SEARCH · Search NASA
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
This is a presentation to be given at an INL workshop. "Crossroads of Nonproliferation and Safeguarding Technologies for Implementation in Molten Salt Reactors", December 6-7, 2023. The presentation discusses historical molten salt reactor technologies and basic salt chemistries. Nothing in the presentation is sensitive or proprietary.
This report describes the salt chemistry and sedimentation studies that were completed in FY23 as part of the Pyrochemical Fuel Cycles – ANL project. The primary objective of these activities was to employ electrochemical methods in order to quantify and gain insights into the reaction mechanisms associated with the interaction of O2 and moisture impurities with the molten chloride salts used for the pyrochemical processing of nuclear materials. If not monitored and controlled, the ingression of these atmospheric impurities can lead to changes in the salt redox conditions and initiate the formation of oxide particles, potentially resulting in operational and safeguards challenges. By elucidating the mechanisms underlying the formation of oxide particles, we can effectively monitor the conditions of the salt and design systems to mitigate the influence of atmospheric O2 and H2O. To achieve these goals, we designed a test system that allowed for precisely controlled gas ingressions into the molten salt vessel. This system included on-line monitoring provided by electrochemical probes that enable near real-time measurements of the salt conditions throughout the course of the experiment. Using this system, we systematically varied experimental conditions, including O2/Ar flow rates and O2 concentrations, to comprehensively understand their impact on solid particle formation. We also used a particle size and shape analyzer to characterize the particles that were generated. Tests in FY23 concentrated on the formation of CeO2 particles, but we also prepared a separate apparatus targeting UO2 particles for use in FY24. We additionally conducted extensive modeling activities in support of this work. This included multiphysics simulations of the gas ingressions along with the development of a machine learning workflow to enable accelerated molecular dynamics modeling of the molten salt chemistry of LiCl-KCl-UCl3. The combination of experimental and modeling tools has allowed us to begin to get a more complete understanding of the reactions that occur when atmospheric ingressions occur in pyroprocessing systems.
For the successful molten salt synthesis of La 0.8 Sr 0.2 MnO 3 , the salt cation is more influential than the anion. With a KNO 3 solvent, pure phase LSM nanoparticles are synthesized at 600 °C in 1 hour.
Molten salts are crucial materials with exceptional properties that make them suitable for applications such as heat transfer media, coolants, and liquid fuels in molten salt nuclear reactors and the concentrated solar power industry. Understanding their properties requires unraveling the intricate mysteries of their structure. To achieve this, advanced characterization tools are essential. Among various techniques, X‐ray absorption fine structure (XAFS) stands out as a versatile method capable of studying the structure of molten salts under in situ conditions. This review highlights recent advancements in the application of XAFS for investigating the local structure of molten salts, discusses its limitations and potential improvements, and explores complementary approaches such as simulations, machine learning, and correlative experimental methods.
Defining the relative influence of intramolecular and intermolecular forces is a fundamental problem in chemistry that is difficult to quantify. To address this challenge, we developed a method to evaluate the relative impact of direct chemical bonding in the inner-coordination sphere vs effects from cations in the outer-coordination sphere by comparative analysis of uranium redox reactivity in various molten salts. We observed that outer-coordination sphere cations (M 1+ ) and inner-coordination sphere anions (X 1– ) both affected uranium redox reactivity, with more polarizing M 1+ and larger X 1– favoring uranium in low oxidation states. Changing M 1+ (Li, Na, K) shifted the U IV + e 1– ⇌ U III (U IV/III ) and U III + 3e 1– → U 0 metal potentials by +330 and +240 mV, respectively. Changing X 1– (Cl, Br, I) caused larger shifts of +440 mV for the U IV/III redox potential and +1060 mV for the U 0 metal deposition potential. Using Coulomb’s Law, we correlated these potentials with electrostatic interactions between UIII and the molten salt. This model provided a facile way of predicting redox chemistry within molten salts.
DOE BES highlight slide for work performed and published under the DOE CEM initiative.
