Search NASASearch

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “embrittlement”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 19 records

Assessment of irradiation embrittlement effect on fatigue life of a pressurized-water reactor pressure vessel using the fracture toughness master curve approach

The reactor pressure vessel (RPV) is a critical structural component in pressurized-water reactors, and it is designed to withstand extreme conditions, such as high pressures, elevated temperatures, and prolonged radiation exposure. Ensuring RPV integrity is essential for the safe and reliable long-term operation of nuclear power plants, especially as aging mechanisms such as fatigue and irradiation embrittlement pose increased risks. Fatigue, caused by cyclic thermal and mechanical loading, can lead to crack initiation in localized high-stress regions. Simultaneously, neutron irradiation, particularly in the beltline region, progressively reduces fracture toughness, increasing susceptibility to brittle fracture. These combined effects of fatigue and irradiation embrittlement potentially impact the RPV structural integrity, necessitating fitness-for-service assessments. This study applies the fracture toughness master curve approach to evaluate the impact of irradiation embrittlement on RPV fatigue life. A coupled thermo-mechanical stress analysis identifies critical stress locations under normal service transients, pinpointing regions most vulnerable to fatigue crack initiation and growth. Stress intensity factors for postulated flaws at these locations are calculated, enabling an assessment of fatigue life under irradiated and unirradiated conditions. The results indicate that neutron irradiation embrittlement accelerates the conditions in which a critical crack can form and lead to failure, particularly at lower temperatures. The failure occurs where reduced fracture toughness limits the material’s resistance to crack growth. Axial cracks at nozzle corners are the most life limiting without irradiation, while circumferential cracks demonstrate longer fatigue lives. The findings highlight the importance of incorporating irradiation effects into fatigue life predictions to ensure the long-term structural integrity of RPVs.

22 - GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS

Evaluation of liquid metal embrittlement of F82H and 4340 steels in liquid lithium

Here, to evaluate the liquid metal embrittlement (LME) susceptibility of F82H, a reduced activation ferritic-martensitic (RAFM) steel, a testing procedure using hollow cylindrical tensile specimens was used. Tensile tests are compared between specimens filled with argon and lithium at 200 °C. To validate the procedure, initial testing was performed on type 4340 steel, which is well-known to exhibit LME. Compared to 4340 steel, F82H only showed minor effects of Li exposure, including pre-testing exposures with Li at 400 °C for 1 h and 500 °C for 500 h. Furthermore, changing the strain rate or tensile test temperature also did not show significant embrittlement.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY

Hydrogen embrittlement and mechanical response of 304L steel with ZrC additions

While stainless steels are widely used for hydrogen storage infrastructure, they can still be vulnerable to hydrogen embrittlement justifying the need to further improve their hydrogen resiliency. Here, we investigate the potential for transition metal carbide additions to improve the hydrogen compatibility of austenitic stainless steels. ZrC nanoparticles were dispersed in contents of 0.01–10 wt% in 304 L stainless steel powder, mixed via high energy ball milling, and subsequently consolidated using direct current sintering. To assess hydrogen compatibility, the tensile properties of similarly processed 304 L without ZrC nanoparticles were compared to 304 L with the ZrC additions; both materials were evaluated prior to and after hydrogen exposure (non-charged and H-precharged, respectively). Depending upon the ZrC phase fraction, the yield strengths varied from ∼325 to 560 MPa in the non-charged condition and from ∼375 to 550 MPa in the H-precharged condition. Strain at failure varied from ∼5 to 90 % and from ∼5 to 35 % in the non-charged and hydrogen-precharged conditions, respectively. Results from stress-strain profiles demonstrate limited efficacy of ZrC as a method to mitigate hydrogen embrittlement entirely but does demonstrate the potency of ZrC inclusions as strengthening addition to 304 L alloys without a loss of ductility.

08 HYDROGEN

Micro-Mechanically Guided High-Throughput Alloy Design Exploration Towards Metastability-Induced H Embrittlement Resistance

We develop a high-throughput approach for studying H embrittlement (HE)-resistance in alloys, which is based on combinatorial compositional screening of metastability effects by in situ scanning electron microscopy H-analyses. The project objective included: (i) technique development of high-throughput screening (HTS) for HE-resistance, (ii) discovery of new metallic materials with superior HE-resistance, (iii) Multiscale verification of HE-resistance of the new alloys and H-barrier layers, from atomic scale to an engineering scale. The investigation focused on a model system that enables exploration of different metastable states in Fe-based complex-concentrated alloys. Composition spread islands with hundreds of varying compositions are fabricated on a single substrate using a combinatorial co-sputtering technique. To screen these alloys, we developed and employed a home-built SEM-based integrated analysis system capable of characterizing H-permeability, H-trapping, H-influence on mechanical properties, and other material properties, as well as atomistic to continuum simulations to study the underlying physics.

