Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “load damage detection”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 19 records
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
NASA NTRS2018

Detection of Damage During Quasi-Static Loading of a Single Stringer Panel Using Passive Thermography and Acoustic Emission

The purpose of this paper is to describe the methodology of measuring damage onset and growth in a composite structure during quasi-static loading using passive thermography and acoustic emission. The early detection and measurement of damage progression is important to understand failure modes. A single stringer panel was subjected to quasi-static loading to induce deformation which resulted in the formation of damage between the stiffener flange and skin. The loading was stopped when damage growth was detected. Passive thermography and acoustic emission were used to detect damage in real-time as a function of the applied load. Of particular interest are the small transient thermographic signals resulting from damage formation which can be challenging to detect, as compared to the persistent passive thermography indications of cyclic fatigue loading. We describe a custom developed thermal inspection system for detection of composite damage during quasi-static loading. The thermal results are compared to a two-dimensional multi-layered thermal simulation based on the quadrupole method. Acoustic emission is used to further characterize the damage by comparing the acoustic emission events with the thermal imagery. Results are compared to ultrasonic measurements to document the damage through-the-thickness.

Zalameda, Joseph N.↗
NASA NTRS2018

Real Time Detection of Damage During Quasi-Static Loading of a Single Stringer Panel Using Passive Thermography

Real time nondestructive evaluation is required for composites load testing. The early detection and measurement of damage progression is important to understand failure modes. A single stringer panel was subjected to quasi-static loading to induce deformation which can result in the formation of delamination damage between the stiffener flange and skin. Passive thermography was used to detect damage in real time as a function of the applied load. The loading was stopped when damage growth was detected. Of particular interest was the early detection of damage formation which can be challenging, as compared to cyclic fatigue loading. Passive thermography data were acquired and processed in real time and revealed damaged areas due to heating from fiber breakage and delamination formation. The processed thermal imagery was also compared to acoustic emission and ultrasound data.

Zalameda, Joseph N.↗
NASA NTRS2010

Thermography Inspection for Detection and Tracking of Composite Cylinder Damage During Load Testing

Two thermography techniques, passive and active, are used to detect damage initiation and progression in a cyclically loaded composite cylinder. The passive thermography tracks damage progression in real time during cyclic loading. Active flash thermography, using a flash tube enclosed within the cylinder, images delaminations in a cylinder under different loads. A differential thermography processing technique eliminates normal material variations and improves sensitivity to and sizing of delaminations. The thermography results were compared to nonimmersion ultrasonic results.

Zalameda, J. N.↗
NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Acquisition and Processing of Passive Thermography Fatigue Test Data

Passive thermography is a large area inspection technique and is commonly used during fatigue loading of composite structures. Passive thermography allows for real time tracking of damage. This provides an accurate assessment of the damage progression as a function of load cycles and determines when the loading is stopped for ultrasonic or X-ray CT evaluations for detail damage assessment through-the-thickness. In addition, if new areas of damage growth are detected, with passive thermography, then those areas are additionally inspected with ultrasound or X-ray CT. A custom developed passive thermography inspection system for fatigue loading is presented. Passive thermography of damage progression is compared to ultrasound inspections as a function of the fatigue cycles. Discussion is made on processing of the thermal data for periodic and non-periodic thermal responses.

Thermal nondestructive evaluation↗
NASA NTRS2012

Thermography Inspection for Early Detection of Composite Damage in Structures During Fatigue Loading

Advanced composite structures are commonly tested under controlled loading. Understanding the initiation and progression of composite damage under load is critical for validating design concepts and structural analysis tools. Thermal nondestructive evaluation (NDE) is used to detect and characterize damage in composite structures during fatigue loading. A difference image processing algorithm is demonstrated to enhance damage detection and characterization by removing thermal variations not associated with defects. In addition, a one-dimensional multilayered thermal model is used to characterize damage. Lastly, the thermography results are compared to other inspections such as non-immersion ultrasonic inspections and computed tomography X-ray.

Zalameda, Joseph N.↗
NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Characterization of Composite Damage Using Passive Thermography

Passive thermography is used to monitor small increases in temperature on a composite structure during loading. A rise in temperature can be attributed to damage formation due to matrix cracking and fiber breaks. An infrared camera allows for imaging the damage location, size, and shape. Recently, a technique has been developed to estimate the depth of the damage in a composite hat-stiffened panel during quasi-static loading. This technique is based on two heat generation components. The first component is an instantaneous thermoelastic response due to a strain release. The second component is mechanical heating, at the interface of failure, due to fracture damage. This second component produces a transient rise in temperature that is a function of the damage depth and thermal diffusivity. The first component defines the thermal start time for the transient response. A one-dimensional thermal model is used to determine the damage depth for a known thermal diffusivity. The results are compared to ultrasonic and X-ray CT data and show good agreement for damage depth.

Thermal nondestructive evaluation↗
NASA NTRS2016

Combining Passive Thermography and Acoustic Emission for Large Area Fatigue Damage Growth Assessment of a Composite Structure

Passive thermography and acoustic emission data were obtained for improved real time damage detection during fatigue loading. A strong positive correlation was demonstrated between acoustic energy event location and thermal heating, especially if the structure under load was nearing ultimate failure. An image processing routine was developed to map the acoustic emission data onto the thermal imagery. This required removing optical barrel distortion and angular rotation from the thermal data. The acoustic emission data were then mapped onto thermal data, revealing the cluster of acoustic emission event locations around the thermal signatures of interest. By combining both techniques, progression of damage growth is confirmed and areas of failure are identified. This technology provides improved real time inspections of advanced composite structures during fatigue testing.Keywords: Thermal nondestructive evaluation, fatigue damage detection, aerospace composite inspection, acoustic emission, passive thermography

Zalameda, Joseph N.↗
NASA NTRS1994

Test and analysis of a stitched RFI graphite-epoxy panel with a fuel access door

A stitched RFI graphite-epoxy panel with a fuel access door was analyzed using a finite element analysis and loaded to failure in compression. The panel was initially 56-inches long and 36.75-inches wide and the oval access door was 18-inches long and 15-inches wide. The panel was impact damaged with impact energy of 100 ft-lb prior to compressive loading; however, no impact damage was detectable visually or by A-scan. The panel carried a failure load of 695,000 Ib and global failure strain of .00494 in/in. Analysis indicated the panel would fail due to collapse at a load of 688,100 Ib. The test data indicate that the maximum strain in a region near the access door was .0096 in/in and analysis indicates a local surface strain of .010 in/in at the panel's failure load. The panel did not fail through the impact damage, but instead failed through bolt holes for attachment of the access door in a region of high strain.

Jegley, Dawn C.↗
DOE OSTI2023

Unsupervised acoustic detection of fatigue-induced damage modes from wind turbine blades

This paper proposes a new in-situ damage detection approach for wind turbine blades, which leverages blade-internal non-stationary acoustic pressure fluctuations caused by the mechanical loading as the main source of excitation. This acoustic excitation was leveraged for the detection of fatigue-related damage modes on a full-scale wind turbine blade undergoing edgewise fatigue testing. An unsupervised, data-driven structural health monitoring strategy was developed to learn the normal cavity-internal acoustic sequences generated by the blade’s load cycles and to detect damage-related anomalies in the context of those sequences. A linear cepstral-coefficient based feature set was used to characterize the cavity-internal acoustics and LSTM-autoencoders were trained to accurately reconstruct healthy-case sequences. The reconstruction error was then used to characterize anomalous acoustic patterns within the blade cavity. The technique was able to detect a damage event earlier than a strain-based system by 120,000 load cycles.

17 WIND ENERGY↗
NASA NTRS2006

Quasi-Static 3-Point Reinforced Carbon-Carbon Bend Test and Analysis for Shuttle Orbiter Wing Leading Edge Impact Damage Thresholds

Static 3-point bend tests of Reinforced Carbon-Carbon (RCC) were conducted to failure to provide data for additional validation of an LS-DYNA RCC model suitable for predicting the threshold of impact damage to shuttle orbiter wing leading edges. LS-DYNA predictions correlated well with the average RCC failure load, and were good in matching the load vs. deflection. However, correlating the detectable damage using NDE methods with the cumulative damage parameter in LS-DYNA material model 58 was not readily achievable. The difficulty of finding internal RCC damage with NDE and the high sensitivity of the mat58 damage parameter to the load near failure made the task very challenging. In addition, damage mechanisms for RCC due to dynamic impact of debris such as foam and ice and damage mechanisms due to a static loading were, as expected, not equivalent.

Fasanella, Edwin L.↗
NASA NTRS2001

Minimizing Load Effects on NA4 Gear Vibration Diagnostic Parameter

NA4 is a vibration diagnostic parameter, developed by researchers at NASA Glenn Research Center, for health monitoring of gears in helicopter transmissions. The NA4 reacts to the onset of gear pitting damage and continues to react to the damage as it spreads. This research also indicates NA4 reacts similarly to load variations. The sensitivity of NA4 to load changes will substantially affect its performance on a helicopter gearbox that experiences continuously changing load throughout its flight regimes. The parameter NA4 has been used to monitor gear fatigue tests at constant load. At constant load, NA4 effectively detects the onset of pitting damage and tracks damage severity. Previous research also shows that NA4 reacts to changes in load applied to the gears in the same way it reacts to the onset of pitting damage. The method used to calculate NA4 was modified to minimize these load effects. The modified NA4 parameter was applied to four sets of experimental data. Results indicate the modified NA4 is no longer sensitive to load changes, but remains sensitive to pitting damage.

Dempsey, Paula J.↗
NASA NTRS1991

Nondestructive Structural Damage Detection in Flexible Space Structures Using Vibration Characterization

Spacecraft are susceptible to structural damage over their operating life from impact, environmental loads, and fatigue. Structural damage that is not detected and not corrected may potentially cause more damage and eventually catastrophic structural failure. NASA's current fleet of reusable spacecraft, namely the Space Shuttle, has been flown on several missions. In addition, configurations of future NASA space structures, e.g. Space Station Freedom, are larger and more complex than current structures, making them more susceptible to damage as well as being more difficult to inspect. Consequently, a reliable structural damage detection capability is essential to maintain the flight safety of these structures. Visual inspections alone can not locate impending material failure (fatigue cracks, yielding); it can only observe post-failure situations. An alternative approach is to develop an inspection and monitoring system based on vibration characterization that assesses the integrity of structural and mechanical components. A methodology for detecting structural damage is presented. This methodology is based on utilizing modal test data in conjunction with a correlated analytical model of the structure to: (1) identify the structural dynamic characteristics (resonant frequencies and mode shapes) from measurements of ambient motions and/or force excitation; (2) calculate modal residual force vectors to identify the location of structural damage; and (3) conduct a weighted sensitivity analysis in order to assess the extent of mass and stiffness variations, where structural damage is characterized by stiffness reductions. The approach is unique from other existing approaches in that varying system mass and stiffness, mass center locations, the perturbation of both the natural frequencies and mode shapes, and statistical confidence factors for structural parameters and experimental instrumentation are all accounted for directly.

Ricles, James M.↗
DOE OSTI2025

Embedded Sensing in Additive Manufacturing Metal and Polymer Parts: A Comparative Study of Integration Techniques and Structural Health Monitoring Performance

This study presents a comparative evaluation of post-process sensor integration in additively manufactured (AM) metal and the in-situ process for polymer structures for structural health monitoring (SHM), with an emphasis on embedded sensors. Geometrically identical specimens were fabricated using copper via metal fused filament fabrication (FFF) and PLA via polymer FFF, with piezoelectric transducers (PZTs) inserted into internal cavities to assess the influence of material and placement on sensing fidelity. Mechanical testing under compressive and point loads generated signals that were transformed into time–frequency spectrograms using a Short-Time Fourier Transform (STFT) framework. An engineered RGB representation was developed, combining global amplitude scaling with an amplitude-envelope encoding to enhance contrast and highlight subtle wave features. These spectrograms served as inputs to convolutional neural networks (CNNs) for classification of load conditions and detection of damage-related features. Results showed reliable recognition in both copper and PLA specimens, with CNN classification accuracies exceeding 95%. Embedded PZTs were especially effective in PLA, where signal damping and environmental sensitivity often hinder surface-mounted sensors. This work demonstrates the advantages of embedded sensing in AM structures, particularly when paired with spectrogram-based feature engineering and CNN modeling, advancing real-time SHM for aerospace, energy, and defense applications.

