DOE ART Graphite R&D Program
Graphite overview: Material science, supply chain facts, nuclear material science, licensing thoughts
SEARCH · Search NASA
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Graphite overview: Material science, supply chain facts, nuclear material science, licensing thoughts
Introduction of ART Graphite R&D to include oxidation activities, oxidation resistant graphite, model development, ASME component failure, ASME code development (design rules), ceramic composites, AGC update, molten salt intrusion, split-disk studies, wear testing, and concluding remarks.
The USA DOE Advanced Reactor Technologies (ART) graphite R&D program supporting HTR design is one of the longest running nuclear graphite R&D programs. Significant progress has been made in several areas of research within this extensive program including unirraidated and irradiated testing of nuclear graphite, oxidation results and modeling, fracture behavior, irradiation damage studies, and several international collaboration studies. The latest results in these research areas as well as a discussion of a new direction in nuclear graphite irradiation for the USA program will be presented. Recently, the USA made a decision to support moderate to high dose irradiation of nuclear graphite (0.5 to 15 dpa). This will provide irradiation data for graphite HTR core components up to 15 dpa for numerous nuclear graphite grades. The irradiation plan and a tentative schedule for this new irradiation direction will be presented in detail.
Structure of the program Graphite material issues of interest How do things fit together Status of the program Baseline AGC Experiment Update AGC-4 and HDG-1 Irradiation Oxidation Modeling ASME Code development Discussion of how the data can be used Modeling behavior of core components Licensing/code development Interaction with vendors Collaborations (domestic and international)
Five Research Areas: Licensing and Code Graphite Research and Development Behavior Models Virgin Properties Mechanisms and Analysis Irradiation
The DOE-ART Graphite R&D program has been generating significant amounts of irradiated and unirradiated graphite data since 2006 when the program was part of the DOE NGNP (Next Generation Nuclear Plant) Project. This data includes critical irradiation creep and irradiated material property changes from the Advanced Graphite Creep (AGR) experiment as well as significant amounts of data on unirradiated material property values on several current nuclear graphite grades (Baseline program). Previously, Idaho National Laboratory has developed an internal analysis tool to assist with analysis of the unirradiated and irradiated data. The Graphite Analytical Tool (GAT) is intended to provide easy access to the graphite data in the form of comparing unirradiated and irradiated material property changes, comparison of material property differences between various nuclear graphite grades, and illustrate trends within the irradiated and unirradiated data generated within the DOE-ART Graphite R&D program. This report summarizes the progress to-date on the development of this analytical tool.
The Next Generation Nuclear Plant (NGNP) Graphite R&D program is currently measuring irradiated material property changes in several grades of nuclear graphite for predicting their behavior and operating performance within the core of new Very High Temperature Reactor (VHTR) designs. The Advanced Graphite Creep (AGC) experiment consisting of six irradiation capsules will generate this irradiated graphite performance data for NGNP reactor operating conditions. All samples in the experiment will be fully characterized before irradiation, irradiated in the Advanced Test Reactor (ATR), and then re-examined to determine the irradiation induced changes to key materials properties in the different graphite grades. The information generated during the AGC experiment will be utilized for NRC licensing of NGNP reactor designs, shared with international collaborators in the Generation IV Information Forum (GIF), and eventually utilized in ASME design code for graphite nuclear applications. This status report will describe the process the NGNP Graphite R&D program has developed to record the AGC1 pre-irradiation examination data.
General description of the ART Graphite Program with Status for 2023. This includes list of staff members, and brief description of behavior models, licensing & code, graphite R&D, As-Fab'd Properties, Machanism and Analysis, Irradiation. Also detail FY23 Activites, with AGC Update, Oxidation Activiteis, Baseline STatus, ASME Code Development, VIC Project Update, Molten salt studies. Slide included to highlight each employee contributions for work and papers and NEUPs.
