Distinguishing Leptothrix and Sphaerotilus genera by an integrated genomic-phenotypic analysis supported by new Leptothrix genomes
The Sphaerotilus-Leptothrix group of bacteria includes one of the first described microorganisms, Leptothrix ochracea, an uncultured type strain, plus isolates of Leptothrix and Sphaerotilus. This group is unified by the ability to form sheaths and oxidize metals, although L. ochracea exhibits obvious ecological, morphological, and functional differences from the rest of Sphaerotilus-Leptothrix. Recently, there have been calls to combine the group into one genus, Sphaerotilus; however, these studies lacked adequate genomic representation of L. ochracea. Here, we present a comprehensive comparative genomic analysis of the Sphaerotilus-Leptothrix group, including expanded representation of L. ochracea, a closely related novel species, Leptothrix toolikensis, and two new isolates (Leptothrix mechoopdaensis). Analysis of 38 genomes resolves three phylogenetic and functional groups: the ochracea-type Leptothrix (Group 1), the mobilis-type Leptothrix (Group 2), and Sphaerotilus (Group 3). Group 1 genomes form a separate genus based on average nucleotide identity and alignment fraction. The genomes clearly diverge from the rest of Sphaerotilus-Leptothrix in phylogeny, size, and metabolic potential. Group 1 genomes are much smaller (2.59–3.04 Mb) than those of Groups 2 (4.55–6.06 Mb) and 3 (3.94–5.07 Mb), while encoding more metal oxidases and fewer carbohydrate-active enzymes. Group 2 clusters with Group 3 phylogenetically and is similar in organic carbon metabolisms but maintains more metal oxidation genes. Group 2 members lack homogeneity in phenotype and genotype, suggesting that additional isolates and genomes are needed for confident classification. However, Group 1 genomes (L. ochracea and L. toolikensis) show clear divergence, precluding their inclusion in Sphaerotilus and supporting the retention of the genus Leptothrix.