Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “laser-induced damage testing”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 19 records
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
DOE OSTI2023

Monolayer organic thin films as particle-contamination–resistant coatings

Abstract Three organic monolayers coatings were developed and tested for their effectiveness to increase cleaning efficiency of attached microscale particles by air flows. The experiments were performed using silica substrates coated with these organic thin films and subsequently exposed to stainless-steel and silica microparticles as a model of contamination. Laser-induced–damage tests confirmed that the coatings do not affect the laser-induced–damage threshold values. The particle exposure results suggest that although the accumulation of particles is not significantly affected under the experimental conditions used in this work, the coated substrates exhibit significantly improved cleaning efficiency with a gas flow. A size-distribution analysis was conducted to study the adsorption and cleaning efficiency of particles of different sizes. It was observed that larger size (> 5-μm) particles can be removed from coated substrates with almost 100% efficiency. It was also determined that the coatings improve the cleaning efficiency of the smaller particles (≤ 5 μm) by 17% to 30% for the stainless steel metal and 19% to 38% for the silica particles.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2023

Enhanced laser-induced damage performance of all-glass metasurfaces for energetic pulsed laser applications

To fabricate optical components with surface layers compatible with high power laser applications that may operate as antireflective coatings, polarization rotators, or harness physical anisotropy for other uses, metasurfaces are becoming an appealing candidate. In this study, a large-beam (1.05 cm diameter) 351-nm laser-induced damage testing was done on an all-glass metasurface structure composed of cone-like features with a subwavelength spacing of adjacent features. These structures were fabricated on untreated fused silica glass and damage tested, as were structures that were fabricated on fused silica glass that experienced a preliminary etching process to remove the surface Beilby layer that is characteristic of polished fused silica. The laser-induced damage onset for structures on untreated fused silica glass was 19.3 J∙cm -2 , while the sample that saw an initial pretreatment etch exhibited an improved damage onset of 20.4 J∙cm -2 , only 6% short of the reference pretreated glass damage onset of 21.7 J∙cm -2 . For perspective, the National Ignition Facility (NIF) operational average fluence at this wavelength and pulse length is about 10 J/cm2. At a fluence of 25.5 J∙cm -2 , the reference (pretreated) fused silica initiated 5.2 damage sites per mm 2 , while the antireflective metasurface sample with a preliminary etching process treatment initiated 9.8 damage sites per mm 2 . In conclusion, these findings demonstrate that substrate-engraved metasurfaces are compatible with high energy and power laser applications, further broadening their application space.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2026

Fabrication of freeform potassium dihydrogen phosphate crystals by belt-on-wheel polishing for spatially tailored polarization control in high-power lasers

Large-aperture (>30 cm) optical components that provide spatially tailored control of the properties of a laser beam, such as phase, polarization, and amplitude, have been the focus of much research and development in recent years. Such optics can improve energy throughput and target implosion efficiency in high-power laser systems conducting inertial confinement fusion research. Here, a method is demonstrated for fabricating freeform surface topographies into the birefringent crystalline material, potassium dihydrogen phosphate (KDP). Belt-on-wheel polishing with an oil-based fluid, developed to mitigate the deliquescent properties of KDP, is used to deterministically polish a freeform topography into KDP, enabling the fabrication of a wave plate with spatially arbitrary retardance. Testing of the laser-induced damage threshold of belt-on-wheel polished KDP was conducted at a wavelength of 351 nm and a pulse duration of 1 ns. The results revealed that the polished surfaces are highly resistant to laser-induced damage, making them suitable for large-aperture, high-power laser applications.

Urban, Nathaniel D. [Univ. of Rochester, NY (Unite↗
DOE OSTI2026

Understanding spectral dependance of laser-induced damage precursors in dielectric materials (Abbreviated report_23-ERD-006)

