Coal Combustion Residuals for Critical Minerals
Presentation on Coal Combustion Residuals for CORE-CM
Gray, Danny↗
SEARCH · Search NASA
Results for “coal combustion residues”
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Accumulation of trace elements in soil and fauna within a site historically contaminated with coal combustion residues
Legacy contaminants tied to energy production are a worldwide concern. Coal combustion residues (CCRs) contain high concentrations of potentially toxic trace elements such as arsenic (As), mercury (Hg), and selenium (Se), which can persist for decades after initial contamination. Coal combustion residue disposal methods, including aquatic settling basins and landfills, can facilitate environmental exposure through intentional and accidental releases. Wildlife exposed to CCRs can experience numerous deleterious effects, such as on development, reproduction, and survival. In the current study, we quantified and compared concentrations of As, Hg, Se, and strontium (Sr) within soils and target fauna (three vertebrate and three invertebrate taxa) from a CCR-contaminated site and a reference site within the U.S. Department of Energy’s Savannah River Site, South Carolina, United States. Our objectives were to (1) compare current concentrations of tested elements in soil and resident fauna to levels from our reference site, (2) assess natural attenuation of elements in soils by comparing current concentrations to historic levels, and (3) evaluate the biomagnification potential of the elements measured via body burden and trophic position correlations among fauna. Here, element concentrations were higher in contaminated soils than reference soils; however, concentrations in 2022 were unchanged from concentrations measured in 2003, suggesting no natural attenuation of tested elements. Additionally, target fauna had elevated As, Se, and Sr levels in comparison to reference samples. A positive correlation was observed in southern toads between Sr concentrations and trophic position, as assessed by nitrogen stable isotope ratios, suggesting potential for biomagnification of Sr within our study system. Collectively, our results demonstrate that legacy contaminants are still present and bioaccumulate in a diversity of taxa in a CCR-contaminated site that has not received effluents in more than 50 years, suggesting monitoring programs in CCR-contaminated sites should be maintained long term in the absence of remediation.
63 RADIATION, THERMAL, AND OTHER ENVIRON. POLLUTAN↗
High Strength, Encapsulated, Commercially Useful Components and Particles Made from Coal Combustion Residuals
This project has developed and demonstrated two high-volume applications for Coal Combustion Residuals (CCR) with annual usage on the order of billions of pounds. The CCR is encapsulated in a recently developed water-impervious inorganic resin coating to reduce leaching of toxic elements from CCR by more than 80% as a first step. Target commercial applications demonstrated for the encapsulated CCR were as reinforcement for high-strength structural columns composed of CCR embedded in a ceramic matrix and as filler in high-volume plastics such as polypropylene. The encapsulated particles produced columns with properties superior to concrete, and a 30% to 50% improvement in stiffness over current fillers in plastics. CCR from bituminous and lignite coal was evaluated and shown to provide high performance, with the bituminous CCR producing the strongest columns and the lignite-based CCR provided the best performance as coated filler in polypropylene. The two-year project advanced both material systems from a Technology Readiness Level (TRL) of 2 to TRL 4.
