SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “Negative Triangularity”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

SourceResearch connectionFrom yearThrough year

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 19 records

All sources NASA NTRS DOE OSTI

DOE OSTI2025

Infernal instabilities in negative-triangularity plasmas with negative central shear

Abstract A systematic numerical investigation is carried out to understand magnetohydrodynamic stability of the ideal infernal-kink instability in tokamak plasmas with both negative triangularity (neg-D) shaping and negative central shear for the equilibrium safety factor profile. The latter is motivated by the desire to form the internal transport barrier in the neg-D configuration, which is known to have difficulty in forming the edge transport barrier. The infernal-kink mode is generally found to be more unstable in neg-D plasmas as compared to their positive D-shaped (pos-D) counterpart. This is mainly due to less favorable (or even unfavorable) average magnetic curvature near the radial location of the minimum safety factor ( q min ) as compared to the pos-D configuration. The larger Shafranov shift associated with the neg-D shape helps the mode stabilization but is not sufficient to overcome the destabilizing effect due to bad curvature. Strong poloidal mode coupling due to plasma shaping (toroidicity, elongation, triangularity, etc.) helps explain the slight shift with respect to that predicted by the analytic theory of the peak location of the computed mode growth versus q min .

Zhang, X. M.↗

DOE OSTI2024

Overview of results from the 2023 DIII-D negative triangularity campaign

Negative triangularity (NT) is a potentially transformative configuration for tokamak-based fusion energy with its high-performance core, edge localized mode (ELM)-free edge, and low-field-side divertors that could readily scale to an integrated reactor solution. Previous NT work on the TCV and DIII-D tokamaks motivated the installation of graphite-tile armor on the low-field-side lower outer wall of DIII-D. A dedicated multiple-week experimental campaign was conducted to qualify the NT scenario for future reactors. During the DIII-D NT campaign, high confinement ($H_\mathrm{98y,2}\gtrsim$ 1), high current ($q_\mathrm{95} \lt$ 3), and high normalized pressure plasmas ($\beta_\mathrm{N} \gt$ 2.5) were simultaneously attained in strongly NT-shaped discharges with average triangularity $\delta_\mathrm{avg}$ = −0.5 that were stably controlled. Experiments covered a wide range of DIII-D operational space (plasma current, toroidal field, electron density and pressure) and did not trigger an ELM in a single discharge as long as sufficiently strong NT was maintained; in contrast, to other high-performance ELM-suppression scenarios that have narrower operating windows. These strong NT plasmas had a lower outer divertor X-point shape and maintained a non-ELMing edge with an electron temperature pedestal, exceeding that of typical L-mode plasmas. Also, the following was achieved during the campaign: high normalized density ($n_\mathrm{e}$/$n_\mathrm{GW}$ of at least 1.7), particle confinement comparable to energy confinement with $Z_\mathrm{eff}\sim2$ , a detached divertor without impurity seeding, and a mantle radiation scenario using extrinsic impurities. These results are promising for a NT fusion pilot plant but further questions on confinement extrapolation and core-edge integration remain, which motivate future NT studies on DIII-D and beyond.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

DOE OSTI2025

On the formation of edge electric fields in negative triangularity plasmas

The Negative Triangularity (NT) plasma edge is studied with full orbit simulations and compared with similar simulations using a Positive Triangularity (PT) edge geometry. It is found that the thermal edge ions in NT are less well confined than in PT. The edge ion losses in NT set-up an electric field inside the plasma in the loss region. This electric field leads to counter-current edge plasma flows and are consistent with observations in NT plasmas. It could also explain the good edge confinement in NT discharges via the E × B flow shear turbulence suppression mechanism.

