Results for “Tow steering”

NASA NTRS2016

Imperfection Insensitivity Analyses of Advanced Composite Tow-Steered Shells

Two advanced composite tow-steered shells, one with tow overlaps and another without overlaps, were previously designed, fabricated and tested in end compression, both without cutouts, and with small and large cutouts. In each case, good agreement was observed between experimental buckling loads and supporting linear bifurcation buckling analyses. However, previous buckling tests and analyses have shown historically poor correlation, perhaps due to the presence of geometric imperfections that serve as failure initiators. For the tow-steered shells, their circumferential variation in axial stiffness may have suppressed this sensitivity to imperfections, leading to the agreement noted between tests and analyses. To investigate this further, a numerical investigation was performed in this study using geometric imperfections measured from both shells. Finite element models of both shells were analyzed first without, and then, with measured imperfections that were then, superposed in different orientations around the shell longitudinal axis. Small variations in both the axial prebuckling stiffness and global buckling load were observed for the range of imperfections studied here, which suggests that the tow steering, and resulting circumferentially varying axial stiffness, may result in the test-analysis correlation observed for these shells.

Wu, K. Chauncey↗

NASA NTRSDate not supplied

A Design Framework for Thick and Thin Tow-Steered Composites Using Mechanics of Structure Genome

The design of tow-steered composites is one of the most popular and promising topics under the class of variable stiffness structures. In this work, the authors propose a new design framework and tool for the optimization of tow-steered composites. Mechanics of structure genome (MSG) provides accurate computation of plate/shell section properties including thick and highly curved structures. The computed section properties can be directly used in commercial computer-aided engineering tools. Tow-steered composites are modeled through a design framework wherein tow paths are parameterized in a general way and projected onto a finite element mesh, and MSG calculates the local shell/plate properties. The result is a complete workflow from design parameter input to structural performance evaluation. An open-source optimization software package is used to enable constrained optimization of structural stiffness for the broad tow-steered composite design space. Numerical examples are provided to demonstrate the capabilities of this tool and the promise and potential of tow-steered designs that optimize structural performance while satisfying manufacturing constraints.

Su Tian↗

NASA NTRSDate not supplied

A Design Framework for Thick and Thin Tow-Steered Composites Using Mechanics of Structure Genome

The design of tow-steered composites is one of the most popular and promising topics under the class of variable stiffness structures. In this work, the authors propose a new design framework and tool for the optimization of tow-steered composites. Mechanics of structure genome (MSG) provides accurate computation of plate/shell section properties including thick and highly curved structures. The computed section properties can be directly used in commercial computer-aided engineering tools. Tow-steered composites are modeled through a design framework wherein tow paths are parameterized in a general way and projected onto a finite element mesh, and MSG calculates the local shell/plate properties. The result is a complete workflow from design parameter input to structural performance evaluation. An open-source optimization software package is used to enable constrained optimization of structural stiffness for the broad tow-steered composite design space. Numerical examples are provided to demonstrate the capabilities of this tool and the promise and potential of tow-steered designs that optimize structural performance while satisfying manufacturing constraints.

Su Tian↗

NASA NTRSDate not supplied

An Integrated Design Tool for Tow-Steered Laminates of Composites in Abaqus and MSC.Patran/Nastran

Tow-steered composites can be tailored for optimal mechanical performance of lightweight structures. However, there are no commercial-grade design tools for tow-steered composite structures, which hinders the design innovation of tow-steered composites in realistic structures. The novelty of this paper is to develop an integrated design framework along with the development of graphical user interface (GUI) plug-ins in commercial finite element (FE) software Abaqus and MSC.Patran/Nastran. The GUI plug-ins take all the design setups and communicate with external codes for the material modeling and optimization, and hence provide a unified design environment within the FE codes. The mechanics of structure genome (MSG) plate model computes shell element properties based on user-defined fiber paths and layup, which are defined via the GUI plug-ins. The optimization is performed by an open-source code, Dakota, from Sandia National Laboratories (Sandia), which also coordinates the structural analysis, material modeling, and optimization in design iterations. Two examples are presented to demonstrate the user-friendliness and versatility of the developed GUI plug-ins. The developed tools will ease the design process and facilitate the application of tow-steered composites in realistic aerospace structures.