01 COAL, LIGNITE, AND PEAT↗
Novel Membrane and Electrodeposition-Based Separation and Recovery of Rare Earth Elements from Coal Combustion Residues (Final Report)
This project developed a hydrometallurgical-based technology to extract and concentrate rare earth elements (REEs) from a representative group of coal combustion residuals (CCRs) from major coal sources in the United States. The approach for REE recovery comprises two general components: (1) Leaching of REEs from CCRs and (2) Separation of REEs from other major ions in the CCR leachate. The leaching step entails acid leaching with nitric or hydrochloric acid, and in some cases, pretreatment of CCRs with alkaline roasting prior to acid leaching. The follow-up REE recovery steps involve a series of membrane-based methods to separate and concentrate rare earth ions from other major ions in acid leachates of CCRs. These methods include liquid emulsion membranes, supported liquid membranes and electrodeposition with carbon nanotube electrochemical filters. The advantage of these separation approaches (relative to conventional approaches such as solvent extraction) is a reduction in the usage of solvents and other costly chemicals and a reduction of hazardous waste products that are challenges in conventional REE separation methods. In the testing of our process, we selected a representative set of CCR samples from our collection and performed a suite of characterization measurements (total REE content and major mineralogy). The major results of this work demonstrated that heated acid leaching could efficiently extract REEs from PRB-based coal fly ashes while the Appalachian and Illinois Basin CCRs required alkaline roasting with NaOH prior to acid leaching at room temperature. The supported liquid membrane (SLM) configuration and electrochemical deposition (ED) system yielded the most promising methods of REE recovery from the acid leachates of fly ash. Our most concentrated product to date comprised 1 wt.% (dry basis) REEs produced from an Appalachian-based fly ash leached and purified by SLM. The SLM separation process was more selective for heavy REEs over the light REEs. When SLM was combined with ED, preliminary results demonstrated that a final product of >2 wt.% REEs was possible.
01 COAL, LIGNITE, AND PEAT↗
A Scalable Process for Upcycling Carbon Dioxide (CO 2 ) and Coal Combustion Residues into Construction Products
Anthropogenic sources of carbon dioxide are generated from a number of sources, but the key among these are ordinary Portland cement (OPC) production and combustion of fossil fuels. Cement production is the largest global CO 2 source from the mineral decomposition of carbonates. Combination of the limestone decomposition and thermal requirements of the clinkering process causes cement production to contribute 8-9% of annual global CO 2 emissions. Combustion of fossil fuels (coal, oil and gas) was shown to contribute a much larger portion of global CO 2 emissions. As of 2018, combustion of fossil fuels accounted for 65% of global CO 2 , where 41% was derived from stationary sources for electricity and heat generation and the other 24% was related to transport. To reduce these contributions, key steps forward in CO 2 utilization technologies are required. The purpose of this project is to demonstrate the feasibility of the Reversa process evolving from a TRL-3 technology at the bench-scale up to TRL-6 technology at the pilot-scale. The reliability of the Reversa technology was tested to prove the effective production of concrete masonry units (CMUs) at bench scale, where the units exceeded the required 13.8 MPa compressive strength requirements. The overall goal of this project was to accelerate the development of a CO 2 mineralization process that synergistically utilizes CO 2 in flue gas and coal combustion residues (CCRs) to synthesize carbonated concrete, a functional replacement for traditional concrete. The culmination of this work resulted in 12 successful production runs at the Integrated Test Center (ITC), Gillette, WY using coal flue gas as a CO 2 source. This was followed by 6 production runs which were completed at the National Carbon Capture Center (NCCC), Wilsonville, AL, using coal-fired and natural gas (NG) flue gas as the CO 2 source. Over the course of the production runs at NCCC and ITC, the CO 2 utilization as a function of time, 24-h CO 2 uptake, electricity usage, and 28-d net area compressive strength recorded for each run. The ITC and NCCC demonstrations achieved an average of 0.19 and 0.1 g CO 2 /g reactant, respectively. Both demonstrations exceeded the project’s target goals of uptake > 0.05 g CO 2 /g reactant. Average compressive strength of the ITC blocks was 18.24 MPa at 28-days. This exceeded the target strength of 13.8 MPa specified by ASTM C90. ITC and NCCC produced an average CO 2 utilization efficiency of 74.9 and 57.9%, respectively. Both demonstration averages were within the target range of 50 to 90% utilization efficiency. For some production runs the NCCC demo did exceeded the a CO 2 utilization efficiency of 75%. An LCA of the Reversa process compared to an industry standard product revealed a net CO 2 reduction of 39% to 42%. This exceeded the target requirement of >25% net CO 2 reduction. Collection of this data was used to determine that the project was successful as the demonstration goals were achieved: (1) achieving in excess of 75% CO 2 utilization efficiency, (2) utilizing greater than 250 kg of CO 2 per production batch/run, and (3) ensuring compliance of carbonated blocks with industry standard specifications (ASTM C90).
