Lignin Valorization: Improving Lignin Processing in the Biorefinery
Abstract not provided
SEARCH · Search NASA
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Abstract not provided
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Lignin is a potentially plentiful source of renewable organics, with %7E50Mtons/yr produced by the pulp/paper industry and 200-300 Mtons/yr projected production by a US biofuels industry. This industry must process approximately 1 billion tons of biomass to meet the US Renewable Fuel goals. However, there are currently no efficient processes for converting lignin to value-added chemicals and drop-in fuels. Lignin is therefore an opportunity for production of valuable renewable chemicals, but presents staggering technical and economic challenges due to the quantities of material involved and the strong chemical bonds comprising this polymer. Aggressive chemistries and high temperatures are required to degrade lignin without catalysts. Moreover, chemical non-uniformity among lignins leads to complex product mixtures that tend to repolymerize. Conventional petrochemical approaches (pyrolysis, catalytic cracking, gasification) are energy intensive (400-800 degC), require complicated separations, and remove valuable chemical functionality. Low-temperature (25-200 degC) alternatives are clearly desirable, but enzymes are thermally fragile and incompatible with liquid organic compounds, making them impractical for large-scale biorefining. Alternatively, homogeneous catalysts, such as recently developed vanadium complexes, must be separated from product mixtures, while many heterogenous catalysts involve costly noble metals. The objective of this project is to demonstrate proof of concept that an entirely new class of biomimetic, efficient, and industrially robust synthetic catalysts based on nanoporous Metal- Organic Frameworks (MOFs) can be developed. Although catalytic MOFs are known, catalysis of bond cleavage reactions needed for lignin degradation is completely unexplored. Thus, fundamental research is required that industry and most sponsoring agencies are currently unwilling to undertake. We introduce MOFs infiltrated with titanium and nickel species as catalysts for the C-O bond hydrogenolysis in model compounds, which mimic the b-O-4, a-O-4, and 4-O-5 linkages of natural lignin. The versatile IRMOF-74(n) series is proposed as a platform for creating efficient hydrogenolysis catalysts as it not only displays tunable pore sizes, but also has the required thermal and chemical stability. The catalytic C-O bond cleavage occurs at 10 bar hydrogen pressure and temperatures as low as 120 degC. The conversion efficiency of the aromatic ether substrates into the corresponding hydrocarbons and phenols varies as PhCH 2 CH 2 OPh > PhCH 2 OPh > PhOPh (Ph = phenyl), while the catalytic activity generally follows the following trend Ni@IRMOF-74>Ti@IRMOF-74>IRMOF-74. Conversions as high as 80%, coupled with good selectivity for hydrogenolysis vs. hydrogenation, highlight the potential of MOF-based catalysts for the selective cleavage of recalcitrant aryl-ether bonds found in lignin and other biopolymers. This project supports the DOE Integrated Biorefinery Program goals, the objective of which is to convert biomass to fuels and high-value chemicals, by addressing an important technology gap: the lack of low-temperature catalysts suitable for industrial lignin degradation. Biomass, which is %7E30 wt% lignin, constitutes a potentially major source of platform chemicals that could improve overall profitability and productivity of all energy-related products, thereby benefiting consumers and reducing national dependence on imported oil. Additionally, DoD has a strong interest in low-cost drop-in fuels (Navy Biofuel Initiative) and has signed a Memorandum of Understanding with DOE and USDA to develop a sustainable biofuels industry.