High peak and average power laser systems are typically limited by the handling fluence of the optical components. In particular, the multilayer dielectric coatings are known to be much lower operational fluence than the more ideal bulk materials. In this project we proposed and succeeded in probing different established classes of damage prone precursors at different wavelengths to understand their fundamental laser damage response as a function of wavelength. This study helped to shed light on the fundamental physics of the non-linear precursors that govern laser damage phenomena for ns-regime pulsed laser damage. In this study, we utilized the onsite coating capabilities (VPL, IBS coating lab) to purposefully generate laser damage-prone precursors in hafnia-based coatings (both single and multi-layer coatings). Specifically, we engineered coatings with craze lines initiated by nodules, generated coatings with our xenon-based coating process to suppress nanobubble formation and generated hafnia coatings under controlled oxygen flow conditions to study hafnia sub-oxides and oxygen flow dependance. In these studies we found that craze lines are rife with precursors that are sensitive to ultra-violet light but not to infrared light; we found that the removal of nanobubbles helps with all wavelengths tested, but is most impactful for ultra-violet light; we also found that ultra-violet laser damage performance of hafnia is closely matched to oxygen flow rate, while the infrared performance may be slightly better at lower flow rates. During this LDRD we also successfully stood up a new laser damage testing capability, namely a wavelength agile damage test station to study the spectral response of known laser-induced damage precursors. This is a unique and important capability for Lawrence Livermore National Lab, allowing us to understand the spectral response of materials under high intensity irradiation and damage. This is a vital tool to understand non-linear optical response at wavelengths that we have previously been unable to test at.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2025

Development of a robust damage analysis scheme at the National Ignition Facility

The onset of laser-induced damage in optical materials is a limiting factor in the design and operation of most high-energy laser systems. As such, significant effort has been dedicated to developing laser damage testing protocols and procedures to inform laser system design and operating limits. These tests typically rely on multiple laser exposures for statistical validation. Historically, small beam single fluence (N / 1) or ramped fluence (R / 1) tests have been used to quantify the “laser-induced damage threshold” of a material. However, due to various distributions in damage precursor populations, the laser fluence at which damage occurs for a given sample varies with beam size and is therefore better described as the onset of observed damage for that testing geometry. In conclusion, we document the development of irradiation, measurement, and analysis methods for damage testing resulting in damage initiation density as a function of incident fluence or ρ(ϕ) which is suitable for both small and large beam area testing and more conducive to extrapolating from one to the other.

Beam diameter↗
DOE OSTI2026

Asymptotic inconsistency of the cumulative algorithm for laser-induced damage probability analysis

The “cumulative algorithm” is a data analysis method that has been proposed to provide an objective, nonparametric determination of laser-induced damage probability as a function of fluence from experimental data that contain both damaged sites and undamaged sites (i.e., 1-on-1 or S-on-1 testing protocols). In this work, the limitations of this approach are explored by considering the asymptotic limit of a large number of test sites. It is shown that the cumulative algorithm does not converge to the true probability distribution and significantly underestimates the damage probability near the damage onset. Here, based on the results of this work, the cumulative algorithm is not recommended for accurate estimation of damage probability.

Computational methods↗
DOE OSTI2026

Nanosecond dual-wavelength irradiation effects on laser-induced damage in hafnia coatings

Nanosecond dual-wavelength laser-induced damage was investigated at 1064 nm (1ω) and 355 nm (3ω) on ion-beam-sputtered hafnia single-layer coatings. Single-wavelength 1-on-1 tests were first conducted to establish reference onset fluences. Dual-wavelength tests combined a primary beam with variable fluence at one wavelength and a background, secondary wavelength beam with fixed fluences set to several percentages of the corresponding onset fluence. When 1ω was used as the background irradiation, the perceived damage resistance at 3ω decreased gradually. Here, in contrast, 3ω background irradiation at as little as 10% of the onset fluence led to an ≈ 50% abrupt reduction in the perceived 1ω damage resistance, followed by modest changes upon further increases in 3ω background fluences. Scanning electron microscopy and conversion ratios indicate that 3ω light is the primary driver of damage onset in the case of dual wavelength irradiation. A two-step precursor generation and activation model reproduces the 3ω behavior (1ω as background), but not the strong initial 1ω reduction (3ω as background), suggesting additional 3ω-induced precursors that saturate at low fluence.

Optics and optical instruments↗
DOE OSTI2026

Influence of Oxygen Flow and Stoichiometry on Optical Properties and Damage Resistance of Hafnium Oxide Thin Films

