Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “Subcooled flow boiling”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 19 records
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
DOE OSTI2023

Development of experimental and computational frameworks to predict subcooled flow boiling in the LANL Isotope Production Facility

Cooling is crucial to maintain the integrity of target systems in isotope production facilities. At Los Alamos National Laboratory (LANL)’s Isotope Production Facility (IPF), multiple encapsulated targets are stacked and irradiated in tandem with a 100 MeV, ~250μA proton beam. To facilitate effective heat removal, these stacked targets are separated and cooled via a series of water channels. At these beam currents, this high-energy proton beam heats the target system, likely initiating subcooled flow boiling in the cooling channels. However, in-beam monitoring of the IPF target system is not possible due to the extreme radiation environment, and the necessarily significant shielding. To better understand high-power target performance, we developed ex-situ experimental and computational frameworks to predict the behavior of subcooled flow boiling at IPF. Subcooled flow boiling experiments on Inconel 625 samples under IPF conditions (2 bar pressure, 10 GPM flow rate (i.e., 2249 kg/m 2 /s), 85 K subcooling) revealed that IPF's average operating power is at the early stage of boiling with a heat transfer coefficient of 48,000 W/m 2 /s. The proposed modeling framework enables us to predict a complete boiling curve, i.e., single-phase heat transfer, onset of nucleate boiling, two-phase heat transfer, and critical heat flux (CHF), with specification of input boiling parameters up to intermediate heat flux levels. The estimated CHF under IPF conditions is 5.2 MW/m 2 . Experimental data under reduced conditions (2 bar pressure, 1.5 GPM flow rate (i.e., 337 kg/m 2 /s), 45 K subcooling) served as validation cases for the computational modeling. This computational model can be further extended to more complicated systems replicating the real IPF configuration, for instance, to study void distribution as a function of the incident proton beam profile and coolant velocity profile of multiple cooling channels. Finally, the proposed experimental and computational frameworks provide a means to better understand cooling systems in the isotope production facilities at different accelerators, where in-beam monitoring of the cooling process is not available.

07 ISOTOPE AND RADIATION SOURCES↗
DOE OSTI2022

Automated bubble analysis of high-speed subcooled flow boiling images using U-net transfer learning and global optical flow

Capturing and analyzing the bubble dynamics is crucial to improving the understanding of boiling heat transfer mechanisms and predicting boiling heat transfer coefficient and boiling crisis. High speed video (HSV) imaging has been used for decades towards this end. Still, there is no universal approach to quantitatively analyze bubble dynamics from HSV images. In this study, we propose a data-driven post-processing approach to segment, track, and identify wall-attached vapor bubbles from HSV images of the boiling process in subcooled flow conditions. Firstly, we employ a transfer learning framework with a U-Net-based convolution neural network (CNN) architecture to detect and segment bubbles in HSV images of diverse contrast and surface texture using very little data (e.g., 10 images) for training. Then, we evaluate the trained CNN model with 100 ground-truth images, and the validation results show that the model accuracy and precision in detecting the optical footprint of bubbles are higher than 90%. Finally, we suggest a criterion to identify a condensing bubble based on the divergence of the bubble displacement, which is calculated from sequential segmented bubble images using a global optical flow code. Using this combination of machine learning and optical flow, we can identify nucleation sites and track the growth of bubbles nucleating at each site to quantify nucleation site density, nucleation frequency, and other fundamental boiling parameters. The proposed system is validated using results obtained on a special heater, which enables both infrared (IR) thermometry and HSV imaging on a metallic surface. We compare the fundamental boiling parameters obtained by the two different diagnostics. The results show good agreement. In conclusion, the difference between the measurements of nucleation site density, averaged nucleation frequency, and averaged growth time performed with the two techniques is always within ± 20% and mostly ± 10% of the values measured with IR thermometry.

