Benchmark Mechanical Test Results of Westinghouse Zirconium Cladding and Irradiated Testing Readiness
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Garrison, Ben [ORNL] (ORCID:0000000316880682)↗
SEARCH · Search NASA
Results for “Zirconium cladding”
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Evaluating transient fission gas release in high burnup light water reactor fuel during loss of coolant accident conditions via new capabilities
In this work, the role of transient fission gas release (tFGR) in the cladding burst behavior of high burnup fuel during a loss-of-coolant accident (LOCA) in commercial light water reactors was further investigated via the use of a new apparatus. During the LOCA-related temperature ramps of high burnup fuel, the release of fission gases exceeds the steady-state release observed under normal operating conditions. An enhancement was made to the Oak Ridge National Laboratory Severe Accident Test Station (SATS) to probe the various factors influencing tFGR. Experiments were performed on commercially irradiated, zirconium-clad uranium dioxide fuel, and this paper details the design of the experimental setup, the initial test results, and the subsequent post-test analyses. Notably, the first test on high burnup fuel demonstrated a LOCA-relevant tFGR of 5.3% from an unpressurized fuel segment. The ultimate tFGR was 10.7% for beyond LOCA conditions. A follow-up test on similar fuel revealed a tFGR of 12.6% under comparable conditions. Microstructural analysis and an analysis of the released gas provide some insight regarding the source of tFGR in the fuel. Finally, a grain boundary bubble model may aid in the interpretation of the results and offer a guide for future work.
11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗
High Burnup Transient Fission Gas Release Testing and Post-Test Examinations
The contribution of transient fission gas release (tFGR) to the burst behavior of high burnup fuel during a loss of coolant accident (LOCA) for commercial light water reactors is a complex phenomenon that is not fully understood. During the temperature ramp associated with a LOCA, there is significant additional transient fission gas release in excess of the steady state fission gas release from normal operation. An addition to the Oak Ridge National Laboratory Severe Accident Test Station (SATS) was created to explore the different conditions that impact transient fission gas release. Four tests on commercially irradiated zirconium clad uranium dioxide nuclear fuel were performed to support transient fission gas release study. These experiments and their post-test analyses are discussed. The first test on high burnup fuel revealed a LOCA relevant transient fission gas release of 5.3% for an unpressurised segment. Subsequent tests have measured transient fission gas release at different conditions that span from 4.8% to 14.4 % transient fission gas release.
22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗
High Temperature High Vacuum Mechanical Property Assessment of Zirconium Nuclear Fuel Cladding
This report presents the mechanical characterization of a specific Zry-4 cladding batch serving as the foundation for a diverse range of fuel performance research at Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL). This effort supports research needs for the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE), particularly regarding evaluating accident tolerant fuel (ATF) cladding coating concepts, expanding understanding of cladding response to loss-of-coolant accidents (LOCA) transients, refining post-critical heat flux (CHF) limits (t@T), and upcoming irradiation campaigns. The central objective was to define the baseline performance of the substrate Zircaloy-4 (Zry-4) material leveraged across ORNL Advanced Fuel Campaign (AFC) efforts through controlled high-temperature vacuum tensile testing. This work begins to address gaps in existing models where implementation based on nominal heat-treatment labels, such as stress relief annealed (SRA), often fail to capture the interplay of recovery, recrystallization, and grain growth. To quantify this, data was benchmarked against the Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL) stress strain model to determine where this material falls in comparison to assumed values for materials in the same heat treatment regime. Analysis of the tensile data revealed that this specific SRA batch exhibits a transitional microstructural state best described by an effective cold-work (CW) parameter of 0.09, diverging from the previous estimation of 0.5 for SRA materials. Additionally, comparative testing of Cr coated specimens demonstrated no distinct difference in axial strength relative to the bare substrate. This suggests that the strengthening benefits of Cr coatings observed in burst scenarios are driven by residual stress mechanisms acting solely in the hoop direction.