electric fields↗

DOE OSTI2024

Assessment of vertical stability for negative triangularity pilot plants

Abstract Negative triangularity (NT) tokamak configurations may be more susceptible to magneto-hydrodynamic instability, posing challenges for recent reactor designs centered around their favorable properties, such as improved confinement and operation free of edge-localized modes. In this work, we assess the vertical stability of plasmas with NT shaping and develop potential reactor solutions. When coupled with a conformal wall, NT equilibria are confirmed to be less vertically stable than equivalent positive triangularity (PT) configurations. Unlike PT, their vertical stability is degraded at higher poloidal beta. Furthermore, improvements in vertical stability at low aspect ratio do not translate to the NT geometry. NT equilibria are stabilized in PT vacuum vessels due to the increased proximity of the plasma and the wall on the outboard side, but this scenario is found to be undesirable due to reduced vertical gaps which give less spatial margin for control recovery. Instead, we demonstrate that informed positioning of passively conducting plates can lead to improved vertical stability in NT configurations on par with stability metrics expected in PT scenarios. An optimal setup for passive plates in highly elongated NT devices is presented, where plates on the outboard side of the device reduce vertical instability growth rates to 16% of their baseline value. For lower target elongations, integration of passive stabilizers with divertor concepts can lead to significant improvements in vertical stability. Plates on the inboard side of the device are also uniquely enabled in NT geometries, providing opportunity for spatial separation of vertical stability coils and passive stabilizers.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

DOE OSTI2024

Verification of the kinetic electron role in the microinstabilities in a negative triangularity model equilibrium

Effect of kinetic electrons on negative triangularity plasmas has been investigated and compared against the corresponding positive triangularity plasmas, using the global gyrokinetic code X-point Gyrokinetic Code with scale-separated delta-f option without Coulomb collisions. Our model magnetic equilibria have strong positive and negative triangularities and weak magnetic shear. However, unusually large ρ i > a and low density plasmas are chosen to maximize the nonlocal effect to investigate the finite ρ i effect and to be clearly away from kinetic ballooning modes. Similar conclusions to previous flux tube and global simulations have been obtained in this highly nonlocal model plasma: it is essential to include kinetic electrons in the micro-instability study of negative triangularity plasmas. Most physics findings agree with existing reports, with some disagreement. We offer a new “effective trapping fraction” concept that can add to the explanation of the growth rate difference between NT and PT plasmas, pointing to the significant variation in trapped particle fractions that have turning points in the mode growth regions.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

DOE OSTI2024

Comparison of detachment in Ohmic plasmas with positive and negative triangularity

Abstract In recent years, negative triangularity (NT) has emerged as a potential high-confinement L-mode reactor solution. In this work, detachment is investigated using core density ramps in lower single null Ohmic L-mode plasmas across a wide range of upper, lower, and average triangularity (the mean of upper and lower triangularity: δ ) in the TCV tokamak. It is universally found that detachment is more difficult to access for NT shaping. The outer divertor leg of discharges with δ ≈ − 0.3 could not be cooled to below 5 eV through core density ramps alone. The behavior of the upstream plasma and geometrical divertor effects (e.g. a reduced connection length with negative lower triangularity) do not fully explain the challenges in detaching NT plasmas. Langmuir probe measurements of the target heat flux widths ( λ q ) were constant to within 30% across an upper triangularity scan, while the spreading factor S was lower by up to 50% for NT, indicating a generally lower integral scrape-off layer width, λ int . The line-averaged core density was typically higher for NT discharges for a given fuelling rate, possibly linked to higher particle confinement in NT. Conversely, the divertor neutral pressure and integrated particle fluxes to the targets were typically lower for the same line-averaged density, indicating that NT configurations may be closer to the sheath-limited regime than their PT counterparts, which may explain why NT is more challenging to detach.