The Advanced Reactor Technology (ART) Graphite R&D program is conducting an extensive graphite irradiation program to provide data for licensing of a high temperature reactor (HTR) design. In past applications, graphite has been used effectively as a structural and moderator material in both research and commercial high temperature gas cooled reactor (HTGR) designs. Nuclear graphite H 451, used previously in the United States for nuclear reactor graphite components, is no longer available. New nuclear graphite grades have been developed and are considered suitable candidates for new HTR reactor designs. To support the design and licensing of new HTR core components within a commercial reactor, a complete properties database must be developed for these current grades of graphite. Quantitative data on in service material performance is required for the physical, mechanical, and thermal properties of each major graphite grade with a specific emphasis on data accounting for the life limiting effects of irradiation creep on key physical properties of the HTR candidate graphite grades. Further details on the research and development activities and associated rationale required to qualify nuclear grade graphite for use within the HTR are documented in the graphite technology research and development plan. Based on experience with previous graphite core components, the phenomenon of irradiation induced creep within the graphite has been shown to be critical to the total useful lifetime of graphite components. Irradiation induced creep occurs under the simultaneous application of high temperatures, neutron irradiation, and applied stresses within the graphite components. Significant internal stresses within the graphite components can result from a second phenomenon—irradiation induced dimensional change—where the graphite physically changes (i.e., first shrinking and then expanding with increasing neutron dose). This disparity in material volume change can produce significant internal stresses within graphite components. Irradiation induced creep relaxes these large internal stresses, thus reducing the risk of crack formation and component failure. Obviously, higher irradiation creep levels tend to relieve more internal stress, thus allowing the components longer useful lifetimes within the core. Determining the irradiation creep rates of nuclear grade graphite is critical for determining the useful lifetime of graphite components and is a major component of the Advanced Graphite Creep (AGC) experiment. The AGC experiment is currently underway to determine the in service behavior of these new graphite grades for HTR and molten salt reactor designs. This experiment will examine properties and behavior of nuclear grade graphite over a large spectrum of temperatures, irradiation fluencies and applied stress levels that are expected to cause irradiation creep strains within a HTR graphite component. Irradiation data are provided through the AGC test series, which is comprised of six planned capsules irradiated in the Advanced Test Reactor (ATR) in a large flux trap located at Idaho National Laboratory (INL). Each irradiation capsule consists of over 400 graphite specimens that are characterized before and after irradiation to determine the irradiation induced material properties changes and life-limiting irradiation creep rate for each graphite grade.
DOE ART Graphite R&D program is currently involved in developing the structural code for licensing the new High Temperature Reactor (HTR) designs through the ASME Boiler Pressure Vessel Code (BPVC). The basic structural design code for graphite core components has been written, approved, and within the BPVC since 2012. However, several areas within the graphite code remain to be improved, specifically the addition of material property changes resulting from environmental degradation (neutron flux and oxidation). The incorporation of this data, which can significantly affect the graphite components and alter the structural integrity of the core during operation, is proving to be an important activity. How this data will be incorporated within the code and how it will be used for license applications will be critical to a number of HTR applicants in the future. These modifications to the code must take into account the unique irradiation and oxidation response of the wide spectrum of available nuclear graphite grades currently under consideration for HTR applications. Additionally, the ASME BPVC requires material property testing within the expected operational conditions of the HTR core including neutron radiation flux, elevated temperatures, and after chronic/acute oxidation of the graphite components. Currently, no standardized graphite testing methods are approved for these environmental conditions. New American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM) standardized tests for elevated temperature testing, small sample testing, and testing after oxidation must be developed to support the requirements within the ASME code.
The NGNP Graphite R&D program is currently establishing the safe operating envelope of graphite core components for a Very High Temperature Reactor (VHTR) design. The program is generating quantitative data necessary for predicting the behavior and operating performance of the new nuclear graphite grades. To determine the in-service behavior of the graphite for pebble bed and prismatic designs, the Advanced Graphite Creep (AGC) experiment is underway. This experiment is examining the properties and behavior of nuclear grade graphite over a large spectrum of temperatures, neutron fluences and compressive loads. Each experiment consists of over 400 graphite specimens that are characterized prior to irradiation and following irradiation. Six experiments are planned with the first, AGC-1, currently being irradiated in the Advanced Test Reactor (ATR) and pre-irradiation characterization of the second, AGC-2, completed. This data package establishes the readiness of 512 specimens for assembly into the AGC-2 capsule.