Xin Liu↗

NASA NTRSDate not supplied

An Integrated Design Tool for Tow-Steered Laminates of Composites in Abaqus and MSC.Patran/Nastran

Tow-steered composites can be tailored for optimal mechanical performance of lightweight structures. However, there are no commercial-grade design tools for tow-steered composite structures, which hinders the design innovation of tow-steered composites in realistic structures. The novelty of this paper is to develop an integrated design framework along with the development of graphical user interface (GUI) plug-ins in commercial finite element (FE) software Abaqus and MSC.Patran/Nastran. The GUI plug-ins take all the design setups and communicate with external codes for the material modeling and optimization, and hence provide a unified design environment within the FE codes. The mechanics of structure genome (MSG) plate model computes shell element properties based on user-defined fiber paths and layup, which are defined via the GUI plug-ins. The optimization is performed by an open-source code, Dakota, from Sandia National Laboratories (Sandia), which also coordinates the structural analysis, material modeling, and optimization in design iterations. Two examples are presented to demonstrate the user-friendliness and versatility of the developed GUI plug-ins. The developed tools will ease the design process and facilitate the application of tow-steered composites in realistic aerospace structures.

Xin Liu↗

NASA NTRSDate not supplied

The Effect of Fiber-Angle Fidelity on the Linear Response of Tow-steered Composite Plates

Composite laminate tailoring is traditionally performed by uniformly changing the in-plane ply orientation to obtain the desired mechanical performance. The emergence of tow-steered plies, where the fibers follow a prescribed curvilinear path, have increased the tailorability of composite laminates. However, characterizing the behavior of tow-steered laminates using finite element analysis is challenging because additional, and often numerous, orientation definitions may be required. The additional orientation definitions detrimentally increase the computational cost and hinder the use of advanced analysis techniques, such as Monte Carlo or uncertainty quantification, in the design process. To reduce computational cost without adversely affecting mechanics-based performance, the results of a parametric study that was used to investigate the effects of fiber-angle fidelity, element size, and tow-steered radius-of-curvature on various loading scenarios for tow-steered composite plates are presented. The three loading scenarios that were analyzed using finite element analysis included an axial tension load, an applied constant through-thickness-direction pressure load, and an axial compression load. Results for mechanics-based metrics of interest are presented and discussed for each loading scenario. Little sensitivity (less than one percent difference) to the effect of fiber-angle fidelity is observed in the mechanics-based metrics until the coarse-end of the considered range. Sensitivity to element size generally dominates the observed results for the mechanics-based metrics. Notable reductions in the preprocessing time are observed for increasingly coarse element size and fiber-rounding parameters. The preprocessing times decreased up to three orders of magnitude from a few thousand seconds to a few seconds without loss of accuracy in the mechanics-based metrics. Such increased computational performance is of particular interest to the structural design and analysis communities that may be conducting large counts of finite-element analyses, such as in other parametric studies, Monte-Carlo analyses, uncertainty quantification, or tow-steered optimization.

tow-steered composites↗

NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Structural Sizing of a Tow-Steered Truss-Braced Wing Box Test Article

Tailoring of composite laminates is traditionally performed by changing the orientation of straight fibers in one or more plies. Modern automated fiber placement machines facilitate placement of bundles of curved fibers (tows) in a process called tow-steering, but additional variables must be used to define the shapes of tow-steered fiber paths. In this paper, the design of a tow-steered truss-braced wing test article called the Structural Wing Experiment Evaluating Truss-bracing 15-ft concept (SWEET-15) is discussed. The SWEET-15 test article is scaled to 18.6% of the span length and chord width of a full-scale vehicle. The test article is designed to withstand +2.5-g (positive limit) and -1.0-g (negative limit) maneuvering loads with a factor of safety of 1.5 under strength and buckling constraints. Design studies were performed using commercial finite element analysis and optimization software in conjunction with a tow-steering modeling tool called ATSCOOL (Automated Tool for Steered COmposite Optimizable Laminates) developed at NASA Langley Research center. A 6.4% weight reduction in the upper cover panels was achieved using a tow-steered layup configuration.

Structural Optimization↗

NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Structural Sizing of a Tow-Steered Truss-Braced Wing Box Test Article

Tailoring of composite laminates is traditionally performed by changing the orientation of straight fibers in one or more plies. Modern automated fiber placement machines facilitate placement of bundles of curved fibers (tows) in a process called tow-steering, but additional variables must be used to define the shapes of tow-steered fiber paths. In this paper, the design of a tow-steered truss-braced wing test article called the Structural Wing Experiment Evaluating Truss-bracing 15-ft concept (SWEET-15) is discussed. The SWEET-15 test article is scaled to 18.6% of the span length and chord width of a full-scale vehicle. The test article is designed to withstand +2.5-g (positive limit) and -1.0-g (negative limit) maneuvering loads with a factor of safety of 1.5 under strength and buckling constraints. Design studies were performed using commercial finite element analysis and optimization software in conjunction with a tow-steering modeling tool called ATSCOOL (Automated Tool for Steered COmposite Optimizable Laminates) developed at NASA Langley Research center. A 6.4% weight reduction in the upper cover panels was achieved using a tow-steered layup configuration.

