Understanding Degradation at the Lithium-Ion Battery Cathode/Electrolyte Interface: Connecting Transition-Metal Dissolution Mechanisms to Electrolyte Composition
Not Available
SEARCH · Search NASA
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Not Available
Not Available
All-solid-state batteries (ASSBs) using a ceramic fast Li-ion conductor as a solid-state electrolyte (SSE) have been proposed as a promising strategy to significantly increase the energy density of lithium batteries. Due to their high ion conductivity and excellent stability, Li-stuffed garnets exhibit the most promising physical and chemical properties for SSEs. However, the typical microstructure, thick (>100 μm) bulk electrolyte and simple planar electrode/electrolyte interfaces, combined with poor electrode wetting of the garnet result in excessively high area specific resistances (ASRs) that severely limit achievable current density and cell energy density. In this project, the team is building on their demonstrated expertise with garnet electrolytes and ASSBs to accomplish the following: (1) engineer interfaces to overcome high NMC/LLZ interfacial impedance and interfacial degradation; (2) develop processing and fabrication techniques to achieve high loading NMC/LLZ composite cathodes with low resistance and high cyclability; and (3) integrate the NMC/LLZ cathodes into all-solid-state Li-metal/LLZ cells to achieve high-energy-density batteries.
17th International Symposium on Solid Oxide Fuel Cells (SOFC-XVII), Virtual, July 18-23, 2021
Garnet-structured Li 6.75 La 3 Zr 1.75 Ta 0.25 O 12 (LLZTO) is one of the most promising electrolyte materials for solid-state Li batteries (SS-LiB). The design and fabrication of a good cathode/electrolyte interface is an important criterion for the SS-LiB. In this work, we performed a systematic study on the impact of cathode crystal structure and chemical compositions on their chemical stabilities against the LLZTO at elevated temperatures, which are required for their adhesion during cell fabrication processes. X-ray Diffraction (XRD) and Rietveld refinement analyses revealed the chemical stabilities of various cathode materials in contact with the LLZTO. While layered LiCoO 2 cathode showed good stability in contact with LLZTO to 900 °C, LiNiO 2 or Ni-rich LiNi x Mn y Co 1–x–y O 2 (NMC) cathodes suffered from the formation of La 4 NiLiO 8 due to La-diffusion from LLZTO. Furthermore, Mn-rich LiMn 2 O 4 spinel and layered LiNi 1/3 Mn 1/3 Co 1/3 O 2 cathodes suffered from the formation of La 2 Zr 2 O 7 due to Li-diffusion and production of Li 2 MnO 3 . As a result, LiNi 0.6 Mn 0.2 Co 0.2 O 2 , having an ideal balance of Ni/Mn/Co composition, or Li 2 MnO 3 containing cathodes such as Li 1.2 Ni 0.15 Mn 0.55 Co 0.1 O 2 were found to have excellent phase stability as the cathodes for LLZTO-based SS-LiBs.
A high‐performance cathode is necessary to realize the great potentials of solid‐state batteries such as high energy density and long cycle life. It is also needed to validate electrolyte performance, which is lacking. Currently, cathodes for solid‐state batteries are thinner and have lower cathode active material content than their lithium‐ion battery counterpart, resulting from insufficient conductivity and limiting the battery energy density. This review article provides an overview of recent development in cathode microstructures and their impact on battery properties, including compatibility between cathode and electrolyte, cathode architecture design, interface engineering, correlation between material properties, cathode processing approaches, and performance, as well as the advanced characterization methods used to understand the above correlations . Some perspectives on future development are shared including utilizing in situ and operando characterization tools to better understand dynamic evolution of the cathode/electrolyte interface, adapting artificial intelligence and machine learning to design and optimize cathode structures. The article is aimed to promote research interest on cathode development and advance solid‐state battery technologies.
