Search NASASearch

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “functionally graded materials”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 19 records

Controlling homogenization length scales and microstructure in additively manufactured Ti-Ta functionally graded materials

Materials with smooth compositional gradients or functionally grade materials (FGMs) produced via additive manufacturing (AM), enables joining dissimilar materials and optimizing multiple properties in advanced engineering applications. However, as-printed AM microstructures exhibit micro-segregation and solidification defects which, when combined with controlling macroscale gradient properties, complicates necessary post-processing. Here, we use CALPHAD-informed diffusion modelling to design post-processing heat treatments for lightweight to refractory FGMs. Ti-Ta (0 to 85 at. % Ta) FGMs were fabricated using laser-based directed energy deposition AM. Post-processing heat treatments at 1000° C and 1500° C were designed to promote homogenization across specific length scales and experimentally validated. Investigation of chemical segregation and microstructures demonstrated that the length scale of homogenization is controlled as a function of time, temperature, and local composition. Ta-rich regions exhibited incomplete homogenization compared to Ti-rich layers. Unmelted Ta particles were found to completely dissolve at 1500 °C. By controlling cooling rate (200 °C/min), martensitic structures were produced between 14–36 at. % Ta, consistent with martensite-start temperatures calculations, while furnace cooling (2 °C/min) produced α+β morphologies. This work establishes a validated predictive framework for designing post-processing to tailor microstructure and chemical architecture in AM FGMs, facilitating their deployment in demanding environments.

Materials science

Optimization of Functionally Graded Materials Using Additive Manufacturing: An Integrated Experimental and Computational Approach (Abbreviated Final Report)

Many advanced technologies, such as next-generation energy systems, aerospace vehicles, and defense platforms, require materials that can withstand extreme environments, including high temperatures, corrosion, and radiation, while remaining strong and lightweight. Traditionally, joining different materials to achieve these properties introduces weak, failure-prone interfaces and defects that limit performance. Our research aimed to overcome this challenge by using additive manufacturing, specifically directed energy deposition, to create functionally graded materials—components with smooth transitions between different metals. This approach eliminates sharp boundaries and allows for tailored material properties throughout a part.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE

Area-based composition predictions of materials fabricated using simultaneous wire-powder-directed energy deposition

Functionally graded materials are an emergent method for designing components with programmable site-specific material properties. These materials are typically fabricated using metal additive manufacturing tools by simultaneously feeding multiple wire and/or powder feedstocks at various rates to achieve spatial composition change. The wire-powder-directed energy deposition (WP-DED) technique is of particular interest for many functionally graded material applications by balancing the low raw materials cost of wire with the high resolution of powder. However, feeding wire and powder are inherently different processes since all extruded wire enters the melt pool, while much of the blown powder is scattered, which makes determining the composition of the build challenging. In this study, we devise a simple area-based measurement method for estimating the composition of WP-DED structures. WP-DED single beads are printed using 309L stainless steel wire and commercially pure Fe powder at five wire feed rates (0.5, 0.75, 1.00, 1.25, 1.50 mm/mm) and five powder feed rates (2, 4, 6, 8, 10 rpm). Characteristic defects including interface gaps and macrosegregation (lack of mixing) tendencies are examined. High powder feed rates (8, 10 rpm) result in interface gaps at all wire feed rates, but smooth deposition and complete mixing is achieved at low powder feed rates, particularly with lower wire feed rates as well. The area-based composition measurement method is within ±20% of energy dispersive x-ray spectroscopy measurements for all samples, showing its effectiveness as a rapid composition estimate for WP-DED materials development.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE

An innovative radial gradient material design using hot isostatic pressing for applications in extreme environments

Functionally graded materials (FGMs) are highly advanced continuous or discontinuous structures whose structural and material properties vary along a singular geometric dimension either in the axial or radial direction. Here, the radial gradient FGM design makes for an optimal structural design to incorporate a bi-metallic structure with a copper-based high entropy alloy (Cu-HEA) with good mechanical properties and high irradiation resistance, and Chromium (Cr) with great corrosion resistance. This study focuses on the experimental design of a metal powder loading mechanism to fabricate a bi-metallic radial gradient structure using Cu-HEA and 99.9 % pure Cr metal powders. The powder loading strategy uses custom-designed concentric cylindrical dividers to separate the individual compositions. Two benchtop trial runs were performed for design optimization. The optimized design was then implemented to eventually load the HEA and Cr powders for consolidation via powder metallurgy hot isostatic pressing (PM-HIP). The electron microscopy analysis reveals the successful fabrication of the radial gradient structure with the chemical mapping analysis, demonstrating the gradual composition shift from the HEA at the center to the pure-Cr at the periphery via a three-step gradient.