The NGNP Graphite R&D program is currently establishing the safe operating envelope of graphite core components for a Very High Temperature Reactor (VHTR) design. The program is generating quantitative data necessary for predicting the behavior and operating performance of the new nuclear graphite grades. To determine the in-service behavior of the graphite for pebble bed and prismatic designs, the Advanced Graphite Creep (AGC) experiment is underway. This experiment is examining the properties and behavior of nuclear grade graphite over a large spectrum of temperatures, neutron fluences and compressive loads. Each experiment consists of over 400 graphite specimens that are characterized prior to irradiation and following irradiation. Six experiments are planned with the first, AGC-1, currently being irradiated in the Advanced Test Reactor (ATR) and pre-irradiation characterization of the second, AGC-2, completed. This data package establishes the readiness of 512 specimens for assembly into the AGC-2 capsule.
The Next Generation Nuclear Plant (NGNP) Graphite R&D program is currently measuring irradiated material property changes in several grades of nuclear graphite for predicting their behavior and operating performance within the core of new Very High Temperature Reactor (VHTR) designs. The Advanced Graphite Creep (AGC) experiment consisting of six irradiation capsules will generate this irradiated graphite performance data for NGNP reactor operating conditions. All six AGC capsules in the experiment will be irradiated in the Advanced Test Reactor (ATR), disassembled in the Hot Fuel Examination Facility (HFEF), and examined at the INL Research Center (IRC) or Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL). This is the first in a series of status reports on the progress of the AGC experiment. As the first capsule, AGC1 was irradiated from September 2009 to January 2011 to a maximum dose level of 6-7 dpa. The capsule was removed from ATR and transferred to the HFEF in April 2011 where the capsule was disassembled and test specimens extracted from the capsules. The first irradiated samples from AGC1 were shipped to the IRC in July 2011and initial post irradiation examination (PIE) activities were begun on the first 37 samples received. PIE activities continue for the remainder of the AGC1 specimen as they are received at the IRC.
This report formally documents the completion of the Advanced Reactor Technologies (ART) Level 3 Milestone (M3TG-24OR0501054), “Continue activities related to Split Disc-DIC - complete analysis of effect of sample thickness on one fine grain graphite,” due May 31, 2024. Details within this report outline the status of activities aimed at elucidating the effect of sample thickness on the tensile strength measurement using the small-disc, split-disc testing standard in support of the US Department of Energy’s ART Graphite R&D Program. The ASTM D8289, Standard Test Method for Tensile Strength Estimate by Disc Compression of Manufactured Graphite, was developed to provide an alternative means for testing tensile strength on smaller specimens, which are compatible with available irradiation capsule volumes, and other compatibility measurements. ASTM D8289 specifies that acceptable specimen diameter can range from 6 to 12.7 mm and that the maximum allowed sample thickness should be half of the diameter. However, information is limited with respect to the effect of thickness on the measured splitting tensile strength. This report documents efforts to understand the effect of sample thickness on splitting tensile strength. The work involved testing Ø12.7 mm samples of fine-grain graphites 2114 and IG-110 of different thicknesses (6.35, 5, 4, and 3 mm). The digital image correlation (DIC) method was applied to the samples, along with the ASTM D8289 Standard, to help interpret the measured results.