Composites↗

NASA NTRS2023

A Tool for Defining Tow-Steered Laminates for Finite Element Grids

Tailoring of composite laminates is traditionally performed by changing the orientation of straight fibers in one or more plies. Modern automated fiber placement machines facilitate placement of bundles of curved fibers (tows) in a process called tow-steering, but additional variables must be used to define the shapes of tow-steered fiber paths. In this paper, a Python-based tool, called Automated Tool for Steered COmposite Optimizable Laminates (ATSCOOL), is presented for modeling steered tows as chains of circular arcs. The geometry for defining tow path shapes using four input variables is described. The formulae for determining gaps and overlaps between clusters of consecutive tows, called courses, and for determining the number of steered courses needed to cover a rectangular panel are presented. Graphical representation of courses and thickness distribution in an example panel using the ATSCOOL software are presented. Finally, an example of a finite element analysis performed using the property information output from ATSCOOL is shown.

finite element analysis↗

NASA NTRS2005

Enhancements of Tow-Steering Design Techniques: Design of Rectangular Panel Under Combined Loads

An extension to existing design tools that utilize tow-steering is presented which is used to investigate the use of elastic tailoring for a flat panel with a central hole under combined loads of compression and shear. The elastic tailoring is characterized by tow-steering within individual lamina as well as a novel approach based on selective reinforcement, which attempts to minimize compliance through the use of Cellular Automata design concepts. The selective reinforcement designs lack any consideration of manufacturing constraints, so a new tow-steered path definition was developed to translate the prototype selective reinforcement designs into manufacturable plies. The minimum weight design of a flat panel under combined loading was based on a model provided by NASA-Langley personnel and analyzed by STAGS within the OLGA design environment. Baseline designs using traditional straight fiber plies were generated, as well as tow-steered designs which incorporated parallel, tow-drop, and overlap plies within the laminate. These results indicated that the overlap method provided the best improvement with regards to weight and performance as compared to traditional constant stiffness monocoque panels, though the laminates did not measure up to similar designs from the literature using sandwich and isogrid constructions. Further design studies were conducted using various numbers of the selective reinforcement plies at the core and outer surface of the laminate. None of these configurations exhibited notable advantages with regard to weight or buckling performance. This was due to the fact that the minimization of the compliance tended to direct the major stresses toward the center of the panel, which decreased the ability of the structure to withstand loads leading to instability.

Tatting, Brian F.↗

NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Nonlinear Buckling Analysis of Tow-Steered Composite Cylinders with Cutouts

The buckling and postbuckling behavior of two composite tow-steered shells with cutouts of different sizes is assessed using nonlinear finite element (FE) analysis and compared to experimental measurements. The cylindrical shells are manufactured using an automated fiber placement system, where the shells’ fiber orientation angles vary continuously around the shell circumference from 10 degrees on the crown and keel to 45 degrees on the sides. One shell features thickness variations due to tow overlaps that result from application of all 24 tows during each pass of the fiber placement system. The second shell uses the system’s tow drop/add capability to achieve a more uniform wall thickness without overlaps. Unreinforced cutouts of two different sizes—the first smaller cutout representing a passenger door on a commercial aircraft and the second larger cutout a cargo door—were machined into each of the two cylinders resulting in a total of four test cases. These cylinders were tested in axial compression and buckled elastically in previous work and are now analyzed using nonlinear FE models to compare bifurcation buckling loads as well as the load-displacement response in the prebuckling and postbuckling regimes. For all four shells analyzed, the prebuckling stiffness, buckling load, and deformation mode sequence throughout the loading-unloading cycle is accurately reproduced by the models. In particular, the shells first buckle locally around the cutouts in a stable (super-critical) manner with only a slight decrease in axial stiffness, which occurs due to the favorable load redistribution facilitated by tow steering. The shells then buckle globally in an unstable (sub-critical) manner with diamond-shaped buckles forming to the left and right of the cutouts. The buckling load of all shells with cutouts is at least 82% of the buckling load of the pristine shells without cutouts. Overall, the ability to sustain local buckling phenomena, and the relatively small reductions in global buckling load compared to pristine shells without cutouts, demonstrates the great potential of using tow steering to mitigate the adverse effects of cutouts in axially-compressed shell structures.

Buckling↗

NASA NTRS2014

Aeroelastic Tailoring via Tow Steered Composites

The use of tow steered composites, where fibers follow prescribed curvilinear paths within a laminate, can improve upon existing capabilities related to aeroelastic tailoring of wing structures, though this tailoring method has received relatively little attention in the literature. This paper demonstrates the technique for both a simple cantilevered plate in low-speed flow, as well as the wing box of a full-scale high aspect ratio transport configuration. Static aeroelastic stresses and dynamic flutter boundaries are obtained for both cases. The impact of various tailoring choices upon the aeroelastic performance is quantified: curvilinear fiber steering versus straight fiber steering, certifiable versus noncertifiable stacking sequences, a single uniform laminate per wing skin versus multiple laminates, and identical upper and lower wing skins structures versus individual tailoring.

Stanford, Bret K.↗

NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Testing and Analyses of Advanced Composite Tow-Steered Shells with Cutouts

The structural response of two composite tow-steered shells with small cutouts in end compression is assessed using analyses and experimental measurements. The cylindrical shells were manufactured without cutouts using an automated fiber placement system, where the shells’ fiber orientation angles vary continuously around the shell circumference from ±10 degrees on the axially stiff crown and keel, to ±45 degrees on the shear-stiff sides. The first shell with overlaps has laminate thickness variations on the crown and keel that result from application of all 24 tows during each pass of the fiber placement system. The second shell without overlaps uses the fiber placement system’s tow drop/add capability to achieve a more uniform shell wall thickness. These shells without cutouts were tested in axial compression and buckled elastically. An unreinforced cutout representative of a passenger door on a commercial aircraft fuselage is machined into one side of each shell. Results from nonlinear finite element analysis are compared with their corresponding load, displacement, and strain measurements in prebuckling through stable postbuckling. Results from tests and analyses of shells with large cutouts are also discussed. The very good agreement observed in this study increases confidence in applying tow-steered composites to operational vehicles.

Tow-Steered↗

NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Nonlinear Buckling Analysis of Tow-Steered Composite Cylinders with Cutouts

The buckling and postbuckling behavior of two composite tow-steered shells with cutouts of different sizes is assessed using nonlinear finite element (FE) analysis and compared to experimental measurements. The cylindrical shells are manufactured using an automated fiber placement system, where the shells’ fiber orientation angles vary continuously around the shell circumference from ±10 degrees on the crown and keel to ±45 degrees on the sides. One shell features thickness variations due to tow overlaps that result from application of all 24 tows during each pass of the fiber placement system. The second shell uses the system’s tow drop/add capability to achieve a more uniform wall thickness without overlaps. Unreinforced cutouts of two different sizes—the first smaller cutout representing a passenger door on a commercial aircraft and the second larger cutout a cargo door—were machined into each of the two cylinders resulting in a total of four test cases. These cylinders were tested in axial compression and buckled elastically in previous work and are now analyzed using nonlinear FE models to compare bifurcation buckling loads as well as the load-displacement response in the prebuckling and postbuckling regimes. For all four shells analyzed, the prebuckling stiffness, buckling load, and deformation mode sequence throughout the loading-unloading cycle is accurately reproduced by the models. In particular, the shells first buckle locally around the cutouts in a stable (super-critical) manner with only a slight decrease in axial stiffness, which occurs due to the favorable load redistribution facilitated by tow steering. The shells then buckle globally in an unstable (sub-critical) manner with diamond-shaped buckles forming to the left and right of the cutouts. The buckling load of all shells with cutouts is at least 82% of the buckling load of the pristine shells without cutouts. Overall, the ability to sustain local buckling phenomena, and the relatively small reductions in global buckling load compared to pristine shells without cutouts, demonstrates the great potential of using tow steering to mitigate the adverse effects of cutouts in axially-compressed shell structures.

composites↗

NASA NTRS2020

Static Loads Testing of a High Aspect Ratio Tow-Steered Wingbox

Static loads testing was performed on a 39-foot, high-aspect-ratio wingbox comprising carbon fiber tow-steered wing skins that were tailored for aircraft fuel efficiency under aeroelastic loads. The test article was designated the Passive Aeroelastic Tailored (PAT) wing. To date, the PAT wing, which has an aspect ratio of 13.5, is the largest wingbox designed and built to employ variably oriented carbon fibers along the span of the wing. During testing, distributed point loads were applied to the wingbox to simulate both -1g and 2.5g maneuver loads. To determine the wingbox’s flexural axis location, individual point loads were applied. The global response of the wing (displacement and rotation measurements) showed similar trends compared to the finite element model predictions, though discrepancies of up to 17% were observed when comparing actual values between model and test. It was concluded that the boundary conditions and nonstructural features of the wingbox were the likely cause of the inconsistencies. The local response of the wingbox (strain measurements), which was much less affected by factors unrelated to tow-steering, exhibited good agreement with the model predictions, validating the modelling techniques employed for tow-steered composites.

Tow-steered composites↗

NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Detection and Localization of a Fold, Twist, and Overlaps within Tow-Steered Composite Panels During Autoclave Cure

Because of the anisotropic properties of carbon fiber reinforced polymer (CRFP) composites, novel layup architectures, such as tow-steering, can be used to tailor mechanical properties of the composite structure to the loading condition during use. In this work, a tow-steered composite panel was de-signed, laid up using the Integrated Structural Assembly of Advanced Com-posites (ISAAC) automated fiber placement (AFP) machine located at the NASA Langley Research Center (LaRC), and cured while simultaneously be-ing inspected using an ultrasonic inspection system operating inside the auto-clave. The composite panel contained overlaps that are intrinsic to the tow-steered design and had intentionally introduced layup defects including folds, wrinkles, splices, tow twists, foreign object debris (FOD), gaps, and additional overlaps. The inspections during the cure cycle focused on the ar-ea within the laminate containing a fold, a twist, and intrinsic overlaps. The ultrasonic inspections performed during the cure cycle were analyzed and compared to post-cure ultrasonic inspections of the entire laminate.

Composites↗

NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Detection and Localization of a Fold, Twist, and Overlaps within Tow-Steered Composite Panels During Autoclave Cure

Because of the anisotropic properties of carbon fiber reinforced polymer (CRFP) composites, novel layup architectures, such as tow-steering, can be used to tailor mechanical properties of the composite structure to the loading condition during use. In this work, a tow-steered composite panel was de-signed, laid up using the Integrated Structural Assembly of Advanced Com-posites (ISAAC) automated fiber placement (AFP) machine located at the NASA Langley Research Center (LaRC), and cured while simultaneously be-ing inspected using an ultrasonic inspection system operating inside the auto-clave. The composite panel contained overlaps that are intrinsic to the tow-steered design and had intentionally introduced layup defects including folds, wrinkles, splices, tow twists, foreign object debris (FOD), gaps, and additional overlaps. The inspections during the cure cycle focused on the ar-ea within the laminate containing a fold, a twist, and intrinsic overlaps. The ultrasonic inspections performed during the cure cycle were analyzed and compared to post-cure ultrasonic inspections of the entire laminate.

Composites↗

NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Local Analysis-Test Correlation Of Tow-Steered Composite Shells With Small Cutouts

The prebuckling and postbuckling behavior of two composite tow-steered shells with small cutouts is assessed using nonlinear dynamic finite element analyses and compared in detail with experimental measurements. The cylindrical shells were manufactured without cutouts using an automated fiber placement system, where the shells’ fiber orientation angles vary continuously around the shell circumference from ±10 degrees on the axially stiff crown and keel, to ±45 degrees on the shear-stiff sides. The first shell with overlaps has laminate thickness variations on the crown and keel that result from application of all 24 tows during each pass of the fiber placement system. The second shell without overlaps uses the fiber placement system’s tow drop/add capability to achieve a more uniform shell wall thickness. An unreinforced cutout representing a passenger door on a commercial aircraft fuselage is machined into the side of each of the two shells. These shells with cutouts were tested in axial compression and buckled elastically in previous work. Detailed nonlinear finite element analysis results are compared with their corresponding measured local load-displacement and load-strain responses in prebuckling, at global buckling, and into a stable postbuckled state. Test data from displacement transducers, strain gages, and digital image correlation are extracted at the centers of the crown and keel, and at the middles of the top and left edges of the cutout. The overall agreement between these measured and analytical responses is excellent in prebuckling through global buckling, and very good from global buckling through postbuckling. As such, the excellent correlation observed here increases confidence in applying tow-steered composites in operational vehicles.

Composites↗