Experimental measurement and numerical modeling of the effective thermal conductivity of TRISO fuel compacts
Not Available
SEARCH · Search NASA
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Not Available
A natural uranium-based, unirradiated tristructural isotropic (TRISO) fuel compact was nondestructively imaged using both X-ray (XCT) and neutron computed tomography (nCT). While XCT of compacts can provide information on fuel kernels, imaging artifacts preclude examination of the graphite matrix. In this work, nCT was used for the first time on a TRISO compact to examine the graphite matrix. A crack was clearly resolved within the graphite matrix, proving that nCT is a viable tool for nondestructive volumetric examination of the matrix material in TRISO fuel compacts. The XCT and nCT data were then fused together to create a more comprehensive dataset containing both matrix and fuel kernels.
Post-irradiation examination was completed on two as-irradiated compacts from the US Advanced Gas Reactor Fuel Development and Qualification Program’s second irradiation test. These compacts were selected for examination because there were indications that they may have contained particles that released cesium through a failed or defective SiC layer. The coated particles were recovered from these compacts by electrolytic deconsolidation of the surrounding graphitic matrix in nitric acid. The leach-burn-leach (LBL) process was used to dissolve and analyze exposed metallic elements (actinides and fission products), and each particle was individually surveyed for relative cesium retention with the Irradiated Microsphere Gamma Analyzer (IMGA). Data from IMGA and LBL examinations provided information on fission product release during irradiation and whether any specific particles had below-average retention that could be related to coating layer defects or radiation-induced degradation. A few selected normal-retention particles and six with abnormally-low cesium inventory were analyzed using X-ray tomography to produce three-dimensional images of the internal coating structure. Four of the low-cesium particles had obviously damaged or degraded SiC, and X-ray imaging was able to guide subsequent grinding and polishing to expose the regions of interest for analysis by optical and electron microscopy. Additional particles from each compact were also sectioned and examined to study the overall radiation-induced microstructural changes in the kernel and coating layers.
TRISO (TRi-structural ISOtropic) – compact-type micro-particle fuels – are next generation nuclear fuel compacts designed with safety in mind. Structural integrity and characterisation before and after irradiation are important to determine the performance of the fuel compacts under real reactor conditions. X-ray computed tomography can be an important tool for non-destructive evaluation of these fuel compacts. The fuel particles are highly attenuating for X-rays which creates metal artefact, rendering the images unusable. Our artefact correction can mitigate these artefacts significantly. The proposed method works by first segmenting highly-attenuating structures (metal) and forward projecting to localise the source of artefacts in the projection domain, then, using a traditional or U-net-based deep learning architecture, contextually interpolating those regions to remove the artefacts. Finally the reconstruction from the modified projection is fused with the segmented metal. The proposed method shows a significant improvement in the image quality while significantly reducing the reconstruction time compared to the standard technique.
Four post-irradiation heating tests of fuel compacts from the U.S. Advanced Gas Reactor (AGR)-3/4 irradiation experiment were completed. In addition to tristructural isotropic (TRISO)-coated driver fuel, each compact contained designed-to-fail (DTF) particles with fuel kernels coated only in pyrocarbon so as to simulate exposed kernels. Tests at 1600/1700°C, 1400°C, and 1200°C were performed to measure fission product release as a function of time and temperature. Silver release was highest in the 1200°C test, supporting the observation that silver release rates are highest in the 1100–1300°C range. Compared to tests of AGR-1 compacts with no exposed kernels, the Cs-134 and Kr-85 releases were noticeably higher in AGR-3/4. The exposed kernels’ contributions to Eu and Sr release are inconclusive, due to the difficulty in distinguishing among the combined effects of higher irradiation temperatures in these particular AGR-3/4 compacts, the presence of the DTF particles, and the Fuel Accident Condition Simulator (FACS) test temperatures. These data can be used to make inferences about fission product retention in exposed kernels as a function of time and temperature.
Irradiation testing of MiniFuel compacts bearing tristructural isotropic (TRISO) fuel particles was performed at Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) to support the development of Kairos Power’s (KP’s) fluoride salt–cooled high-temperature reactor concept. The fuel compacts were fabricated with TRISO fuel particles of different types—including low-enriched uranium oxide, uranium carbide (LEUCO), natural uranium oxide, uranium carbide (NUCO), and low-enriched uranium dioxide (LEUO 2 )—and inserted into MiniFuel irradiation targets. Five targets were assembled and inserted in the High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR) for four cycles. The data collected post-irradiation will provide experimental input to validate TRISO fuel performance models for high particle power operations. This report summarizes the completion of the HFIR irradiation, the as-irradiated numerical analysis, and the post-irradiation work performed to date. This work was performed under the Nuclear Science User Facility program.
To support the development of Kairos Power’s fluoride-salt-cooled high-temperature reactor, irradiation testing of tristructural isotropic (TRISO) fuel compacts was performed at the Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR) to collect experimental data on TRISO fuel during high particle-power operation and validate fuel performance models. Fuel compacts containing enriched uranium oxycarbide (UCO), natural UCO (NUCO), or uranium dioxide (UO 2 ) TRISO particles were fabricated at ORNL and inserted into MiniFuel targets for HFIR irradiation. Five MiniFuel targets were successfully assembled, welded, tested, and delivered to HFIR, along with their quality assurance documentation. The targets were inserted into HFIR’s inner vertical experiment facility within the permanent beryllium reflector. Each target contains six fuel compacts and will be irradiated in HFIR for four cycles, with target temperatures of 500, 700, and 900°C. This report summarizes the experiment design, test matrix, and fabrication. This work was performed under the Nuclear Science User Facility program.
Japan Atomic Energy Agency (JAEA) has started R and D on SiC/C mixed matrix fuel element of high temperature gas-cooled reactors (HTGRs) to improve oxidation resistance of fuel. Nuclear thermal design of HTGR with SiC/C mixed matrix fuel compacts was carried out as a part of above R and Ds. Nuclear thermal design was carried out based on a small sized HTGR for developing countries, HTR50S, which thermal power is 50 MW and burn-up period is 2 years. Maximum enrichment of uranium is set to be 10 wt%, because coated fuel particles with 10 wt% uranium have been fabricated in Japan. Numbers of kinds of enrichment and burnable poisons (BPs) were set to be same as those of original HTR50S (3 and 2, respectively). We succeeded in nuclear thermal design of a small sized HTGR which performance was equivalent to original HTR50S, with SiC/C mixed matrix fuel compacts. Based on nuclear thermal design, intactness of coated fuel particles was evaluated to against internal pressure increase by burnup. It was shown that intactness was kept for burnup condition of HTR50S. (authors)
Three post-irradiation heating tests of fuel compacts from the US AGR-3/4 irradiation experiment. In addition to TRISO-coated driver fuel, each compact contained 20 particles with UCO fuel kernels coated only in pyrocarbon to simulate exposed kernels. Tests at 1600/1700°C, 1400°C, and 1200°C were performed to measure fission product releases as a function of time and temperature. Silver releases were highest in the 1200°C test, supporting the observation that silver release rates are highest in the temperature range of 1100-1300°C. Except for Ag-110m (which was released in multiple particle equivalents) releases of Cs, Kr, Eu, and Sr were all less than one particle inventory per compact. This suggests that exposed kernels retain little Cs and Kr after irradiation. Despite these low releases, compared to tests of compacts with no exposed kernels, the Cs and Kr releases were noticeably higher, and at 1600°C the exposed kernels contributed noticeably more Eu and Sr than in AGR-1 compacts with no exposed kernels. These data can be used to make inferences on retention of fission products in exposed kernels.
Five AGR-3/4 fuel compacts were previously heated in the Fuel Accident Condition Simulator (FACS) furnace. Three of these compacts were also reirradiated in the Neutron Radiography (NRAD) reactor before the FACS tests. One of these was heated to 1200°C, two were heated to 1400°C, one was heated to 1600°C, and one was held for a period of time at 1600 and 1700°C. After these FACS tests, the compacts were subjected to destructive post-irradiation examination (PIE) via radial-deconsolidation-leach-burn-leach (RDLBL) at INL. The RDLBL process deconsolidated the compacts in multiple radial steps, followed by a final, single-step axial deconsolidation. The samples generated at each step were analyzed for isotopes of key fission products and actinides. After each deconsolidation step, the compact volume was assessed, and this was used to normalize the measured quantities of nuclides of interest to give volumetric concentrations as a function of radial position within the compact. The total inventories of measured fission products and actinides and the radial concentration profiles were compared with their sibling compacts within the same capsule (similar irradiation conditions) that went through RDLBL in the as-irradiated state. These data will be used to refine the fission product transport models.
Eight as-irradiated AGR-3/4 fuel compacts were subjected to destructive post-irradiation examination via radial-deconsolidation-leach-burn-leach (RDLBL) at INL. The RDLBL process deconsolidated the compacts in multiple, radial steps, followed by a final, single-step axial deconsolidation. The samples generated at each step were analyzed for isotopes of key fission products and actinides. After each deconsolidation step, the compact volume was assessed, and this was used to normalize the measured quantity of nuclides of interest to give a volumetric concentration as a function of radial position within the compact. The total inventories of measured fission products and actinides and the radial concentration profiles were compared among the eight compacts deconsolidated at INL and four other as-irradiated compacts examined at ORNL. The results were analyzed for the effects of irradiation temperature. These results will be used for comparisons with fission product transport models and as input from which fission product diffusivities can be calculated.
This work studies the impact of explicit and homogenized modeling approaches on the multiphysics simulation of TRistructural ISOtropic (TRISO) fuel compacts in prismatic High Temperature Gas Reactors (HTGRs) and the silver release predictions. TRISO fuel compacts exhibit complex double heterogeneity that significantly affects heat conduction, neutron transport, and fission products release. In this work, we use Cardinal, a multiphysics tool based on the Multiphysics Object-Oriented Simulation Environment (MOOSE) framework, to couple neutron transport and heat conduction. OpenMC is used for neutron transport and the MOOSE heat transfer module is used for the heat conduction. Then, we use BISON for the silver release predictions. Two different modeling approaches—explicit modeling of individual TRISO particles and homogenized representation using effective thermal properties—are compared at high TRISO packing fractions (20% and 40%) across varying power densities. Results demonstrate that homogenization significantly under-predicts peak temperatures, for the case of high power/TRISO, there is a difference of 83.73 K in the maximum temperature. Additionally, homogenization underestimates the silver release predictions compared to explicit modeling. Specifically, the temperature and power density differences lead to significant differences in silver release predictions. This work demonstrates the importance of accurately modeling heterogeneity of the TRISO particles to reliably predict fission product release and assess reactor safety margins.
The AGR-3/4 irradiation tests combined the third and fourth planned irradiation experiments in the US Department of Energy’s Advanced Gas Reactor (AGR) testing campaign of tri-structural isotropic (TRISO) fuel compacts. In this article, we present post-irradiation examination (PIE) using X-ray computed tomography (XCT) of two unirradiated and two irradiated compacts from the AGR-3/4 irradiation tests. The irradiated compacts studied (compact 7–1 and compact 12–4) represent the upper and lower limit of burnup within the AGR-3/4 irradiation experiment. This article presents a detailed quantitative analysis on the post-irradiation structure of TRISO fuel compacts. Various quantitative parameters including shape, size, and packing of kernels, and their spatial distribution, were utilized to gain insights into the structural changes caused by irradiation. The equivalent diameter and sphericity were found to increase and decrease, respectively, in irradiated compact 7–1 due to its higher burnup. Nearest neighbor distance between fuel kernels decreased after irradiation, suggesting irradiation-induced shrinkage of graphitic matrix. Furthermore, each compact in AGR-3/4 irradiation tests contained 20 designed-to-fail (DTF) fuel particles that were meant to act as a source of fission product release to the experiment test train. Furthermore, in the present work, all DTF fuel particles in the four compacts studied were identified, and it was found that they exhibited larger kernel swelling in compact 12–4 and smaller kernel swelling in compact 7–1, compared to the driver particles.
In this study, 3-D image analysis when combined with a non-destructive examination technique such as X-ray computed tomography (CT) provides a highly quantitative tool for the investigation of a material’s structure. In this investigation 3-D image analysis and X-ray CT were combined to analyze the microstructure of a preliminary subsized fuel compact for the Transient Reactor Test Facility’s low enriched uranium conversion program to assess the feasibility of the combined techniques for use in the optimization of the fuel compact fabrication process. The quantitative image analysis focused on determining the size and spatial distribution of the surrogate fuel particles and the size, shape, and orientation of voids within the compact. Additionally, the maximum effect of microstructural features on heat transfer through the carbonaceous matrix of the preliminary compact was estimated. The surrogate fuel particles occupied 0.8% of the compact by volume with a log-normal distribution of particle sizes with a mean diameter of 39 μm and a standard deviation of 16 μm. Roughly 39% of the particles had a diameter greater than the specified maximum particle size of 44 μm suggesting that the particles agglomerate during fabrication. The local volume fraction of particles also varies significantly within the compact although uniformities appear to be evenly dispersed throughout the analysed volume. The voids produced during fabrication were on average plate-like in nature with their major axis oriented perpendicular to the compaction direction of the compact. Finally, the microstructure, mainly the large preferentially oriented voids, may cause a small degree of anisotropy in the thermal diffusivity within the compact. α∥/α⊥, the ratio of thermal diffusivities parallel to and perpendicular to the compaction direction are expected to be no less than 0.95 with an upper bound of 1.