08 HYDROGEN

Gaseous Hydrogen Embrittlement of L-PBF Ni-Based Superalloys for Service in Natural Gas Turbines

Efforts to improve efficiency of industrial gas turbine engines have focused on increasing operating temperatures by use of fuel-flexible gas blends. Ni-based superalloys are susceptible to hydrogen embrittlement (HE), leading to potential risk of premature component failure. Certain turbine components exposed to hydrogen-rich environments are manufactured from additive processes like laser powder bed fusion (L-PBF). The HE susceptibility was evaluated for three Ni-based superalloys: solid solution strengthened Alloy 625, γ’/γ’’-precipitation strengthened Alloy 718, and γ’-precipitation strengthened Haynes® 282®. L-PBF samples were pre-charged under medium and high pressure gaseous hydrogen before tensile testing at temperatures up to 260 °C using a fast strain rate. Selected samples were subjected to a service conditioning heat treatment prior to hydrogen charging to evaluate the change in susceptibility after prolonged service. The susceptibility to HE and HE mechanisms of these three alloys is compared.

additive manufacturing

Development and Evaluation of Embrittlement Resistant Alloys for Advanced LWR Cladding

The primary challenge preventing the deployment of reactor designs that leverage wrought FeCrAl as an advanced light-water reactor (LWR) cladding is irradiation hardening and embrittlement. Wrought FeCrAl alloys experience a loss of post-irradiation ductility and fracture toughness under low-temperature neutron irradiation (< 350°C)resulting from the combined effects of dislocation loop formation and the irradiation-enhanced precipitation of Cr-rich alpha-prime precipitates throughout the microstructure. Over the past decade, significant improvements in our understanding regarding the effect of Cr and Al content have been enabled through neutron irradiations, but even optimized wrought alloys such as C26M remain vulnerable to brittle failure during storage, transportation, and handling following irradiation.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS

Development and Evaluation of Embrittlement Resistant Alloys for Advanced LWR Cladding

The primary challenge preventing the deployment of reactor designs that leverage wrought FeCrAl as an advanced light-water reactor (LWR) cladding is irradiation hardening and embrittlement. Wrought FeCrAl alloys experience a loss of post-irradiation ductility and fracture toughness under low-temperature neutron irradiation (< 350°C) resulting from the combined effects of dislocation loop formation and the irradiation-enhanced precipitation of Cr-rich alpha-prime precipitates throughout the microstructure. Over the past decade, significant improvements in our understanding regarding the effect of Cr and Al content have been enabled through neutron irradiations, but even optimized wrought alloys such as C26M remain vulnerable to brittle failure during storage, transportation, and handling following irradiation. This report summarizes multiple irradiation campaigns initiated over the past 7 years and provides recent insights into the effect of (1) minor alloying composition, (2) alloy processing strategy, (3) crystal structure, and (4) the use of advanced oxide dispersion strengthened (ODS) alloys. The first irradiation campaign irradiated body-centered cubic FeCrAl alloy C26M with and without elements such as Mo and Y. It also included face-centered cubic alumina-forming austenitic (AFA) alloys that have a steeper neutronic penalty but that have far superior high-temperature strength than wrought FeCrAl. Finally, this campaign compared conventional wrought C26M with the same material produced using modern powder metallurgical hotisostatic pressing (PM-HIP). The second irradiation campaign, initiated in 2018, irradiated wrought and FeCrAl-ODS materials up to 50 dpa to assess their irradiation resistance to high-doses. The results of this work indicate that wrought C26M suffers significant degradation following neutron irradiation at LWR-relevant temperatures regardless of Mo and Y content. The PM-HIP variant appears to be more resilient to irradiation-induced ductility loss in comparison with wrought variants but still loses almost all ductility by 8 dpa. Notably, the AFAs retained at least 5% total elongation after irradiation at the same dose and temperature condition, although additional deterioration may be expected at higher fluence levels. FeCrAl-ODS materials show the greatest promise as a transformative longer-term accident-tolerant fuel (LT-ATF) cladding material. The extruded 106ZY10C alloy retained 10% total elongation after 16 dpa irradiation and retained 8% total elongation after 50 dpa. Additional challenges with FeCrAl-ODS alloys also remain, including optimization of end cap joining methodologies, enhancement of fracture toughness, scaling production to prove economic viability, and optimizing post-pilger heat treatments to maximize ductility and irradiation resistance. This series of irradiations demonstrates the efficacy of the LWR testbed available within the United States for the rapid irradiation and down-selection of LT-ATF candidates. As the country rapidly accelerates its timeline for the deployment of advanced reactor concepts, the effective utilization of the High Flux Isotope Reactor for separate-effects style irradiations should continue to be prioritized to answer the final questions pertaining to LT-ATF candidates necessary for the deployment of advanced boiling water reactors and small modular reactors.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS

Assessment of Vibration and Shock Loading Environments on Steels Used in Railroad Applications Considering Hydrogen Embrittlement

Studies that examine the combined effects of hydrogen and rail loading environments in the context of hydrogen embrittlement of steels have not been performed. Large-scale hydrogen storage requires either gaseous hydrogen stored in pressure vessels and tubing or liquid hydrogen in cryogenic, insulated tanks. Since the focus of this study is on steels, we examine the influence of hydrogen on stainless steel used for high pressure tubing and cryogenic tanks and Cr-Mo steel liners used in gaseous pressure vessels. Literature studies show that despite hydrogen degradation, these steels can be used effectively and safely if the stresses are managed. The shock and vibration environment on railcars present unique environments where stresses and loading rates can be high. A literature review was conducted to understand the accelerations experienced in rail by examining instrumented railcars of nuclear fuel casks. Hydrogen studies were examined that focused on steel pressure hardware with an emphasis on fatigue, fast loading rates, and low temperatures. A simplified fatigue assessment was performed to examine design cycles for three different hydrogen components: stainless steel tubing, stainless steel cryogenic tanks, and gaseous pressure vessels. The assessments were idealized and used bounding cases of accelerations in both normal rail conditions and coupling events. In normal shock and vibration environments when accelerations were less than 2 g, infinite design life was calculated. In extreme shock or coupling environments, finite design life was calculated which was shown to be dependent on unsupported lengths of pressure components. It was shown that adjusting the unsupported length can reduce the bending stress thereby increasing design life.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE

Hydrogen embrittlement of Zircaloy-4 fabricated by ultrasonic additive manufacturing

Ultrasonic additive manufacturing (UAM) was successfully applied to the zirconium material system to create a planar geometry. Following fabrication, SS-J3 type tensile specimens of the UAM and wrought Zircaloy-4 with a nominal gage section of 5×1.2×0.75 mm were machined for hydriding studies and mechanical testing. The SS-J3 type tensile specimens were gas-charged with hydrogen using a custom system that precisely controls hydrogen gas flow rate, hydrogen partial pressure, and temperature. To avoid altering the UAM material, the maximum process temperature was limited to 550°C. Using different initial hydrogen gas pressures and flow rates, various hydrogen contents (70–1755 wppm) were achieved for Zircaloy-4 specimens. Tensile testing shows that, regardless of hydrogen content, all UAM specimens measured yield strengths in the range of 557±16 MPa and ultimate tensile strengths of 660±4MPa. However, total elongation clearly decreased as a function of increasing hydrogen content. Further, at the lowest hydrogen content, the total plastic elongation measured 21.5%, and this value decreased to less than 2% when the hydrogen content was increased to 1000 wppm. Cross-sectional optical microscopy images revealed that the hydride distributions are randomly oriented. For the low hydrogen content specimen, these randomly distributed hydrides are isolated from each other. A sandwiched structure, consisting of high-density and low-density layers, was also observed for the specimens with hydrogen content between 200 and 400 wppm. As the hydrogen content increases, the hydrides diffuse into the low-density hydride layers to form a network across the whole specimen. Although the tensile properties of UAM and wrought Zircaloy-4 exhibit the same behavior with increasing hydrogen content, the distinctions in grain orientations led to differences in the hydride orientations at low and intermediate hydrogen concentrations.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE

Limitations of Hydrogen Detection After 150 Years of Research on Hydrogen Embrittlement

Hydrogen's significance in contemporary society lies in its remarkable energy density, yet its integration into the worldwide energy grid presents a substantial challenge. Exposing materials to hydrogen environments leads to degradation of mechanical properties, damage, and failure. While the current approach for assessing hydrogen's impact on materials involves mainly multiscale modeling and mechanical testing, there exists a significant deficiency in detecting the intricate interactions between hydrogen and materials at the nanoatomic scales and under in situ conditions. This perspective review highlights the experimental endeavors aimed at bridging this gap, pointing toward the imminent need for new experimental techniques that can detect and map hydrogen in materials’ microstructures and their site‐specific dependencies.

Tunes, Matheus A.

Effects of oxygen on the tensile properties and fracture behavior of the Ta-10 W refractory alloy at quasi-static and impact strain rates

This study investigates effects of pre-charged oxygen at levels up to ∼1750 ppm on the tensile properties of the refractory alloy Ta-10 W. Tests were conducted at temperatures to 1100 °C and strain rates from quasi-static (∼10−3 s−1) to impact (∼103 s−1). At all temperatures, ductility decreased with increasing oxygen concentration and could be visually identified as a ductile-to-brittle transition (DBT). Additionally, for a given oxygen concentration, ductility was lower at impact strain rate than at quasi-static. The DBT was accompanied by a change from ductile transgranular to more brittle modes, intergranular and transgranular cleavage. The oxygen concentrations associated with the DBT depend on test temperature and strain rate. However, the transitions themselves are not sharp and cannot be defined as occurring at a specific oxygen concentration. At impact strain rates, ductility is relatively insensitive to test temperatures in the range 300–1100 °C with similar embrittling effects of oxygen; however, oxygen has a more severe embrittling effect at room temperature. This behavior is reversed at quasi-static strain rates where the embrittling effect of oxygen is more severe at elevated temperatures than at room temperature. It appears this difference is related to the kinetics of oxygen diffusion to grain boundaries and crack tips. Specimens that were not pre-charged with oxygen but tensile tested in various partial pressures of oxygen underwent dynamic embrittlement during the test, with the degree of embrittlement increasing as the partial pressure of oxygen in the environment increased. Consistent with such a mechanism, ductility increased with increasing strain rate for a given oxygen partial pressure, which would be the reverse if only intrinsic dislocation mobilities were controlling.

Miller, Roger [ORNL] (ORCID:0000000172155851)

Direct observation of strain-enhanced hydrogen segregation and failure at high-angle grain boundaries in nickel

Understanding the mechanisms underlying hydrogen embrittlement remains difficult, even in single-element metals. Both microstructure and stress state influence hydrogen distribution in metals and alloys, which impacts deformation and failure. Here, in this work, we use in-situ Kelvin probe force microscopy (KPFM) to monitor the hydrogen distribution in pure nickel over time at 1.1 % and 3.5 % strain. The sample strained to 3.5 % results in preferential hydrogen segregation to high-angle grain boundaries whereas the sample strained to 1.1 % does not exhibit preferential hydrogen segregation. Optical digital image correlation (DIC) shows that hydrogen charging results in both localized and reduced strains during tensile testing of a notched sample. Later stages of deformation and failure (e.g. microcracking) are studied by using in-situ transmission X-ray microscopy (TXM). TXM reveals nanoscale structural changes to a propagating crack in a hydrogen environment. Localized void growth and secondary cracking occur at grain boundaries near the primary crack front. Correlative electron backscattering diffraction (EBSD) is used to relate the cracking at grain boundaries to the hydrogen segregation observed in KPFM. These findings are unified in a proposed hydrogen embrittlement mechanism that describes the interaction of hydrogen with grain boundaries, and the role of grain boundaries in hydrogen embrittlement.

Grain boundary fracture

Ductility evaluation of nitrided Zircaloy-4 cladding by ring compression testing

Here, this study evaluated the embrittlement of Zircaloy-4 cladding by dry air and dry nitrogen environments as a function of process temperature and duration of exposure. A Netzsch thermogravimetric analyzer was used to measure the mass gain of cladding sections over time with specified temperature and gas flow programs. Oxidation of Zircaloy in dry air produced a brittle ZrO 2 layer with ductile unreacted metal. In contrast, nitridation of Zircaloy had a slower reaction rate but produced a brittle cladding that was more easily breached during ring compression tests. The ring compression tests demonstrated that ductility of Zircaloy cladding decreases as nitrogen pickup increases; a ductile-to-brittle transition occurs near a mass gain of 2.1 wt %. Nitridation showed minimal temperature dependency in ductility degradation, whereas oxidation showed significant temperature dependency in ductility degradation, with severe embrittlement occurring at 1200 °C. Optical micrographs confirmed the formation of uniform ZrN layers (approximately 12 µm thick) on the cladding surface, indicating that cladding embrittlement is primarily the result of nitrogen diffusion rather than metal layer thinning.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE