Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “electron transfer (ET)”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 19 records
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
DOE OSTI2022

Unusual reactivity of a flavin in a bifurcating electron-transferring flavoprotein leads to flavin modification and a charge-transfer complex

From the outset, canonical electron transferring flavoproteins (ETFs) earned a reputation for containing modified flavin. We now show that modification occurs in the recently recognized bifurcating (Bf) ETFs as well. In Bf ETFs, the ’electron transfer’ (ET) flavin mediates single electron transfer via a stable anionic semiquinone state, akin to the FAD of canonical ETFs, whereas a second flavin mediates bifurcation (the Bf FAD). We demonstrate that the ET FAD undergoes trans- formation to two different modified flavins by a sequence of protein-catalyzed reactions that occurs specifically in the ET site, when the enzyme is maintained at pH 9 in an amine-based buffer. Our optical and mass spectrometric characterizations identify 8-formyl flavin early in the process and 8-amino flavins (8AFs) at later times. The latter have not previously been documented in an ETF to our knowledge. Mass spectrometry of flavin products formed in Tris or bis-tris-aminopropane solutions demonstrates that the source of the amine adduct is the buffer. Stepwise reduction of the 8AF demonstrates that it can explain a charge transfer band observed near 726 nm in Bf ETF, as a complex involving the hydroquinone state of the 8AF in the ET site with the oxidized state of unmodified flavin in the Bf site. This supports the possibility that Bf ETF can populate a conformation enabling direct electron transfer between its two flavins, as has been proposed for cofactors brought together in complexes between ETF and its partner proteins.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2023

Facet-dependent electron transfer induces distinct arsenic reallocations on hematite

The interfacial electron transfer (ET) between electron shuttling compounds and iron (Fe) oxyhydroxides plays a crucial role in the reductive dissolution of Fe minerals and the fate of surface-bound arsenic (As). However, the impact of exposed facets of highly crystalline hematite on reductive dissolution and As immobilization is poorly understood. In this study, we systematically investigated the interfacial processes of the electron shuttling compound cysteine (Cys) on various facets of hematite and the reallocations of surface-bound As(III) or As(V) on the respective surfaces. Our results demonstrate that the ET process between Cys and hematite generates Fe(II) and leads to reductive dissolution, with more Fe(II) generated on {001} facets of exposed hematite nanoplates (HNPs). Reductive dissolution of hematite leads to significantly enhanced As(V) reallocations on hematite. Nevertheless, upon the addition of Cys, a raipd release of As(III) can be halted by its prompt re-adsorption, leaving the extent of As(III) immobilization on hematite unchanged throughout the course of reductive dissolution. This is due to that Fe(II) can form new precipitates with As(V), a process that is facet-dependent and influenced by water chemistry. Electrochemical analysis reveals that HNPs exhibit higher conductivity and ET ability, which is beneficial for reductive dissolution and As reallocations on hematite. In conclusion, these findings highlight the facet-dependent reallocations of As(III) and As(V) facilitated by electron shuttling compounds and have implications for the biogeochemical processes of As in soil and subsurface environments.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗
DOE OSTI2022

Reorganization Energies for Interfacial Proton-Coupled Electron Transfer to a Water Oxidation Catalyst

The reorganization energy (λ) for interfacial electron transfer (ET) and proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) from a conductive metal oxide (In 2 O 3 :Sn, ITO) to a surface-bound water oxidation catalyst were extracted from kinetic data measured as a function of the thermodynamic driving force. Visible light excitation resulted in rapid excited-state injection (k inj > 10 8 s -1 ) to the ITO, which photo-initiated the two interfacial reactions of interest. The rate constants for both reactions increased with the driving force, −ΔG°, to a saturating limit, k max , with rate constants consistently larger for ET than for PCET. Marcus-Gerischer analysis of the kinetic data provided the reorganization energy for interfacial PCET (0.90 ± 0.02 eV) and ET (0.40 ± 0.02 eV), respectively. The magnitude of k max for PCET was found to decrease with pH, behavior that was absent for ET. Both the decrease in k max and the larger reorganization energy for an unwanted competing PCET reaction from the ITO to the oxidized catalyst showcases a significant kinetic advantage for driving solar water oxidation at high pH. Computational analysis revealed a larger inner-sphere reorganization energy contribution for PCET than for ET arising from a more significant change in the Ru–O bond length for PCET. Extending Marcus-Gerischer theory to PCET by including the excited electron-proton vibronic states and the proton donor-acceptor motion provided an apparent reorganization energy of 1.01 eV. Furthermore, this study demonstrates that the Marcus-Gerischer theory initially developed for ET can be reliably extended to PCET for quantifying and interpreting reorganization energies observed experimentally.

Catalysts Kinetic parameters↗
DOE OSTI2024

Direct Evidence for a Sequential Electron Transfer–Proton Transfer Mechanism in the PCET Reduction of a Metal Hydroxide Catalyst

Here, the proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) mechanism for the reaction M ox -OH + e − + H + → M red -OH 2 was de-termined through kinetic resolution of the independent electron transfer (ET) and proton transfer (PT) steps. The reaction of interest was triggered by visible light excitation of [Ru II (tpy)(bpy′)H 2 O] 2+ , Ru II -OH 2 , where tpy is 2,2′:6′,2″-terpyridine and bpy′ is 4,4′-diaminopropylsilatrane-2,2′-bipyridine, anchored to In 2 O 3 :Sn (ITO) thin films in aqueous solutions. Interfacial kinetics for the PCET reduction reaction were quantified by nanosecond transient absorption spectroscopy as a function of solution pH and applied potential. Data acquired from pH = 5-10 revealed a stepwise electron-transfer proton-transfer (ET-PT) mechanism, while kinetic measurements made below the pK a (Ru III -OH/OH 2 ) = 1.3 were used to study the analogous interfacial reaction where electron transfer was the only mechanistic step. Analysis of this data with a recently reported multi-channel kinetic model was used to construct a PCET zone diagram and supported the assignment of an ET-PT mechanism from pH = 5-10. Ultimately, this study represents a unique example amongst M ox -OH/M red -OH 2 reactivity where the protona-tion and oxidation state of the intermediate was kinetically and spectrally resolved to firmly establish the PCET mechanism.

Charge transfer↗
DOE OSTI2021

Ir(III)-Naphthoquinone complex as a platform for photocatalytic activity

Inspired by the primary events that take place in Photosystem II (PSII), we designed and synthesized a heteroleptic Ir(III) complex featuring an attached naphthoquinone (NQ) as an electron transfer (ET) auxiliary reminiscent of the plastoquinone electron acceptor in PSII. In this design, NQ is covalently attached to the 2,2'-bipyridyl (bpy) ligand of [Ir(dF(CF 3 )ppy) 2 (bpy)][PF 6 ], (dF(CF 3 )ppy = 2-(2,4-difluorophenyl)-5-(trifluoromethyl)pyridine). Following excitation of the photocatalyst ([Ir(dF(CF 3 )ppy) 2 (bpy-NQ)][PF 6 ]), reduced NQ (NQ •– ) was observed in transient absorption spectroscopy. Here, this novel catalyst has potential applications in oxidative and reductive photocatalytic processes.

32 ENERGY CONSERVATION, CONSUMPTION, AND UTILIZATI↗
DOE OSTI2020

Inverted Region in Bimolecular Electron Transfer in Solution Enabled by Delocalization

Rate constants for bimolecular electron transfer (ET) increased with driving force, -ΔG°, reached a plateau, and then decreased in an inverted region. This rate data was described well by electron transfer theory subject to a diffusion-controlled limit. These were for ET from radical anions of polydecylthiophene (P3DT) to a series of acceptors in THF solution. When the donor was the smaller anion of quaterthiophene (T4 •- ) the inverted region was much less prominent, and still less so for when the donor was the anion of bithiophene (T2 •- ). Description of the data using ET theory identifies smaller electronic couplings for the highly-delocalized P3DT anions as enabling the inverted behavior: The presence of a Marcus inverted region is a consequence of delocalized electronic states. The results of this study further imply that electronic couplings smaller than usually found for molecules in contact could boost efficiency of energy storage by electron transfer, and identifies size-mismatch as an important concept in control of electronic couplings.

14 SOLAR ENERGY↗
DOE OSTI2022

New Perspective on Electron Transfer through Molecules

Motivated by experiments which display unusual length and temperature effects for electron transfer in the nanometer length regime, we propose a new approach for describing long range electron transfer (ET) processes through molecules. We posit that the electron reorganization in the molecules (e.g., the electronic polarization of a macromolecule or organic film by an applied electric potential, or the injected charge generating a dipole moment) should be included in the description. We numerically solve a one-dimensional model for the electron transport, which includes electron-electron interactions explicitly; and we show that it generates a power law distance dependence for electron similar to that observed in experiments. The model does not include vibrations explicitly and should be consistent with the weak temperature dependences observed experimentally. This approach emphasizes the need to treat the electronic changes in the molecule(s) more explicitly to understand the behavior.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2020

Active-Site Environmental Factors Customize the Photophysics of Photoenzymatic Old Yellow Enzymes

The development of non-natural photoenzymatic systems has reinvigorated the study of photoinduced electron transfer (ET) within protein active sites, providing new and unique platforms for understanding how biological environments affect photochemical processes. Here, we use ultrafast spectroscopy to compare the photoinduced electron transfer in known photoenzymes. 12-Oxophytodienoate reductase 1 (OPR1) is compared to Old Yellow Enzyme 1 (OYE1) and morphinone reductase (MR). The latter enzymes are structurally homologous to OPR1. We find that slight differences in the amino acid composition of the active sites of these proteins determine their distinct electron-transfer dynamics. Our work suggests that the inside of a protein active site is a complex/heterogeneous dielectric network where genetically programmed heterogeneity near the site of biological ET can significantly affect the presence and lifetime of various intermediate states. Our work motivates additional tunability of Old Yellow Enzyme active-site reorganization energy and electron-transfer energetics that could be leveraged for photoenzymatic redox approaches.

75 CONDENSED MATTER PHYSICS, SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND↗
DOE OSTI2024

Single-Molecule Detection of the Encounter and Productive Electron Transfer Complexes of a Photosynthetic Reaction Center

Small, diffusible redox proteins play an essential role in electron transfer (ET) in respiration and photosynthesis, sustaining life on Earth by shuttling electrons between membrane-bound complexes via finely tuned and reversible interactions. Ensemble kinetic studies show transient ET complexes form in two distinct stages: an “encounter” complex largely mediated by electrostatic interactions, which subsequently, through subtle reorganization of the binding interface, forms a “productive” ET complex stabilized by additional hydrophobic interactions around the redox-active cofactors. Here, using single-molecule force spectroscopy (SMFS) we dissected the transient ET complexes formed between the photosynthetic reaction center-light harvesting complex 1 (RC-LH1) of Rhodobacter sphaeroides and its native electron donor cytochrome c 2 (cyt c 2 ). Importantly, SMFS resolves the distribution of interaction forces into low (~150 pN) and high (~330 pN) components, with the former more susceptible to salt concentration and to alteration of key charged residues on the RC. Thus, the low force component is suggested to reflect the contribution of electrostatic interactions in forming the initial encounter complex, whereas the high force component reflects the additional stabilization provided by hydrophobic interactions to the productive ET complex. Employing molecular dynamics simulations, we resolve five intermediate states that comprise the encounter, productive ET and leaving complexes, predicting a weak interaction between cyt c 2 and the LH1 ring near the RC-L subunit that could lie along the exit path for oxidized cyt c 2 . The multimodal nature of the interactions of ET complexes captured here may have wider implications for ET in all domains of life.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2022

An SECM-Based Spot Analysis for Redoxmer-Electrode Kinetics: Identifying Redox Asymmetries on Model Graphitic Carbon Interfaces

The fundamental process in non-aqueous redox flow battery (NRFB) operation revolves around electron transfer (ET) between a current collector electrode and redox-active organic molecules (redoxmers) in solution. Here, we present an approach utilizing scanning electrochemical microscopy (SECM) to evaluate interfacial ET kinetics between redoxmers and various electrode materials of interest at desired locations. This spot-analysis method relies on the measurement of heterogeneous electron transfer rate constants (k f or k b ) as a function of applied potential (E-E 0 '). As demonstrated by COMSOL simulations, this method enables the quantification of Butler-Volmer kinetic parameters, the standard heterogeneous rate constant, k 0 , and the transfer coefficient, α. Our method enabled the identification of inherent asymmetries in the ET kinetics arising during the reduction of ferrocene-based redoxmers, compared to their oxidation which displayed faster rate constants. Similar behavior was observed on a wide variety of carbon electrodes such as multi-layer graphene, highly ordered pyrolytic graphite, glassy carbon, and chemical vapor deposition-grown graphite films. However, aqueous systems and Pt do not exhibit such kinetic effects. Our analysis suggests that differential adsorption of the redoxmers is insufficient to account for our observations. Displaying a greater versatility than conventional electroanalytical methods, we demonstrate the operation of our spot analysis at concentrations up to 100 mM of redoxmer over graphite films. Looking forward, our method can be used to assess non-idealities in a variety of redoxmer/electrode/solvent systems with quantitative evaluation of kinetics for applications in redox-flow battery research.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2025

Cryo-EM captures the coordination of asymmetric electron transfer through a di-copper site in DPOR

Enzymes that catalyze long-range electron transfer (ET) reactions often function as higher order complexes that possess two structurally symmetrical halves. The functional advantages for such an architecture remain a mystery. Using cryoelectron microscopy we capture snapshots of the nitrogenase-like dark-operative protochlorophyllide oxidoreductase (DPOR) during substrate binding and turnover. DPOR catalyzes reduction of the C17 = C18 double bond in protochlorophyllide during the dark chlorophyll biosynthetic pathway. DPOR is composed of electron donor (L-protein) and acceptor (NB-protein) component proteins that transiently form a complex in the presence of ATP to facilitate ET. NB-protein is an α 2 β 2 heterotetramer with two structurally identical halves. However, our structures reveal that NB-protein becomes functionally asymmetric upon substrate binding. Asymmetry results in allosteric inhibition of L-protein engagement and ET in one half. Residues that form a conduit for ET are aligned in one half while misaligned in the other. An ATP hydrolysis-coupled conformational switch is triggered once ET is accomplished in one half. These structural changes are then relayed to the other half through a di-nuclear copper center at the tetrameric interface of the NB-protein and leads to activation of ET and substrate reduction. These findings provide a mechanistic blueprint for regulation of long-range electron transfer reactions.

Computational biophysics↗
DOE OSTI2020

Mimicking Natural Photosynthesis: Designing Ultrafast Photosensitized Electron Transfer into Multiheme Cytochrome Protein Nanowires

Efficient nanomaterials for artificial photosynthesis require fast and robust unidirectional electron transfer (ET) from photosensitizers through charge-separation and accumulation units to redox-active catalytic sites. We explored the ultrafast time-scale limits of photo-induced charge transfer between a Ru(II)tris(bipyridine) derivative photosensitizer and PpcA, a 3-heme c-type cytochrome serving as a nanoscale biological wire. Four covalent attachment sites (K28C, K29C, K52C, and G53C) were engineered in PpcA enabling site-specific covalent labeling with expected donor-acceptor (DA) distances of 4–8 Å. X-ray scattering results demonstrated that mutations and chemical labeling did not disrupt the structure of the proteins. Time-resolved spectroscopy revealed three orders of magnitude difference in charge transfer rates for the systems with otherwise similar DA distances and the same number of covalent bonds separating donors and acceptors. All-atom molecular dynamics simulations provided additional insight into the structure-function requirements for ultrafast charge transfer and the requirement of van der Waals contact between aromatic atoms of photosensitizers and hemes in order to observe sub-nanosecond ET. This work demonstrates opportunities to utilize multi-heme c-cytochromes as frameworks for designing ultrafast light-driven ET into charge-accumulating biohybrid model systems, and ultimately for mimicking the photosynthetic paradigm of efficiently coupling ultrafast, light-driven electron transfer chemistry to multi-step catalysis within small, experimentally versatile photosynthetic biohybrid assemblies.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2020

