SEARCH · Search NASA
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Surface quality plays an important role in the performance of SRF cavities. We report the topographic evolution of H degassed, N and O doped Nb surfaces subjected to electropolishing using atomic force microscopy. N doped Nb shows a substantial increase in roughness due to formation of niobium nitrides into the surface. Implications of the topography on magnetic field enhancement and vortex entry are discussed.
Improving surface finishing is the critical step in the application of an additively manufactured (AM) component in high fatigue and corrosion-sensitive fields. This paper provides insights into surface properties of electropolished AM component made up of 316 stainless steel with > 6% carbon. We performed surface analysis with profilometer, scanning electron microscope, and AFM to investigate the electropolished and unpolished AM components. The first major discovery of the present work is that our optical profilometry study provided an estimate of the amount of material to be removed to achieve a shiny and smooth surface on 316 stainless steel AM part. One needs to remove more than 200 μm thick layer from the surface to make a mirror-smooth surface. Such estimation can enable researchers to incorporate requisite tolerance during the design stage itself. The second important finding of our work is that ultrasmooth microstructure on the AM surface appeared when preferential material removal occurred along the boundary of the hexagonal microscopic features. Additionally, our optical profilometry studies provided an analysis of several roughness parameters on the electropolished surface. Electropolishing was effective in reducing the surface roughness below ~ 0.1 μm RMS over microscopic regions. Observation of sub-μm RMS roughness was consistently observed with the optical profilometer, SEM, and AFM. SEM study revealed a significant change in the microstructure of the electropolished samples in a medium and highly smooth state. Here, we also conducted a water contact angle study and spectroscopic reflectance study on electropolished and unpolished AM component surfaces. Our study revealed that electropolishing is a highly promising route for improving the surface finishing of AM components.
Aluminum sheets-based mirrors are finding applicability in high-temperature solar concentrating technologies because they are cost-effective, lightweight and have high mechanical properties. Nonetheless, the reflectance percentages obtained by electropolishing are not close to the reflectance values of the currently used evaporated films. Therefore, controlling key factors affecting electropolishing processes became essential in order to achieve highly reflective aluminum surfaces. This study investigated the effect of both the electropolishing process and previous heat treatment on the total reflectance of the AA 1100 aluminum alloy. An acid electrolyte and a modified Brytal process were evaluated. Total reflectance was measured by means of UV–Vis spectrophotometry. Reflectance values higher than 80% at 600 nm were achieved for both electrolytes. Optical microscopy and scanning electron microscopy images showed uneven dissolution for the acid electropolished samples causing a reflectance drop in the 200-450 nm region. The influence of heat treatment, previously to electropolishing, was tested at two different temperatures and various holding times. It was found that reflectance increases around 15% for the heat-treated and electropolished samples versus the non-heat-treated ones. A heat treatment at low temperature combined with a short holding time was enough to improve the sample total reflectance.
Focused ion beam (FIB) milling has become the dominant approach for site-specific transmission electron microscopy (TEM) specimen preparation; however, FIB damage remains a critical limitation for reliable microstructural characterisation, particularly in radiation effects studies. Tungsten is especially susceptible to FIB damage due to its high nuclear stopping power, which promotes the formation and strong diffraction contrast of FIB-induced ‘black spot’ defects that are indistinguishable from very fine irradiation-induced loops/defects resulting from low to intermediate temperature neutron irradiation. In this work, flash electropolishing is systematically evaluated as a post-FIB treatment for minimising preparation-induced artefacts for TEM analysis of tungsten-based alloys. Using a range of non-, ion-, and neutron-irradiated tungsten materials, the effectiveness of flash electropolishing has been assessed through direct comparison with conventional FIB and plasma-FIB preparation including low-energy Ga, Ar, Xe ion cleaning. The results demonstrate that flash electropolishing effectively removes FIB-damaged layers and ‘black spot’ defects, thereby enabling reliable observation of irradiation-induced dislocation structures. Key processing parameters governing flash electropolishing quality – including lamella thickness, applied voltage, polishing duration, electrolyte chemistry, and cathode geometry – have been systematically evaluated, and clear criteria were established for determining when flash electropolishing is required to ensure reliable microstructural analysis. This work also provides practical guidance for implementing flash electropolishing as an artefact-controlled specimen-preparation approach for TEM characterisation of FIB-produced specimens. The systematic protocol can be extended to other, non-tungsten materials.