11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗
Multilayer Architecture Barriers for High Temperature Nuclear Applications
Innovative thin film multilayer metal/ceramic barrier coatings have been developed by Argonne National Laboratory to protect fuel cladding against different phenomena that can be encountered under the harsh operating conditions of advanced nuclear reactors. One phenomenon is Fuel-Cladding Chemical Interaction (FCCI), which can represent a challenge to the performance of steel-clad metallic fuels in sodium-cooled fast reactors (SFRs), especially when operating to high burnups at elevated cladding temperatures, and long fuel residence time. Another phenomenon is the corrosion of zirconium-based cladding under prototypic boiling water reactor (BWR) conditions and associated cladding during off normal conditions, including loss of coolant accidents (LOCA). This work provides details of the development and testing of a thin film (few microns) multilayer metal/ceramic (CrY/Y 2 O 3 ) coatings on steel cladding and its performance against FCCI. The coating architecture evolved through systematic mechanical testing, radiation tolerance assessments, and high-temperature diffusion studies from a preliminary multilayer concept to an optimized high-performance design. The optimized structure leverages stoichiometric Y 2 O 3 for its exceptional radiation stability, chemical inertness, and ultra-low fission product diffusivity (e.g., Ce diffusivity ~10 -20 m 2 /s in irradiated Y 2 O 3 at 650 °C). This is paired with ductile chromium-rich interlayers (Cr 95 Y 5 ), which significantly enhance fracture toughness and mechanical resilience. Design refinements, including increased ceramic layer thickness and optimized Cr–Y interlayer composition, eliminated fracture propagation and preserved coating integrity under extreme mechanical stress (>10× typical reactor conditions) and prolonged radiation exposure (~300 dpa). Those conditions are well beyond expected conditions during normal operations in SFR, and cover some of the transient conditions as well. In addition, the coating deposition was demonstrated to be applied uniformly to the inner surface of steel tubes representing prototypic SFR cladding. Another phenomenon under consideration in this work is the corrosion of zirconium-based cladding under prototypic boiling water reactor (BWR) conditions and associated off normal conditions including loss of coolant accident (LOCA). Another multilayer thin film coating is considered for mitigation of this phenomenon, where a coating of yttrium aluminum and yttrium aluminum ceramic/metal thin film coating. Preliminary results on the coating performance during high temperature thermal cycling (up to 1000 C) have shown promising performance of the coating. On-going optimization of the coating will continue in FY26.
22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗
PIE-Enabled Study of Aqueous Corrosion & Zr Hydriding in Cr-Coated Cladding: M3GV-23PN0101132
Chromium-coated zirconium alloy cladding is under investigation as an accident-tolerant fuel (ATF) concept to extend performance to higher burnups via improved oxidation resistance and reduced hydrogen pickup. However, hydrothermal corrosion behavior and hydrogen transport mechanisms governing in-service hydriding of these coatings remain poorly understood. In a collaborative study between Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL), Idaho National Laboratory (INL), and the University of Huddersfield, cold spray (CS) and physical vapor deposition (PVD) Cr-coated Optimized ZIRLO™ cladding samples were characterized after exposure to PWR-simulated water chemistry under both in-core (neutron irradiation) and out-of-core (aqueous-only) conditions at the MIT Research Reactor. Multi-scale characterization was performed independently at PNNL and INL to evaluate coating integrity, microstructural evolution, Cr/Zr interface chemistry, and hydride formation. Both laboratories observed a consistent divergence in hydriding behavior: out-of-core CS Cr-coated cladding exhibited elevated hydride concentrations exceeding those of uncoated cladding, whereas in-core CS samples showed substantially suppressed hydriding. In-core specimens also displayed irradiation-specific features, including nanoscale voids within the Cr coating and radiation-induced segregation clusters in the Zr substrate. CS coatings retained an interdiffusion-free Cr/Zr bond with no intermetallic layer, whereas PVD coatings exhibited inferior quality with visible cracks and pores. An automated image-based hydride quantification method systematically overestimated bulk hydrogen content relative to inert gas fusion measurements, underscoring the need for standardized sample preparation and reference standards. Interpretation of hydride nucleation and growth is complicated by the open inner-diameter of the specimens, which provides additional hydrogen pathways. The results motivate further foundational studies to support predictive models of hydrothermal corrosion and hydrogen transport in unirradiated and irradiated Cr-coated cladding.
11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗
ATF Cladding Mechanical Properties Report: Capability Demonstration
This report documents mechanical testing capability demonstration activities performed in fiscal year (FY)2025 at Oak Ridge National Laboratory(ORNL)on chromium-coated (Cr-coated) and uncoated advanced zirconium alloy claddings irradiated in the High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR) to approximately 4 displacements per atom (dpa), corresponding to ~13GWd/t burnup. Specimens were prepared in axial tension (ATT) and ring tension (RTT) geometries, and passive silicon carbide(SiC)thermometry (TM) was employed to determine irradiation temperatures, which averaged 38–43 °C below the 330 °C design target. Mechanical testing at ambient temperature demonstrated the expected irradiation-induced hardening, with yield strength(YS)and ultimate tensile strength(UTS)values increasing substantially relative to unirradiated counterparts. However, this strengthening was accompanied by a reduction in ductility, as indicated by lower uniform and total elongations(UE and TE). Both coated and uncoated claddings exhibited similar mechanical response, though Cr-coated specimens showed surface cracking perpendicular to the loading direction, attributable to the hardness mismatch between the coating and substrate. Fracture in all cases remained ductile, and no coating spallation was observed following HFIR irradiation. Complementary efforts were directed toward the fabrication of test specimens from commercially irradiated cladding (rod 47I, ~31.1 GWd/t average burnup). Axial sectioning and computer numerical control(CNC)machining successfully produced ATT geometries suitable for benchmarking against HFIR-irradiated specimens. This capability enables direct comparison of cladding behavior between test reactor and commercial reactor environments, thereby supporting the validation of HFIR as a surrogate irradiation platform for accident tolerant fuel (ATF) development. Once HFIR irradiations are completed in FY26,the relevant comparison tests will be completed. Collectively, the FY 2025 PIE campaign has provided mechanical performance data for irradiated advanced claddings The demonstrated capabilities support the framework for mechanical testing and further evaluations in subsequent years. These efforts will represent an important contribution toward the licensing and deployment of Cr-coated zirconium alloy cladding as a near-term ATF solution.
36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
Step-loaded creep testing of Zircaloy-4 cladding at higher temperatures in the α-phase
A refined understanding of zirconium-based cladding thermomechanical performance during rapid transients is essential for enhancing the safety and operation of light-water reactors. Traditional models for zirconium alloys under accident conditions generally assume that creep dominates fuel cladding performance. Here, these historic models have largely remained unchanged and serve as the basis for safety criteria development. As the U.S. nuclear industry pursues higher burnup levels, the increased release of fission gases during transients raises the risk of cladding failure in the low-temperature hcp α-phase, making the fidelity of these models of greater importance. Creep testing was conducted from 550–700°C with 25–120 MPa applied hoop stresses to investigate Zircaloy-4 deformation at accident-relevant temperatures in the α-phase. Step-loading was employed to capture creep behavior across a wide stress range from a single sample. The stress-strain rate data at higher temperatures (650 and 700°C) were well-described by isotropic versions of the Erbacher and Kaddour models, while the lower temperature data (550 and 600°C) were underpredicted by both anisotropic and isotropic model variants. Greater strain rates during the initial loading step at 650 and 700°C were attributed to recrystallization and grain growth of sub-micron crystallites. Yet, texture analysis revealed the basal split texture remained after testing. These observations produced results suggesting Zircaloy-4 claddings experience higher creep rates across the α-phase than previously thought, possibly related to dynamic anisotropy due to temperature dependent activation of deformation mechanisms, effects of biaxial loading, and variation in material condition between the current testing used in previous model development.
36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
ATF Cladding Mechanical Properties Report: Capability Demonstration
This report documents post-irradiation examination (PIE) activities performed in FY 2025 at Oak Ridge National Laboratory on chromium-coated (Cr-coated) and uncoated advanced zirconium alloy claddings irradiated in the High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR) to approximately 4 displacements per atom (dpa), corresponding to ~40 GWd/t burnup. Specimens were prepared in axial tension (ATT) and ring tension (RTT) geometries, and passive silicon carbide thermometry was employed to determine irradiation temperatures, which averaged 38–43 °C below the 330 °C design target.
