Search NASASearch

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “damage”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 19 records

Heterogeneous energetic material damage simulator (HEDS): A deep learning approach to simulate damage–sensitivity linkages

Damage in the microstructures of energetic materials (EMs), such as propellants and plastic bonded explosives (PBXs), can significantly alter their response to external loads. Both sensitization and desensitization can occur, causing concerns with safety and performance in the field; predictive models that connect damage and the sensitivity of EMs can enable design and provide confidence in their robustness and reliability. However, modeling of damage evolution is challenging for real microstructures of EMs; samples of damaged EMs are difficult to obtain, thereby hindering experiments and direct numerical simulations to determine the sensitivity of EMs at various stages of damage. Here, we develop an approach to generate synthetic, i.e., in silico produced, damaged microstructures for use in simulations to connect damage levels to sensitivity. The development of the present workflow to generate and impose varying levels of damage in microstructures, known as HEDS (Heterogeneous Energetic Material Damage Simulator), begins with a small set of images of damaged PBXs and combines a collection of deep neural network techniques to generate microstructures with varying levels of damage. By making the synthetic microstructures conform closely to those observed in available real, imaged microstructures, we develop an ensemble of damaged microstructures that can be used for in silico shock experiments. HEDS develops these microstructure ensembles as level set fields, which are directly employed in a sharp interface Eulerian hydrocode where shock simulations are performed to quantify the energy release rate from hotspot fields generated in the microstructure. These capabilities can be useful for the analysis and assessment of changes in the sensitivity of EMs and to design formulations that are less susceptible to damage-induced changes in sensitivity and performance.

Fang, Irene (ORCID:0009000844557122)

Monte Carlo simulation analysis for radiation damage on Glidcop Al-15 caused by 17-20 MeV/u heavy ions

The Facility for Rare Isotope Beams (FRIB) SRF linear heavy-ion accelerator is designed to accelerate all ions up to uranium to a maximum beam power of 400 kW. Several beam intercepting devices (BIDs) are essential to the successful operation of the accelerator, including a low power charge selector (LPCS) made of copper containing 0.15% precipitated aluminum oxide by weight called Glidcop Al-15. As FRIB ramps up the primary beam power beyond the current 20 kW level, the charge selector must withstand higher radiation damage rates, typically measured in displacements per atom (dpa). Significant beam induced radiation damage including significant deformation, like swelling, blistering, and cracking has been observed on a recently removed LPCS. We also observed physical features up to about 5.5 mm wide and appear to be deeper than the projected range of any ions. This paper presents the results of Monte Carlo simulations carried out using the Particle and Heavy Ion Transport code System (PHITS), quantifying the total damage dose and ion concentration, etc. Simulating an accurate irradiation history is essential to determining the scope of post irradiation examination (PIE) work.

Fletcher, Ethan [Michigan State U.]

Modeling Clustered DNA Damage by Ionizing Radiation Using Multinomial Damage Probabilities and Energy Imparted Spectra

Simple and complex clustered DNA damage represent the critical initial damage caused by radiation. In this paper, a multinomial probability model of clustered damage is developed with probabilities dependent on the energy imparted to DNA and surrounding water molecules. The model consists of four probabilities: (A) direct damage of sugar-phosphate moieties leading to SSB, (B) OH− radical formation with subsequent SSB and BD formation, (C) direct damage to DNA bases, and (D) energy imparted to histone proteins and other molecules in a volume not leading to SSB or BD. These probabilities are augmented by introducing probabilities for the relative location of SSB using a ≤10 bp criteria for a double-strand break (DSB) and for the possible success of a radical attack that leads to SSB or BD. Model predictions for electrons, 4He, and 12C ions are compared to the experimental data and show good agreement. Thus, the developed model allows an accurate and rapid computational method to predict simple and complex clustered DNA damage as a function of radiation quality and to explore the resulting challenges to DNA repair.

Biochemistry & Molecular Biology

A chain stretch-based gradient-enhanced model for damage and fracture in elastomers

