Evidence for an ancient lunar magnetic field
Lunar rocks 12002 and 12022 remanent magnetic moment as evidence for ancient lunar magnetic field
SEARCH · Search NASA
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Lunar rocks 12002 and 12022 remanent magnetic moment as evidence for ancient lunar magnetic field
We use L1-norm model regularization of |Br| component at the surface on magnetic monopoles bases and along-track magnetic field differences alone (without vector observations) to derive high quality global magnetic field models at the surface of the Moon. The practical advantages to this strategy are the following: monopoles are more stable at closer spacing in comparison to dipoles, improving spatial resolution; L1-norm model regularization leads to sparse models which may be appropriate for the Moon which has regions of localized magnetic field features; and along-track differences reduce the need for ad-hoc external field noise reduction strategies. We examine also the use of Lunar Prospector and SELENE/Kaguya magnetometer data, combined and separately, and find that the Lunar Prospector along-track vector field differences lead to surface field models that require weaker regularization and, hence, result in higher spatial resolution. Significantly higher spatial resolution (wavelengths of roughly 25–30 km) and higher amplitude surface magnetic fields can be derived over localized regions of high amplitude anomalies (due to their higher signal-to-noise ratio). These high-resolution field models are also compared with the results of Surface Vector Mapping approach of Tsunakawa et al. (2015, https://doi.org/10.1002/2014JE004785). Finally, the monopoles- as well as dipoles-based patterns of the Serenitatis high amplitude magnetic feature have characteristic textbook patterns of Br and Bθ component fields from a nearly vertically downwardly magnetized source region and it implies that the principal source of the anomaly was formed when the region was much closer to the north magnetic pole of the Moon.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Examination of the lunar magnetic field as deduced from the orbital magnetometer data, with major emphasis on the general mapping of the lunar field over the orbit track of the Apollo 15 subsatellite. A detailed analysis of the data from a series of overflights of the Van de Graaff region at two different altitudes is also presented. This latter set of data makes it possible to determine the scale size of the region and the contrast between the remanent magnetization associated with the magnetic feature and its surroundings. The low altitude data from the Apollo 16 subsatellite, just prior to its impact into the lunar surface, are then examined. Data obtained while the moon was in the solar wind are used to construct a map which shows the lunar limb regions associated with the detection of limb compressions. This map is used to make qualitative inferences concerning the lunar remanent field in regions not covered by the contour maps.
Assuming that the physical properties of solar-wind ions have remained unchanged over the past 4 billion years, the observation of solar-wind ions in lunar breccias with compaction ages greater than 3.2 billion years places constraints on the nature and origin of the ancient lunar magnetic field. Solar-wind ions would not be expected to occur in old lunar breccias if a surface magnetic field of more than 0.03 gauss was present. Several explanations of this phenomenon are consistent with the global lunar dynamo theory of the origin of the lunar dipole field, including a wandering of the lunar dipole axis, late onset of dynamo action, and reversals of the lunar dipole field, producing a long-term field close to zero. Models invoking external field magnetization as the cause of the ancient lunar magnetic field constrain the dipole axis, precluding field reversals, and do not provide an alternative explanation for the observed occurrence of solar-wind ions in lunar breccias.
Measurements conducted with the aid of the Apollo 15 subsatellite reported by Coleman et al. (1972) showed that the lunar field was detectable at an altitude of 100 km. Since that time there has been much activity in mapping the lunar magnetic field from orbit. A review is presented of the mapping procedure used in producing lunar field maps and an investigation is conducted of the altitude dependence of the lunar magnetic field which significantly affects these maps. Attention is also given to the history of lunar magnetic field maps, the fine-scale maps, low-altitude Apollo 16 maps, the altitude dependence, and the source of the magnetization of the lunar crust. It is found that the strong altitude dependence evident in the records is different for the three components.
The Apollo 15 subsatellite magnetometer data have been used to map the lunar magnetic field over a narrow band of the lunar surface. Within this band the magnetic field is generally stronger and more variable over the farside highlands than the nearside maria. The correspondence between the strong variable lunar field regions and the source regions for limb compressions suggests that limb compressions arise as the result of the deflection of the solar wind just upstream of the terminator by the lunar magnetic field. Using this apparent relationship between field strength and limb compression source regions, it is deduced that the field strength in the northern farside highlands is not as strong as in the southern hemisphere at similar longitudes. Simultaneous measurements of the interplanetary magnetic field obtained by Explorer 35 and the Apollo 15 subsatellite above the dayside hemisphere are essentially identical. Thus, both instruments are measuring the undisturbed interplanetary field.
Study of the compression of the remanent lunar magnetic field by the solar wind, based on measurements of remanent magnetic fields at four Apollo landing sites and of the solar wind at two of these sites. Available data show that the remanent magnetic field at the lunar surface is compressed as much as 40% above its initial value by the solar wind, but the total remanent magnetic pressure is less than the stagnation pressure by a factor of six, implying that a local shock is not formed.
Thermal demagnetization of lunar breccia 15498,36 shows that the natural remanent magnetization is a simple thermoremanence carried by metallic iron. Using the classical Thellier-Thellier method the strength of the magnetizing field at the time of sample formation was found to be 2100 plus or minus 80 gammas.
Computer-generated contour maps of strong lunar remanent magnetic fields are presented and discussed. The maps, obtained by previously described (Eliason and Soderblom, 1977) techniques, are derived from a variety of direct and indirect measurements from Apollo 15 and 16 and Explorer 35 magnetometer and electron reflection data. A common display format is used to facilitate comparison of the maps over regions of overlapping coverage. Most large scale features of either weak or strong magnetic field regions are found to correlate fairly well on all the maps considered.
Using the asymmetric theory of lunar induction the total and induced magnetic field line structure within the Moon and the diamagnetic cavity were obtained. Total field distributions are shown for orientations of the oscillating interplanetary field parallel, perpendicular and at 45 deg to the cavity axis. Induced field lines are shown only for the orientations of the interplanetary field parallel and orthogonal to the cavity axis. When compared with the field lines derived using the long wavelength limit of spherically symmetric vacuum induction theory, the configurations obtained using the asymmetric theory exhibit significant distortion. For all orientations of the interplanetary field, the field lines are strongly compressed on the sunlit hemisphere because of the confining solar wind pressure at the lunar surface and the exclusion of the field by the lunar core.
Analysis of the returned samples, surface observations, and the orbital surveys reveal the presence of a widespread magnetism on the lunar surface but no global field. In the light of Runcorn's proof that internally generated fields do produce magnetization patterns in a spherical crust whose magnetic field lines are confined to within the crust, the above fact is explained in terms of an ancient lunar dynamo which magnetized the lunar crust and then disappeared. The possibility of ancient uniform magnetization by an external field is ruled out, for such magnetization would have been erased as the moon warmed up due to radioactive decay. Although the terrestrial field model is consistent with the measurements, this possibility is also ruled out, because the moon would have had to remain close to earth for about one billion years. The direction of the present magnetization is not predominantly north-south, but is radial and east-west, a fact explained by the assumption that the ancient lunar magnetic dipole moment was not along the present rotation axis.
Using the asymmetric theory of lunar induction derived by Schubert et al. (1973), a picture of both the total and induced magnetic field line distributions in and around the moon is provided for certain orientations of the interplanetary field fluctuations. These field line pictures are compared with the distributions one would obtain using a spherically symmetric vacuum theory of lunar induction. It is found that the induced lunar field line distribution bears a marked resemblance to the structure of the solar-wind distorted geomagnetic field.
Palaeointensity determinations on Apollo 11, 16 and 17 rocks have indicated that 3.9 - 4.0 AE ago the strength of the surface lunar magnetic field was about 1.3 Oe while there is evidence from younger rocks that a field of about one quarter of this value was present at a later time (3.6 AE).
Palaeointensity determination on Apollo 11, 16, and 17 rocks have indicated that from 3.9 to 4.0 AE ago the strength of the surface lunar magnetic field was about 1.3 Oe, while there is evidence from younger rocks that a field of about one quarter of this value was present at a later time (3.6 AE).
It is well known that solar-wind-implanted hydrogen and helium-3 in lunar soils are potentially usable resources for future manned activities. For economical mining of these implanted gases, it is desirable that relative concentrations exceed that of typical soils. It has previously been noted that the monthly variation of solar wind flux on the surface due to lunar immersion in the geomagnetic tail may have measurable consequences for resource utilization. It is pointed out that, for a constant external flux, locally strong lunar crustal magnetic fields will exert the dominant influence on solar wind volatile implantation rates. In particular, the strongest lunar crustal magnetic fields will both deflect and focus incident ions in local regions leading to local enhancements of the incident ion flux. Thus, the most economical sites for extraction of solar-wind-implanted volatiles may be within or adjacent to strong crustal magnetic fields. In addition, solar wind ion deflection by crustal magnetic fields must be considered in evaluating the issue of whether remnant cometary ice or water-bearing minerals have survived in permanently shadowed regions near the lunar poles. This is because sputter erosion of water ice by solar wind ions has been suggested to be an important ice loss mechanism within permanently shadowed regions. Thus, permanently shadowed regions that are also shielded from the solar wind by locally strong crustal fields could be the most promising locations for the survival of cometary ice. Additional numerical simulations are employed to show that solar wind ion deflection by strong lunar magnetic anomalies can produce local increases in the implantation rate of solar wind gases such as hydrogen.
Steady magnetic field measurements of magnitude 30 to 100 gamma on the lunar surface impose problems of interpretation when coupled with the nondetectability of a lunar field at 0.4 lunar radius altitude and the limb induced perturbations of the solar wind at the Explorer orbit. The lunar time-varying magnetic field clearly indicates the presence of eddy currents in the lunar interior and permits calculation of an electrical conductivity profile. The problem is complicated by the day-night asymmetry of the moon's electromagnetic environment, the possible presence of the transverse magnetic mode, and the variable wave directions of the driving function. The electrical conductivity is calculated to be low near the surface, rising to a peak of .006/ohm meter at 250 km, dropping steeply inwards to a value of about .00005/ohm meter, and then rising toward the interior. A transition at 250 km depth from a high conductivity to a low conductivity material is inferred, suggesting an olivine-like core at approximately 800 C, although other models are possible.
Lunar Prospector data show that strong magnetic fields lie antipodal to large impact basins, while the basins are low. This suggests that physical mechanisms associated with the impacts are responsible for the large scale magnetization pattern.