Additively manufactured (AM) components’ surface finishing is crucial in adopting them for intended applications in challenging environments involving fatigue, corrosion, high temperature, and nuclear radiation. In our prior research, chempolishing (C) was utilized as an electroless etching process that uniformly smoothens complex AM components’ accessible interior and exterior surfaces (Tyagi et al. Additive Manufacturing, 25:32–38, 22). A wide range of electropolishing (E) has been demonstrated for AM surface finishing. However, electropolishing can impact a surface that can be juxtaposed to counter electrode and can yield a very smooth surface to sub-micrometer level roughness. However, a knowledge gap exists about the impact of applying both approaches on the same surface one after another and what new advantages may arise because of combining two methods. This paper uses dual-stage liquid-based surface finishing strategies produced by alternating the chempolishing (C) and electropolishing (E) steps. Two dual-stage surface finishing approaches, i.e., chempolishing followed by electropolishing (CE) and electropolishing followed by chempolishing (EC), were performed on the 316 stainless AM steel component. Impacts of EC and CE approaches were compared with single-stage C and E surface finishing approaches. An optical microscope and mechanical profilometer were utilized to investigate the wide range of surface roughness parameters. CE and EC produced Ra ~ 1.4 µm and ~ 1.6 µm, respectively. Surface roughness on CE- and EC-treated AM samples was lower than those individually treated by C and E approaches. Scanning electron microscopy provided further insights into the microstructural difference between CE- and EC-treated AM samples. This paper reports a liquid contact angle study on CE- and EC-treated AM samples to provide insights into the relative difference in surface energy that is crucial for making coatings on AM parts. A spectroscopic reflectance study was also employed to register the difference in physical properties of AM components treated with CE and EC approaches. Further, this study reveals industrially practicable interior and exterior surface finishing approaches for complex AM metal components that require minimum tooling and real-time process monitoring.
The preparation of transmission electron microscopy (TEM) samples is a critical step in the characterization of materials, and the focused ion beam (FIB) technique is a commonly used method. However, a significant limitation of this technique is the FIB-induced damages on the foil surfaces, which can obscure the real features of interest, particularly in radiation effects studies. To overcome this limitation, this study presents a detailed description of the flash electropolishing technique, which can be used to remove the FIB damage from samples. The flash electropolishing technique has been successfully applied to a range of materials, including Fe, Fe-based model alloys, commercial Fe-Cr alloys, and advanced Fe-Cr alloys, both in their as-received and ion-irradiated states. Furthermore, the parameters used for Fe-Cr model alloys can be adjusted for commercial and advanced alloys with minimal modifications. Further, the study also examined the effects of electropolishing variables, such as perchloric acid concentration, electropolishing temperature, Cr concentration, and voltage. Qualitatively, a general trend and scoping test strategy is explored in our experiments. Overall, the flash electropolishing technique offers a promising solution to the challenges posed by FIB-induced damages in the preparation of TEM samples.
Electropolishing is used to remove material from the surface of a metal using electric potential and current. U-10Mo fuel is produced from a low enriched uranium plate alloyed with 10% molybdenum (U-10Mo). Electropolishing is being considered in two steps of the process of fabricating this U-10Mo fuel. First, it could be used as a means initially improving the surface finish of the cast plate while removing smut from the casting process from the surface prior to homogenization. Second, it could be used again after homogenization to remove oxidation and continue to improve the surface finish prior to hot rolling. The purpose of this work is to demonstrate the process on full-size ingots and optimize the process. A depleted uranium U-10Mo plate was electropolished three times: the first two times were prior to homogenization and the third after a homogenization step. The first two polishes decreased the overall roughness, as measured by laser confocal microscopy. After each polish, a smoother and shinier blue-gold surface was left on the plate. Upon homogenization, the surface had a more matte appearance and the surface roughness increased back to the pre-homogenization values obtained prior to the initial polish. After electropolishing the homogenized pieces, the changes in surface roughness increased, as measured by laser confocal microscopy. The final polishing step was not long enough to return the surface roughness to pre-homogenization conditions, implying less polishing is needed before the homogenization versus afterwards. Heat generation during the polish was addressed by circulating the electrolyte solution through an external heat exchanger; however, solubility and anodization challenges require further study.
To improve the superconducting performance of niobium SRF cavities, electropolishing (EP) with a sulfuric and hydroflouric acid mixture is used. The chemistry of this reaction is complex due to the interactions between diffusion mechanisms, surface oxide structure, and multiple chemical species. Past studies on the EP process have produced a certain set of optimum parameters that have been used successfully for a long time. However, two recent developments have called the efficacy of the existing EP process into question. Since the introduction of nitrogen doping the surface quality of some cavities has been very poor. Also, EP performed at colder than standard temperatures leads to an increase in the cavity performance. To understand these questions, we perform a multivariate study on the EP process using niobium test samples electropolished at different temperatures and potentials. We find that electropolishing at lower potentials leads to rough surface features such as pitting and grain etching. Some of the surface features show similarities to features seen in niobium cavities. The effect of electropolishing temperature is not clear based on the results of this study.