Physics↗

DOE OSTI2023

Geometric dependencies of the mean E × B shearing rate in negative triangularity tokamaks

Abstract This paper presents a comparative study of the poloidal distribution of the mean E × B shearing rate for positive triangularity (PT) and negative triangularity (NT) tokamaks. The effects of flux surface up–down asymmetry due to asymmetric upper and lower triangularities are also considered. Both direct eddy straining and the effects on Shafranov shift feedback loops are examined. Shafranov shift increases the shearing rate at all poloidal angles for all triangularities, due to flux surface compression. The maximum shearing rate bifurcates at a critical triangularity δ crit ( ≲ 0 ) . Thus, the shearing rate is maximal off the outboard midplane for NT, while it is maximal on the outboard midplane for PT. For up–down asymmetric triangularity, the usual up–down symmetry of the shearing rate is broken. The shearing rate at the outboard midplane is lower for NT than for PT, suggesting that the shearing efficiency in NT is reduced. Implications for turbulence stabilisation and confinement improvement in high- β p NT and internal transport barrier discharges are discussed.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

DOE OSTI2026

Exploring the fusion power plant design space: comparative analysis of positive and negative triangularity tokamaks through optimization

The optimal configuration choice between positive triangularity (PT) and negative triangularity (NT) tokamaks for fusion power plants hinges on navigating different operational constraints rather than achieving specific plasma performance metrics. This study presents a systematic comparison using constrained multi-objective optimization with the integrated FUsion Synthesis Engine (FUSE) framework. Over 200 000 integrated design evaluations were performed exploring the trade-offs between capital cost minimization and operational reliability (maximizing q 95 ) while satisfying engineering constraints including 250 ± 50 MW net electric power, tritium breeding ratio > 1.1, power exhaust limits and an hour flattop time. Both configurations achieve similar cost-performance Pareto fronts through contrasting design philosophies. PT, while demonstrating resilience to pedestal degradation (compensating for up to 40% reduction), are constrained to larger machines (R 0 > 6.5 m) by the narrow operational window between L–H threshold requirements and the research-established power exhaust limit (P sol /R < 15 MW m –1 ). This forces optimization through comparatively reduced magnetic field (∼8 T). NT configurations exploit their freedom from these constraints to access compact, high-field designs (R 0 ~ 5.5 m, B 0 >12 T), creating natural synergy with advancing HTS technology. Sensitivity analyses reveal that PT’s economic viability depends critically on uncertainties in L–H threshold scaling and power handling limits. Notably, a 50% variation in either could eliminate viable designs or enable access to the compact design space. These results suggest configuration selection should be risk-informed: PT offers the lowest-cost path when operational constraints can be confidently predicted, while NT is robust to large variations in constraints and physics uncertainties.

FUSE framework↗

DOE OSTI2024

Characterization of the ELM-free negative triangularity edge on DIII-D

Tokamak plasmas with strong negative triangularity (NT) shaping typically exhibit fundamentally different edge behavior than conventional L-mode or H-mode plasmas. On DIII-D, every plasma with sufficiently negative triangularity (δ < δ crit ≃ -0.12) is found to be inherently free of edge localized modes (ELMs), even at injected powers well above the predicted L-H power threshold. It is also possible to access an ELM free state at weaker average triangularities provided that at least one of the two x-points is still sufficiently negative. Access to the ELM-free NT scenario is found to coincide with the closure of the second stability region for infinite-n ballooning modes, suggesting that ballooning stability may play a role in limiting the accessible pressure gradient in NT plasmas. Despite this, NT plasmas are able to support small pedestals and are typically characterized by an enhancement of edge pressure gradients beyond those found in traditional L mode plasmas. Further, the pressure gradient inside of this small pedestal is unusually steep, allowing access to high core performance that is competitive with other ELM-free regimes previously achieved on DIII-D. Since ELM-free operation in NT is linked directly to the magnetic geometry, NT fusion pilot plants are predicted to maintain advantageous edge conditions even in burning plasma regimes, potentially eliminating reactor core-integration issues caused by ELMs.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

DOE OSTI2024

Simultaneous access to high normalized density, current, pressure, and confinement in strongly-shaped diverted negative triangularity plasmas