High Entropy Alloys (HEAs)

Fabrication of ceramic to metal graded structure for high temperature CSP receiver application using solid state additive manufacturing

The overarching goal of this project is to come up with an innovative joining solution for integration of SiC ceramic to structural materials such as stainless steels (SS)/Ni-base alloys, where intimate metallurgical bonding between SiC ceramic and the structural metallic alloy is demonstrated at the interface. Implementation of a simple, yet robust joining method would help in increasing the application space of SiC in a high-temperature CSP (concentrated solar power) plant, especially in the receiver section. This research goal has been achieved by creating a functionally graded material (FGM) interface between SiC and the selected structural material with the help of powder metallurgy (PM) approach and demonstrate intimate metallurgical bonding between monolithic RB-SiC and 316L stainless steel alloy blanks.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE

Development of direct ink write radially graded alumina/zirconia

Functionally graded materials (FGMs) are of interest in multiple fields, yet many materials combinations are limited by coefficient of thermal expansion (CTE) mismatch. Here, a radially graded alumina/yttria-doped zirconia (Al 2 O 3 /8YZ) FGM is used to demonstrate processing strategies to mitigate CTE and sintering behavior differences between these oxides. FGM materials are especially sensitive to ink stability during printing, as all components (in this case, Al 2 O 3 and 8YZ) must be stabilized in the same dispersant or additive solution. Thus, this system is also ideal to demonstrate ink optimization best practices. Materials were characterized throughout processing to correlate the effects of common additives on both the ceramic particle suspensions and final sintered components. Aggregation observed in the initial additive-containing suspensions were present in the sintered component. The differences in sintering onset temperature and shrinkage rate resulted in internal stresses within the sintered component, which ultimately caused mechanical failure of the component under low stress. In conclusion, a processing strategy was recommended to mitigate the sintering behavior mismatch of alumina and 8 wt% yttria-stabilized zirconia.

Lamm, Benjamin W. [Oak Ridge National Laboratory (

Systematic analysis of melt pool dynamics in laser processing of mixed powder feedstocks

Functionally graded materials (FGMs) fabricated via additive manufacturing of blended powders offer the potential to spatially tailor properties for new technologies, such as fusion first-wall systems, turbine blades, and spacecraft. However, processing these materials is difficult due to the multiplicity of processing parameters to optimize, all of which must be changed as substrate material, powder feedstock compositions, and melt pool dynamics evolve. Here, this work systematically evaluates the qualitative and quantitative effects of these variables on the melt pool size, shape, composition, and particle distribution in an exemplar Ti-Ta system, and connects the experimental results to Marangoni flow behavior and phenomena observed in other systems. Increasing laser power linearly increases melt pool size and layer thickness, driving engineering considerations such as part/geometrical tolerances. Decreasing laser velocity changes the melt pool shape from lenticular to convex and reduces chemical homogeneity due to extreme thermal and compositional gradients between the melt pool center and boundaries. Thermophysical property differences between the powder feedstock and substrate material, as well as the directionality of the gradient, affect dilution and melt pool dynamics, which in turn affect the melt pool boundary characteristics, shape, and uniformity. Mixed powder feedstocks of intermediate compositions do not behave according to linear interpolations between single-material endpoints, instead building taller and wider melt pools. As such, it is recommended to quantify process maps for at least one intermediate composition in the FGM or multi-material system of interest to ensure optimized processing parameters, predictable melt pool sizes and shapes, and compositional and spatial precision.

Dissimilar

Directed energy deposition of radially functionally graded nickel based superalloys IN625 and IN738: Microstructure and mechanical properties

This study investigates the microstructure and mechanical properties of radially functionally graded (RFG) materials fabricated from nickel-based superalloys IN625 and IN738 using directed energy deposition (DED). RFG cylindrical deposits with radial gradients of IN625-IN738 and IN738-IN625 were successfully fabricated and confirmed to be crack-free through tailored composition grading, scan strategy and process parameters that minimized thermal gradients and solidification velocities. Microstructural analysis revealed distinct variations across the gradient, characterized by differences in dendrite arm spacing, microsegregation, and the formation of distinct γ' precipitates and carbide/boride phases (MC, M 6 C, M 2 C, and MB 2 ) in as-deposited (AD) conditions, which evolved into M 23 C 6 and M 2 B upon subsequent heat treatment (HT). EBSD showed predominant columnar grains with a [100] texture, while microhardness profiles demonstrated consistent variation across the gradients. Mechanical testing highlighted the synergy of the graded structure, combining IN738's strength with IN625's ductility, resulting in enhanced properties such as a yield strength of 1131 MPa, ultimate tensile strength of 1382 MPa, and elongation of 12 % for HT IN625-IN738 grading. Numerical simulations employing CALPHAD thermodynamic calculations and finite element thermal modeling are used to establish phase evolution and microstructural feature correlation with thermal profiles, aiding in the optimization of process-structure-property relationship.

Additive manufacturing

Computational Design of Interlayers for Thermally Stable Compositionally Graded Coatings on Nickel Alloys

To extend the service life of Ni-based superalloys, refractory metal coatings are often used. However, direct bonding between metals with dissimilar crystal structure promotes brittle intermetallic phase formation. This work presents a computational thermodynamic framework for high throughput design of functionally graded interlayers to suppress deleterious phases that may form at the interlayer. The Thermo-Calc software package was used to screen candidate metallic interlayer elements based on stability of solid-solution phases. Vanadium was identified as a promising interlayer due to its consistent suppression of intermetallic phases. Temperature-dependent phase diagram mapping between 600 and 1000 °C guided selection of a compositional pathway that significantly reduced intermetallic formation compared to directly joining the Ni-based and Nb refractory alloys. Time–temperature–transformation analysis was performed to assess whether equilibrium-predicted phases are kinetically accessible along regions of the graded path where non-solid-solution phases are not fully suppressed. The methodology was further applied to additional Ni-based alloy and coating systems, illustrating its transferability as an approach for rapid computational design of graded interlayers in dissimilar high-temperature materials.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE

Multi-material direct ink writing and co-sintering of gadolinium oxide – zirconium oxide components

Methods for fabrication of multi-material or functionally graded ceramic composite architectures are of interest for numerous applications. However, conventional co-sintering of multi-material ceramic parts is a challenge because differences in the sintering behavior of the two materials leads to interfacial strain and, ultimately, component failure. Direct ink writing (DIW) is an extrusion-based additive manufacturing process that excels at multi-material printing because multiple extrusion nozzles can be installed on the same gantry system. Furthermore, the use of DIW as a method to fabricate multi-material ceramic green bodies offers an additional variable for controlling and potentially matching sintering kinetics in the slurry formulation used for two dissimilar feedstocks. In the work documented in this manuscript, we explored two strategies to successfully co-sinter multi-material ceramic oxides: slurry optimization to match sintering kinetics and material gradients to step from one material to another. This manuscript also quantifies the allowable mismatch that avoids part cracking in solid solution forming multi-material systems and discusses best strategies to reduce mismatch during co-sintering. Inks composed of gadolinium oxide (Gd 2 O 3 ) and zirconium oxide (ZrO 2 ), a surrogate for uranium oxide (UO 2 ), were thermally matched, which resulted in a sintering mismatch reduction of over 10%. It was found that ~1% mismatch is tolerable during debind cycles and that ~5% mismatch is manageable during sintering cycles after slurry formulations are optimized to match the sintering behavior. Use of continuous gradients is shown to reduce sintering mismatch, although geometric resolution may be lost due to solid solution formation.

Snarr, Patrick L. [Oak Ridge National Laboratory (

Bonding of vanadium- and Iron-based alloys as interlayers for plasma-facing and structural materials in fusion systems

Vanadium alloys and FeCrAl were investigated as interlayers between tungsten and reduced activation ferritic martensitic steel for fusion system components to avoid formation of intermetallic phase at operating temperatures between 550 and 1100 °C, while maintaining a body centered cubic phase throughout the interface. Physical and mechanical properties need to be graded between tungsten and steel, but recent results showed a significant hardness increase at the FeCrAl to vanadium alloy interface. Here, a sintered sample of these alloys was annealed for extended time, and the microstructure was investigated to provide a better understanding of the phenomena. A comparison with an additively manufactured interface of the same material is provided. An unexpected L2 1 intermetallic phase formation has been revealed using microscopy and synchrotron techniques and will inform future additive manufacturing approaches of the interface. A Cr layer interface as a preliminary solution was proposed between the Vanadium alloy and FeCrAl alloy interface.

Additive manufacturing

Directed energy deposition of functionally graded V-4Cr-4Ti to Fe-9Cr transition for fusion power systems

This study proposes a graded structure via additive manufacturing for divertor and first wall blanket applications in fusion reactors. Materials were selected based on thermodynamic calculations to operate from 1100 °C at the plasma-facing level to 550 °C at the structural steel level. Conventional joining methods often lead to failures due to discrete reaction layers with significant mechanical property differences. Using laser beam-directed energy deposition (LB-DED), this study demonstrates the fabrication of a VCrTi-Gr91 steel functionally graded component through a novel process parameter optimization framework. A systematic approach included powder characterization, single-track depositions, and construction of printability maps. Near full-density specimens of each interlayer were additively manufactured, and a transition from V-based alloys to reduced activation ferritic martensitic steels was achieved. Computational material selection of interlayer alloys and thermodynamic/diffusion kinetics simulations prevented most interface incompatibilities. A brittle intermetallic formed at one interface, causing cracking, which was not predicted by current thermodynamic models. Transition alloy design approach was updated with a more recent database and a mitigation strategy has been proposed to eliminate the formation of deleterious intermetallic phases. Ultimately, LB-DED has proven effective for producing multi-material graded systems for fusion applications, with the demonstrated process parameter optimization framework applicable to various materials.

Additive manufacturing

Rapid data acquisition and machine learning-assisted composition design of functionally graded alloys via wire arc additive manufacturing

Abstract The lack of high-quality datasets in materials science hinders artificial intelligence (AI)-driven alloy design. To address this challenge, wire arc additive manufacturing (WAAM) was employed to fabricate graded alloys, generating extensive data for machine learning (ML)-assisted property prediction. ML models were developed using high-throughput experiments, computational models, and genetic algorithm to optimize feature selection, successfully predicting hardness and porosity. The ML model demonstrated its efficacy by designing a gradient alloy with enhanced properties. However, scaling up revealed uncertainties in tensile property and porosity due to differences in size and thermal conditions between the designed alloy build and the gradient print used to construct the ML model. This underscores the need for uncertainty quantification and process optimization in WAAM-driven alloy design. Our work advances AI-integrated additive manufacturing, offering a rapid approach to exploring process–structure–property relationships and accelerating materials development.

Wang, Xin

The effect of high-power transient events on tungsten and tungsten coatings used for radio frequency launcher applications

High-temperature plasma-facing material coatings used for radio frequency (RF) launchers need to be robust enough to survive RF breakdown arcing or other transient events from the plasma (e.g., an edge localized mode) without causing a catastrophic failure of the coating. High-power transient effects are being explored by using an RF-induced vacuum arc to determine the robustness of tungsten coatings made by a variety of manufacturing methods. A 1/4-wavelength resonant section of vacuum transmission line terminated with an open circuit electrode structure with a well-defined electric field (30-60 kV/mm) produces repeatable arcing conditions. The initial focus is on tungsten as a plasma-facing material, including sintered tungsten, tungsten coatings on steel produced via physical vapor deposition (PVD), and functionally graded tungsten/steel coatings deposited by low-pressure plasma-spraying (LPPS). Thin PVD coatings (1-2 microns) fail catastrophically from an arc and result in severe delamination of the coating. The arc-induced damage of thicker coatings, such as those made via LPPS, tend to be restricted to the top few microns of the surface. Arcing often initiates on sharp surface microstructures and causes localized melting of tungsten at the surface of all the materials studied and results in resolidified melt pools with surface cracks. The resolidified surface results in a reduction in overall deuterium retention when exposed to typical RF plasma sheath conditions.

Caughman, John [ORNL] (ORCID:0000000206091164)