Similar to quasi-brittle materials, it has been recently shown that elastomers can exhibit a macroscopically diffuse damage zone that accompanies the fracture process. In this study, we introduce a stretch-based gradient-enhanced damage (GED) model that allows the fracture to localize and also captures the development of a physically diffuse damage zone. This capability contrasts with the paradigm of the phase field method for fracture, where a sharp crack is numerically approximated in a diffuse manner. Capturing fracture localization and diffuse damage in our approach is achieved by considering nonlocal effects that encompass network topology, heterogeneity, and imperfections. These considerations motivate the use of a statistical damage function dependent upon the nonlocal deformation state. From this model, fracture toughness is realized as an output. While GED models have been classically utilized for damage modeling of structural engineering materials (e.g., concrete), they face challenges when trying to capture the cascade from damage to fracture, often leading to damage zone broadening (de Borst and Verhoosel, 2016). This deficiency contributed to the popularity of the phase-field method over the GED model for elastomers and other quasi-brittle materials. Other groups have proceeded with damage-based GED formulations that prove identical to the phase-field method (Lorentz et al., 2012), but these inherit the aforementioned limitations. To address this issue in a thermodynamically consistent framework, we implement two modeling features (a nonlocal driving force bound and a simple relaxation function) specifically designed to capture the evolution of a physically meaningful damage field and the simultaneous localization of fracture, thereby overcoming a longstanding obstacle in the development of these nonlocal strain- or stretch-based approaches. Here, we discuss several numerical examples to understand the features of the approach at the limit of incompressibility, and compare them to the phase-field method as a benchmark for the macroscopic response and fracture energy predictions.

Elastomers

Understanding spectral dependance of laser-induced damage precursors in dielectric materials (Abbreviated report_23-ERD-006)

High peak and average power laser systems are typically limited by the handling fluence of the optical components. In particular, the multilayer dielectric coatings are known to be much lower operational fluence than the more ideal bulk materials. In this project we proposed and succeeded in probing different established classes of damage prone precursors at different wavelengths to understand their fundamental laser damage response as a function of wavelength. This study helped to shed light on the fundamental physics of the non-linear precursors that govern laser damage phenomena for ns-regime pulsed laser damage. In this study, we utilized the onsite coating capabilities (VPL, IBS coating lab) to purposefully generate laser damage-prone precursors in hafnia-based coatings (both single and multi-layer coatings). Specifically, we engineered coatings with craze lines initiated by nodules, generated coatings with our xenon-based coating process to suppress nanobubble formation and generated hafnia coatings under controlled oxygen flow conditions to study hafnia sub-oxides and oxygen flow dependance. In these studies we found that craze lines are rife with precursors that are sensitive to ultra-violet light but not to infrared light; we found that the removal of nanobubbles helps with all wavelengths tested, but is most impactful for ultra-violet light; we also found that ultra-violet laser damage performance of hafnia is closely matched to oxygen flow rate, while the infrared performance may be slightly better at lower flow rates. During this LDRD we also successfully stood up a new laser damage testing capability, namely a wavelength agile damage test station to study the spectral response of known laser-induced damage precursors. This is a unique and important capability for Lawrence Livermore National Lab, allowing us to understand the spectral response of materials under high intensity irradiation and damage. This is a vital tool to understand non-linear optical response at wavelengths that we have previously been unable to test at.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE

Laser damage of crazed electron-beam high-reflectors following infrared and ultraviolet irradiation in the nanosecond pulse regime

Laser damage of optical components can be a limiting factor in scaling the energetics of high-peak and average power laser systems. Specifically for optical coatings, damage under nanosecond pulsed irradiation is initiated by pre-existing defects in the coating layers, including those that cause discontinuities in the structure, like craze lines. Crazing or cracking in a multilayer dielectric optical coating is induced when the overall coating stress is sufficiently tensile, and is an occasionally observed issue when employing more porous deposition techniques like electron-beam evaporation. Here, in this study, electron-beam high-reflectors were fabricated utilizing process parameters that are known to induce crazing based on prior processing history to systematically evaluate the impact of crazing on reflector damage performance for 1064 and 355 nm lasers. The crazing that was observed was apparently nucleated at nodular defects. When the cross-section of these nodules was investigated, it was observed that there were cracks into the fused silica substrate of approximately 5 µm in depth. The craze lines were irradiated with 1064 and 355 nm light at fluences slightly above the onset of damage initiation fluence of the coating. The 1064 nm irradiated sub-apertures exhibit laser damage but with no spatial correlation with the craze line, whereas the 355 nm irradiated area exhibited many damage sites along the craze line. Finite-difference time-domain electric-field simulations were conducted, and ∼2× field amplification in hafnia was observed for the 355 nm wavelength case. The laser damage can be attributed to a slight electric-field intensification coincidental with an area where UV damage-prone precursors are known to occur. The 355 nm laser damage in uncoated fused silica substrates has been previously correlated to initiate through localized UV absorption at the broken silica bonds in the tips of fractures.