11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗
In-situ strain behavior and BISON simulations of Zircaloy cladding subjected to temperature cycling separate-effects tests in a steam environment
Understanding fuel system performance during anticipated transients without scram (ATWSs) in boiling water reactors (BWRs) is necessary for refining current and future safety limits. High-fidelity material models and simulations are fundamental to rigorous assessment of zirconium-based cladding performance. However, experimental thermomechanical data during simulated ATWSs to validate these modes are limited. To provide relevant in-situ data, Zircaloy-4 cladding was subjected to cyclic heating in a steam environment to simulate an out-of-pile BWR ATWS. Digital image correlation was used to capture the cladding strain behavior in-situ for comparison against simulations using the BISON finite element code. Conventional high-temperature models were compared using multiple schemes to gain a better understanding of the applicability of three BISON models to BWR ATWS: (1) the default combination of creep models in BISON, (2) the high-temperature Erbacher model alone, and (3) the low-temperature Limback-Andersson model alone. The cases run with the Limback-Andersson model alone produced the lowest root mean square error (RMSE). The lowest RMSE for the Limback-Andersson model alone was 0.659%, and the highest RMSE reported was 4.22%. A data gap within the model in the temperature regime of interest was also identified, and to account for this gap, the current model in BISON is linearly interpolated between two separate datasets. In conclusion, this evaluation highlights the need to either develop a new model or to improve the existing model to capture transient creep effects resulting from a cyclic temperature transient.
Anticipated transient without SCRAM↗
Study of hydride reorientation and ductility of SRA ZIRLO and PRXA ZIRLO using ring compression testing (RCT)
Before dry storage, spent nuclear fuel is dried at high temperatures, which induces hydride dissolution. Radial hydride particles precipitate when cooled under a stress above a threshold stress. This process can severely degrade the ductility of cladding tubes. Zirconium alloys with different microstructures, such as grain boundary density, were quantified and studied to examine their effect on hydride reorientation. The ring compression loading mode creates a range of stress states depending on the location within the ring with respect to the applied load, producing various hydride morphologies that can be used to study the effects of microstructures on hydride reorientation. Finite element modeling was performed to calculate the hoop stress, which is the dominant stress, during hydride reorientation. These results were coupled with hydride morphology to determine the threshold stress for hydride reorientation, depending on the microstructure. In conclusion, the samples were then mechanically tested using ring compression to evaluate the ductility of zirconium alloys as a function of different hydride morphologies.
Hydride embrittlement↗
Work updates for Prof. Lee
I want to update my work which I have done so far in INL, including matlab GUI for neutron radiography and some fuel EBSD works.
11 - NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗
Device for steam cladding oxidation testing at TREAT
To compare the chemical degradation of conventional zirconium alloy (Zry) cladding to advance silicon carbide (SiC) cladding in a post loss of coolant accident (LOCA) environment, new nuclear testing capabilities are necessary. The Transient Reactor Test (TREAT) Facility at Idaho National Laboratory (INL) has matured its transient fuel testing capabilities since its 2017 restart. The most recent experiment architecture is the Transient Water Irradiation System in TREAT (TWIST), which is designed to support qualification of accident tolerant fuels in light water reactors. INL has designed and analyzed a natural circulation steam flow modification for TWIST to produce prototypic conditions of cladding oxidation. The in-situ device will be electrically heated to drive natural circulation. Moreover, the SiC cladding requires heating above 1700 °C to observe failure, thus internal prototypic nuclear heating with radiation effects will be used. Thermal hydraulic analysis with RELAP5-3D (Reactor Excursion and Leak Analysis Program) estimated steam fluxes greater than 50 mg cm −2 s −1 can be achieved. These fluxes are adequate to test Zry cladding according to draft regulatory guides and to test SiC cladding according to past experiments.