Understanding accident progression and the potential/conditions for fission product release from fuel is necessary to evaluate safety for any nuclear reactor system. Molten Salt Reactors (MSRs) under development need such analysis to support safety evaluations. Fission product chemistry specific to MSR concepts is a critical area that introduces distinct considerations relative to the current state-of-knowledge in reactor safety, primarily developed for water-moderated nuclear reactor systems. In Light Water Reactor (LWR) systems, it is necessary to capture the chemical interaction of fission products with the reactor evironment, containment and confinement systems. The overall effects at this point are relatively well understood for the purposes of performing safety evaluations. A key insight from LWR studies is that fission product chemical behavior can be reasonably captured by modeling approaches where the chemistry is "frozen". These modeling approaches assume that radionuclide reaction and speciation can be represented by chemical classes, each with characteristic transport behavior that is invariant under a broad range of thermochemical conditions. However, radionuclides can exhibit a range of behavior in the liquid salt-melt phase of the coolant used in MSRs. Radionuclides, salt, and the metal containment surfaces (i.e. pipes) can co-exist in dynamic equilibrium that could evolve with small system mass changes. A detailed investigation to the degree the equilibrium state can dynamically evolve with changes in the conditions of the molten salt mixture has not been previously conducted. It is currently not well understood where frozen chemistry assumptions are valid. Expanding the state-of-knowledge in this regard is relevant to better assessing the range of chemical effects that should be incorporated as part of MSR safety assessments. This investigation used the Oak Ridge Isotope GENeration (ORIGEN) module of the Standardized Computer-Analysis for Licensing Evaluation (SCALE) code to generate simulated radionuclide inventories for the MSR Experiment (MSRE) and then modeled reactor chemical speciation using the Molten Salt Thermodynamic Database – Thermochemical (MSTDB-TC) coupled with Thermochimica. The effect of composition variation during decay of fission product inventory in a molten salt over a period of 500 days prolonged post- at multiple temperatures was studied. Mass fractions for fluorine and berilium were varied in order to probe the effects of free fluorine control. Finally, speciation of fluoride reactors were showed by comparing MSRE readionuclide inventories with a FLiBe based molten salt breeder reactor (MSBR). The results showed that fission product mass change has little effect on phase mass changes and vapor pressures for fluoride species, but differ with varying carrier and fuel salt compositions. However, iodine species were found to have a vapor pressure not only dependent on temperature, but also the free fluorine potential, releasing iodine when the free fluorine potential is equal to the iodine inventory. This observation, however, arose under free fluorine potentials that are very unlikely to be realized in typical molten salt mixtures. Despite this observation, temperature was found to be the dominant parameter that drove phase change and fission product species vapor pressure. The results indicate that the current frozen chemistry approach is adequate for MSR analysis.
Understanding molten salt chemistry is essential in ongoing research of the molten salt nuclear reactor (MSR). In this context, detailed understanding of the mechanisms underlying selective oxidation of metal species, such as Cr, is required to guide the design of effective corrosion mitigation strategies in molten salts. An important starting point for such mechanistic understanding is knowledge of the solvation structure and its role in controlling metal speciation. In this work, we use ab initio molecular dynamics simulations to study the short-range (on the scale of the nearest-neighbor bond lengths) and medium-range (over length scales of several neighbor spacings) structure in three different fluoride melts with and without Cr addition; namely, 2KF-NaF, 2LiF-BeF 2 , and 3LiF-AlF3. We find that Cr 0 ,Cr 2+ ,Cr 3+ can each be coordinated by different numbers of F-, with the variance in coordination number decreasing as oxidation state increases, and that these coordination geometries are largely independent of solvent. The manner by which Cr changes the medium-range structure, however, is found to be solvent-dependent. While 2KF-NaF melts show short and medium range order that is highly dynamic, 2LiF-BeF 2 and 3LiF-AlF 3 are characterized by molecular associates that are relatively long-lived that organize into oligomer structures on larger length scales. Rather than being solvated by F- ions alone, we find that Cr can incorporate into and be solvated within this oligomer structure. Fluoroacidity, alone, may therefore prove too simple a metric for assessing the corrosivity of molten fluorides. As our work suggests, the ability of Cr to solvate must be understood in the context of the short- and medium-range structure of the solvent.