Solvent influence on non-adiabatic interfacial electron transfer at conductive oxide electrolyte interfaces

The kinetics for interfacial electron transfer (ET) from a transparent conductive oxide (tin-doped indium oxide, ITO, Sn:In 2 O 3 ) to molecular acceptors 4-[N,N-di(p-tolyl)amino]benzylphosphonic acid, TPA, and [Ru II (bpy) 2 (4,4' -(PO 3 H 2 ) 2 -bpy)] 2+ , RuP, positioned at variable distances within and beyond the electric double layer (EDL), were quantified in benzonitrile and methanol by nanosecond absorption spectroscopy as a function of the thermodynamic driving force, -ΔG ° . Relevant ET parameters such as the rate constant, k et , reorganization energy, λ, and electronic coupling, Hab, were extracted from the kinetic data. Overall, k et increased as the distance between the molecular acceptor and the conductor decreased. For redox active molecules within the Helmholtz planes of the EDL, k et was nearly independent of -ΔG° , consistent with a negligibly small λ value. Rips–Jortner analysis revealed a non-adiabatic electron transfer mechanism consistent with H ab < 1 cm -1 . The data indicate that the barrier for electron transfer is greatly diminished at the conductor–electrolyte interface.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2020

Electron transfer calculations between edge sharing octahedra in hematite, goethite, and annite

A key reaction underlying the charge transport in iron containing oxides, clays, micas is the Fe$^{2+}$-Fe$^{3+}$ exchange reaction between edge-sharing iron octahedra. These reactions facilitate conduction in these minerals by the thermally-activated hopping of small polarons across the lattice. Depending on the mineral and local charge state the small polaron can either encase an electron or hole. The probability for conduction of small polarons depends strongly on the height and adiabicity of the reaction barrier, with larger and more diabatic barriers yielding slow conduction associated with either weak coupling or a large prerequisite rearrangement of the lattice during charge transport. To model these reactions, a first principle electron transfer (ET) method was developed to model the small polaron hopping between the edge-sharing octahedra sites in hematite ($e^{-}$ polaron), goethite ($e^{-}$ polaron), and annite ($h^{+}$ polaron) bulk structures. The ET method is based on electronic structure methods (i.e., plane-wave Density Functional Theory) capable of performing calculations with periodic cells and large size systems efficiently while at the same time being accurate enough to be used in the estimation of the electron-transfer coupling matrix element, $V_{AB}$, and the electron transfer transmission factor, $\kappa_{el}$. Additionally, the calculations confirmed the existence of small polarons in all three minerals, and the reactions were predicted to be strongly adiabatic. It was found that transfer of a hole in the octahedral layer of annite had an adiabatic barrier of $0.311$ eV, and the transfer of an extra electron in hematite and goethite had adiabatic barriers of $0.242$ eV and $0.232$ eV respectively. The electronic coupling parameters,$V_{AB}$, were found to be $0.188$ eV, $0.196$ eV, and $0.102$ eV respectively for hematite, goethite, and annite. While similar bonding topologies pertain, the underlying basis for the differences is the subtle differences in local structures.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2024

Extracellular Charge Transport in Microbial Redox Chains: Linking the Living and Non-Living Worlds

The fundamental process of electron transfer (ET) within and between molecules dictates all biological energy conversion strategies, including respiration and photosynthesis. This project resulted in a comprehensive physics-based understanding of the mechanisms and limits of redox networks that mediate and regulate electron transport through microbial metabolic pathways, with special emphasis on environmental microbes that can acquire energy by catalyzing anodic or cathodic reactions on solid-state electrodes (extracellular electron transfer, or EET). By performing electron transfer to/from electrodes, such microbes may be used as biocatalysts for converting the energy stored in diverse chemical fuels to electricity, or vice versa (microbial electrosynthesis), in renewable energy technologies.