42 ENGINEERING↗
DOE OSTI2022

Effect of PVD-coated chromium on the subcooled flow boiling performance of nuclear reactor cladding materials

Here we elucidate the separate effect of a thin Cr coating deposited by physical vapor deposition (PVD) on the subcooled flow boiling performance of zircaloy-4. First, we run flow boiling experiments on prototypical zircaloy-4 surfaces mimicking the scratch pattern and surface roughness of nuclear reactor claddings. Then, we PVD-coat a 0.3 µm thick chromium layer on the same exact surface and repeat the same flow boiling investigations. All experiments are run using deionized water at atmospheric pressure, flowing on a 1 × 3 cm 2 rectangular cross section channel at a rate of 1000 kg/m 2 /s and a subcooling of 10 K. We measure the average temperature of the boiling surface at increasing surface heat fluxes, covering a wide range of heat transfer regimes, from single-phase forced convection to the boiling crisis. We also record high-speed videos of the boiling process, which we postprocess to measure bubble nucleation site density, growth time, departure diameter and frequency. The surface analysis reveals that, while the chromium coating does not seem change the surface roughness and morphology, it improves surface wettability. However, it decreases the critical heat flux. The chromium coating causes an increase of nucleation temperature, bubble departure diameter and growth time, and a reduction of the nucleation site density. The concurrence of these observations indicates that a size reduction of the nucleation sites, conformally covered by the chromium coating, may be the cause of the boiling performance deterioration. We confirm this hypothesis repeating the same analysis on a FeCrAl sample prepared and tested using the same protocol as the zircaloy-4 sample, but with a different initial surface texture.

32 ENERGY CONSERVATION, CONSUMPTION, AND UTILIZATI↗
DOE OSTI2020

Force Balance Model Assessment for Mechanistic Prediction of Sliding Bubble Velocity in Vertical Subcooled Boiling Flow

The bubble sliding after departing from nucleation site is frequently observed in flow boiling systems and, the crucial impact on wall heat transfer has been evidenced through many experiments. As a result, the heat transfer modeling associated with sliding bubble has become one of the subjects of great attention in CFD boiling heat transfer community. The modeling efforts are primarily aimed at improving the existing Heat Flux Partitioning (HFP) model via the implementation of sliding bubble-induced heat transfer. The performance of HFP model depends inherently on the fidelity of sub-models used to predict the fundamental bubble parameters (e.g., bubble departure/lift-off diameter). In the same context, the accurate prediction of sliding bubble parameters (e.g., sliding bubble growth, sliding bubble velocity) is essential to achieving the successful heat transfer modeling associated with sliding bubble. Of many sliding bubble parameters, this paper deals with the sliding bubble velocity. Specifically, the force balance model was assessed in view of the sliding bubble velocity prediction. The parametric effect of key sub-models (e.g., drag force, bubble growth models) used in the force balance equation was investigated. The experimental data from Maity (2000) and Yoo et al. (2016) were used for demonstrating the model predictive performance. It was found that the force balance model proposed in this study was able to predict well the bubble sliding velocity based on the accurate prediction of bubble growth during sliding. The predictive performance was proven with the experimental data measured under various subcooled boiling conditions of both water and refrigerant (NOVEC-7000) flowing upward in vertical channels.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗
DOE OSTI2020

Achievements and Ongoing Challenges for advanced CFD Boiling Closure Model Development using Physical Insights from Validation-Oriented High-Fidelity Boiling Experiment

The fundamental understanding of the boiling-associated heat transfer, including sliding bubble effect, is still challenging despite the intensive research for decades in both experimental and computational boiling research communities. One of the main difficulties of boiling experiment come from the fact that direct observation of the underlying principle through experiment is very difficult due to the high complexity of the boiling phenomenon. Also, since the heat transfer characteristics associated with boiling is the result of non-linear interaction of various physical parameters coupled to each other, it is challenging to find the relationship between the parameters for modeling. This paper discusses the authors’ past and ongoing boiling research under CASL (Consortium for Advanced Simulation of Light Water Reactors) program, including the efforts to overcome the difficulties of boiling measurement and model development. In particular, we focus on describing the major achievements, lessons learnt, and ongoing challenges for the CFD boiling closure model development based on the high-fidelity subcooled flow boiling experiment at Texas A&M University (TAMU). The major research achievements discussed through this paper include (i) novel boiling measurement strategy and high-fidelity validation data production, (ii) dedicated effort to identify the critical measurement issues in boiling experiment, (iii) new physical insight into sliding bubble heat transfer mechanisms, and (iv) new boiling closure model development. Discussion is also made on the ongoing challenges for the boiling closure model development and the future research plan based on the lessons learnt.