additive manufacturing↗
NASA NTRS2011

The Effects of Foam Thermal Protection System on the Damage Tolerance Characteristics of Composite Sandwich Structures for Launch Vehicles

For any structure composed of laminated composite materials, impact damage is one of the greatest risks and therefore most widely tested responses. Typically, impact damage testing and analysis assumes that a solid object comes into contact with the bare surface of the laminate (the outer ply). However, most launch vehicle structures will have a thermal protection system (TPS) covering the structure for the majority of its life. Thus, the impact response of the material with the TPS covering is the impact scenario of interest. In this study, laminates representative of the composite interstage structure for the Ares I launch vehicle were impact tested with and without the planned TPS covering, which consists of polyurethane foam. Response variables examined include maximum load of impact, damage size as detected by nondestructive evaluation techniques, and damage morphology and compression after impact strength. Results show that there is little difference between TPS covered and bare specimens, except the residual strength data is higher for TPS covered specimens.

Nettles, A. T.↗
NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Testing of a Multi-Stringer Post-Buckled Panel with Incremental Damage Detection

A multi-stringer panel was designed and tested to produce a failure mode of skin-stiffener delamination due to compression loading of a post-buckled skin to support the validation of high-fidelity progressive damage failure analysis modeling. The test procedure included multiple methods of data acquisition ranging from multiple strain gages, front and back digital image correlation, passive thermography, acoustic emission, and ultrasonic inspection to capture key events and damage progression prior to catastrophic failure. Detailed data showing the initial stiffness, onset of skin buckling, buckled mode shape, damage initiation load, damage propagation morphology, and peak load was captured. Two panel configurations were tested. The first had a Teflon insert placed in the interface between the skin and the stiffener flanges adjacent to the center skin bay. The second was subjected to impact damage to the skin-stiffener flange. In each case, continuously-loaded-to-failure tests were conducted first with passive thermography being used exclusively to determine key damage events. Then, incrementally loaded tests were completed where ultrasonic inspections were conducted between each increment. The amount of load applied between each increment was determined based on the in-situ damage detection provided by the passive thermography system. The results of the testing showed a complex delamination growth pattern which migrated between ply interfaces through matrix splits in the upper skin ply of the panel. The result of the testing produced very detailed data which will prove to be useful for validation of delamination growth and migration predictions from progressive damage failure analysis methods.

Jason Action↗
NASA NTRS2021

Modular Composite Damage Detection System (MCDDS)

The 2020 CIF funded Modular Composite Damage Detection System (MCDDS) aims to advance the technology of damage detection in composites in the areas of thin, flexible damage detection panel construction, encapsulation techniques in composite matrixes, innovative integration and interfacing techniques with flexible embedded sensory panels, repair methods of composite materials, and improved packaging of the MCDDS. Custom thin, flexible polyimide printed circuit boards (PCBs) were designed and procured for fabrication of test specimens. A custom interface PCB was designed and fabricated to monitor the newly developed damage detection test specimens. Test specimens were fabricated using the novel flexible circuitry that were either fully or partially encapsulated. The fully encapsulated specimens were used to demonstrate embedded damage detection concepts and the partially encapsulated specimens were used to demonstrate surface-mounted (laminate) damage detection concepts. The new composite damage detection test specimens were tested and evaluated to determine if the novel damage detection sensory panels could withstand low-cycle threshold fatigue loading per a modified version of American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM) D 7264 for up to 50 cycles without void formation. The data for multiple sensory panels indicates that the newly fabricated sensory panels are robust and do indeed withstand three-point bend flexural loading for more than 50 cycles. Additionally, testing was performed to determine if damage could be detected in damage detection test specimens subjected to failure using a 3-point bend test per a modified version of ASTM D 7264. Again, multiple sensory panels (both fully and partially encapsulated) showed the ability to detect damage to specimens subjected to failure per a modified version of ASTM D 7264. Additionally, a novel concept for tracking and monitoring of cracking (and potentially delamination) in composites was designed and developed that utilizes painted-on conductors.

Christopher Forney↗