37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
Bioaccumulation of contaminants in Scarabaeidae and Silphidae beetles at sites polluted by coal combustion residuals and radiocesium
Anthropogenic contamination from coal-fired power plants and nuclear reactors is a pervasive issue impacting ecosystems across the globe. As a result, it is critical that studies continue to assess the accumulation and effects of trace elements and radionuclides in a diversity of biota. In particular, bioindicator species are a powerful tool for risk assessment of chemically contaminated habitats. Using inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (ICP-MS) and auto-gamma counting, we analyzed trace element and radiocesium contaminant concentrations in Scarabaeidae and Silphidae beetles (Order: Coleoptera), important taxa in decomposition and nutrient cycling, at contaminated and reference sites on the Savannah River Site, South Carolina, U.S. Our results revealed variability in trace element concentrations between Scarabaeidae and Silphidae beetles at uncontaminated and contaminated sites. Compared to Scarabaeidae, Silphidae had higher levels of chromium (Cr), copper (Cu), iron (Fe), manganese (Mn), nickel (Ni), and zinc (Zn). Unexpectedly, concentrations of Cr, Cu, and Ni were higher in both taxa at the uncontaminated sites. Scarabaeidae and Silphidae beetles at the coal combustion waste site consistently had high concentrations of arsenic (As), and Scarabaeidae had high concentrations of selenium (Se). Of the 50 beetles analyzed for radiocesium levels, two had elevated radioactivity concentrations, both of which were from a site contaminated with radionuclides. Furthermore, our results suggest carrion beetles may be particularly sensitive to bioaccumulation of contaminants due to their trophic position and role in decomposition, and thus are useful sentinels of trace element and radionuclide contamination.
59 BASIC BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES↗
Synthesis and Functionalization of Coal Fly Ash-Derived Zeolites for Boron Removal From Wastewater
There are hundreds of both active and unused surface impoundments in the United States containing coal combustion residuals (CCRs) produced by coal-fired power plants which can leach toxic elements into surface and groundwater. Therefore, the development of efficient means for both the clean-up of surface impoundments and for deriving economically viable products from CCRs are urgent tasks for researchers. Herein, a microwave-assisted strategy is presented for converting a common coal combustion residual, coal fly ash (CFA), into zeolite-based sorbents for boron (B) removal from wastewater. Specifically, CFA constitutes the main source of Si and Al ions to produce zeolite type-A and the resulting sorbent subsequently undergoes simple cation exchange with Ca to enhance its B adsorption capacity. Structure and composition of the sorbents were characterized by X-ray diffraction (XRD), scanning electron microscopy (SEM), energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDS), inductively coupled plasma (ICP)-mass spectrometry (MS), and ICP-optical emission spectroscopy (OES). The Ca-modified zeolite sorbent derived from CFA exhibits comparable B removal capacity with similar commercial zeolites.
Muldoon, Patrick↗
Predictive Assessment of the Chemical Composition of Coal Ash in Reserve at U.S. Disposal Sites
In the United States, more than 2 Gt of coal combustion residuals (i.e., coal ash) are stored in hundreds of disposal units. Recent federal regulations mandate the closure or retrofitting of most coal ash impoundments, presenting significant challenges for waste management. These regulatory pressures also present opportunities to reuse coal ash. However, the quality and quantity of discarded coal ash across the U.S. are not well known, even though this information is crucial for spurring its reuse for conventional and new material applications. This study describes a predictive model for the major element composition of coal ash in reserve at disposal sites of major U.S. coal-fired power plants. This model was constructed from coal purchase records of 705 power stations from 1973 to 2022 and was trained on coal ash composition data, showing that coal ash elemental composition is strongly associated with the source of feedstock coal. The model showed regional shifts in the major element contents of ash produced by power plants in the last 50 years, particularly for calcium and iron (expressed as %CaO and %Fe2O3), as power stations changed their source of coal over this time frame. Our approach enables an estimation of chemical composition for ash stored in waste impoundments at individual power stations. Such information can help to delineate the regional market resource potential of supplementary cements for concrete and other material innovations that would utilize coal ash harvested from disposal sites across the U.S.
01 COAL, LIGNITE, AND PEAT↗
Elucidating Arsenic and Selenium Speciation in Coal Fly Ashes
Coal fly ash (CFA) is produced during the coal combustion process and contains trace elements (<100 ppm) including selenium (Se) and arsenic (As), both detrimental for environmental and human health. Existing management strategies for CFAs involve disposal in landfills and ash ponds, as well as beneficial usage in other applications such as in concrete. Both the direct disposal and beneficial usage of CFA raise concerns for environmental hazards due to the potential leaching of Se and As. CFAs were classified as reusable material by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) with the first federal regulation (Disposal of Coal Combustion Residuals from Electric Utilities, CCR) for its disposal established six years ago. During coal combustion process, parameters such as furnace firing type, emissions controls, coal rank, use of additives, and particulate matter controls, could contribute to significant variability in As/Se concentrations and their speciation. Although there have been a handful of studies on As/Se speciation on small sets of samples, they do not fully represent the current state of coal-fired electrical generating units. Little information exists on the detailed speciation (e.g. oxidation state, complexation state) of As/Se in large set of fly ash samples. To better investigate the role of the potential contributing parameters, a large-scale survey study with representative samples of typical coal source and combustion conditions is highly desired. The overall goal of this research is to systematically characterize As and Se speciation of representative coal fly ash samples using state-of-the-art synchrotron based spectroscopic and microscopic techniques, in order to develop a correlation between coal source/type, operation condition, As/Se speciation, and As/Se mobility. A detailed survey study was conducted documenting the current state-of-knowledge on fossil power generating units as a function of coal type/source, operating conditions, environmental control systems, additive use, and fly ash handling methods. Based on this survey, a matrix of fly ash samples representing a range of conditions were chosen and collected. The collected ash samples were analyzed for bulk characteristics such as elemental composition, microstructure, chemical and mineralogical composition, surface area, and particle size distribution. State-of-the-art synchrotron X-ray microscopy and spectroscopy techniques were applied to reveal the molecular scale speciation information of As and Se, such as oxidation state, association with other elements/minerals, and complexation states.
01 COAL, LIGNITE, AND PEAT↗
A Data-driven Phytotechnology Framework for Identification and Remediation of Leached-Metals-Contaminated Soil Near Coal Ash Impoundments
This project developed and evaluated advanced remote sensing and machine learning approaches to identify, monitor, and address environmental contamination associated with coal combustion residual (CCR) impoundments and landfills at coal-fired power plants. In Phase I, historical and multi-temporal Sentinel-2 satellite imagery, groundwater monitoring data, and environmental variables were integrated to detect vegetation stress potentially caused by toxic metal leaching from coal ash disposal sites. Multiple vegetation and biophysical indices were analyzed to determine their effectiveness in identifying abnormal vegetation growth patterns linked to contamination. Results from case studies conducted at coal ash–impacted power plant sites in North Carolina and Virginia demonstrated that satellite-based vegetation monitoring can serve as an effective early indicator of environmental stress associated with metals such as arsenic, cadmium, cobalt, lead, lithium, radium, and thallium.
01 COAL, LIGNITE, AND PEAT↗
Advanced Characterization of Wastewaters with a Focus on the Environment & Economics (Final Technical Progress Report)
This project, funded by the U.S. Department of Energy under award DE-FE0032457 and conducted at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, focused on advancing the characterization of coal combustion residual (CCR) effluents. The primary objectives were to develop analytical methods for detecting major cations, anions, trace metals, and rare earth elements (REEs) in CCR wastewater, assess environmental impacts, and explore opportunities for resource recovery. The project advanced the development of a "One-Shot" analysis system designed to simultaneously analyze multiple analytes in CCR effluents.
