SEARCH · Search NASA
Results for “accident tolerant cladding material”
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Modification of MELCOR for severe accident analysis of candidate accident tolerant cladding materials
A number of materials are currently under development as candidate accident tolerant fuel and cladding for application in the current fleet of commercial light water reactors (LWRs). The safe, reliable and economic operation of the nation’s nuclear power reactor fleet has always been a top priority for the nuclear industry. Continual improvement of technology, including advanced materials and nuclear fuels, remains central to the industry’s success. Enhancing the accident tolerance of light water reactors became a topic of serious discussion following the 2011 Great East Japan Earthquake, resulting tsunami, and subsequent damage to the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear power plant complex. The overall goal for the development of accident tolerant fuel (ATF) systems for LWRs is to identify alternative fuel system technologies to further enhance the safety, competitiveness, and economics of commercial nuclear power. Designed for use in the current fleet of commercial LWRs, or in reactor concepts with design certifications (GEN-III+), to achieve their goal enhanced ATF must endure loss of active cooling in the reactor core for a considerably longer period of time than the current fuel system, while maintaining or improving performance during normal operation. Many available nuclear fuel performance analysis tools are specifically developed for the current UO 2 – Zirconium alloy fuel system. The MELCOR severe-accident analysis code, under development at the Sandia National Laboratory in New Mexico (SNL-NM) for the US Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC), is one of these tools. This article describes modifications made to a version of the MELCOR code by the Idaho National Laboratory (INL) that allows its application to alternate fuel-cladding systems. Preliminary analysis results are presented in this paper for candidate silicon carbide and FeCrAl cladding concepts.
Hydrothermal Corrosion of SiC Materials for Accident Tolerant Fuel Cladding with and Without Mitigation Coatings
As a candidate material for accident-tolerant fuel cladding for light water reactors (LWR), SiCf–SiC composite materials possess many attractive properties. However, prior work has shown that SiC is susceptible to aqueous dissolution in LWR coolant environments. To address this issue, candidate coatings have been developed to inhibit dissolution. For this study, CVD SiC samples were prepared with Cr, CrN, TiN, ZrN, NiCr, and Ni coatings. Uncoated SiC and SiCf–SiC samples were also prepared. The samples were exposed for 400 h in 288 °C water with 2 wppm DO in a constantly-refreshing autoclave to simulate BWR–NWC. Cr and Ni coated samples lost less mass than the uncoated SiC sample, indicating an improvement in performance. The CrN coating resisted oxidation, but some of the coating was lost due to poor adhesion. The TiN coated sample gained significant mass due to oxidation of the coating. ZrN and NiCr coatings showed significant corrosion attack. SiCf–SiC ceramic matrix composite materials dissolved much faster than the CVD SiC sample, demonstrating the need for mitigation coatings if CMCs are to be used in LWRs. This work demonstrates the promise of Cr, Ni and CrN coatings for corrosion mitigation in LWRs, and shows that NiCr and ZrN are not promising coating materials.
Investigations on the Thermal-hydraulic Behavior of Accident Tolerant Fuel Cladding Materials
Since the 2011 Fukushima accident, significant research has been devoted to developing accident-tolerant fuel (ATF) cladding materials. These investigations have mostly focused on the ability to resist runaway steam oxidation and retain mechanical strength and structural integrity under thermal shocks. However, much remains unknown about the materials’ thermal-hydraulic behavior, particularly under light-water reactor (LWR) operating conditions. Two phenomena that determine safety margins in both normal and off-normal operating conditions - i.e., the critical heat flux (CHF) and Leidenfrost point (LFP) temperature - have not been investigated thoroughly for ATF materials. Surface properties, such as wettability and roughness, are known to influence pool and flow boiling CHF, as well as the LFP temperature. However, little is known about the surface wettability of ATF materials, particularly at LWR pressure and temperature. Little has been done on flow-boiling CHF and quenching heat transfer, especially for droplet quenching. Nonetheless, it is known that CHF in transient conditions, e.g., an exponentially escalating power transient, can be significantly different from that expected in steady-state operation. Very few studies have investigated transient CHF, either on ATF materials or under LWR pressure and temperature. The thorough understanding of transient CHF under prototypical reactor conditions will benefit not only the deployment of ATF but also the upcoming national efforts to study transient ATF behavior in the Transient Reactor Test Facility (TREAT) at Idaho National Laboratory. In summary, as a part of ATF development efforts, there is an urgent need to understand how and how much these materials may affect two-phase heat transfer phenomena in nuclear reactor conditions.
