The effect of an anisotropic pressure of thermal particles on resistive wall mode stability
Not Available
Berkery, J. W.↗
SEARCH · Search NASA
Results for “Resistive Walls”
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
MST resistive wall tearing mode simulations
Here, the Madison Symmetric Torus (MST) is a toroidal device that, when operated as a stan dard tokamak, does not have major disruptions. Unlike most tokamaks, the MST plasma is surrounded by a close fitting highly conducting wall, with a resistive wall penetration time two orders of magnitude longer than in JET or DIII-D, and three times longer than in ITER. The MST can operate with edge q a ⩽ 2, unlike standard tokamaks. Simulations presented here indicate that the MST is unstable to resistive wall tearing modes (RWTMs) and resistive wall modes (RWMs). They could in principle cause disruptions, but the predicted thermal quench time is much longer than the experimental pulse time. If the MST thermal quench time were comparable to measurements in JET and DIII-D, theory and simulations predict that disruptions would have been observed in MST. This is consistent with the modeling herein, predicting that disruptions are caused by RWTMs and RWMs. In the low q a ~ 2 regime of MST, the RWTM asymptotically satisfies the RWM dispersion relation. The transition from RWTM to RWM occurs smoothly at q a = m/n, where m, n are poloidal and toroidal mode numbers.
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
Multiple branches of resistive wall mode instability in a resistive plasma
We observe that the resistive wall mode (RWM) instability is numerically investigated for a toroidal resistive plasma, with results compared to those of an analytic cylindrical model. The full toroidal code MARS-F [Liu et al. , Phys. Plasmas 7, 3681 (2000)] is applied for a computational study. The results indicate that there are two branches of unstable RWMs, when the toroidal favorable average curvature effect (the GGJ effect) is taken into account in the resistive layer. In addition, the GGJ physics not only directly affects the mode growth rate, but also indirectly modifies the mode stability by changing the continuum damping through modifying the mode frequency in the plasma frame. Furthermore, the plasma resistivity can either stabilize or destabilize the RWM, depending on the regime of key plasma parameters (e.g., the plasma rotation). Similarly, the plasma rotation can stabilize or destabilize the RWM, depending on the plasma resistivity. These numerical results from MARS-F are qualitatively confirmed by an analytic theory model which includes the GGJ effect.
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
Control of linear modes in cylindrical resistive magnetohydrodynamics with a resistive wall, plasma rotation, and complex gain
Feedback stabilization of magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) modes in a tokamak is studied in a cylindrical model with a resistive wall, plasma resistivity, viscosity, and toroidal rotation. The control is based on a linear combination of the normal and tangential components of the magnetic field just inside the resistive wall. The feedback includes complex gain, for both the normal and for the tangential components, and it is known that the imaginary part of the feedback for the former is equivalent to plasma rotation [J. M. Finn and L. Chacon, Phys. Plasmas 11, 1866 (2004)]. The work includes (1) analysis with a reduced resistive MHD model for a tokamak with finite β and with stepfunction current density and pressure profiles, and (2) computations with a full compressible visco-resistive MHD model with smooth decreasing profiles of current density and pressure. The equilibria are stable for β = 0 and the marginal stability values β{sub rp,rw} < β{sub rp,iw} < β{sub ip,rw} < β{sub ip,iw} (resistive plasma, resistive wall; resistive plasma, ideal wall; ideal plasma, resistive wall; and ideal plasma, ideal wall) are computed for both models. The main results are: (a) imaginary gain with normal sensors or plasma rotation stabilizes below β{sub rp,iw} because rotation suppresses the diffusion of flux from the plasma out through the wall and, more surprisingly, (b) rotation or imaginary gain with normal sensors destabilizes above β{sub rp,iw} because it prevents the feedback flux from entering the plasma through the resistive wall to form a virtual wall. A method of using complex gain G{sub i} to optimize in the presence of rotation in this regime with β > β{sub rp,iw} is presented. The effect of imaginary gain with tangential sensors is more complicated but essentially destabilizes above and below β{sub rp,iw}.
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
Multi-region approach to free-boundary three-dimensional tokamak equilibria and resistive wall instabilities
Free-boundary 3D tokamak equilibria and resistive wall instabilities are calculated using a new resistive wall model in the two-fluid M3D-C1 code. In this model, the resistive wall and surrounding vacuum region are included within the computational domain. This implementation contrasts with the method typically used in fluid codes in which the resistive wall is treated as a boundary condition on the computational domain boundary and has the advantage of maintaining purely local coupling of mesh elements. This new capability is used to simulate perturbed, free-boundary non-axisymmetric equilibria; the linear evolution of resistive wall modes; and the linear and nonlinear evolution of axisymmetric vertical displacement events (VDEs). Calculated growth rates for a resistive wall mode with arbitrary wall thickness are shown to agree well with the analytic theory. Equilibrium and VDE calculations are performed in diverted tokamak geometry, at physically realistic values of dissipation, and with resistive walls of finite width. Simulations of a VDE disruption extend into the current-quench phase, in which the plasma becomes limited by the first wall, and strong currents are observed to flow in the wall, in the SOL, and from the plasma to the wall.