42 ENGINEERING↗
DOE OSTI2019

Assessment on DNB performance for high pressure subcooled boiling with modified CASL boiling model

Understanding and predicting the Departure from Nucleation Boiling phenomena in the nuclear power industry has been a grand challenge due to its large impact on the reactor safety and operational economics. Over the past several years, CASL THM team has extensively investigated and demonstrated a state of art Multiphase CFD framework to provide a high-fidelity DNB simulation capability based on the two-fluid Eulerian model in conjunction with a wall heat flux partitioning approach. The overarching goal of this task is to develop and demonstrate a robust CFD-based DNB model which is capable of predicting an entire boiling history up to the DNB condition in which the wall boiling mode is transitioning from the nucleate boiling mode to the film boiling mode. Three different flow channel configurations (pipe flow, 5x5 fuel bundle with and without mixing vane tests) were studied and thorough closure sensitivity studies were performed to evaluate the wall boiling and momentum closure effect on the DNB performance. Predicated DNB values were compared to the measurements from high pressure subcooled flow boiling tests resulting in a consistent under-predictive trend for all three validation campaigns in FY16-18. With extensive closure sensitivity study, a modified CASL boiling closure model (i.e. Gen1-FY19) is introduced with the following key changes: 1) improved wall boiling closure for high pressure application, 2) newly calibrated lift and wall lubrication force models with modified interfacial length scale model, and 3) updated liquid phase condensation model calibrated for the subcooled boiling application.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗
DOE OSTI2026

A non-intrusive framework using acoustic signals and deep learning for boiling diagnostics in visual-limited environments

Accurate monitoring of boiling heat transfer is critical for safeguarding high-power systems operating in environments where conventional optical diagnostics are hindered by radiation fields or restricted visual accessibility. This study presents a non-intrusive framework that integrates hydroacoustic sensing with deep learning to infer near-wall boiling characteristics and enable predictive thermal assessment without visual access. In a prototypical subcooled flow-boiling facility representative of the Isotope Production Facility (IPF) at Los Alamos, hydrophones capture boiling-induced acoustic emissions that are transformed into background-removed Short-Time Fourier Transform (STFT) spectrograms. A convolutional neural network (CNN) then regresses heat flux, wall superheat, and key bubble parameters directly from these spectrograms. The CNN achieved predictive accuracy under nominal conditions and demonstrated robustness and generalization under acoustic noise for Signal-to-Noise Ratios (SNRs) down to approximately 0 dB. When integrated into an ANSYS CFX wall-boiling model, the acoustically inferred parameters reproduced boiling curve and critical heat flux (CHF) values consistent with image-based benchmarks. Furthermore, the model retained reliable performance under moderate variations in bulk temperature, flow rate, and hydrophone placement, confirming its generalizability across practical boundary conditions. These results demonstrate the feasibility of hydroacoustic-based deep learning as a viable path toward real-time, radiation-tolerant boiling diagnostics and predictive thermal safety assessment in inaccessible systems such as the IPF.

42 ENGINEERING↗
DOE OSTI2020

Two-phase flow measurements and observations in a cooling panel of the reactor cavity cooling system

The analysis of the flow behavior within a cooling panel of a scaled water-cooled reactor cavity cooling system has been performed supported by high-resolution measurements of the void fraction at the risers’ outlet. The results have shown a stable, symmetric distribution of the flow through the risers during subcooled boiling conditions, characterized by small, slow bubbles with average void fraction lower than 0.3 for all risers. As the temperature increased to saturation, flow distribution appeared strongly asymmetrical and unstable, with peaks of void fraction as high as 0.9. Large, faster bubbles were observed during these peaks, immediately followed by flow of subcooled liquid water. Flow stagnation and inversion has also been observed. The high resolution void fraction results, complemented by the measurements of the coolant flow rate and temperatures, not only have further described the behavior of the system under hypothetical accident conditions, but represent a unique set of data to support the validation of system-level codes, and more advanced computational tools.