Oxidation↗
Recent Advances in Cladding Material Extraction from Fuels in Nuclear Fuel Cycles
An improved recycling and recovery process for the cladding material from spent nuclear fuels is very important toward confirming nuclear energy to support ongoing sustainable development of nuclear management by reducing waste and conserving resources. Nuclear spent fuel cladding materials such as zirconium alloys have economic values and can be recovered, and their recovery eliminates problems in waste disposal and conserves valuable resources. Over 110 published reports and journal articles are reviewed and summarized herein, with a main focus on documenting recovery techniques used to recover cladding materials from spent nuclear fuel and recent developments. Several recovery techniques which are used at present times, such as mechanical separation, chemical dissolution, and hydrometallurgical processes have been covered with examples and discussions. Difficulties within the recovery process are also discussed, and most probable areas for future research in improving efficiency and sustainability of recovering cladding material are identified and discussed at the end. Here, this review could be an important document to the field of spent nuclear fuel reprocessing, recovering valuables and thereby offering guidance on how to effectively manage, safely handle, and reduce nuclear waste. In addition to reducing the volume and radiotoxicity of high-level waste, this review also highlights the potential economic benefit of recovering zirconium from spent fuel cladding by relating typical zirconium metal prices to the mass of cladding per tonne of spent fuel, illustrating that the recoverable material value is non-negligible compared with back-end fuel-cycle costs.
Mondal, Kunal [Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL↗
A LOCA Analysis Tool: Coupling RELAP5-3D to BISON
Experimental evidence illustrates that at burnups slightly above the current regulatory limit of a rod-averaged burnup of 62 MWd/kgU, the ceramic UO 2 inside light-water reactor fuel rods becomes susceptible to a phenomenon known as fuel fragmentation, relocation, and dispersal (FFRD) during a loss of coolant accident (LOCA) transient. The severity of FFRD is strongly influenced by the zirconium-based (Zircaloy) cladding behavior during the LOCA transient. A Technology Commercialization Fund (TCF) project was awarded to an Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI)/Idaho National Laboratory team to create a LOCA analysis tool that couples BISON to the systems/thermal-hydraulics code RELAP5-3D [1] for analysis of LOCA scenarios. In addition, further refinements to existing BISON models were identified as necessary to more accurately represent more recent experimental evidence from the Studsvik Cladding Integrity Project (SCIP) and other experimental programs.
11 - NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗
Site-specific nanoscale characterization of zirconium hydrides in the hydride rim structure of hydrogen-charged zircaloy-4 cladding
Zircaloy-4 cladding tubes were hydrogen-charged using a static pressure hydrogen charging method to experimentally produce a zirconium-hydride rim structure similar to that observed in Zircaloy-4 cladding tubes after operation in commercial light-water nuclear reactors. Detailed characterization was performed using electron energy loss spectroscopy (EELS) and four-dimensional scanning transmission electron microscopy (4D-STEM). By mapping the position of the plasmon peak in the low-loss EELS spectrum, it was determined that the zirconium hydrides formed were predominantly solid δ-phase zirconium hydrides. 4D-STEM was used to generate phase and strain maps at nanoscale. The interactions between two zirconium hydride platelets less than 200 nm apart leads to the localized lattice rotations and possible phase change, revealing a potential hydride growth mechanism.
4D-STEM↗
Material Characterization Report of EBR II Mark IV Fuel Element
The focus of this report is the characterization of an unirradiated as-built fuel element from the Experimental Breeder Reactor II (EBR-II) Mark IV driver fuel design. The fuel in this element is a metallic uranium-zirconium alloy, and the cladding material is HT9 stainless steel. Both the metallic fuel and cladding materials are characterized, including chemical composition, grain size, morphology, phase composition, precipitate composition, crystallography, density, and hardness.
11 - NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗
Zr Nuclear Data Campaign: Measurement of (n,γ) cross section of 90,91 Zr [Abstract]
The isotopes of Zr with mass number A = [90; 91; 92; 94] make up more than 97% of naturally occurring Zr and are important to many nuclear applications due to their desirable mechanical and nuclear properties. For example, the zirconium alloys are used as cladding material in nuclear reactors. In addition to the mechanical properties, Zr-90 has a closed neutron shell, hence the capture cross sections of the zirconium isotopes are relatively small, such that they improve the neutron economy in reactors by preferentially scattering neutrons rather than absorbing them. This same quality also presents a challenge to measuring the capture cross section, σ γ (E), of Zr isotopes. For incident neutron energies < 0.1 MeV, the ENDF library reports a relative uncertainty of approximately 20% and uncertainty greater than 20% above this energy. This motivates the Nuclear Criticality Safety Program (NCSP) to perform new neutron induced cross section measurements to accurately evaluate these four isotopes of Zr.
ENDF↗