Hafnium oxide (HfO 2 ) is predominantly used as a high-index material in multi-layer dielectric coatings for high-peak- and high-average-power lasers, but laser damage often initiates within the HfO 2 layers despite their wide bandgap. Oxygen deficiency during deposition can introduce vacancy-related sub-bandgap states and absorptive defects, lowering damage resistance. This study investigates how oxygen flow during HfO 2 deposition with ion beam sputtering (IBS) affects its stoichiometry, defect formation, and nanosecond laser-induced damage threshold (LIDT) and whether single-layer trends predict multilayer performance. Single layers were deposited at varying oxygen flows, characterized for optical and structural properties, and tested for the LIDT at 1064 nm and 355 nm. Increasing oxygen flow drove the layer toward near-stoichiometric HfO 2 , reduced the refractive index, and altered the density of surface pinhole-like features. The single-layer LIDT at 355 nm increased with oxygen, whereas the 1064 nm LIDT was comparatively less sensitive to oxygen flow, consistent with the wavelength-dependent roles of absorptive precursors and microstructural defects. In contrast, a HfO 2 -based high-reflector (HR) showed a higher LIDT at lower oxygen flow, indicating that the family of damage precursors changes between single layers and multilayers; in stacks, structural properties such as stress, gas entrapment and thermal dissipation may outweigh the isolated absorptive defects found in single layers. These results demonstrate that the optimal oxygen flow condition depends on both LIDT wavelength and film architecture. We identified, for single layers, a 15–35 sccm window for maximizing the 1064 nm LIDT and a high-flow optimum (45 sccm) for the 355 nm LIDT and, for 355 nm HR stacks, a distinct lower-flow regime (~10 sccm).

Optics and optical instruments↗
DOE OSTI2024

Broadband 920-nm mirror thin film damage competition

The 2023 Laser Damage conference thin-film damage competition was devoted to a survey on the state-of-the-art broadband near-IR multilayer dielectric (MLD) mirrors designed for ultra-short pulsed laser applications. The requirements for the coatings were a minimum reflection of 99.5% at 45-deg incidence angle for S-polarization from 830 nm to 1010 nm and group delay dispersion (GDD) < ± 50fs 2 . The participants were allowed to select the coating materials, coating design, and coating deposition method. Samples were damage tested at a single testing facility to enable direct comparison among the participants using a 25 ± 5 fs optical parametric chirped-pulse amplification (OPCPA) laser system operating at 5 Hz. The testing results from this set of 37 samples showed that dense coatings by ion-beam sputtering (IBS), magnetron sputtering (MS), and electron-beam ion assisted deposition (e-beam IAD) exhibited highest damage initiation onset (laser-induced damage threshold or LIDT) while e-beam coatings were low performers. In addition, multilayer coatings using tantala and/or hafnia as high index materials were top performers. Furthermore, this competition included for the first time the measurement of the damage growth onset (laser-induced damage growth threshold or LDGT). This latter performance metric plays an important role in establishing the safe operational conditions for larger aperture ultrashort pulsed lasers. Information pertaining to the morphology of the damage sites and their evolution under subsequent exposure to different laser fluences leading to damage growth is presented. Finally, not all coating samples in the survey met the GDD requirements stated above and associated measurements are discussed in the context of the present and past thin-film damage competitions focused on similar broadband near-IR MLD coatings.

23 broadband high reflectors↗
DOE OSTI2025

Pulse duration dependent effects of ultrafast laser induced damage on a 1030 nm multi-layer dielectric mirror for high repetition rate, high average power laser systems

High repetition rate, high peak, and average power laser systems are crucial for next-generation particle accelerators, inertial confinement fusion, and secondary particle sources. These applications demand durable laser optics, particularly interference coatings on optics lasting millions of shots at high fluence. This study focuses on designing, testing, and simulating multi-layer dielectric (MLD) mirrors for pulse durations of 260 fs, 77 fs, and 25 fs at 1030 nm wavelength and 45-degree incidence angle with p -polarization. S-on-1 laser-induced damage thresholds (LIDT) for varying pulse numbers were determined, with single-shot LIDT values of 0.98 Jcm -2 , 1.63 Jcm -2 , and 2.3 Jcm -2 for 25 fs, 77 fs, and 260 fs respectively. A strong correlation between blister shape and local fluence was observed, implying that the layer expansion in a blister depends on local fluence. We have also examined mechanisms responsible for laser-induced stress generation and energy release rates in blister formation. Damage mechanisms are further explored by finite-difference time-domain (FDTD) simulations, incorporating Keldysh strong field ionization, whose predictions were in excellent agreement with the onset of damage determined experimentally. These findings offer insights for enhancing MLD coating technology, promising more efficient and resilient laser systems for diverse scientific and industrial applications.