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗
DOE OSTI2018

Predicting departure from nucleate boiling with advanced data- and physics-driven approaches

The subcooled and low-quality saturated flow boiling critical heat flux (CHF) corresponding to the departure from nucleate boiling (DNB) is one of the major limiting factors in the design and operation of pressurized water reactors (PWRs). Due to lack of agreement on its physical mechanisms, development of an accurate DNB-type CHF model has been elusive. The various steady-state (SS) predictive tools that have been proposed can be grouped into two categories: (1) data-driven methods—namely best-fit empirical correlations and look-up tables that result in relatively good agreement with specific experimental datasets but often fail to extend beyond their ranges of validity, and (2) the physics-based mechanistic models that rely on reasonable yet limited understanding of the underlying physics and apply constitutive relations to close the conservation equations. On one hand, with recent advances in computational capabilities and optimization techniques, machine learning (ML)-based methods constitute an alternative and a more advanced, data-driven approach. With enough data, they can be particularly useful in engineering fields where the physical phenomena are complex and challenging to model. On the other hand, a state-of-the-art physics-driven approach would not only provide more accurate prediction of SS CHF, but it would also help better understand and model transient applications. The data-driven regression models use deep feed-forward neural networks (NNs) and random forests to cross-validate with 1,865 CHF test cases, covering a wide range of flow conditions and channel geometries. The best-estimate ML-based predictors compare favorably with the widely used look-up table for annulus and plate, and sensitivity analysis has confirmed their effectiveness. The key advantage of ML-based methods is their online extensibility of applicability domain. The proposed physics-driven approach combines key assumptions and parameters in the relatively well-accepted theories of liquid sublayer dryout and near-wall bubble crowding. A more realistic understanding of local mechanisms has been modeled. The new model has been optimized and validated against 1,439 tube data, and it shows considerably improved performance when compared to a recent mechanistic model, demonstrating unbiased close agreement with measurements over a wide range of operating conditions. Future work will extend the improved physics-driven model to non-tube geometry applications and will couple the model with ML via a hybrid approach. The mechanistic SS work will also serve to improve understanding and to model transient CHF scenarios.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗
DOE OSTI2020

Power Generation Cycle with RELAP-7

Balance of plant of a High-Temperature gas-cooled Reactor – Pebble bed Module (HTR-PM) is modeled using RELAP-7. The model includes the primary helium loop where the heat produced by the core is transferred to a helical-coil steam generator and the secondary loop where super-heated steam is fed to a turbine to extract power. The steam is then condensed to subcooled water and pumped back into the steam generator. Results demonstrate that RELAP-7 has the capability to model different regimes encountered in two-phase flow with wall boiling, superheated steam, subcooled liquid and condensation. RELAP-7 also has the capability of modeling different fluids with their own specific models in a very flexible way, without any code change. This also demonstrates the capability of modeling the transfer of fission power into electrical power.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗
DOE OSTI2021

Recent progresses on thermal–hydraulics evaluations of accident tolerant fuel cladding materials

Thermal–hydraulics (T-H) experiments have been on the progress to evaluate boiling heat transfer characteristics of accident tolerant fuel (ATF) candidates for further supporting the core-loading of these advanced ATF concepts in light water reactors (LWRs). Here this study covers recent experimental studies of ATF claddings and summarizes some significant results. Recent T-H experimental results of ATF cladding candidates demonstrated that the material thermal–physical properties have pronounced effects on critical heat flux (CHF). Such effects have not been well resolved in the current physics-governing models. These effects of cladding materials on CHF could be potentially rationalized by the material-conjugated boiling heat transfer, where the material-dominated heat conduction competes with the flow boiling-dominated heat convection. As progressively increasing the mass flux and/or liquid subcooling, CHF differences between different materials gradually decrease, which is in agreement with the recent T-H experimental results of ATF claddings. This is because the dominance of heat convection over heat conduction is primarily improved by liquid subcooling and/or mass flow rate. It is noteworthy that surface oxidization of claddings may have unknown impacts on T-H performances because the formation of oxide layers on cladding surfaces introduces variations of material thermal–physical properties and then changes the surface morphological features, which results in some difficulties in evaluating the thermal safety margins of ATF claddings.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2020

Elucidating the Impact of Flow on Material-Sensitive Critical Heat Flux and Boiling Heat Transfer Coefficients: An Experimental Study with Various Materials

In this work, steady-state internal flow boiling critical heat flux (CHF) experiments were carried out at 10°C inlet subcooling and atmospheric pressure (84 kPa at an altitude of about 5300 feet) with mass flux ranging from 200 to 2,000 kg/m 2 -s on seven tube materials, including the accident-tolerant fuel cladding candidate FeCrAl (C26M) alloy. At a relatively low flow rate, the sensitivity of CHF to different materials was appreciable (the average difference among the tested materials was 19% at 200 kg/m 2 -s). As the absolute CHF differences stayed constant for higher flow rates, the increased flow rate led to reduced relative CHF differences among the tested materials (average relative difference of 15% at 1,000 kg/m 2 -s). FeCrAl alloy claddings that were oxidized under simulated Light Water Reactor (LWR) conditions yielded CHF comparable to as-received FeCrAl alloy cladding, with less than 1.8% difference. Experimental CHF results imply marginal material sensitivity impacts on the departure from nucleate boiling ratio in steady-state nuclear reactor cores. Yet, for accident progression analysis, material sensitivity may hold importance, as boiling behavior variation at low mass flux is appreciable. Macroscopic material parameters (surface wettability, surface roughness, and thermal properties) do not provide a suitable explanation for observed material-sensitive CHFs. Yet, surface roughness and thermal effusivity revealed power and linear relations, respectively, to the nucleate boiling heat transfer coefficients at low mass flux. At high mass flux, material sensitivity on nucleate boiling heat transfer significantly decreased due to the increased shear stress on boiling surface overwhelming material-related boiling implications.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2024

Flow reversal benchmark of a one-sided heated narrow rectangular channel with CATHARE and RELAP5

Flow reversal in narrow coolant channels can be a crucial phenomenon for the safety of research reactors with a downward nominal flow direction. During a loss of forced flow accident, the downward flow stagnates briefly before transitioning into an upward natural circulation flow. The fuel may be damaged if dryout occurs and threshold fuel and/or cladding temperatures are exceeded. A comprehensive study is provided for flow reversal in narrow rectangular channels by examining experimental data and conducting software model analyses. The literature on flow reversal was reviewed, and selected experimental datasets were used to benchmark against CATHARE and RELAP5 models and also compare the code calculations with each other. The experimental data comes from flow reversal tests conducted with a narrow rectangular channel with one-sided heating. The results were compared with experimental data for successful flow reversal tests and predicted dryout power for dryout conditions. Also, the study examined the effects of the pump coastdown period, inlet liquid temperature, system pressure, and localized pressure drops. The experimental results showed that shorter coastdown periods, reduced pressure drops, and lower coolant inlet temperatures increased the dryout power. However, the system pressure did not noticeably affect the results. The simulation results showed that both CATHARE and RELAP5 agreed with experimental data, capturing the trends of the experimental results. Slight differences between each code calculation, as well as the predicted and measured dryout powers, were attributed to experimental uncertainties and the modeling of physical phenomena such as wall nucleation, interfacial heat transfer, drag coefficients, and critical heat flux. Overall, this study provides an understanding of flow reversal and the prediction capabilities of thermal-hydraulics software models. In conclusion, a future study of the flow reversal benchmark of a narrow rectangular channel with two-sided heating may provide additional valuable insights.

CATHARE↗
DOE OSTI2018

Interface Tracking Investigation of Geometric Effects on the Bubbly Flow in PWR Subchannels

We report that absorbing heat from the fuel rod surface, water as coolant can undergo subcooled boiling within a pressurized water reactor (PWR) fuel rod bundle. Because of the buoyancy effect, the vapor bubbles generated will then rise along and interact with the subchannel geometries. Reliable prediction of bubble behavior is of immense importance to ensure safe and stable reactor operation. However, given a complex engineering system like a nuclear reactor, it is very challenging (if not impossible) to conduct high-resolution measurements to study bubbly flows under reactor operation conditions. The lack of a fundamental two-phase-flow database is hindering the development of accurate two-phase-flow models required in more advanced reactor designs. In response to this challenge, first-principles–based numerical simulations are emerging as an attractive alternative to produce a complementary data source along with experiments. Leveraged by the unprecedented computing power offered by state-of-the-art supercomputers, direct numerical simulation (DNS), coupled with interface tracking methods, is becoming a practical tool to investigate some of the most challenging engineering flow problems. In the presented research, turbulent bubbly flow is simulated via DNS in single PWR subchannel geometries with auxiliary structures (e.g., supporting spacer grid and mixing vanes). The geometric effects these structures exert on the bubbly flow are studied with both a conventional time-averaging approach and a novel dynamic bubble tracking method. Lastly, the new insights obtained will help inform better two-phase models that can contribute to safer and more efficient nuclear reactor systems.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