Why Are 5-Thioglycopyranosyl Donors More Axially Selective than their Glycopyranosyl Counterparts? A Low and Variable Temperature NMR Spectroscopy and Computational Study
5-Thioglycopyranosyl donors differ in reactivity and selectivity from simple glycopyranosyl donors. An extensive study has been conducted on the nature and stability of the reactive intermediates generated on the activation of per-O-acetyl and per-O-methyl 5-thioglucopyranosyl donors and the corresponding glucopyranosyl donors. Variable temperature nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) studies with per-O-methylated or per-O-acetyl glycosyl sulfoxides and trichloroacetimidates on activation with trifluoromethanesulfonic anhydride or trimethylsilyl triflate are reported. These show that following initial adduct formation with the promoter conversion of the 5-thioglucopyranosyl donors to the 5-thioglucopyranosyl triflates requires higher temperatures than that of the glucopyranosyl donors to the glucopyranosyl triflates. It is demonstrated that neighboring group participation is a less important phenomenon for the peracetylated thioglucosyl donors than for the peracetylated glucosyl donors. A simple thiocarbenium ion was generated by protonation of 2,3-dihydro-4H-thiopyran at low temperature and characterized by NMR spectroscopy. However, the corresponding 5-thioglucopyranosyl thenium ions were not observed in any of the NMR studies of the 5-thiopyranosyl donors: the electron-withdrawing C–O bonds around the thiopyranoside core discourage thiocarbenium ion formation, just as they discourage oxocarbenium ion formation. Density functional theory (DFT) calculations reveal the tetrahydrothiopyranyl thiocarbenium ion to be approximately 2.5 kcal/mol lower in energy than the corresponding tetrahydropyranyl oxocarbenium ion relative to the corresponding covalent triflates. However, the computations reveal a 5.8 kcal/mol activation barrier for conversion of the tetrahydrothiopyranyl triflate to the thiocarbenium ion, while formation of the oxocarbenium ion–triflate ion pair from tetrahydropyranyl triflate requires only 2.6 kcal·mol –1 . Overall, the greater axial selectivity of 5-thioglycopyranosyl donors compared to analogous glycopyranosyl donors derives from (i) the lower kinetic reactivity necessitating higher reaction temperatures, (ii) the greater stability of the thiocarbenium ion over the oxocarbenium ion facilitating equilibration under thermodynamic conditions, (iii) the greater magnitude of the anomeric effect in the 5-thiosugars, and (iv) decreased neighboring group participation in the per-esterified 5-thiosugars.