Noor, Mohamed Yaseen (ORCID:000000021036644X)↗
DOE OSTI2022

Multiparameter laser performance characterization of liquid crystals for polarization control devices in the nanosecond regime

Abstract Interactions of liquid crystals (LC’s) with polarized light have been studied widely and have spawned numerous device applications, including the fabrication of optical elements for high-power and large-aperture laser systems. Currently, little is known about both the effect of incident polarization state on laser-induced–damage threshold (LIDT) and laser-induced functional threshold (LIFT) behavior at sub-LIDT fluences under multipulse irradiation conditions. This work reports on the first study of the nanosecond-pulsed LIDT’s dependence on incident polarization for several optical devices employing oriented nematic and chiral-nematic LC’s oriented by surface alignment layers. Accelerated lifetime testing was also performed to characterize the ability of these devices to maintain their functional performance under multipulse irradiation as a function of the laser fluence at both 1053 nm and 351 nm. Results show that the LIDT varies as a function of input polarization by 30–80% within the same device, while the multipulse LIFT (which can differ from the nominal LIDT) depends on irradiation conditions such as laser fluence and wavelength.

47 OTHER INSTRUMENTATION↗
DOE OSTI2024

A model for oblique impacts on material surfaces

Many practical situations of material damage, wear, and erosion involve collisions between small particles and surfaces at inclined angles. While there are many well-validated models of normal incidence impact situations, elastic-plastic models for oblique incidence impact events are lacking. Here the finite element method is used to predict the normal and tangential coefficient of restitution in oblique impacts for hard, elastic spheres impacting an elastic-perfectly plastic material surface. The proposed model covers various impact angles ranging from 0° to 45°, within a limiting impact velocity below which the effects of heating are negligible. The normal coefficient of restitution follows power-laws with respect to normalized values of the impact velocity. Interestingly, the tangential coefficient of restitution follows a linear relationship with impact velocity. Together, these results provide a semi-empirical set of equations predicting oblique impact rebounds (both velocity and trajectory) for a wide range of conditions and material properties, with which experimental results can be rapidly interpreted. As a result, Laser-Induced Particle Impact Test (LIPIT) data are also presented for aluminum particles impacting aluminum substrates, at impact angles of 25° and 40°; the results compare favorably with the model and validate the general use of such models for the analysis of experimental data.

Coefficient of restitution↗
DOE OSTI2023

Design, construction, and validation of an in-situ groundwater trace element analyzer with applications in carbon storage

Abstract It is estimated that carbon emissions should reach net-zero by 2050 to meet important climate targets. Carbon capture is likely necessary to reach these targets, requiring a long-term storage solution such as geological carbon sequestration. However, as with any subsurface activity, leakage can occur, potentially impacting groundwater quality near the storage site. Rapid detection is essential to mitigate damage to this resource. Since CO 2 will acidify groundwater, the concentrations of acid soluble minerals and associated cations will increase. Thus, an in-situ, real-time element analysis system based on laser-induced breakdown spectroscopy (LIBS) is under development to monitor these elements. The system splits the traditional LIBS system into a miniature, all-optical sensor head built around a passively Q-switch laser fiber coupled to a control unit. Previous work has validated the LIBS technique for use at high pressure as well as the split system design. In this work, a fieldable prototype sensor is developed and tested in an onsite monitoring well where trace elements concentrations (approx. 0–3 ppm) were tracked over 20 days. These concentrations varied in response to local rainfall, diluting with increased rain, demonstrating the ability of a LIBS-based sensor to track trace elements under real-world conditions.

54 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES↗
DOE OSTI2023

Performance characterization of freeform finished surfaces of potassium dihydrogen phosphate using fluid jet polishing with a nonaqueous slurry

Abstract Potassium dihydrogen phosphate (KDP) and its deuterated analog (DKDP) are unique nonlinear optical materials for high power laser systems. They are used widely for frequency conversion and polarization control by virtue of the ability to grow optical-quality crystals at apertures suitable for fusion-class laser systems. Existing methods for freeform figuring of KDP/DKDP optics do not produce surfaces with sufficient laser-induced–damage thresholds (LIDT’s) for operation in the ultraviolet portion of high-peak-power laser systems. In this work, we investigate fluid jet polishing (FJP) using a nonaqueous slurry as a sub-aperture finishing method for producing freeform KDP surfaces. This method was used to selectively polish surface areas to different depths on the same substrate with removals ranging from 0.16 μm to 5.13 μm. The finished surfaces demonstrated a slight increase in roughness as the removal depth increased along with a small number of fracture pits. Laser damage testing with 351 nm, 1 ns pulses demonstrated excellent surface damage thresholds, with the highest values in areas devoid of fracture pits. This work demonstrates, for the first time, a method that enables fabrication of a waveplate that provides tailored polarization randomization that can be scaled to meter-sized optics. Furthermore, this method is based on FJP technology that incorporates a nonaqueous slurry specially designed for use with KDP. This novel nonaqueous FJP process can be also used for figuring other types of materials that exhibit similar challenging inherent properties such as softness, brittleness, water-solubility, and temperature sensitivity.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2024

Effect of THz-bandwidth incoherent laser radiation on bulk damage in potassium dihydrogen phosphate crystals

Abstract The laser-damage performance characteristics of potassium dihydrogen phosphate (KDP) samples under exposure to a distinctive broadband incoherent laser pulse are investigated. A laser system providing such pulses is intended to explore improved energy-coupling efficiency on the target in direct-drive inertial confinement fusion experiments and provides incoherent bandwidths as large as 10 THz in a nanosecond pulse. A consequence of this bandwidth is very rapid fluctuations in intensity capable of reaching maxima much larger than the average intensity within the pulse. A custom damage-test station has been built to perform measurements with broadband incoherent pulses in order to determine what effect these fast and high-intensity oscillations have on laser damage. A set of experiments under different bandwidth and beam configurations shows the effect to be minimal when probing bulk damage in KDP. Modeling indicates this behavior is supported by long electron-relaxation times compared to the source-field fluctuations, following excitation of individual electrons in the conduction band. The results help better understand the laser-induced–damage mechanisms in KDP, and its ability to operate in broadband temporally incoherent high-energy lasers that may be particularly suitable for future laser-fusion energy systems.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2025

Increasing the deuterated potassium dihydrogen phosphate crystal laser resistance by an additional conditioning with nanosecond pulses

Laser conditioning with 355-nm sub-nanosecond laser light is a well-known procedure to increase the bulk laser-induced damage resistance of deuterated potassium dihydrogen phosphate (DKDP) crystals. In this study, we investigate a new process to further increase the bulk damage resistance of DKDP crystals by performing additional conditioning with a 6.7-ns 355-nm laser after first conditioning with a 500-ps 355-nm laser. Here, damage tests (using both small and large beams) show that the second nanosecond conditioning raster increased the fluence required to produce the same density (large beam test) and probability (small beam test) of bulk damage by ∼30%.

Crystals↗
DOE OSTI2025

Investigation of the distribution of laser-induced damage precursors in etched grating sidewalls fabricated using inductively coupled plasma reactive-ion etching

Inductively coupled plasma reactive-ion etching for grating fabrication is explored with emphasis on the type and distribution of process-induced defects that can act as precursors to laser-induced damage initiation. To provide flexibility in the ability to perform a variety of material characterization methods, grating-like features with large pitch were fabricated in silica monolayers. The results indicate that the etch process introduces surface fluorine and subsurface carbon-containing contamination, which reduces the laser-induced damage threshold. The local relative concentrations of the laser-damage precursors introduced during the etch step of the manufacturing process were investigated using angle-resolved damage testing, taking advantage of the shift of the location of the peak electric-field intensity incident on the grating sidewall. The results suggest an increased level of etch-related defects near the base of the sidewall, with directly fluorinated silicon identified as the primary defect.

Dent, R. [Univ. of Rochester, NY (United States). ↗
DOE OSTI2025

Enhancing the performance of solvent-borne poly(ethyl methacrylate) coatings for high-power laser applications via low-temperature drying

Organic polymers are a versatile class of materials employed in a broad range of optical coating applications. However, their use as coatings in high-power laser applications, particularly in the UV spectral region, has been limited in scope due to their relatively low laser-induced damage thresholds (LIDTs), which decrease further with exposure to multiple pulses. This study explores the effect of post-deposition drying temperature and residual solvent on the LIDT of solvent-borne polymer coatings. In this work, poly(ethyl methacrylate) (PEMA) coatings were deposited by first spin coating solutions of PEMA (dissolved in 2,2,2-trichloroethanol (TCE)) onto fused silica substrates, then baking at temperatures of either 130°C (soft-bake) or 180°C (hard-bake). Analysis of the two coatings revealed that the soft-bake coating retained a significant amount of TCE within the polymer matrix, which functioned to plasticize the coating and reduce internal stress. The laser-induced damage resistance of the two coatings was evaluated using 351-nm, 1-ns laser pulses. The testing protocols included single-pulse (1-on-1), 1-pulse ramp (R-on-1), and a 1000-pulse ramp (1000R-on-1) test. The results showed that the plasticized, soft-bake coating exhibits a significantly increased LIDT, especially for multipulse irradiation conditions.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