Not Available
Biological lignin valorization to fuels and value-added chemicals enables sustainable and economic biorefineries. Even though significant progress has been made, several major challenges arose due to high recalcitrance and heterogeneity of lignin, which needs to be addressed to improve lignin processing. This work demonstrates an overview of biological lignin conversion and its regulation from a metabolic engineering and systems biology viewpoint. Biological lignin valorization includes three stages: lignin depolymerization, aromatics degradation, and target product biosynthesis. Ligninolytic microorganisms have an extensive enzymatic toolbox to break down the lignin and convert heterogeneous lignin derivatives to central intermediates, such as protocatechuate or catechol, through a peripheral pathway. These intermediates undergo ring cleavage via the β-ketoadipate pathway and are ultimately transformed into metabolites by yielding acetyl-CoA for internal product biosynthesis, such as triacylglycerols, polyhydroxyalkanoates, etc. Bioprospecting will expand the knowledge base of ligninolytic microbial communities, strains, and enzymes to facilitate the understanding of aromatics metabolism. Systems biology analyses achieve an understanding of molecular and systems-level degradation mechanisms and metabolic pathways of lignin and aromatics. By identifying these mechanisms, synthetic biology provides promising approaches to create the lignin conversion pathways and engineer ligninolytic strains suitable as potential hosts for lignin conversion. Techno-economic analysis of biological lignin upgrading to coproducts in biorefineries will guide the implementation of lignin valorization by mitigating technical risk for scale-up and improving the profitability of biorefinery. Through improving the understanding of biological lignin valorization, it should be possible to create biological lignin valorization route to effectively produce value-added products from lignin.
In 2014, Linger et al. presented a tandem process for lignin valorization by integrating chemical and biological catalysis. Chemical pretreatment of corn stover generated mixed lignocellulose-derived monomers that were converted to a single product, polyhydroxyalkanoates, by Pseudomonas putida. Tandem processes have since been developed for diverse feedstocks to support the bioeconomy.
Biological lignin valorization represents a promising approach contributing to sustainable and economic biorefineries. Here, the low level of valuable lignin–derived products remains a major challenge hindering the implementation of microbial lignin conversion. Lignin's properties play a significant role in determining the efficiency of lignin bioconversion. To date, despite significant progress in the development of biomass pretreatment, lignin fractionation, and fermentation over the last few decades, little efforts have gone into identifying the ideal lignin substrates for an efficient microbial metabolism. In this Minireview, emerging and state–of–the–art strategies for biomass pretreatment and lignin fractionation are summarized to elaborate their roles in modifying lignin structure for bioconversion. Fermentation strategies aimed at enhancing lignin depolymerization for microbial utilization are systematically reviewed as well. With an improved understanding of the ideal lignin structure elucidated by comprehensive metabolic pathways and/or big data analysis, modifying lignin chemistry could be more directional and effective. Ultimately, together with the progress of fermentation process optimization, biological lignin valorization will become more competitive in biorefineries.
Significance Lignin valorization is critical for economic viability of future biorefineries but is hindered due to the challenges of engineered bio-chassis such as the slow kinetics of substrate uptake, aromatics toxicity, and cost. Here, an autoregulatory system involving a vanillin autoinducible promoter is demonstrated with an aromatics transporter in Escherichia coli that is induced by lignin-derived aromatics and simultaneously converted to value-added platform chemical with diverse applications. In addition to alleviating toxicity, the engineered E. coli strain eliminates the need for an external inducer such as isopropyl β- d -1-thiogalactopyranoside during fermentation, thereby significantly reducing the process cost. This study demonstrates an autoregulatory system for aromatics bioconversion and serves as a platform for future strain development for lignin valorization.
Given lignin's heterogeneity, catalytic depolymerization results in aromatic compound mixtures, and conversion of this complex substrate to a single product is challenging. To that end, the Biological Lignin Valorization (BLV) project is pursuing biological funneling, wherein aromatic catabolic microbes are engineered to convert a mixture of lignin-derived compounds to a single product. Namely, we employ Pseudomonas putida and pursue atom-efficient products, such as muconic acid, which can be further converted to direct replacements or used in performance-advantaged bioproducts. Overall, biological lignin conversion can make major contributions to reduce the minimum fuel selling price of the integrated biorefinery. Early industrial efforts in this area are also leading to value-added products, including in collaboration with the BLV project. Primary challenges associated with BLV efforts include accessing bio-available monomers from lignin (with the Lignin Utilization project), enabling commercial titers, rates, and yields of bioproducts from lignin-derived compounds, and overcoming substrate and product toxicity. To date, we have 1) demonstrated 49 g/L of muconate from aromatic compounds and 4 g/L of muconate from lignin, 2) improved the toxicity tolerance of P. putida to key aromatic substrates, 3) debottlenecked biological funneling for higher rates, and 4) engineered P. putida to convert S, G, and H-type lignin-derived compounds to a single product.