Structural evolutions are crucial for determining the performance of high-voltage lithium, manganese-rich layered cathodes. Moreover, interface between electrode and electrolyte plays a critical role in governing ionic transfer in all-solid-state batteries. In this work, we unveil two different types of porous structure in Li 1.2 Ni 0.2 Mn 0.6 O 2 cathode with LiPON solid-state electrolyte. Na-nopores are found near the cathode/electrolyte interface at pristine state, where cation mixing, phase transformation, oxygen loss and Mn reduction are also found. In situ Li + extraction induces the evolution of nanovoids, initially formed near the inter-face then propagated into the bulk. Despite the development of nanovoids, layered structure is conserved, suggesting the nature of nanopores and nanovoids are different and their impact would be divergent. This work demonstrates the intrinsic interfacial layer, as well as the dynamic scenario of nanovoid formation inside high-capacity layered cathode, which help understanding the performance fading in cathodes and offer insights into the all-solid-state battery design.
The primary goal of this project is to leverage data-driven methods and machine learning strategies to develop accurate multi-physics models for all-solid-state Li-S battery (ASLSB) materials that can capture electrochemical and transport phenomena over atomic to mesoscopic length/timescales. These models will be rigorously validated by synthesis and advanced characterization experiments. The team will leverage the predictive power of these models, alongside synthesis/characterization experiments and battery fabrication to address longstanding issues at the electrode/electrolyte interfaces in ASLSBs. The project’s proposed technology involves the following: (1) halide-doped solid sulfide electrolytes that can concurrently provide high Li + ion conductivity and suppress dendrite growth; (2) novel mesoporous cathode composed of super-P and carbon nanotubes co-infiltrated with sulfur and sulfide electrolyte, which hold potential to allow high sulfur loading and optimal ion/electron pathways; and (3) functionalization of sulfide electrolyte with ionic liquids to improve physical contact and minimize impedance at the cathode/electrolyte interface. Successful development of proposed predictive models (at multiple scales) will bridge this knowledge gap and will advance fundamental understanding of reaction chemistry, kinetics, charge transfer, and dendrite growth at electrified SSIs. This will enable predictive design of effective strategies to mitigate interfacial problems in ASSLSBs, including poor interfacial contact, interfacial impedance to Li + ion transport, and poor electron/ion conduction within cathodes. Ultimately, the fundamental knowledge gained will lead to development of high-performance ASSLSBs.
Na 3 V 2 (PO 4 ) 2 F 3 (NVPF) has been considered an up-and-coming cathode material candidate for sodium (Na) ion batteries in light of its high specific capacity and working voltage. However, an erratic cathode/electrolyte interface layer is inevitably formed, accompanied by continuous electrolyte decomposition on the NVPF surface, when the voltage exceeds 4.2 V vs Na + /Na. Herein, the interphase features of NVPF are obviously enhanced owing to the ameliorated electronic conductivity obtained by combining it with carbon nanotubes (CNT). The NVPF with 3 wt % CNT (NVPF@3% CNT) reduces the Na + diffusion kinetic energy barrier and electron transport resistance. Furthermore, the conducting network formed by CNT with sturdy structure strength can promptly accommodate the volumetric changes during sequential Na + extraction/insertion and thus effectively improve the long-term cyclic performance of NVPF/hard carbon full cells. The initial discharge capacity approaches 105 mA h g –1 at 0.5C, and it retains 94% capacity retention after 200 cycles at the temperature of –10 °C. The cathode/electrolyte interphase characterization results further demonstrate that the interphase layer on the NVPF@3% CNT cathode is thinner and more compact compared with pristine samples. Here, this research provides a competitive strategy to facilitate the interfacial compatibility between the NVPF and electrolytes and accelerate the commercialization of high-performance Na-ion batteries.
Understanding the chemo-mechanical behaviors of electrodes, particularly at the electrode/electrolyte interfaces, is critical for improving the performance of all-solid-state batteries. However, due to the instability of electrolyte materials under ambient conditions, such characterizations are challenging, particularly for sulfide-based all-solid-state batteries. Herein, by combining time-of-flight secondary-ion mass spectroscopy (ToF-SIMS) and in-SEM nanoindentation measurements, a systematic quantitative investigation of the chemo-mechanical behaviors of pyrene-4,5,9,10-tetraone (PTO) /Li 6 PS 5 Cl composite cathodes is carried out. Chemical and quantitative mechanical information of the composite cathode were collected with high spatial resolution after developing and implementing an air-free characterization protocol. By directly connecting the Young’s modulus and hardness with the Li distribution in the composite cathode, a comprehensive chemo-mechanical mapping of the PTO/ Li 6 PS 5 Cl composite cathode has been established. Furthermore, this work improves our knowledge of the critical chemo-mechanical phenomena that occur at the cathode/electrolyte interfaces in all-solid-state batteries.
Layered Ni-rich LiNi x Mn y Co 1-x-y O 2 (NMC) materials are the most promising cathode materials for Li-ion batteries due to their favorable energy densities. However, the low thermal stability typically caused by detrimental oxygen release leads to significant safety concerns. Determining the pathways of oxygen evolution reaction is essential, as the ideal safety countermeasure is to break the reaction chain of thermal runaway. In this study, we demonstrate that two endogenous pathways of oxygen involved in strong exothermic reactions lead the NMC811|graphite pouch cell to an uncontrollable state, and we quantify the individual contribution of the pathways to thermal runaway. Approximately 41% of thermal-induced oxygen reacts aggressively with ethylene carbonate (EC) at the cathode/electrolyte interface with 16% heat generation, accelerating the self-heating rate and thereby further triggering thermal runaway. The residual oxygen that survives the reaction with carbonate spreads to the lithiated anode with major heat generation (65%), bringing the battery to the maximum destructive temperature during thermal runaway. By confirming the significant roles of EC and anode, a deeper understanding on battery fire was achieved. Finally, the revealed mechanism can help guide studies on stopping the two reaction pathways, allowing for the safer use of high-energy lithium-ion batteries in the future.
Layered LiNi 0.6 Co 0.2 Mn 0.2 O 2 (NCM622) attracts widespread attention primarily due to its potential for high energy density and moderate thermal stability. However, the low initial coulombic efficiency (ICE) of the material limits the maximum utilization of their capacity. The capacity loss in the first cycle occurs under 4.0V and keep almost constant are considered as common characteristics for NCM-based materials. A clear cognition on the initial capacity loss may light the way to improve the practical reversible capacity of NCM622 at 4.0V. Conducting operando X-ray diffraction during galvanostatic charge/discharge cycling at different temperature (25 degrees C, 45 degrees C and 60 degrees C) and different current (0.1C, 0.01C, 1C=120 mA g -1 ) in the voltage range of 2.7-4.0V, we find that only 8% of the measured initial irreversible capacity loss is associated with parasitic reactions that form cathode/electrolyte interface, and that the dominant contributors include the slow Li + diffusion kinetics (similar to 46% contribution) and irreversible O3/H1-3 phase transition (similar to 46% contribution). Finally, this semi-quantitative study provides new insight on initial capacity loss, guiding further targeted modification and fully utilization of NCM622.
Cobalt-free cation-disordered rocksalt (DRX) cathodes are a promising class of materials for next-generation Li-ion batteries. Although they have high theoretical specific capacities (>300 mA h/g) and moderate operating voltages (~3.5 V vs Li/Li + ), DRX cathodes typically require a high carbon content (up to 30 wt %) to fully utilize the active material which has a detrimental impact on cell-level energy density. To assess pathways to reduce the electrode’s carbon content, the present study investigates how the carbon’s microstructure and loading (10–20 wt %) influence the performance of DRX cathodes with the nominal composition Li 1.2 Mn 0.5 Ti 0.3 O 1.9 F 0.1 . While electrodes prepared with conventional disordered carbon additives (C65 and ketjenblack) exhibit rapid capacity fade due to an unstable cathode/electrolyte interface, DRX cathodes containing 10 wt % graphite show superior cycling performance (e.g., reversible capacities ~260 mA h/g with 85% capacity retention after 50 cycles) and rate capability (~135 mA h/g at 1000 mA/g). Furthermore, a suite of characterization tools was employed to evaluate the performance differences among these composite electrodes. Overall, these results indicate that the superior performance of the graphite-based cathodes is largely attributed to the: (i) formation of a uniform graphitic coating on DRX particles which protects the surface from parasitic reactions at high states of charge and (ii) homogeneous dispersion of the active material and carbon throughout the composite cathode which provides a robust electronically conductive network that can withstand repeated charge–discharge cycles. Overall, this study provides key scientific insights on how the carbon microstructure and electrode processing influence the performance of DRX cathodes. Based on these results, exploration of alternative routes to apply graphitic coatings is recommended to further optimize the material performance.