Harthcock, Colin [Lawrence Livermore National Labo

Development of a robust damage analysis scheme at the National Ignition Facility

The onset of laser-induced damage in optical materials is a limiting factor in the design and operation of most high-energy laser systems. As such, significant effort has been dedicated to developing laser damage testing protocols and procedures to inform laser system design and operating limits. These tests typically rely on multiple laser exposures for statistical validation. Historically, small beam single fluence (N / 1) or ramped fluence (R / 1) tests have been used to quantify the “laser-induced damage threshold” of a material. However, due to various distributions in damage precursor populations, the laser fluence at which damage occurs for a given sample varies with beam size and is therefore better described as the onset of observed damage for that testing geometry. In conclusion, we document the development of irradiation, measurement, and analysis methods for damage testing resulting in damage initiation density as a function of incident fluence or ρ(ϕ) which is suitable for both small and large beam area testing and more conducive to extrapolating from one to the other.

Beam diameter

Satellite Imagery of PV Site Storm Damage

"This repository contains multiple data sets focused on visible damage to photovoltaic (PV) installations following extreme weather events such as hailstorms and hurricanes. Data sets are split into two categories: the first category, the ‘manually labeled’ data, was compiled by researchers manually, and contains manually identified PV sites exposed to storms. The second data set, the ‘aggregated’ data, is a compilation of the manually labeled PV sites and deep learning-identified PV sites. The hail damage data set focuses on post-storm PV damage following a September 24, 2023 hailstorm in Austin, TX, which caused over $600 million in damages in the Austin metro area. The hurricane damage data set focuses on post-storm PV damage following Hurricanes Irma and Maria in Puerto Rico and the US Virgin Islands. Hurricanes Irma and Maria were back-to-back category 5 hurricanes, which pummeled the Caribbean and southeastern United States in September 2017, causing an estimated $115.2 billion in damages."

14 SOLAR ENERGY

Heterogeneous fatigue damage in a nickel-based single-crystal superalloy unraveled using correlative 3D X-ray technology

Nickel-based single-crystal (Ni-SX) superalloys under cyclic stress are susceptible to cracking at stress-concentration sites, eventually leading to low-cycle fatigue (LCF) failure. LCF cracks typically originate from intrinsic defects (e.g., voids and carbides) within solidified dendrites. However, systematic quantitative experimental analyses of defect-mediated local damage remain limited. To thoroughly understand the microscopic origins and evolution of LCF damage, correlated 3D mapping of dendrites across various regions is essential. Here, in this study, macroscale micro-computed tomography (μ-CT) was initially used to capture internal interdendritic secondary cracks within bulk DD413 superalloy after LCF testing at 760 °C. Subsequently, a multimodal methodology combining synchrotron 3D microdiffraction (3D-μXRD), high-resolution μ-CT, and electron microscopy was established. This approach allowed precise localization of internal damage zones near interdendritic secondary cracks and detailed mapping of the 3D correlated distributions of dendrites, defects, and residual stress/strain fields within these zones at submicron spatial resolution. Finally, the same approach was applied to specimens subjected to interrupted loading at approximately 40 % of the fatigue life to uncover the early damage states of dendrites. The dendrite cores (DCs) and interdendritic regions (IDs) exhibit microscale heterogeneous mechanical responses: nearly defect-free DCs accumulate local irreversible slip along specific slip systems to generate slip bands, while the IDs containing various defects accommodate local microplasticity through the activation of multiple slip systems around these defects. The local tensile stress near defects in the IDs exceeds that in the DC slip band regions by more than threefold, leading to the generation of local damage zones within the IDs. Chain-like defect distributions facilitate the interconnection of these local zones into a continuous damage region, further elevating the overall tensile stress in the IDs. Additionally, geometrically necessary dislocations alone are insufficient as indicators of LCF damage; both the internal stress state and its magnitude must be considered. These experimental results provide critical data and insights for the development of multi-physics fatigue models.

Localized deformation

Detecting damage in composites using volume decomposition analysis of tomographic data

Detection of damage in a single tow ceramic matrix composite specimen has been achieved using orthogonal decomposition of volumetric tomographic datasets collected at four tensile loads. This decomposition approach has been applied at two different length scales: (i) individual fibres and (ii) bulk volumes containing fibres and matrix material. Volumes were first decomposed to feature vectors, orders of magnitude smaller than the original volume they describe, and then comparisons between datasets at different load levels were made in feature vector space. The results show quantitative measurements of damage location, damage morphology and the relative growth of this damage with increased load when compared with a dataset with less or no damage. No prior knowledge of the dataset or training of algorithms is required for damage to be detected, it is only necessary that at least two datasets are available for comparison, e.g. from in situ or repeated scanning measurements. Results are generated on significantly shorter timescales when compared with previous automated approaches to tomography data processing. This approach has the potential to be applied to damage detection in a range of materials through comparisons of volumetric datasets from a range of measurement or computational techniques.