Lignin, an aromatic biopolymer found in plant cell walls, is a key component of lignocellulosic biomass and generally utilized for heat and power. However, lignin's chemical composition makes it an attractive source for biological and catalytic conversion to fuels and chemicals. Bringing together experts from biology, catalysis, engineering, analytical chemistry, and techno-economic/life-cycle analysis, Lignin Valorization presents a comprehensive, interdisciplinary picture of how lignocellulosic biorefineries could potentially employ lignin valorization technologies. Chapters will specifically focus on the production of fuels and chemicals from lignin and topics covered include (i) methods for isolating lignin in the context of the lignocellulosic biorefinery, (ii) thermal, chemo-catalytic, and biological methods for lignin depolymerization, (iii) chemo-catalytic and biological methods for upgrading lignin, (iv) characterization of lignin, and (v) techno-economic and life-cycle analysis of integrated processes to utilize lignin in an integrated biorefinery. The book provides the latest breakthroughs and challenges in upgrading lignin to fuels and chemicals for graduate students and researchers in academia, governmental laboratories, and industry interested in biomass conversion.
The Biological Lignin Valorization (BLV) project develops microbial strains and associated bioprocesses to convert lignin-derived aromatic compounds into value-added bioproducts. Our main objective in the BLV project is to achieve industrially relevant bioproduction metrics that can directly contribute to the economic viability and improved sustainability of the integrated lignocellulosic biorefinery, in collaboration with complementary BETO-funded lignin valorization projects. Specifically, the BLV project works closely with the BETO-funded Lignin Utilization project, which provides bio-available aromatic compounds from chemo-catalytic lignin depolymerization. We use the robust soil bacterium, Pseudomonas putida, as our primary microbial host for the conversion of lignin-derived compounds to bioproducts. To date, we have focused on atom-efficient bioproducts that can be used as either direct replacement chemicals or performance-advantaged bioproducts, including cis,cis-muconic acid, beta-ketoadipic acid, and 2-pyrone-4,6-dicarboxylic acid. From model aromatic substrates, we have achieved titers of each of these compounds approaching 40 g/L and productivity values ranging from 0.5 to over 1 g/L/hr, all at 90% molar yield or higher. From real lignin streams, we have thus far achieved 24 g/L, 0.66 g/L/hr, and theoretical yield of beta-ketoadipic acid. A major pursuit now is to reach industrially relevant performance metrics on an expanded slate of lignin-derived streams.
Abstract Lignin nanoparticles (LNPs) are usually produced from lignin solution through supersaturation. The structure of the lignin in solution is still poorly understood due to structural variability of isolated lignins. Here, lignins were extracted from different plants to establish a general pattern of their structure in several lignin solvents. Lignin molecules (lignin subunits) and larger aggregates were observed in dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO), ethylene glycol (EG) and 0.1 N NaOD solutions by small‐angle neutron scattering (SANS). It was proposed that the aggregates were composed of lignin subunits with a higher molecular weight and a higher ratio of the aliphatic to phenolic hydroxyl groups. The size, shape, and compactness are important factors that affect the uses of the LNPs, which were obtained from the SANS data for the first time. A discrepancy in the radius between SANS and DLS was discovered, pointing to a large hydration shell around the LNPs in aqueous solutions. The cytotoxicity of the corncob lignin, kraft lignin, and their LNPs were measured and compared.
Significance Lignin is the only renewable and abundant polymer on the earth with aromatic units as its building blocks; however, it remains as an untapped resource. The current approach to making the biofuel industry cost competitive with the petroleum industry is to derive more value from the lignin. In this study we combined the unique approaches of both chemical engineering and biology to gain a deeper understanding of the metabolism of a soil bacterium, Sphingobium sp. SYK-6, that enables it to survive on lignin-derived monomers and oligomers. Understanding the central metabolism of SYK-6 will enable researchers to redesign the metabolic pathways of Sphingobium sp. SYK-6 more effectively to provide a renewable route for the production of products currently sourced from petrochemicals.