Picosecond ultrasonics has been demonstrated on a tristructural isotropic (TRISO) fuel compact to measure the elastic properties of each compact layer. This technique utilizes an ultrashort pump laser pulse to excite vibrations in a gold transducer film covering the surface of each component and a second probe laser pulse to record the resulting acoustic strain induced change in optical reflectance. From the damping of this film vibration, the acoustic reflection coefficient, which couples the elastic properties of the transducer film and the sample, can be obtained, enabling a calculation of the sample’s acoustic velocity and elastic modulus. Overall, results obtained from this method are consistent with known values of elastic moduli, namely that the SiC coating is the stiffest component of the compact while the carbonaceous matrix is the most compliant. Nanoindentation was conducted as a benchmark technique on the same sample and shows satisfactory agreement with the results of picosecond ultrasonics. Compared to other methods like nanoindentation, picosecond ultrasonics is multimodal with a capability of measuring several key properties simultaneously and has potentials to be coupled into optical fibers for remote sensing. Thus, these demonstration measurements reveal the methodology to be a promising candidate for in-situ and high-throughput optical characterizations of nuclear materials.
As the primary barrier to release of radioactive isotopes emitted from the fuel kernel, retention performance of the SiC layer in tristructural isotropic (TRISO) coated particles is critical to the overall safety of reactors that utilize this fuel design. Most isotopes are well-retained by intact SiC coatings, so pathways through this layer due to cracking, structural defects, or chemical attack can significantly contribute to radioisotope release. In the US TRISO fuel development effort, release of 134 Cs and 137 Cs are used to detect SiC failure during fuel compact irradiation and safety testing because the amount of cesium released by a compact containing one particle with failed SiC is typically ten or more times higher than that released by compacts without failed SiC. Compacts with particles that released cesium during irradiation testing or post-irradiation safety testing at 1600–1800 °C were identified, and individual particles with abnormally low cesium retention were sorted out with the Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) Irradiated Microsphere Gamma Analyzer (IMGA). X-ray tomography was used for three-dimensional imaging of the internal coating structure to locate low-density pathways through the SiC layer and guide subsequent materialography by optical and scanning electron microscopy. In addition, all three cesium-releasing particles recovered from as-irradiated compacts showed a region where the inner pyrocarbon (IPyC) had cracked due to radiation-induced dimensional changes in the shrinking buffer and the exposed SiC had experienced concentrated attack by palladium; SiC failures observed in particles subjected to safety testing were related to either fabrication defects or showed extensive Pd corrosion through the SiC where it had been exposed by similar IPyC cracking.
To address the lack of data on the behavior of short-lived fission products I-131 (t1/2 = 8.02 d) and Xe-133 (t1/2 = 5.24 d) in the TRISO fuel system, loose AGR-2 particles and kernels were reirradiated in NRAD and subjected to post-reirradiation heating in the FACS furnace. This provided data on the release of fission products from exposed kernels, and the results were used to establish FACS condensation plate collection efficiencies for temperatures of 1000, 1200, and 1400°C where previously, the only collection efficiencies were for 1600°C tests. These new collection efficiencies were then applied to the NRAD-FACS tests of entire AGR-3/4 fuel compacts. Understanding the relative behavior of short-lived I-131, for example, is important because it is a significant contributor to offsite dose during postulated accidents, and Xe-133 has previously been used as a conservative indicator of I-131 behavior. These data will be used to support refinement of fission product transport models and HTGR source-term analyses.
Seven as-irradiated Advanced Gas Reactor (AGR) 5/6/7 compacts underwent destructive post-irradiation examination via deconsolidation-leach-burn leach at Idaho National Laboratory (INL). The selection of the compacts extended the upper and lower limits of time-average volume-average (TAVA) temperature for compacts that had gone through deconsolidation-leach-burn leach so far. The measured inventories of fission products and actinides in the compact matrix and outer pyrolytic carbon were reported. Results indicated unexpectedly higher rates of fuel kernel leaching compared to compacts from AGR-1 and AGR-2. These failure rates were attributed to damage during post-irradiation sample handling, rather than irradiation itself. AGR-5/6/7 compacts have little or no matrix coverage for some particles at the top and bottom ends of cylindrical fuel compacts, making them more fragile. Sixty particles were randomly sampled from each compact, and the gamma results were reported. Three SiC shells from were identified, one of which showed signs of chemical attack in the high-irradiation temperature compact.