59 BASIC BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES↗
DOE OSTI2023

Rapid Electron Transfer Self-Exchange in Conformationally Dynamic Copper Coordination Complexes

Here we report the electron transfer (ET) self-exchange rate constants (k 11 ) for a pair of Cu II/I complexes utilizing dpa R (dpa = dipicolylaniline, R = OMe, SMe) ligands assessed by NMR line-broadening experiments. These ligands afford copper complexes that are conformationally dynamic in one oxidation state. With R = OMe, the Cu I complex is dynamic, while with R= SMe, the Cu II complex is dynamic. Both complexes exhibit unexpectedly large k 11 of 2.48(6) x 10 5 and 2.21(9) × 10 6 M –1 s –1 for [CuCl(dpa OMe )] +/0 and [CuCl(dpa SMe )] +/0 , respectively. Among the fastest reported for molecular copper coordination complexes to date, that of [CuCl(dpa SMe )] +/0 exceeds all others by an order of magnitude and compares only to those observed in type 1 blue copper proteins. The dynamicity of these complexes establish pre-steady-state con-formational equilibria that minimize the inner sphere reorganization energies to 0.71 and 0.62 eV for R = OMe and SMe, respectively. In contrast to the emphasis on rigidity in the formulation of entatic states applied to blue copper proteins, the success of these two systems highlight the relevance of conformational dynamicity in mediating rapid ET.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗
DOE OSTI2020

Fast Proton Transfer and Hydrogen Evolution Reactivity Mediated by [Co 13 C 2 (CO) 24 ] 4–

A common approach to speeding up proton transfer (PT) by molecular catalysts is manipulation of the secondary coordina-tion sphere with proton relays and these enhance overall reaction rates by orders of magnitude. In contrast, heterogenous electrocatalysts have band structures that promote facile PT concerted with electron transfer (ET), known as the Volmer mechanism. Here in this paper, we show that [Co 13 C 2 (CO) 24 ] 4– , containing multiple Co-Co bonds to statistically enhance observed rates of PT, promotes PT on the order of 2.3 × 10 9 M -1 s -1 which suggests a diffusion-limited rate. The fast ET and PT chemistry is at-tributed to the delocalized electronic structure of [Co 13 C 2 (CO) 24 ] 4– . Electrochemical characterization of [Co 13 C 2 (CO) 24 ] 4– in the presence and absence of protons reveals ET kinetics and diffusion behavior similar to other small clusters such as nano-materials and fullerenes.

08 HYDROGEN↗
DOE OSTI2021

Charge Transfer and Spin Dynamics in a Zinc Porphyrin Donor Covalently Linked to One or Two Naphthalenediimide Acceptors

We report quantum coherence effects on charge transfer and spin dynamics in a system having two degenerate electron acceptors are studied using a zinc 5,10,15-tri(n-pentyI)-20-phenylporphyrin (ZnP) electron donor covalently linked to either one or two naphthalene-1,8:4,5-bis(dicarboximide) (NDI) electron acceptors using an anthracene (An) spacer, ZnP-An-NDI (1) and ZnP-An-NDI 2 (2), respectively. Following photoexcitation of 1 and 2 in toluene at 295 K, femtosecond transient absorption spectroscopy shows that the electron transfer (ET) rate constant for 2 is about three times larger than that of 1, which can be accounted for by the statistical nature of incoherent ET as well as the electron couplings for the charge separation reactions. In contrast, the rate constant for charge recombination (CR) of 1 is about 25% faster than that of 2. Using femtosecond transient infrared spectroscopy and theoretical analysis, we find that the electron on NDI 2 ∙- in 2 localizes onto one of the two NDIs prior to CR, thus precluding electronically coherent CR from NDI 2 ∙- . Conversely, CR in both 1 and 2 is spin coherent as indicated by the observation of a resonance in the 3* ZnP yield following CR as a function of applied magnetic field, giving spin-spin exchange interaction energies of 2J = 210 and 236 mT, respectively, where the line width of the resonance for 2 is greater than 1. These data show that while CR is a spin-coherent process, incoherent hopping of the electron between the two NDIs in 2, consistent with the lack of delocalization noted above, results in greater spin decoherence in 2 relative to 1.

37 INORGANIC, ORGANIC, PHYSICAL, AND ANALYTICAL CH↗