Pool boiling critical heat flux studies of accident tolerant fuel cladding materials
Pool boiling experiments have been performed at atmospheric pressure on potential accident tolerant fuel (ATF) cladding materials (Zirlo®, Cr coated Zirlo®, FeCrAl coated Zirlo®, and monolithic SiC) to evaluate the Critical Heat Flux (CHF) points. Corrosion resistant coatings of Cr and FeCrAl alloy were deposited on flat Zirlo® samples using cold spray technology. The as-prepared samples after uniform surface polishing were subjected to autoclave tests at 360 °C water and 18.6 MPa for 360 h to simulate prototypic corrosion of the ATF cladding materials in LWR normal operation. Surface characteristics potentially influencing CHF such as surface morphology, roughness, static contact angle, and surface chemistry were characterized using a suite of characterization methods including scanning electron microscopy, 3D optical profilometry, optical contact angle measurements, and x-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS). Thermo-physical properties of the samples such as density, thermal conductivity, and heat capacity were measured by differential scanning calorimetry and laser flash thermal diffusivity measurement. FeCrAl coatings showed CHF values comparable to bare Zirlo® samples, while slightly lower CHF values were observed for Cr coated samples and bulk SiC flats (produced by chemical vapor deposition, CVD). As-deposited Cr coatings showed 67% higher CHF than the as-polished Cr coatings due to its higher surface roughness level. The autoclave testing for the prepared samples generally increased the CHF except for the surface polished Cr coatings. Similar CHF values of bare Zirlo®, FeCrAl coating, and CVD SiC samples were observed after autoclave test but there were negligible change CHF of Cr coatings. XPS studies indicated that the formation or deposition of a few monolayers of hydrophobic carbonaceous species on surface can affect CHF values. The trends in CHF data are discussed in terms of evolution of the surface characteristics of the ATF materials.
FUEL PERFORMANCE MODELING OF FECRAL CLADDING FAILURE DURING LOSS OF COOLANT CONDITIONS
Accident tolerant materials are defined as those that provide significantly increased response time in the event of an accident while providing similar or improved performance as the conventional UO2/Zircaloy-4 fuel rods during normal operation. One avenue for materials to demonstrate enhanced accident tolerance is to have improved reaction (e.g., oxidation) kinetics with steam, resulting in slower hydrogen (or other combustible gases) generation rate, while maintaining acceptable thermo-mechanical properties, fuel-clad interactions, and fission product behavior. Due to their improved reaction kinetics with steam compared to Zircaloy-4, iron-chromium-aluminum (FeCrAl) alloys are being considered as an accident tolerant cladding material. In order to determine whether FeCrAl alloys are indeed accident tolerant materials, comparisons between conventional zirconium-based claddings under accident conditions is required. To this end, we have developed a burst (failure) criterion for FeCrAl using existing experimental data for first-generation alloys. This model was incorporated into the BISON fuel performance code to perform comparative studies with Zircaloy-4 cladding tubes under non-oxidizing and oxidizing LOCA conditions. The separate effects LOCA conditions considered were adopted from the PUZRY and REBEKA test series. Due to the fact that FeCrAl alloys have a larger thermal absorption cross-section and higher stiffness than Zircaloy-4, cladding thickness will be smaller for FeCrAl than for Zircaloy-4. Three different cladding thicknesses were analyzed in this work. The results indicate that for both non-oxidizing (PUZRY) and oxidizing (REBEKA) LOCA conditions, FeCrAl has similar burst behavior (i.e., time to burst and pressure at burst) as Zircaloy-4. It should be noticed that this study used data for first-generation FeCrAl alloys to develop the burst criterion. Although no burst data?currently exists for C35M (a second-generation FeCrAl alloy under development at Oak Ridge National Laboratory), improved burst behavior is anticipated. As burst data for C35M becomes available the burst criterion will be updated and the simulations revisited to determine the accident tolerance of second-generation FeCrAl alloys.
Fuel performance modeling of FeCrAl cladding failure during loss of coolant conditions
Accident tolerant materials are defined as those that provide significantly increased response time in the event of an accident while providing similar or improved performance as the conventional UO2/Zircaloy-4 fuel rods during normal operation. One avenue for materials to demonstrate enhanced accident tolerance is to have improved reaction (e.g., oxidation) kinetics with steam, resulting in slower hydrogen (or other combustible gases) generation rate, while maintaining acceptable thermo-mechanical properties, fuel-clad interactions, and fission product behavior. Due to their improved reaction kinetics with steam compared to Zircaloy-4, iron-chromium-aluminum (FeCrAl) alloys are being considered as an accident tolerant cladding material. In order to determine whether FeCrAl alloys are indeed accident tolerant materials, comparisons between conventional zirconium-based claddings under accident conditions is required. To this end, we have developed a burst (failure) criterion for FeCrAl using existing experimental data for first-generation alloys. This model was incorporated into the BISON fuel performance code to perform comparative studies with Zircaloy-4 cladding tubes under non-oxidizing and oxidizing LOCA conditions. The separate effects LOCA conditions considered were adopted from the PUZRY and REBEKA test series. Due to the fact that FeCrAl alloys have a larger thermal absorption cross-section and higher stiffness than Zircaloy-4, cladding thickness will be smaller for FeCrAl than for Zircaloy-4. Three different cladding thicknesses were analyzed in this work. The results indicate that for both non-oxidizing (PUZRY) and oxidizing (REBEKA) LOCA conditions, FeCrAl has similar burst behavior (i.e., time to burst and pressure at burst) as Zircaloy-4. It should be noticed that this study used data for first-generation FeCrAl alloys to develop the burst criterion. Although no burst data?currently exists for C35M (a second-generation FeCrAl alloy under development at Oak Ridge National Laboratory), improved burst behavior is anticipated. As burst data for C35M becomes available the burst criterion will be updated and the simulations revisited to determine the accident tolerance of second-generation FeCrAl alloys.
In-situ tube burst testing and high-temperature deformation behavior of candidate materials for accident tolerant fuel cladding
The high resistance of cladding to plastic deformation and burst failure is one of the most essential properties of accident tolerant fuel (ATF) for maintaining structural integrity during a loss-of-coolant accident (LOCA) since the deformation and burst behavior governs the cooling efficiency of flow channels and process of fission product release. To simulate and evaluate such deformation and burst process of thin-walled cladding, an in-situ testing and evaluation method has been developed on the basis of visual imaging and image analysis techniques. The method uses a specialized optics system consisted of a high-resolution video camera, light filtering unit, and monochromatic light sources, and the in-situ testing is performed using a 50 mm long pressurized thin-walled tubular specimen set in a programmable furnace. In this study eleven (11) candidate cladding materials for ATF, i.e., 6 FeCrAl alloys and 5 nanostructured steels, were tested using the newly developed method, and the time-dependent images were analyzed to produce detailed deformation and burst data such as true hoop stress, strain (creep) rate, and failure stress. Relatively soft FeCrAl alloys deformed and burst below 800°C while negligible strain rates were measured for higher strength alloys and/or for relatively thick wall specimens.