Cold electropolishing (EP) of a nitrogen-doped (N-doped) niobium (Nb) superconducting RF (SRF) cavity was found to improve its quality factor. In order to understand the effect of EP temperature on N-doped and undoped surfaces, a systematic EP study was conducted with 2/0 N-doped and heat-treated Nb samples in a beaker. The Nb samples were electropolished at different surface temperatures ranging from 0 to 42 C. The results showed that the doped surface was susceptible to the sample temperature during EP. EP resulted in the surface pitting on the doped samples where the number density of pits increased at a higher temperature. The surface results were compared with the surface of cutouts from a 9-cell cavity which was 2/0 N-doped and electropolished. This paper shows de-tailed surface features of the N-doped and undoped Nb surfaces electropolished at different temperatures.
Surface finish plays an essential role in the performance of superconducting radio frequency cavities. Several surface treatments have been developed to reduce surface resistance at a moderate accelerating gradient. We investigated the effects of sequential electropolishing on samples vacuum heat-treated at 300 and 600 °C and N-doped Nb samples using atomic force microscopy. The N-doping process precipitates niobium nitrides within grains and, most notably, continuously and deeply along some grain boundaries. Upon electropolishing, the nitrides are preferentially removed leaving behind a topographically imperfect surface marked by relatively deep holes and grooves with low radius of curvature edges. The progression of magnetic field enhancement and superheating field suppression factors upon electropolishing were investigated using atomic force micrographs. While minor changes in magnetic field enhancement and superheating field suppression factors are observed for the 300 and 600 °C heat-treated Nb, substantial improvements are observed for N-doped Nb. In this system, the most severe topographic defects are the grain boundary grooves which substantially suppress the superheating field. We find that the severity of topographic defects is related to the N-doping process.
An investigation was conducted to determine the effect of electropolishing precision-forged blades and of machining blades from oversize forgings on the engine performance of Nimonic 80 and Nimonic 80A turbine blades. These blades, along with precision-forged blades, were run in a J33-9 turbojet engine. The tests resulted in the following conclusions: (1) Electropolishing of precision-forged blades did not improve engine life relative to the life of nonelectropolished blades. (2) Machining blades from oversize forgings did not improve the engine life of precision-forged blades. (3) The precision-forging and heat-treating practice used in fabricating the blades investigated was such that the surface roughness and oxide penetration was so slight, approximately 0.0005 inch in depth, as to preclude any benefits derived from surface removal by electropolishing or machining.
Electropolishing process and cathodes have undergone modification and optimization for both low- and high-beta 650 MHz five-cell niobium cavities for PIP-II. Cavities treated with these modified electropolishing conditions exhibited smooth surfaces and good performance in baseline tests. Nonetheless, due to administrative constraints on project cavities, maximum gradient performance testing was not conducted. This paper presents a study conducted on a single-cell 650 MHz cavity utilizing the optimized electropolishing conditions, highlighting the maximum performance attained for this specific cavity. The cavity tested at 2 K in a vertical cryostat reached a superior accelerating field gradient of 53.3 MV/m at Q0 of 1.6x1010, which is the highest gradient attained for this type of large-sized cavities.
Electropolishing (EP) is the premier surface preparation method for high-Q, high-gradient superconducting RF cavities made of Nb. This leaves behind an apparently smooth surface, yet the achievable peak magnetic fields fall well below the superheating field of Nb, in most cases. Here, in this work, the ultimate surface finish of EP was investigated by studying its effect on highly polished Nb samples. EP introduces high slope angle sloped-steps at grain boundaries. The magnetic field enhancement and superheating field suppression factors associated with such a geometry are calculated in the London theory. Despite the by-eye smoothness of electropolished Nb, such defects compromise the stability of the low-loss Meissner state, likely limiting the achievable peak accelerating fields in superconducting RF cavities. Finally, the impact of surface roughness on impurity diffusion is investigated which can link surface roughness to the effectiveness of heat treatments like low-temperature baking or nitrogen infusion in the vortex nucleation or hydride hypotheses. Surface roughness tends to decrease the effective dose of impurities as a result of the expansion of impurities into regions with greater internal angle. The effective dose of impurities can be protected by minimizing slope angles and step heights, ensuring uniformity.
