NASA NTRS2020
Hydrous components were measured in nominally anhydrous minerals, primarily lunar feldspar, and reported by Simon et al. (2020). In the feldspar mineral structure, these components are contained in the form of OH, H2O, and/or NH4+molecules (Johnson, 2006 and references therein). The advantages of the ion microprobe technique employed by Simon et al. (2020) include high spatial resolution, apparent insensitivity to crystal orientation, high precision, and low detection limits, but unlike complementary spectroscopy techniques (i.e., FTIR) they preclude assignment of molecular species(Mosenfelder et al. 2015). Convention in the lunar sample community is to report major elemental abundances and hydrogen as oxides, H2O is the oxide for H. This convention was not followed by Simon et al. (2020), but rather the measured hydrogen component was reported as H to avoid the appearance of assigning the measured hydrogen concentration to a specific molecular species. The speciation of the hydrous component in terrestrial feldspars varies predominantly between OH and H2O, with no apparent correlation to feldspar composition, and only slight correlation to volcanic-to-plutonic igneous rock type (Johnson and Rossman, 2004).