Naturally, many aerobic organisms degrade lignin-derived aromatics through conserved intermediates including protocatechuate and catechol. Employing this microbial approach offers a potential solution for valorizing lignin into valuable chemicals for a potential lignocellulosic biorefinery and enabling bioeconomy. In this study, two hybrid biochemical routes combining lignin chemical depolymerization, plant metabolic engineering, and synthetic pathway reconstruction were demonstrated for valorizing lignin into value-added products. In the biochemical route 1, alkali lignin was chemically depolymerized into vanillin and syringate as major products, which were further bio-converted into cis, cis-muconic acid (ccMA) and pyrogallol, respectively, using engineered Escherichia coli strains. In the second biochemical route, the shikimate pathway of Tobacco plant was engineered to accumulate protocatechuate (PCA) as a soluble intermediate compound. The PCA extracted from the engineered Tobacco was further converted into ccMA using the engineered E. coli strain. This study reports a direct process for converting lignin into ccMA and pyrogallol as value-added chemicals, and more importantly demonstrates benign methods for valorization of polymeric lignin that is inherently heterogeneous and recalcitrant. Our approach also validates the promising combination of plant engineering with microbial chassis development for the production of value added and speciality chemicals.
Despite lignin having long been viewed as an impediment to the processing of biomass for the production of paper, biofuels, and high-value chemicals, the valorization of lignin to fuels, chemicals, and materials is now clearly recognized as a critical element for the lignocellulosic bioeconomy. However, the intended application for lignin will likely require a preferred lignin composition and form. To that end, effective lignin valorization will require the integration of plant biology, providing optimal feedstocks, with chemical process engineering, providing efficient lignin transformations. Recent advances in our understanding of lignin biosynthesis have shown that lignin structure is extremely diverse and potentially tunable, while simultaneous developments in lignin refining have resulted in the development of several processes that are more agnostic to lignin composition. Here, we review the interface between in planta lignin design and lignin processing and discuss the advances necessary for lignin valorization to become a feature of advanced biorefining.
Elucidation of the catalyst role during reductive catalytic fractionation, enabling the integration of lignin valorization and bio-ethanol production.
As the largest natural reservoir of aromatics, lignin offers significant potential for bioproduct manufacturing through advances in valorization technologies. However, the intrinsically complex structures of lignin pose significant challenges for its fractionization and downstream valorization. Overcoming challenges in lignin chemistry modification is crucial for achieving effective lignin valorization and establishing sustainable biorefinery industries. This review explores the potential of tailoring lignin reactivity to enable functional bioproduct manufacturing thereby contributing to profitable biorefining. The intrinsic characteristics of lignin are first summarized, highlighting their roles in both fractionization and valorization. The latest progress in lignin fractionation is then presented, emphasizing their potential to tailor lignin chemistry, reactivity, and processibility. Furthermore, advancements in lignin valorization are covered, recognizing that tailored lignin reactivity is key to defining bioproduct functionality. By examining these chemical mechanisms, this review sheds on the structure-function relationships between lignin and its derived products. To address the dilemma of lignin valorization and biorefineries, a promising synergistic biorefinery is proposed. This involves redesigning biomass fractionation strategies, tailoring lignin chemistry, and upgrading both carbohydrate and lignin streams across the entire biorefinery chain—from feedstock to application. Altogether, a deeper understanding of tailored lignin chemistry is crucial for decoding the reaction mechanisms in biomass processing. A synergistic biorefinery could harness lignin's intrinsic properties to improve product functionality and address key challenges, paving the way for cost-effective, sustainable biorefinery solutions.
In this Editorial, Guest Editors Run-Cang Sun, Joseph S. M. Samec, and Arthur J. Ragauskas introduce the Special Issue of ChemSusChem on Lignin Valorization: From Theory to Practice. Here, the significance of and enormous challenges for the utilization of lignin are reviewed, and the contents of the Special Issue with highly interesting contributions from scientists around the world are outlined.