The objective of the international collaboration between United States Department of Energy (U.S.-DOE) and Generation IV International Forum (GIF) is the development of the next generation of nuclear energy systems. The current GIF Project Arrangement (PA) on Materials (2018-2022) was revised in 2019 and extended for another 10 years (2020-2030). The Work Package 1 (“Graphite”) of the extended Project Plan (PP) on Materials specifies technical tasks and High Level Deliverables for research and development (R&D) activities related to using graphite in fuel elements, reflectors, and support structures of Very High Temperature Reactors (VHTR). The graphite tasks include specification and acquisition, qualification and development of new grades, characterization of properties, and development of behavior models. Specifically, Task 1.4 (“Graphite Oxidation Behavior”) outlines planned activities related to acute oxidation by air and chronic oxidation by impurities in the helium coolant. A final report on experimental data regarding graphite oxidation behavior is scheduled for 2022 (deliverable 3.1.1.4.a). In preparation of this deliverable, this document summarizes the R&D activities funded by U.S.-DOE from 2006 (the inception of the VHTR system arrangement) through present (2021). This report is being submitted to the GIF Graphite Working Group (GWG) to serve as input for the GWG high-level deliverable to the Project Management Board (PMB) of PA on Materials. Besides U.S.-DOE, other organizations participating to Task 1.4 of the current PA on Materials are: European Commission’s Joint Research Center (JRC), Korea Atomic Energy Research Institute (KAERI), and Japan Atomic Energy Agency (JAEA). U.S.-DOE is the main contributor on graphite oxidation R&D, with 85 % commitment of total funding during 2018-2022.
ASME Code Development - Nonmetallics slides to include behavior models, licensing & code, graphite R&D Program, As-Fab'd Properties, Mechanisms and Analysis, and Irradiation. Discussion on where these fit into Irradiation behavior, Ceramic Composites, Design, and Component Failure.
This report is responsive to 2017 Idaho National Laboratory (INL) Memorandum Purchase Order No. 00181805, statement of work 13687 “HTR Graphite R&D – FY ORNL 2017 MPO”, Deliverable 12A “issue final report on the HTV PIE to INL”, due June 15 th 2017.The HTV (High Temperature Vessel) was a HFIR (High Flux Isotope Reactor) high temperature target rod capsule in support of the DOE’s (Department of Energy) High Temperature Reactor (HTR) program. The HTV capsule contained eight sub-capsules, each with nine graphite specimens. The sub-capsules were designed to operate at ~900°C, ~1200°C or ~1600°C. The actual irradiation temperature was established by interrogating SiC and graphite TMs during PIE (post-irradiation examination. The capsule dose ranged from 1.49 dpa to 3.34 dpa, and varied with specimen position within the capsule the maximum dose occurring at the reactor mid-plane and the minimum dose occurring at the core periphery. The irradiated graphite specimens were examined during PIE to establish their high temperature dimensional and elastic (Young’s) modulus changes. The PIE results are reported and analyzed here. The dimensional and modulus changes were shown to have a strong thermal dependence. The dimensional changes were small, being of the order of a few percent or less, ranging from a maximum shrinkage of -3.1% (PCEA WG, T irr =1500°C at 3.3 dpa) to +0.131% (2114 AG, T irr = 869 at 3.2 dpa). The specimen volume shrinkages varied from –0.81 (2114, T irr = 840 at 3.1 dpa) to -9.15% (PCEA, T irr =1500°C at 3.3 dpa). The volume changes were larger at higher Irradiation temperatures. Of the six grades examined, only 2114 moved into the net positive dimensional swelling situation. Significantly, the volume change for 2114 remained negative at the doses and temperature tested here. Dimensional and volume changes were explained in terms of the temperature dependence of the crystal growth rate, the anisotropy of the crystal growth (crystallographic c-axis growth and crystallographic a-direction shrinkage) and the thermal closure of aligned micro-porosity. The modulus changes were much larger, being of the order of a few tens of percent. A trend of lesser fractional increases of Young’s Modulus with an increasing T irr was noted. The minimum increase in Young’s Modulus was 20% (H-451 WG, T irr =1500°C at 3.3 dpa) and the maximum 71% (IG-110, T irr = 840(actual) at 3.3 dpa). The rise in Young’s modulus is attributed to dislocation pinning by lattice defects produced by neutron irradiation and the temperature dependency is related to the irradiation temperature influence on the number of defect available to pin dislocations.