Strongly-shaped diverted negative triangularity (NT) plasmas in the DIII-D tokamak demonstrate simultaneous access to high normalized density, current, pressure, and confinement. NT plasmas are shown to exist across an expansive parameter space compatible with high fusion power production, revealing surprisingly good core stability properties that compare favorably to conventional positive triangularity plasmas in DIII-D. Non-dimensionalizing the key parameters, expanded operating spaces featuring edge safety factors below 3, normalized betas above 3, Greenwald density fractions above 1, and high-confinement mode (H-mode) confinement qualities above 1 are observed, even simultaneously, and all with a robustly stable edge free from deleterious edge-localized mode instabilities. Scaling of the confinement time with engineering parameters reveals at least a linear dependence on plasma current although with significant power degradation, both in excess of expected H-mode scalings. These results increase confidence that NT plasmas are a viable approach to realize fusion power and open directions for future detailed study.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

DOE OSTI2025

Experimental characterization of turbulence properties in negative triangularity DIII-D plasmas

Negative Triangularity (NT) plasmas have demonstrated robustly ELM-free high-performance operation and provide a unique testbed to study how plasma shaping affects turbulent transport. The Beam Emission Spectroscopy (BES) diagnostic provides localized 2D measurements of low-k ($k_{\theta} \rho_s < 1$) density fluctuations. In a sweep of upper triangularity at fixed power, H-mode access is suppressed and an NT-edge is observed. The turbulence amplitude ($\tilde{n}/n$) is shown to decrease by $\sim50\%$ for $\rho<0.9$ in the NT-edge phase as compared to the H-mode phase. Additionally, low-velocity edge modes below 70 kHz are suppressed by triangularity and the dominant mode propagating in the electron diamagnetic direction is seen to broaden in wavenumber space in the NT-edge phase. In a strong NT plasma ($\delta_{avg}\sim-0.5$), low amplitude modes ($\tilde{n}/n <0.5\%$) propagating in the ion-diamagnetic direction with radially-poloidally symmetric eddy structure are identified for $\rho \sim 0.65-0.83$ consistent with Ion Temperature Gradient (ITG) turbulence. Modes consistent with Trapped Electron Mode (TEM) turbulence are observed propagating in the electron-diamagnetic direction for $\rho\gtrsim0.83$ with poloidally extended eddy structure and reduced amplitudes observed at the separatrix. The turbulence properties presented in this paper help validate our understanding of NT turbulence and help explain the improved confinement and unique edge features of NT plasmas.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

DOE OSTI2025

Alfvén mode spectrum in the advanced steady-state tokamak scenario with negative triangularity

In the earlier studies [Zheng et al. Fundam. Plasma Phys. 10, 100051 (2024)], the negative triangularity tokamak was shown to have a unique and outstanding feature for the steady-state confinement. In addition to relieving the divertor heat load concern, it can reach a much higher beta limit in the nearly steady-state confinement, about twice the Troyon limit in the positive triangularity case. In this work, we extend the investigation to the Alfvén spectrum and toroidal Alfvén eigenmodes (TAEs). This helps to evaluate the property of energetic particle confinement in this advanced scenario of a negative triangularity tokamak. We found that, because of the large safety factor and reversed magnetic shear in the core plasma region near the magnetic axis, the TAE gap tends to be closed or have only a short radial extension between the continua. in the on-axis core region and open primarily in the off-axis region, where TAEs are shown to be present. This indicates that energetic particle confinement in the core region near the magnetic axis, where nuclear fusion reactions prevail, is not seriously affected by the excitation of TAEs in this scenario. The configuration with off-axis TAEs helps the confinement of energetic particles as compared to the configuration with near-axis TAEs. The results show that the advanced steady-state tokamak scenario with negative triangularity, because of the rapid variation of the safety factor, also has a favorable feature for energetic particle confinement.

Fourier analysis↗

DOE OSTI2024

Characterizing the negative triangularity reactor core operating space with integrated modeling

Negative triangularity (NT) has received renewed interest as a fusion reactor regime due to its beneficial power-handling properties, including low scrape-off layer power and a larger divertor wetted area that facilitates simple divertor integration. NT experiments have also demonstrated core performance on par with positive triangularity (PT) high confinement mode (H-mode) without edge-localized modes (ELMs), encouraging further study of an NT reactor core. In this work, we use integrated modeling to scope the operating space around two NT reactor strategies. The first is the high-field, compact fusion pilot plant concept Modular, Adjustable, NT ARC (MANTA) and the second is a low field, high aspect ratio concept based on work by Medvedev et al. By integrating equilibrium, core transport, and edge ballooning instability models, we establish a range of operating points with less than 50 MW scrape-off layer power and fusion power comparable to PT H-mode reactor concepts. Heating and seeded impurities are leveraged to accomplish the same fusion performance and scrape-off layer exhaust power for various pressure edge boundary conditions. Scans over these pressure edge conditions accommodate any current uncertainty of the properties of the NT edge and show that the performance of an NT reactor will be extremely dependent on the edge pressure. The high-field case is found to enable lower scrape-off layer power because it is capable of reaching high fusion powers at a relatively compact size, which allows increased separatrix density without exceeding the Greenwald density limit. Adjustments in NT shaping exhibit small changes in fusion power, with an increase in fusion power density seen at weaker NT. Infinite-n ballooning instability models indicate that an NT reactor core can reach fusion powers comparable to leading PT H-mode reactor concepts while remaining ballooning-stable. Seeded krypton is leveraged to further lower scrape-off layer power since NT does not have a requirement to remain in H-mode while still maintaining high confinement. We contextualize the NT reactor operating space by comparing to popular PT H-mode reactor concepts, and find that NT exhibits competitive ELM-free performance with these concepts for a variety of edge conditions while maintaining relatively low scrape-off layer power.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

DOE OSTI2024

How does negative triangularity mitigate ITG turbulence and transport?

Improved confinement in negative triangularity (NT) experiments is attributed to reduced fluxes driven by micro-turbulence. The physical mechanism of why thermal confinement improves in NT relative to PT is unknown. This study employs gyrokinetic flux tube simulations using the GENE code with local Miller equilibrium to elucidate the physical mechanisms behind the beneficial effects of NT flux surface shapes. The focus is on collisionless ion temperature gradient (ITG) driven turbulence with adiabatic electrons. The kinetic profiles are held fixed across a scan of triangularity values, thus enabling comparisons on a level playing field. The reduced linear growth rates for NT is shown to be due to a reduced eigenmode averaged magnetic drift frequency and a wider, stronger negative local magnetic shear region about the outboard mid-plane. The nonlinear heat flux is lower for NT than that for PT, due to reduced radial correlation length and increased correlation time (τ c ) of fluctuations. These, in turn, are due to a comparatively higher level of self-generated zero-frequency E × B zonal shearing rate ω E in NT as compared to PT. Though the linear zonal potential residual is lower for NT, the nonlinearly generated E × B zonal shearing rate is higher for NT than for PT. This outcome is linked to the distinctive features of the radial wavenumber spectra of the zonal potential and the zonal shearing rate. The dimensionless parameter ω E τ c is suggested as a figure of merit. This is higher for NT than for PT. Thus, the reduced heat diffusivity for NT is linked to increased ω E τ c . Self-generated temperature corrugations (i.e. zonal temperature gradients) are much weaker than the background mean temperature gradient. Nevertheless, temperature corrugations are more pronounced in NT than in PT.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

DOE OSTI2025

Operation above the Greenwald density limit in high performance DIII-D negative triangularity discharges

The density limit in strongly-shaped negative triangularity (NT) discharges is studied experimentally in the DIII-D tokamak. Record-high Greenwald fractions f G are obtained, using gas puff injection only, with values up to near 2, where f G is defined as the ratio of the line-averaged density over n G = I p /(π a 2 ), with I p [MA] the plasma current and a[m] the plasma minor radius. A clear higher operational limit with higher auxiliary power is also demonstrated, with the ohmic density limit about two times lower than with additional neutral beam injection heating. The evolution of the electron density, temperature and pressure profiles are analyzed as well. The core density can be up to twice the Greenwald density and keeps increasing, while the value at the separatrix remains essentially constant and slightly below n G . The edge temperature gradient collapses to near zero and NT plasmas are shown to be resilient to such profiles in terms of disruptivity. We also present the time evolution of the inverse electron pressure scale length with the value at the last closed flux surface (LCFS) decreasing below the value at the normalized radius 0.9 near the density limit, demonstrating the clear drop of confinement starting from the edge. This inverse scale length ‘collapse’ at the LCFS also defines well the characteristic behavior of the kinetic profiles approaching a density limit.

density limit↗

DOE OSTI2024

Nonlinear gyrokinetic modelling of high confinement negative triangularity plasmas

Abstract Nonlinear gyrokinetic simulations correctly predict particle as well as ion and electron energy fluxes of high confinement plasmas with a negative triangularity cross sectional shape, showing that core transport in these plasmas is well described by standard gyrokinetic models. Experimentally inferred power balance fluxes are mostly reproduced within one standard deviation across a wide portion of the minor radius. Experimental conditions are reproduced by ion scale simulations, without the need to include density and temperature profile curvature effects. The experimental case is used as baseline to predict that the non-dimensional confinement scaling in negative triangularity plasmas increases strongly with plasma current while slightly degrading at increasing normalized pressure and decreasing collisionality. Recent experiments showed that low toroidal rotation negatively impacts confinement; consistent with the experiment, simulations predict that low rotational shear significantly affects confinement unless the plasma effective charge is maintained above a minimum level. Core confinement is predicted to significantly degrade in low aspect ratio devices.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

DOE OSTI2024

First access to ELM-free negative triangularity at low aspect ratio

A plasma scenario with negative triangularity (NT) shaping is achieved on MAST-U for the first time. While edge localized modes (ELMs) are eventually suppressed as the triangularity is decreased below δ ≲ –0.06, an extended period of H-mode operation with Type-III ELMs is sustained at less negative δ even through access to the second stability region for ideal ballooning modes is closed. This documents a qualitative difference from the ELM-free access conditions documented in NT scenarios on conventional aspect ratio machines. The electron temperature at the pedestal top drops across the transition to ELM-free operation, but a steady rise in core temperature as δ is decreased allows for similar normalized β in the ELM-free NT and H-mode positive triangularity shapes.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

DOE OSTI2025

Disentangling core and edge mechanisms of the density limit in DIII-D negative triangularity plasmas

The density limit is investigated in the DIII-D negative triangularity plasmas which lack a standard H-mode edge. We find the limit may not be a singular disruptive boundary but a multifaceted density saturation phenomenon governed by distinct core and edge transport mechanisms. Sustained, non-disruptive operation is achieved at densities up to 1.8 times the Greenwald limit ($n_\mathrm{G}$) until the termination of auxiliary heating. Systematic power scans show distinct power scalings for the core ($n_e \propto P_\mathrm{SOL}^{0.27\pm0.03}$) and edge ($n_e \propto P_\mathrm{SOL}^{0.42\pm0.04}$) density limits. The edge density saturation is triggered by the onset of a non-disruptive, high-field side radiation front and the associated cooling, which clamps the edge density below . In contrast, the core density continues to rise until it saturates, a state characterized by enhanced core turbulence. Core transport evolves from a diffusive to an intermittent, avalanche-like state, as indicated by heavy-tailed probability density functions (kurtosis ≈ 6), increased Hurst exponents, and a $1/f$-type power spectrum. These findings suggest that the density limit in the low-confinement regime is determined by a combination of edge radiative cooling and core turbulent transport. This distinction provides separate targets for control strategies aimed at extending the operational space of future fusion devices.

density limit↗