Material selection for accident tolerant fuel cladding
Alternative cladding materials are being investigated for accident tolerance, which can be defined as >100X improvement (compared to current Zr-based alloys) in oxidation resistance in steam environments at ≥1200°C for short (≤4 h) times. After reviewing a wide range of candidates, current steam oxidation testing is being conducted on Mo, MAX phases and FeCrAl alloys. Recently reported low mass losses for Mo in steam at 800°C could not be reproduced. Both FeCrAl and MAX phase Ti 2 AlC form a protective alumina scale in steam. Therefore, commercial Ti 2 AlC that is not single phase, formed a much thicker oxide at 1200°C in steam and significant TiO 2 , and therefore may be challenging to use as a cladding or a coating. Alloy development for FeCrAl is seeking to maintain its steam oxidation resistance to 1475°C, while reducing its Cr content to minimize susceptibility to irradiation assisted Cr-rich α’ formation. The composition effects and critical limits to retaining protective scale formation at >1400°C are still being evaluated.
Recent progresses on thermal–hydraulics evaluations of accident tolerant fuel cladding materials
Thermal–hydraulics (T-H) experiments have been on the progress to evaluate boiling heat transfer characteristics of accident tolerant fuel (ATF) candidates for further supporting the core-loading of these advanced ATF concepts in light water reactors (LWRs). Here this study covers recent experimental studies of ATF claddings and summarizes some significant results. Recent T-H experimental results of ATF cladding candidates demonstrated that the material thermal–physical properties have pronounced effects on critical heat flux (CHF). Such effects have not been well resolved in the current physics-governing models. These effects of cladding materials on CHF could be potentially rationalized by the material-conjugated boiling heat transfer, where the material-dominated heat conduction competes with the flow boiling-dominated heat convection. As progressively increasing the mass flux and/or liquid subcooling, CHF differences between different materials gradually decrease, which is in agreement with the recent T-H experimental results of ATF claddings. This is because the dominance of heat convection over heat conduction is primarily improved by liquid subcooling and/or mass flow rate. It is noteworthy that surface oxidization of claddings may have unknown impacts on T-H performances because the formation of oxide layers on cladding surfaces introduces variations of material thermal–physical properties and then changes the surface morphological features, which results in some difficulties in evaluating the thermal safety margins of ATF claddings.
Report on Reactor Physics Assessment of Candidate Accident Tolerant Fuel Cladding Materials in LWRs
This work focuses on ATF concepts being researched at Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL), expanding on previous studies of using alternate cladding materials in pressurized water reactors (PWRs). The neutronic performance of two leading alternate cladding materials were assessed in boiling water reactors (BWRs): iron-chromium-aluminum (FeCrAl) cladding, and silicon carbide (SiC)-based composite cladding. This report fulfills ORNL Milestone M3FT-15OR0202332 within the fiscal year 2015 (FY15).
Effect of surface characteristics and environmental aging on wetting of Cr-coated Zircaloy-4 accident tolerant fuel cladding material
Not Available
Neutronic evaluation of coating and cladding materials for accident tolerant fuels
Not Available
Pressure Loading with In-Situ Permeability Measurement of SiC Ceramic Matrix Composite Tube
Silicon carbide fiber in a silicon carbide matrix composite (SiC-SiC) has been actively researched as a potential structural material to be used in advanced high temperature gas reactors (HTGR) and as an accident tolerant cladding material for light water reactors (LWR). This ceramic composite material demonstrates desirable properties for use in nuclear reactor core that include retention of strength from ambient to LWR and HTGR operating and accident temperatures and stability under neutron radiation. However, the ceramic composite material must be designed to meet all the necessary, application driven requirements before it could be implemented in a reactor design. As one of the requirements for a fuel cladding material, the composite has to maintain high level of impermeability as to retain fission gases throughout the fuel cycle. General Atomics (GA) had previously reported results on permeability levels obtained by CVI produced SiC-SiC composites. It has been determined that for LWR size cladding tube that is 51 mm long the permeability allocation equivalent to currently used claddings is 7.3 E-10 atm*cc/sec. With high level of attention to possible sources of leaks in a test setup, it has been demonstrated that a CVI SiC-SiC composites produced by GA can achieve a leak rate of 1 E-12 atm*cc/sec, and therefore it meets the permeability allocation for a fuel cladding. Further study showed that a particular SiC-SiC composite tube can remain impermeable after being pressure loaded well above LWR normal operating conditions. In the study done by Deck et al., hoop stress was applied to a composite tube using pressure load on the inside surface in a load-unload stepwise sequence with increasing maximum applied stress at each step and measuring permeability between steps. The tested composite comprised of 70% thickness of SiC-SiC composite which provides fracture toughness and bears a majority of the applied stress and a 30% thickness of monolithic SiC layer on the outside surface to provide an impermeable barrier. The composite remained impermeable up to internal pressure of 56 MPa which is more than 2.5 times greater than a typical pressure at the end of life in a fuel rod.
A pulse-controlled modified-burst test instrument for accident-tolerant fuel cladding
Pellet-cladding mechanical interaction due to thermal expansion of nuclear fuel pellets during a reactivity-initiated accident (RIA) is a potential mechanism for failure of nuclear fuel cladding. To investigate the mechanical behavior of cladding during an RIA, we developed a mechanical pulse-controlled modified burst test instrument that simulates transient events with a pulse width from 10 to 300 ms. This paper includes validation tests of unirradiated and prehydrided ZIRLO cladding tubes. A ZIRLO cladding sample with a hydrogen content of 168 wt. ppm showed ductile behavior and failed at the maximum limits of the test setup with hoop strain to failure greater than 9.2%. ZIRLO samples showed high resistance to failure even at very high hydrogen contents (1,466 wt. ppm). When the hydrogen content was increased to 1,554 wt. ppm, brittle-like behavior was observed at a hoop strain of 2.5%. Preliminary scoping tests at room temperature with FeCrAl tubes were conducted to imitate the pulse behavior of transient test reactors during integral tests. The preliminary FeCrAl tests are informative from the perspective of characterizing the test rig and supporting the design of integral tests for current and potentially accident tolerant cladding materials.
Wettability and CHF limits of Accident-Tolerant nuclear fuel cladding materials in light water reactor conditions
Here, we present the results of experimental investigations aimed at evaluating the thermal–hydraulic performance of chromium-coated zircaloy, i.e., one of the most promising accident tolerant fuel (ATF) cladding material for light water nuclear reactors. Precisely, we investigate the wettability and critical heat flux (CHF) limits of chromium-coated and conventional zircaloy surfaces in prototypical reactor conditions. For both surface types, we measure the contact angle in a vapor-saturated atmosphere from ambient pressure to the operating pressure of pressurized water reactors (PWRs), i.e., ~15 MPa. We measure the ambient-pressure steady-state flow boiling CHF with a spatially uniform heat flux. We measure the high-pressure steady-state flow boiling CHF with a cosine shape heat flux (up to 20 MPa) and with a uniform heat flux (up to 15 MPa), also exploring the effect of CRUD deposits on the chromium-coated surface. Our results reveal that the chromium surface and the bare zircaloy surface have similar wettability and both become super-hydrophilic in PWR conditions, and that there is practically no difference in the steady-state CHF limits, both at low-pressure and high-pressure conditions, also when the chromium-coated surface is covered by a CRUD deposit. However, while the chromium-coating does not improve the CHF compared to the bare zircaloy surface, it improves the post-CHF behavior. The chromium coating prevents the reaction between zircaloy and steam, which results in the formation of a brittle zirconium oxide through the surface of the cladding. We also measure the transient CHF under exponentially escalating heat flux inputs of a nano-smooth and a rough surface mimicking a chromium-coated zircaloy cladding. Interestingly, the results of the transient heat flux tests suggest that the CHF limit for very short periods (i.e., fast transients) is independent of the surface finish, being the same for a rough chromium surface or a nano-smooth surface.
Solid-liquid phase equilibria of Fe-Cr-Al alloys and spinels
Ferritic FeCrAl alloys are candidate accident tolerant cladding materials. There is a paucity of data concerning the melting behavior for FeCrAl and its oxides. Analysis tools have therefore had to utilize assumptions for simulations using FeCrAl cladding. The focus of this study is to examine in some detail the solid-liquid phase equilibria of FeCrAl alloys and spinels with the aim of improving the accuracy of severe accident scenario computational studies.