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
Resistive wall tearing mode disruptions
Abstract This paper deals with resistive wall tearing mode (RWTM) disruptions. RWTMs are closely related to resistive wall modes. RWTMs are tearing modes whose linear and nonlinear behavior is strongly dependent on the resistive wall outside the plasma. The consequence for ITER, is that the thermal quench timescale could be much longer than previously conjectured. Active feedback stabilization is another possible way to mitigate or prevent RWTM disruptions. Simulations of RWTM disruptions are reviewed for DIII-D and MST. MST has a longer resistive wall time than ITER, and disruptions are not observed experimentally when MST is operated as a standard tokamak. Simulations indicate that the RWTM disruption time scale is longer than the experimental shot time. Edge cooling causes contraction of the current profile, which can destabilize RWTMs. The equilibria studied here have the q = 2 rational surface close to the edge of the plasma, and low current density between the q = 2 surface and the wall. A sequence of low edge current model equilibria has major disruptions only for a resistive, not ideal, wall, and edge q ⩽ 3.4 . This is consistent with regimes of tokamak disruptivity, suggesting that tokamak disruptions caused by edge cooling at low edge q could be RWTMs.
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
Rotational stabilization of the resistive wall modes in tokamaks with a ferritic wall
The dynamics of the rotating resistive wall modes (RWMs) is analyzed in the presence of a uniform ferromagnetic resistive wall with μ{sup ^}≡μ/μ{sub 0}≤4 (μ is the wall magnetic permeability, and μ{sub 0} is the vacuum one). This mimics a possible arrangement in ITER with ferromagnetic steel in test blanket modules or in future experiments in JT-60SA tokamak [Y. Kamada, P. Barabaschi, S. Ishida, the JT-60SA Team, and JT-60SA Research Plan Contributors, Nucl. Fusion 53, 104010 (2013)]. The earlier studies predict that such a wall must provide a destabilizing influence on the plasma by reducing the beta limit and increasing the growth rates, compared to the reference case with μ{sup ^}=1. This is true for the locked modes, but the presented results show that the mode rotation changes the tendency to the opposite. At μ{sup ^}>1, the rotational stabilization related to the energy sink in the wall becomes even stronger than at μ{sup ^}=1, and this “external” effect develops at lower rotation frequency, estimated as several kHz at realistic conditions. The study is based on the cylindrical dispersion relation valid for arbitrary growth rates and frequencies. This relation is solved numerically, and the solutions are compared with analytical dependences obtained for slow (s/d{sub w}≫1) and fast (s/d{sub w}≪1) “ferromagnetic” rotating RWMs, where s is the skin depth and d{sub w} is the wall thickness. It is found that the standard thin-wall modeling becomes progressively less reliable at larger μ{sup ^}, and the wall should be treated as magnetically thick. The analysis is performed assuming only a linear plasma response to external perturbations without constraints on the plasma current and pressure profiles.
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
Stabilization of resistive wall modes using moving metal walls (Final Report)
The UW experiment used a linear pinch experiment to study the stabilization of MHD by moving metal walls. The methodology of the experiment had three steps. (1) Identify and understand the no-wall MHD instability limits and character, (2) identify and understand the thin-wall MHD instabilities (resistive wall mode), and then (3) add the spinning wall and understand its impact on stability properties. During the duration of the grant we accomplished all 3 of these goals, discovered new physics, and completed the experiment as proposed.
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
Magnetohydrodynamic instability excited by interplay between a resistive wall mode and stable ideal magnetohydrodynamic modes in rotating tokamak plasmas
In a rotating toroidal plasma surrounded by a resistive wall, it is shown that linear magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) instabilities can be excited by interplay between the resistive wall mode (RWM) and stable ideal MHD modes, where the RWM can couple with not only a stable external kink mode but also various stable Alfvén eigenmodes that abound in a toroidal plasma. The RWM growth rate is shown to peak repeatedly as the rotation frequency reaches specific values for which the frequencies of the ideal MHD modes are Doppler-shifted to the small RWM frequency. Such destabilization can be observed even when the RWM in a static plasma is stable. A dispersion relation clarifies that the unstable mode changes from the RWM to the ideal MHD mode destabilized by wall resistivity when the rotation frequency passes through these specific values. The unstable mode is excited at these rotation frequencies even though plasma rotation also tends to stabilize the RWM from the combination of the continuum damping and the ion Landau damping.