Middleton, Ceri A.

Capturing the fractocohesive length scale in elastomers through a statistical mechanics-based gradient enhanced damage model

Here, this study aims to examine modeling flaw sensitivity in elastomers. The direct incorporation of polymer chain statistical mechanics considerations into a continuum stretch-based gradient-enhanced damage formulation, in turn, allows a representation of diffuse chain damage and fracture events that align with known micromechanical mechanisms. Through a series of numerical experiments, we simulate crack propagation and extract the fracture energy as an output of the model, while keeping track of the micromechanical signatures of diffuse chain damage that accommodate fracture propagation and eventually influence flaw sensitivity. Finally, by combining the fracture toughness and the work to rupture, we identify a fractocohesive length of the material, corresponding to the full width of the damage process zone. As the damage-to-fracture cascade in the proposed GED model is influenced by the introduction of a length scale associated with network imperfection and long-range load transfer, the emerging relationship of the two length scales is discussed, providing a potential link between microscopic damage mechanisms and the observed macroscopic fracture response.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE

Radiation damage study of POCO ZXF-5Q graphite for neutrino production targets using 4.5 MeV helium ions

To address the challenges of increased beam power and target survivability associated with next-generation particle production beam lines, high dose, high-energy proton beam conditions are simulated using irradiation from low-energy ion beams. A low-energy ion irradiation study of POCO ZXF-5Q graphite under conditions similar to those of the NuMI NT-02 neutrino production target at the Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory is reported. Helium ion irradiation was performed at 100 ∘ C to a maximum damage level of 0.9 displacements per atom (DPA). Irradiation induced hardening, swelling of the irradiated region, inter-plane lattice expansion, and intraplane lattice contraction with increasing ion fluence was observed using micromechanical (nanoindentation, atomic force microscopy) and electron microscopy (high-resolution imaging, selected area diffraction) characterization. Similar changes were also observed in post irradiation examination of the NT-02 target indicating that ion irradiation can be a valuable tool for estimating radiation damage in proton beam targets. Caution must be exercised though, because the hardening, lattice alteration, and swelling occur to different magnitudes for a given damage level. The observed hardening and embrittlement were greater for ion irradiated graphite. For He ion irradiated samples the lattice spacing changes were smaller at low damage levels (78% less expansion and 71% less contraction at 0.1 DPA) and larger at high damage levels (38% more expansion and 5% more contraction at 0.9 DPA) relative to that observed in the NT-02 target. The magnitude of swelling was 8.5× greater under ion irradiation which is influenced by the differing damage gradients and inclusion of implanted He ions in the region of interest.

43 PARTICLE ACCELERATORS

Damage modeling of power tower receiver tubes using the SRLIFE tool

Concentrating Solar Power (CSP) molten-salt central receivers are subject to high, transient incident flux during daily operation. The resulting creep-fatigue damage impacts the receiver’s reliability and restricts the permissible incident flux distribution for a given receiver. This paper aims to reduce CSP plants’ levelized cost of electricity by developing a methodology to predict lifetime and identifies the primary damage mechanism (creep vs fatigue) for any given fluid temperature and temperature gradient. Results are presented in the form of a damage map that serves as a valuable operation guide and design tool. Damage maps can be used to reduce maintenance costs by improving reliability and reduce receiver capital costs by better utilizing the receiver area. FEA simulation and damage modeling of tubes subject to asymmetrical flux conditions is performed in the open-source receiver design tool srlife. Parametric studies are performed over a range of inner tube temperatures and thermal gradients for A230, 316H, 740H, A282, A617, and 800H high temperature alloys. Damage maps are presented for each alloy. A parametric, FEA-based methodology is presented for comparison of fatigue-creep ratios and prediction of tube lifetime based on the critical thermal operating conditions. Fatigue is found to be negligible compared to creep for almost every case. Here, this finding suggests that fatigue effects associated with cloud events are insignificant compared to creep at these high temperature operating conditions. Additionally, lifetime predictions identify thermal conditions where small changes in operating conditions can result in large changes in predicted lifetime.