01 COAL, LIGNITE, AND PEAT↗
Treatment Technology Assessment for Landfill Leachate
This presentation by NETL was given at the 2022 American Society of Mechanical Engineers conference in Pittsburgh, PA (July 18-21, 2022). The presentation gives an overview of an analysis of wastewater emissions associated with coal combustion residual leachate, including constituents present, variability according to coal type burned at the plant, national estimates of total volume of wastewater that requires treatment, and the cost to treat.
Able, Chad↗
Treatment Technology Assessment for Landfill Leachate (Video)
This presentation by NETL was given at the 2022 American Society of Mechanical Engineers conference in Pittsburgh, PA (July 18-21, 2022). The presentation gives an overview of an analysis of wastewater emissions associated with coal combustion residual leachate, including constituents present, variability according to coal type burned at the plant, national estimates of total volume of wastewater that requires treatment, and the cost to treat.
Able, Chad↗
Coal-Waste-Enhanced Filaments for Additive Manufacturing of High-Temperature Plastics and Ceramic Composites
In the United States, coal waste from over a century of mining and burning coal for heat and electricity has accumulated as mountains of coal fly ash and bottom ash and acre-size ponds, coal fines and gob. These materials can be a problem for local communities and water systems. A cost-effective process to utilize high volumes of these coal wastes in a high-value product would be beneficial to those communities by reducing the amount of waste and providing jobs, manufacturing components, and materials from the waste. Many coal-to-products technologies (e.g., carbon fibers, graphene, carbon foam) rely on carefully choosing the starting material and then altering it chemically or thermally to make the products work. Due to the wide variability of composition and coal content in typical coal waste streams, many high-volume coal waste streams are likely to be unsuitable for use in those technologies. Semplastics’ technology has been shown to utilize most types of coal waste successfully without any pre-selection or pre-processing requirements other than a nominal particle-size reduction for wastes like bottom ash. This characteristic of Semplastics’ solution may enable the use of much larger volumes of a wider range of coal wastes than other coal-to-products technologies. In this project, Semplastics leveraged its unique experience with both coal waste (fly ash or coal combustion residuals), resin materials, and 3D printing to develop 3D printer filaments using common coal wastes – bituminous coal fines and fly ash – and researched the feasibility of using other forms of coal waste as fillers. Simple 3D-printed parts were successfully produced from the coal waste enhanced filaments, which were found to have improved strength and stiffness.
01 COAL, LIGNITE, AND PEAT↗
Modeling and Optimization of Zeolites for Contaminant Removal from Coal Combustion Impoundment Leachates
Coal Combustion Residual (CCR) landfills in the U.S. can lead to elevated contaminant concentrations in groundwater and runoff, particularly of arsenic, boron, and selenium. Zeolites can be readily synthesized from materials contained within the coal combustion ash impoundments and can be cation-exchanged to enhance adsorption capacity, selectivity, and reactivity. However, the optimization of zeolites becomes a daunting task when accounting for the variety of Si:Al ratios, the species of extra-framework cations present, and the zeolite pore structure. Molecular simulations provide methods to study and guide the design of zeolites for the sorption of contaminants from aqueous solution. In this work, models that predict the sorption of arsenic, boron, and selenium from water using cation-exchanged zeolites. Because of the lack of experimental adsorption data for these species of contaminants, models were parametrized to reproduce the results of first-principles calculations and then used to predict sorption for zeolites for a dataset containing 6000 combinations of zeolites and sorption conditions. Machine learning was used to train a model to predict sorption for materials in this database based on the results of the molecular simulations. Next, a genetic algorithm was used to optimize zeolites for the removal of each contaminant from aqueous solution for individual impoundment sites based on contaminant concentrations reported by the Electric Power Research Institute.