Surface processing of niobium superconducting RF cavities used in particle accelerators is crucial for determining their performance. The nitrogen (N)-doping method, developed at Fermilab, enhances the cavities’ quality factor by doping the cavity’s interior surface with N atoms at 800 °C. After N-doping, electropolishing (EP) is employed to remove the niobium nitride phases and attain the desired concentration of interstitial N atoms. This study explores the effects of EP conditions on N-doped niobium samples. The samples were electropolished at 5 to 40 °C and voltages between 3 and 22 V. Different EP voltage ranges produced two types of pits, classified based on their sizes. Larger pits, linked to higher voltages, are also affected by the reaction rate. Pitting could be reduced at a lower temperature and adequate EP voltage. However, to effectively minimize gas evolution forming large-sized pitting, peeling off the top nitride layer before EP might be beneficial. This was achieved through precise low-voltage etching, forming a two-step EP process. The process involves removing the top 100–200 nm layer at a low voltage, followed by standard EP to remove the required material. This two-step EP process effectively mitigated the pitting risk associated with gas evolution on N-doped surfaces.
The best performance of niobium SRF accelerating cavities is obtained with surfaces smoothed with electropolishing chemical finishing. Jefferson Lab has recently specified, procured, installed, and commissioned a new versatile production electropolishing (EP) tool. Experience with EP research and operations at JLab as well as vendor interactions and experience guided development of the system specification. Detailed design and fabrication was awarded by contract to Semiconductor Process Equipment Corporation (SPEC). The delivered system was integrated into the JLab chemroom infrastructure and commissioned in 2020. The new EP tool provides much improved heat exchange from the circulating H₂SO₄/HF electrolyte and also the cavity via variable temperature external cooling water flow, resulting in quite uniform cavity wall temperature control and thus improved removal uniformity. With the JLab infrastructure, stabilized process temperature as low as 5 C is available. We describe the system and illustrate operational modes in this contribution.
Electropolishing (EP) of 1.3 GHz niobium (Nb) superconducting RF cavities is conducted to achieve a desired smooth and contaminant-free surface that yields good RF performance. Achieving a smooth surface of a large-sized elliptical cavity with the standard EP conditions was found to be challenging. This work aimed to conduct a systematic parametric EP study to understand the effects of various EP parameters on the surface of 650 MHz cavities used in PIP-II linac. Parameters optimized in this study provided a smooth surface of the cavities. The electropolished cavities met the baseline requirement of field gradient and qualified for further surface treatment to improve the cavity quality factor.
Hydrofluoric acid (HF)-free bipolar pulsed electropolishing (BPEP) offers an environmentally sustainable alternative to conventional Buffered Chemical Polishing (BCP) and Electropolishing (EP) techniques for superconducting radiofrequency (SRF) cavities. Recent studies at Jefferson Lab have demonstrated that a single-cell 1.3 GHz niobium cavity processed using HF-free BPEP achieved an accelerating gradient Eacc of 35 MV/m with a quality factor Q0 of 1E10 at 2 K, following extensive research and optimization. This talk will highlight the challenges encountered in developing this technique, key insights gained from experimental studies, and ongoing efforts to enhance its capabilities. In particular, we will explore its potential for refining Nb3Sn-coated niobium cavities via vapor diffusion techniques and for electroplating Nb3Sn films onto various cavity substrates, contributing to the advancement of high-performance SRF systems.
Electropolishing (EP) is the premier surface preparation method for high-Q, high-gradient superconducting RF cavities made of Nb. This leaves behind an apparently smooth surface, yet the achievable peak magnetic fields fall well below the superheating field of Nb, in most cases. In this work, the ultimate surface finish of EP was investigated by studying its effect on highly polished Nb samples. EP introduces high slope angle sloped-steps at grain boundaries. The magnetic field enhancement and superheating field suppression factors associated with such a geometry are calculated in the London theory. Despite the by-eye smoothness of electropolished Nb, such defects compromise the stability of the low-loss Meissner state, likely limiting the achievable peak accelerating fields in superconducting RF cavities. Finally, the impact of surface roughness on impurity diffusion is investigated which can link surface roughness to the effectiveness of heat treatments like low-temperature baking or nitrogen infusion in the vortex nucleation or hydride hypotheses. Surface roughness tends to decrease the effective dose of impurities as a result of the expansion of impurities into regions with greater internal angle. The effective dose of impurities can be protected by minimizing slope angles and step heights, ensuring uniformity.