Congruence of Clusters Defined By Whole Genome Sequencing and MALDI-TOF for Bacteria Isolated From Cleanrooms
Introduction: Oligotrophic conditions can render cleanrooms inhospitable to microbes. Despite these constraints, fungi and bacteria are frequently isolated from surfaces in astromaterials cleanrooms at the Johnson Space Center. Bacillus species are of particular concern because endospores belonging to this genus are resilient and can affect astromaterials. Current monitoring programs rely on 16S rRNA sequencing and the VITEK2 Compact system. These methods have limited power to resolve Bacillus species. Matrix-assisted laser desorption - time of flight mass spectrometry (MALDI-TOF MS), provides a rapid, low cost, method of identifying bacterial isolates and has a higher resolution than 16S rRNA sequencing, particularly for Bacillus species; however, few studies have compared this method to the industry gold standard, whole genome sequencing (WGS). Methods: Based on 16S rRNA classification, we selected 14 isolates for analysis with MALDI-TOF and WGS. Mass spectra were generated with MALDI-TOF MS and processed with custom scripts to identify clusters of closely related isolates and calculate a matrix of pairwise cosine similarity scores. Hybrid Illumina and Nanopore sequencing were used to generate draft genomes. Pairwise similarity scores were calculated from these genomes based on the average amino acid identity (AAI) predicted from single copy core genes. Congruence of clustering between these methods, was assessed by calculating adjusted Rand and Wallace coefficients. Results: Clusters of species generated from MALDI-TOF MS showed good agreement of phylotypes generated with WGS. Pairs of strains that were > 94% similar to each other in terms of predicted amino acid sequences consistently showed cosine similarities of mass spectra > 0.65 and, of the 9 clusters identified with WGS, 8 were identical with MALDI-TOF. This corresponds to an adjusted Rand index of 0.95 and a 95% confidence interval of 0.80 – 1.00 for adjusted Wallace coefficients. The only discordance was for a pair of isolates that were classified as Paenibacillus species. This pair showed relatively high similarity (0.84) in terms of MALDI-TOF MS but only 85% similarity in terms of AAI. Conclusion: This study shows that MALDI-TOF and WGS exhibit a similar ability to delineate Bacillus species isolated from cleanrooms and taxonomic units described by these two methods are consistent with one another. Since MALDI-TOF MS is low in cost and high in throughput, this approach appears to be an ideal option for routine microbial monitoring and identifying Bacillus species.