Integrating sulfide separators into solid-state batteries (SSBs) containing high energy cathodes typically requires one or more materials and engineering solutions including: (i) applying interfacial coatings to mitigate electrolyte decomposition, (ii) applying high stack pressures to form robust solid-solid contacts, and (iii) using alloying anodes to avoid Li dendrite formation. Despite the promise of these approaches, a lack of standardized testing protocols makes it difficult to directly compare results among different studies. To address this problem, the present work benchmarks the performance of SSBs containing β-Li 3 PS 4 (LPS) separators and composite cathodes. By systematically varying the anode/cathode composition and stack pressure, this work demonstrates that cathode design is a major bottleneck for solid-state cells cycled at low rates (<100 µA cm -2 ). Operando stack pressure measurements show that, while mechanical confinement generally promotes higher active material utilization and cycling stability, this strategy alone does not address interfacial reactivity between LPS and high voltage cathodes. Here, these results also demonstrate that stress evolution during cycling is dominated by volume changes at the Li metal anode. Finally, we show that FeS 2 cathodes with moderate operating voltages (<3 V vs Li/Li + ) exhibit superior cycling performance compared to high voltage cathodes by facilitating formation of stable cathode/electrolyte interfaces.
Electrode materials that exhibit mixed conductivity (that is, both electronic and ionic conductivity) have been investigated in a continuing effort to improve the performance of the alkali metal thermal-to-electric converter (AMTEC). These electrode materials are intended primarily for use on the cathode side of the sodium-ion-conducting solid electrolyte of a sodium-based AMTEC cell. They may also prove useful in sodium-sulfur batteries, which are under study for use in electric vehicles. An understanding of the roles played by the two types of conduction in the cathode of a sodium-based AMTEC cell is prerequisite to understanding the advantages afforded by these materials. In a sodium-based AMTEC cell, the anode face of an anode/solid-electrolyte/cathode sandwich is exposed to Na vapor at a suitable pressure. Upon making contact with the solid electrolyte on the anode side, Na atoms oxidize to form Na+ ions and electrons. Na+ ions then travel through the electrolyte to the cathode. Na+ ions leave the electrolyte at the cathode/electrolyte interface and are reduced by electrons that have been conducted through an external electrical load from the anode to the cathode. Once the Na+ ions have been reduced to Na atoms, they travel through the cathode to vaporize into a volume where the Na vapor pressure is much lower than it is on the anode side. Thus, the cathode design is subject to competing requirements to be thin enough to allow transport of sodium to the low-pressure side, yet thick enough to afford adequate electronic conductivity. The concept underlying the development of the present mixed conducting electrode materials is the following: The constraint on the thickness of the cathode can be eased by incorporating Na+ -ionconducting material to facilitate transport of sodium through the cathode in ionic form. At the same time, by virtue of the electronically conducting material mixed with the ionically conducting material, reduction of Na+ ions to Na atoms can take place throughout the thickness of the cathode. The net effect is to reduce the diffusion and flow resistance to sodium through the electrode while reducing the electronic resistance by providing shorter conduction paths for electrons. Reduced resistance to both sodium transport and electronic conductivity results in an increase in electric power output.
A series of tests were performed to differentiate between surface diffusion and vapor-phase diffusion of chemical species from LSCF cathode material at typical sintering temperatures (up to 1100°C) in SOFC production. A GDC source substrate was printed with LSCF and separated by an air gap from a YSZ target substrate. Various geometries with long surface paths were employed to reduce the possibility of surface transport. Sr and Co were detected on the target substrates via energy dispersive spectroscopy (EDS) and x-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS), including spatially resolved XPS. These results support a vapor-phase transport mechanism for Sr and Co. Sintering conditions and barrier layer requirements may need to be revisited to prevent the formation of undesired strontium zirconate at cathode/electrolyte interface due to vapor-phase transport.
All-solid-state batteries are a candidate for next-generation energy-storage devices due to potential improvements in energy density and safety compared to current battery technologies. Due to their high ionic conductivity and potential scalability through slurry processing routes, sulfide solid-state electrolytes are promising to replace traditional liquid electrolytes and enable All-solid-state batteries, but stability of cathode-sulfide solid-state electrolytes interfaces requires further improvement. Herein we review common issues encountered at cathode-sulfide SE interfaces and strategies to alleviate these issues.