Findley, John↗
A Comprehensive Survey of Coal Ash Law and Commercialization: Its Environmental Risks, Disposal Regulation, and Beneficial Use Markets
This white paper was commissioned by the National Association of Regulatory Utility Commissioners (NARUC) under a grant from the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE), in response to a major rule, Hazardous and Solid Waste Management System; Disposal of Coal Combustion Residuals From Electric Utilities; Final Rule (Final Rule) issued by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) on April 17, 2015, on coal ash disposal and remediation of disposal sites, which has significant implications to states. It subjects state environmental agencies and public utility commissions to regulatory responsibilities to implement federal regulations under the Final Rule and oversee the cost implications on electric customers. To better evaluate the regulatory issues underlying the choices facing utilities and independent power producers (IPPs) regarding coal ash management options under the Final Rule, an overview of coal ash production and disposal practices is helpful. This comprehensive survey provides background information on the following topics: (a) coal ash production by a coal combustion generation plant, (b) the historical practices of utility waste management practices, (c) coal ash toxicity and related constituents, (d) further understanding of potential impacts to groundwater, and (e) the aging structures and outdated designs of coal ash surface impoundments and landfills.
01 COAL, LIGNITE, AND PEAT↗
A survey study on arsenic speciation in coal fly ash and insights into the role of coal combustion conditions
Coal fly ashes (CFAs) are the low-density byproducts of the coal combustion process. Improper or uncontrolled CFA disposal poses significant environmental and health concerns due to the potential leaching of toxic heavy metals such as arsenic (As). Previous studies have investigated the content and speciation of As in different CFA samples, yet systematic information on As speciation in CFA with representative coal source and combustion conditions is still missing. Based on a recent survey study on the typical coal sources and combustion conditions across the U.S., this study selected 19 representative CFA samples to systematically investigate As speciation and potential correlations with these parameters. The composition, morphology, mineralogy, and As speciation of these CFA samples were characterized by complementary analytical, microscopic, and spectroscopic techniques. Synchrotron X-ray spectroscopy and microscopy analyses revealed the dominant As oxidation state to be As(V) and with strong associations to Ca, with the exception of 3 samples that had 19–51% As(III), likely due to the use of selective catalytic reduction (SCR) process. Principal component analysis was conducted to identify potential correlations of As concentration and oxidation state with parameters such as major element content, loss on ignition (LOI), average particle size, coal source, and combustion condition. Al 2 O 3 and FeO content were found to capture a majority of the variability. Further, results from this study provide fundamental basis for understanding the correlations between coal source, combustion conditions, CFA characteristics, and As speciation, and providing insights for downstream beneficial utilization or disposal management.
01 COAL, LIGNITE, AND PEAT↗
NEWTS Economic Data Dashboard: Critical Materials for Energy
The NEWTS Economic Data Dashboard: Critical Materials for Energy is an economic screening tool for assessing the concentration and potential value of the 18 critical materials for energy in fossil energy-related wastewater across the United States. Datasets used to develop the dashboard and complete economic calculations are available as supplementary downloads. These resources were developed primarily using geochemical composition and volume data from the NEWTS Integrated dataset (version 1.0). Energy-related wastewater types presented in the dashboard include produced water (PW), brackish groundwater (BW), acid mine drainage (AMD), coal combustion residual leachate (CCRL), power plant flue gas desulfurization wastewater (FGD), and geothermal fluids. The concentrations of the following critical minerals were included in the analysis, when available: Al, Co, Cu, Dy, F, Ga, Ge, C, Ir, Li, Mg, Mn, Nd, Ni, Pt, Pr, Si, Tb. This economic screening tool was built to support identification of promising critical mineral feedstocks and economic research targets.
Critical Minerals; Critical Minerals and Materials↗