14 SOLAR ENERGY

Doping Metallic Grain Boundaries to Control Atomic Structure and Damage Tolerance

Grain boundaries often act as sites for crack and void nucleation during plastic deformation of metallic materials. While it is known that grain boundary character and structure can greatly influence this damage nucleation process, the current level of control over such details is limited. The objective of this project was to obtain a fundamental understanding of how metallic grain boundary structure can be controlled through intelligent doping, with the idea of inducing planned amorphous grain boundary phases or complexions. The effect of amorphous complexion structure on dislocation accommodation mechanisms was studied, to improve the field’s understanding of damage nucleation at a promising type of interface. Different microstructural descriptors were studied, as grain boundaries can have large variations and complexity of local structure, and influence the mechanical damage resistance of these features was tested. Nanocrystalline systems that contain amorphous grain boundary complexions were prioritized, as these have more extreme variations in interfacial structure and damage tolerance, with an emphasis on isolating the importance of complexion population (type, thickness, etc.), network topology, local structure, and local chemistry. This research used a combination of computational, experimental, and characterization techniques to isolate and understand the importance of nanoscale grain boundary structure and interfacial chemistry. Amorphous grain boundary complexions were found to clearly increase a material’s resistance to mechanical damage, with the local distribution of structural short-range order within the complexions found to be an important descriptor for damage and the proposed focus of future work in this area.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE

Understanding spectral dependance of laser-induced damage precursors in dielectric materials (Full report_23-ERD-006)

The performance of high-energy laser systems is constrained by laser-induced damage in dielectric coatings, particularly those containing hafnium oxide (HfO 2 ). While thresholds at fundamental Nd harmonics are well studied, the spectral dependence of damage initiation—especially under dual-wavelength irradiation—remains poorly characterized. This project provides the first systematic investigation of wavelength-dependent laser damage in hafnia coatings, focusing on nanoscale precursors such as craze lines, nanobubbles, stoichiometric variations, nodules, and controlled crystallization. Coatings were fabricated via ion beam sputtering and electron-beam deposition and characterized using spectrophotometry, ellipsometry, AFM, GI-XRD, RBS, PCI absorption, and fs/ns laser damage testing. Results show that craze lines, benign under infrared light, strongly initiate damage under UV due to wavelength-selective field intensification. Substituting xenon for argon suppresses nanobubbles and improves UV thresholds by up to 32%. Oxygen modulation reveals that fully oxidized films maximize UV resistance, though at the cost of porosity and stress in multilayers. HfO 2 –SiO 2 composites resist crystallization and defects while achieving ppm-level absorption and elevated thresholds, whereas full crystallization of HfO 2 enhances LIDT by reducing defects and improving thermal transport. Collectively, these findings link photon energy, defect states, and bandgap collapse, providing a predictive framework for wavelength-dependent laser damage. The outcomes directly inform the design of durable, multi-wavelength coatings for facilities such as NIF, MEC, HAPLS, and DPAL, advancing the readiness of next-generation optics.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE

Repair strategy for fused silica wedged focus lens with high-density filamentary damage

The National Ignition Facility (NIF) is intentionally operated with the final fused silica glass (SiO2) optics exposed to fluences and intensities with the potential to induce damage that will grow with additional laser exposure. Therefore, the NIF operates a recycle loop to refurbish final optics by mitigating any initiated surface damage to arrest its growth. However, the morphology of filamentary damage, caused by local self-focusing in the bulk of a silica optic, adds complexity to optics mitigation and provides a limitation to optic reusability. Here, we evaluate techniques for mitigating isolated and clustered filamentary damage. Optical microscopy before and after installation on NIF was used to determine the efficacy of filamentary mitigation after a series of high fluence and intensity laser exposures. The challenges and success rate of the methods are compared for various filamentary damage mitigation strategies.

National Ignition Facility

Impact of amorphous pockets on displacement damage evolution in silicon

Silicon has long been known to exhibit amorphization in response to heavy particle bombardment. For doses below the total amorphization threshold, partial amorphization is observed in the form of scattered amorphous pockets. While extensive research has gone into modeling the formation and evolution of amorphous pockets in response to irradiation, no studies yet investigate their impact on the evolution of other damage such as interstitial supersaturation and clustering. In this study, we survey the impact of amorphous pockets on defect evolution in silicon when treated as static sinks. MD is first used to show that amorphous pockets provide energetically favorable sites for point defects relative to the crystalline bulk, supporting the hypothesis that they act as sinks. A 0-D cluster dynamics model is then constructed, taking an interstitial clustering model from the literature and including amorphous pockets as a sink species. We conduct our survey for temperatures between 30 and 400 °C and sink strengths between 1 to 6 x 10 10 cm −2 . Both implantation- and radiation-induced damage states are investigated using interstitial and vacancy concentrations as initial condition variables. We find that, due to the differing migration rates of the interstitial and the vacancy, amorphous pockets have a non-monotonic impact on the final damage state depending on the effective sink strength of the amorphous pockets, resulting in increased damage formation in regimes of intermediate amorphization. In conclusion, this result emphasizes the important role of amorphous pockets in governing the evolution of damage in partially amorphized crystalline materials.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE