft errors on iterative methods. We observe that, across five iterative methods, the detectors studied achieve high but not perfect detection rates. To understand the potential for improved detection, we evaluate a machine-learning based detector that takes as features that are the runtime features observed by the individual detectors to arrive at their conclusions. Our evaluation demonstrates improved but still far from perfect detection accuracy for the machine learning based detectors. This extensive evaluation demonstrates the need for designing error detectors to handle the evolutionary behavior exhibited by iterative solvers.

Silent data corruption, Soft error detection, Iter↗
DOE OSTI2016

Estimation of economic impacts of cellulosic biofuel production: a comparative analysis of three biofuel pathways: Economic impacts of biofuel production

The development of a cellulosic biofuel industry utilizing domestic biomass resources is expected to create opportunities for economic growth resulting from the construction and operation of new biorefineries. We applied an economic input-output model to estimate potential economic impacts, particularly gross job growth, resulting from the construction and operation of biorefineries using three different technology pathways: 1) cellulosic ethanol via biochemical conversion in Iowa, 2) renewable diesel blendstock via biological conversion in Georgia, and 3) renewable diesel and gasoline blendstock via fast pyrolysis in Mississippi. Combining direct, indirect, and induced effects, capital investment associated with the construction of a biorefinery processing 2,000 dry metric tons of biomass per day (DMT/day) could yield between 5,960 and 8,470 full-time equivalent (FTE) jobs during the construction period. Fast pyrolysis biorefineries produce the most jobs on a project level thanks to the highest capital requirement among the three pathways. Normalized for one million dollars of capital investment, the fast pyrolysis biorefineries are estimated to yield slighter more jobs (12.1 jobs) than the renewable diesel (11.8 jobs) and the cellulosic ethanol (11.6 jobs) biorefineries. While operating biorefineries is not labor-intensive, the annual operation of a 2,000 DMT/day biorefinery could support between 720 and 970 jobs when the direct, indirect, and induced effects are considered. The major factor, which results in the variations among the three pathways, is the type of biomass feedstock used for biofuels. The agriculture/forest, services, and trade industries are the primary sectors that will benefit from the ongoing operation of biorefineries.

Biofuels↗
DOE OSTI2021

Comparative analysis of model-free and model-based HVAC control for residential demand response

In this paper, we present a comparative analysis of model-free reinforcement learning (RL) and model predictive control (MPC) approaches for intelligent control of heating, ventilation, and air-conditioning (HVAC). Deep-Q-network (DQN) is used as a candidate for model-free RL algorithm. The two control strategies were developed for residential demand-response (DR) HVAC system. We considered MPC as our golden standard to compare DQN's performance. The question we tried to answer through this work was, What % of MPC's performance can be achieved by model-free RL approach for intelligent HVAC control?. Based on our test result, RL achieved an average of ≈ 62% daily cost saving of MPC. Considering the pure optimization and model-based nature of MPC methods, the RL showed very promising performance. We believe that the interpretations derived from this comparative analysis provide useful insights to choose from various DR approaches and further enhance the performance of the RL-based methods for building energy managements.

Kurte, Kuldeep↗
DOE OSTI2015

Overview of zion comparative analysis project for assessment of Boral{sup R} neutron absorber material performance and monitoring in spent fuel pools - 14618

Neutron absorber materials are used in spent fuel pool (SFP) storage racks to control reactivity. In the United States, about half of the operating plants currently use BORAL{sup R} neutron absorber material in SFP racks. Although operational experience spanning more than 25 years has not shown any loss of the BORAL{sup R} core material, corrosion effects, including blisters and pits, have been observed and reported. To improve understanding for the behavior of BORAL{sup R} in SFPs and evaluate the performance of monitoring approaches, EPRI initiated the Zion comparative analysis project in 2014. The Zion project involves three phases. During the first phase of the project, in situ measurements were performed on selected SFP rack panels in December 2014. Panels for in situ measurements were selected after an extensive analysis of each panel in the pool to ensure that the selected panels represented the pool in terms of variation in neutron and gamma dose values. As part of the second phase of the project, the remaining 10 coupons from the Zion SFP were shipped to a Penn State University (PSU) laboratory for analysis in January 2015. During the final phase of the project, a subset of the panels for which in situ measurements were performed will be harvested from the Zion SFP, cut into samples, and analyzed at PSU. The overall scope of this project will allow comparison of in situ measurements to real panel data as well as data obtained from coupon analysis. In this paper, an overview of the Zion comparative analysis project, the criteria and procedure for panel selection for in situ measurements and harvesting, preliminary coupon analysis results and in situ measurement results are presented. (authors)

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗
DOE OSTI2025

Decarbonizing residential buildings in the United States: A comparative analysis of households and construction professionals

In this study, we present a comparative analysis of surveys distributed to home occupants and construction professionals in the U.S., focused on energy upgrades and electrification retrofits that support residential building decarbonization. The surveys were executed by separate research groups and combined for this study. The study examines the decision-making, sentiments, perceptions, experiences, and practices of both groups by analyzing data from three separate surveys. These surveys assess technologies, attitudes, awareness, motivations, barriers, and opportunities related to energy retrofits and electrification. The analysis highlights key differences in the perceptions and behaviors of households and construction professionals, revealing substantial barriers to achieving decarbonization goals. For example, households cite climate change and sustainability as key motivators for pursuing energy retrofits (89%), while construction industry professionals view these themes as less important for their clients (44%). This suggests an opportunity for the construction industry to align its messaging with the values that households prioritize, helping to advance residential decarbonization. Overall, the study identifies challenges faced by both groups, factors influencing the adoption of energy-efficient practices, and inconsistencies between occupant and construction industry professionals' views. These insights contribute to the development of targeted strategies and policies to accelerate the decarbonization of residential buildings in the U.S.

32 ENERGY CONSERVATION, CONSUMPTION, AND UTILIZATI↗
DOE OSTI2015

A comparative analysis of electronic and molecular quantum dot cellular automata

This paper presents a comparative analysis of electronic quantum-dot cellular automata (EQCA) and Magnetic quantum dot Cellular Automata (MQCA). QCA is a computing paradigm that encodes and processes information by the position of individual electrons. To enhance the high dense and ultra-low power devices, various researches have been actively carried out to find an alternative way to continue and follow Moore’s law, so called “beyond CMOS technology”. There have been several proposals for physically implementing QCA, EQCA and MQCA are the two important QCAs reported so far. This paper provides a comparative study on these two QCAs.

75 CONDENSED MATTER PHYSICS, SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND↗
DOE OSTI2023

Comparative Analysis of Standard and Advanced USL Methodologies [Slides]

This presentation is on the comparative analysis of standard and advanced USL methodologies. Each method has a different way to address/account for experimental biases and uncertainties. This study showed why bias and uncertainty predictions by these popular methods differ significantly in some cases. In order to establish confidence to our validation efforts, especially with new reactor concepts, in designing new critical experiments and claiming experimental coverage for our existing applications, we need to understand capabilities of our methods further.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗
DOE OSTI2017

Comparative analysis of the structural and morphological features of biogenic and synthesized goethite nanoparticles

A comparative analysis of the relationship between the morphological forms and magnetic properties of natural goethite particles from the crust of weathering of the Far East and Vietnam basalts and pure, chemically synthesized goethite particles was performed using Mössbauer spectroscopy, X-ray diffraction analysis, and scanning electron microscopy. It is shown how the shape of biogenic goethite particles affects their magnetic properties, which significantly differ from the magnetic properties of chemically synthesized samples.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2025

Comparative Analysis of Inter-Area Oscillations in the US Eastern and Western Interconnections

This paper presents a comparative analysis of interarea oscillations in the US Eastern and Western Interconnections using frequency disturbance data collected from the advanced wide-area Frequency Monitoring Network (FNET/GridEye), enabling us to investigate and compare the oscillation characteristics of both regions. The study analyzes the statistical data from the two interconnections, including total oscillation events, average dominant frequencies, damping ratios, and maximum amplitudes. We also explore the impact of seasonal and daily variations on oscillation occurrences and the influence of different grid topologies and operational practices. The results provide insights into both interconnections' stability and control characteristics, offering valuable information for power system operators to enhance grid stability and oscillation suppression measures.

Fu, Hao [University of Tennessee, Knoxville (UTK)]↗
DOE OSTI2020

Comparative Analysis of Capacitive Sensors with Different Geometrical layouts for Cable Insulation Degradation Detection

This paper presents a comparative analysis between an Interdigital Capacitor (IDC) sensor and a Serpentine Capacitive (SRC) sensor. The effects of electrode layouts on sensor performance are studied by means of finite element simulation where the geometrical dimensions (except electrode length) and material characteristics of both sensors are identical. Conformal IDC and SRC sensors with equal sensor area are modeled on a cable surface. The simulation results show a tradeoff between IDC and SRC sensors in terms of sensitivity and penetration depth. The SRC sensor shows 13.3% increase in sensitivity and 16.8% increase in capacitance compared to the IDC sensor, though the electric field penetration depth of the SRC sensor is 18.8% lower than the IDC sensor. In addition, the effects of change in electrode width, inter-electrode gap, and number of electrodes on SRC and IDC sensor comparative performance are evaluated.

Interdigital Capacitance, Serpentive Capacitive Se↗
DOE OSTI2015

Comparative analysis of compact heat exchangers for application as the intermediate heat exchanger for advanced nuclear reactors

A comparative evaluation of alternative compact heat exchanger designs for use as the intermediate heat exchanger in advanced nuclear reactor systems is presented in this article. Candidate heat exchangers investigated included the Printed circuit heat exchanger (PCHE) and offset strip-fin heat exchanger (OSFHE). Both these heat exchangers offer high surface area to volume ratio (a measure of compactness [m2/m3]), high thermal effectiveness, and overall low pressure drop. Helium–helium heat exchanger designs for different heat exchanger types were developed for a 600 MW thermal advanced nuclear reactor. The wavy channel PCHE with a 15° pitch angle was found to offer optimum combination of heat transfer coefficient, compactness and pressure drop as compared to other alternatives. The principles of the comparative analysis presented here will be useful for heat exchanger evaluations in other applications as well.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