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
Positional stability of field-reversed-configurations in the presence of resistive walls
We show that in a field-reversed-configuration, the plasma is unstable to either transverse or axial rigid displacement, but never to both. Driving forces are found to be parallel to the direction of displacement with no orthogonal components. Furthermore, we demonstrate that the properties of a resistive wall (geometry and resistivity) in the vicinity of the plasma do not affect whether the plasma is stable or unstable, but in the case of an unstable system determine the instability growth rate. Depending on the properties of the wall, the instability growth is dominated by plasma inertia (and not affected by wall resistivity) or dominated by ohmic dissipation of wall eddy currents (and thus proportional to the wall resistivity).
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
Shaping effects on toroidal magnetohydrodynamic modes in the presence of plasma and wall resistivity
This study explores the effects of plasma shaping on magnetohydrodynamic mode stability and rotational stabilization in a tokamak, including both plasma and wall resistivity. Depending upon the plasma shape, safety factor, and distance from the wall, the β-limit for rotational stabilization is given by either the resistive-plasma ideal-wall (tearing mode) limit or the ideal-plasma resistive-wall (resistive wall mode) limit. In order to explore this broad parameter space, a sharp-boundary model is developed with a realistic geometry, resonant tearing surfaces, and a resistive wall. The β-limit achievable in the presence of stabilization by rigid plasma rotation, or by an equivalent feedback control with imaginary normal-field gain, is shown to peak at specific values of elongation and triangularity. As a result, it is shown that the optimal shaping with rotation typically coincides with transitions between tearing-dominated and wall-dominated mode behavior
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
Stability and Control of Burning Tokamak Plasmas with Resistive Walls: Final Technical Report
This project is focused on theoretical and computational development for quantitative prediction of the stability and control of the equilibrium state evolution in toroidal burning plasmas, including its interaction with the surrounding resistive wall. The stability of long pulse burning plasmas is highly sensitive to the physics of resonant layers in the plasma, sources of momentum and flow, kinetic effects of energetic particles, and boundary conditions at the wall, including feedback control and error fields. In ITER in particular, the low toroidal flow equilibrium state, sustained primarily by energetic alpha particles from fusion reactions, will require the consideration of all of these key elements to predict quantitatively the stability and evolution. The principal investigators on this project have performed theoretical and computational analyses, guided by analytic modeling, to address this physics in realistic configurations. The overall goal has been to understand the key physics mechanisms that describe stable toroidal burning plasmas under active feedback control. Several relevant achievements have occurred during this project, leading to publications and invited conference presentations. In theoretical efforts, with the physics of the resonant layers, resistive wall, and toroidal momentum transport included, this study has extended from cylindrical resistive plasma - resistive wall models with feedback control to toroidal geometry with strong shaping to study mode coupling effects on the stability. These results have given insight into combined tearing and resistive wall mode behavior in simulations and experiment, while enabling a rapid exploration of plasma parameter space, to identify possible domains of interest for large plasma codes to investigate in more detail. Resonant field amplification and quasilinear torques in the presence of error fields and velocity shear have also been investigated. Here it was found, surprisingly, that the Maxwell torque on resonant layers in the plasma which exhibit finite real frequencies ωr in their response is significantly different from the conventional results based on tearing layers with pure real growth (or damping) rates. This observation suggests the possibility that the torque on the tearing layers can lock the plasma rotation to this finite phase velocity, which may lead to locking in which velocity shear is maintained. More broadly, the sources of all torques driving flows in magnetic confinement experiments is not fully understood, and this theoretical work may shed light on puzzling experimental results. It was also found that real frequencies occur over a wide range of plasma response regimes, and are indeed the norm and not the exception, often leading to profound effects on the locking torque. Also, the influence of trapped energetic ions orbiting over the resistive plasma mode structure, a critical effect in burning plasmas, was investigated through analytic modeling and analysis of simulations and experiment. This effort has shown that energetic ions can drive the development of disruptive instabilities, but also damp and stabilize the instabilities, depending on the details of the shear in the equilibrium magnetic field. This finding could be critical to maintaining stable operations in burning plasmas. In the most recent work, a series of simulations have been conducted to study the effect of differential flow and energetic ion effects on entry to the onset of a disruptive instability in the most realistic conditions possible, with preexisting nonlinearly saturated benign instabilities. Throughout this work, the linear and quasilinear theory of resonant layers with differential flow between them, their interaction with resistive wall and error fields, and energetic ions effects, have been used to understand realistic simulations of mode onset and the experimental discharges they represent. These studies will continue to answer remaining questions about the relation between theoretical results obtained in this project and observations of the onset and evolution of disruptive instabilities in experiment.
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
Stability and Control of Burning Tokamak Plasmas with Resistive Walls (Final Report)
Work supported by the grant, "Stability and Control of Burning Tokamak Plasmas with Resistive Walls" in the period Aug 2017 to 2023 can be cast in three general categories: (1) linear tearing regimes and the effects on the response to error fields and resistive walls: (2) nonlinear tearing modes in the presence of error fields, with locking; and (3) energetic particle effects. In the first category, we have completed a study of tearing mode regimes with extended MHD effects, including parallel dynamics and toroidal effects, notably favorable average curvature. This work has been presented at the 2018 Sherwood Conference. This work has been published in the ArXiv and is being prepared for publication in Physics of Plasmas. A systematic study of shaping in a tokamak plasma with resistive tearing layers and a resistive wall has been presented in the PhD dissertation by Dov Rhodes, a student of Andrew Cole at Columbia University. John Finn was on Rhodes's PhD committee, and was a co-author of a paper published in Physics of Plasmas on that work. A detailed study of nonlinear tearing modes in the presence of finite beta, favorable average curvature, and an error field has been nearly completed. In this study it was found that the response to an error field with real frequency a tearing layer agreed with analytic results, and that tearing mode saturation by flattening of the current profile as well as destabilization due to flattening of the pressure profile were important factors in the locking process. This work was presented at the 2017 APS/DPP Conference and at the 2018 Sherwood Conference. The effects of energetic ions on tearing modes was presented at the 2017 APS/DPP Conference and in the PhD dissertation of Michael Halfmoon. John Finn served as a committee member on Halfmoon's PhD committee. Extensions to this work including two fluid effects were performed and presented at the APS/DPP Conference in 2017.
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
Setting up resistive wall modeling for the GA Compact Advanced Tokamak (GA FPP) (Final Report)
Resistive wall implementation for tokamaks has been achieved by both a 'thin wall' approximation in which time-varying fields are matched across a boundary for all modes; and, by meshing the region from the first wall to the outer boundary and setting certain fields to mimic a resistive wall. Both implementations were tested on existing tokamaks.
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
The effects of a finite beam pipe on resistive wall instabilities
The effect of resistive wall instabilities on beam break-up is investigated for beam pipes with finite and infinite thickness walls. Analytic solutions for the electric field along the beam axis are determined for both finite and infinite thickness walls using complex analysis. The longitudinal and transverse impedances are also determined; variations from the infinite wall case are observed when the wall thickness is of the order of the skin depth of the beam pipe material.
43 PARTICLE ACCELERATORS↗
Resistive wall tearing mode disruptions in DIII-D and ITER tokamaks
Disruptions are a serious problem in tokamaks, in which thermal and magnetic energy confinement is lost. This paper uses data from the DIII-D experiment, theory, and simulations to demonstrate that resistive wall tearing modes (RWTMs) produce the thermal quench (TQ) in a typical locked mode shot. Analysis of the linear RWTM dispersion relation shows the parameter dependence of the growth rate, particularly on the resistive wall time. Linear simulations of the locked mode equilibrium show that it is unstable with a resistive wall and stable with an ideally conducting wall. Nonlinear simulations demonstrate that the RWTM grows to sufficient amplitude to cause a complete thermal quench. The RWTM growth time is proportional to the thermal quench time. Here, the nonlinearly saturated RWTM magnetic perturbation amplitude agrees with experimental measurements. The onset condition is that the q = 2 rational surface is sufficiently close to the resistive wall. Collectively, this identifies the RWTM as the cause of the TQ. In ITER, RWTMs will produce long TQ times compared to present-day experiments. ITER disruptions may be significantly more benign than previously predicted.
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗
Combined effects of trapped energetic ions and resistive layer damping on the stability of the resistive wall mode
A dispersion relation is derived for the stability of the resistive wall mode (RWM), which includes both the resistive layer damping physics and the toroidal precession drift resonance damping from energetic ions in tokamak plasmas. The dispersion relation is numerically solved for a model plasma, for the purpose of systematic investigation of the RWM stability in multi-dimensional plasma parameter space including the plasma resistivity, the radial location of the resistive wall, as well as the toroidal flow velocity. It is found that the toroidal favorable average curvature in the resistive layer contributes a significant stabilization of the RWM. This stabilization is further enhanced by adding the drift kinetic contribution from energetic ions. Furthermore, two traditionally assumed inner layer models are considered and compared in the dispersion relation, resulting in different predictions for the stability of the RWM.
70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