This project was initially funded in 2007 and the current technical report is for 2019-2022. The specific objectives of this project (2019-2022) were: (1) Synthesis of actinide peroxide compounds in molten salt eutectics, (2) Studies of new uranyl minerals with fascinating structures and compositions, (3) Drop-solution calorimetric studies of actinide compounds extending into the transuranium elements, with an emphasis on the uranyl-sulfate system, (4) Continuation of studies of uranyl vanadate clusters synthesized using ionic liquids, (5) The training of Ph.D. graduate students in actinide chemistry, and to introduce undergraduate students to actinide research through providing research assistantships and supervision. The report lists 67 archival journal papers describing the work, of which 23 were since 2019. Highlights of the work are summarized for the period 2019-2022.
MOSCATO (Molten Salt Chemistry and Transport) is a multiphysics code that provides high-fidelity, coupled simulations of fluid flow, heat transfer, mass transfer, chemistry, electrochemical phenomena, and alloy evolution for molten salt equipment. In FY24, significant developments were made to the code package, enhancing its capabilities in many aspects. The improvements and advancements can be summarized as follows: 1. Implementation of tritium transport capabilities and validation with experimental data: To enable modeling of tritium and other fission gases within MSRs, we implemented gas transport within MOSCATO via inclusion of couple mass transport equations within the salt and structural alloys. Comparisons to experimental data from literature showed good agreement with respect to tritium release rates. 2. Preliminary implementation of two-phase flow models in MOSCATO: To model tritium and other gases above their solubility limits, we implemented preliminary two-phase flow models within MOSCATO to account for bubble transport. The first model adopted was the Level-Set approach, which can handle the high void fraction regime, but with a requirement for high mesh resolution thus high computational expense. In this report, we present a verification of the Level-Set method using a simple benchmark case. We also performed a demonstration of the code as applied to an experimental case involving cover gas flow through salt in an experimental vessel. The second model adopted was the Eulerian-Eulerian dispersed flow model, which is computationally cheaper but limited to low void fraction regimes, such as bubbly flow. Validation and verification have not yet been performed for the Eulerian-Eulerian approach, but a preliminary implementation was completed. 3. Validation with static corrosion experiments: Static corrosion experimental data for stainless steel coupons within molten salts was used to further validate the corrosion model in MOSCATO. To do so, we leveraged the existing models in MOSCATO and simulated the sample mass loss and mass gain phenomena. Several ion species, including Cr 2+ , Fe 2+ and H + , were simulated in salt using the PNP solver, while Cr 0 and Fe 0 were simulated with a diffusion solver in stainless steel. The mass loss of the samples was compared with experimental data, and good agreement was achieved. These combined activities served to further expand the capabilities of MOSCATO and make it more generally applicable to the full range of phenomena that can control chemistry and corrosion in molten salt reactors.
Here, the electron paramagnetic resonance and diffuse reflectance-optical absorption spectra of room-temperature γ-irradiated KCl–MgCl 2 binary solid salt mixtures (98:2 mol % and 2:98 mol %) and the eutectic (68:32 mol %) are reported. Additionally, powder X-ray diffraction of the pristine salts and thermal annealing studies of the irradiated salts were performed to evaluate the radiolysis product stability, annihilation, and association in metallic particles. The main long-lived transient species detected in 98:2 mol % KCl–MgCl 2 salts were perturbed F-centers, that is, trapped electrons (e t – ) in the vicinity of Mg ions (λ max at 561 nm), and the radiolytic reduction of Mg 2+ to Mg + and Mg 0 . Thermal annealing promoted the diffusion of defects to yield polycations (Mg n + ). On the other hand, irradiation of 2:98 mol % KCl/MgCl 2 salts showed the formation of cationic and neutral Mg dimers (Mg 2 + and Mg 2 ) and trimers as well as centers with a rhombic powder pattern apparently consisting of an electron shared between three Mg 2+ nuclei associated with an anion vacancy (ν a + –Mg 3 5+ ). Trapped electrons (e t – ) (F-centers) were not observed in the irradiated eutectic mixture; instead, Mg 2 , Mg 0 , and Cl 3 – were observed. It was observed that the higher temperature for thermal ionization of radiation-reduced Mg species decreased the extent of electron recombination reactions and the disproportionation of Cl 3 – compared to the pure KCl but enhanced the aggregation of Mg into larger metallic microstructures (metallic particles).
MOSCATO (Molten Salt Chemistry and Transport) is a multiphysics code that provides high-fidelity, coupled simulations of fluid flow, heat transfer, mass transfer, chemistry, electrochemical phenomena, and alloy corrosion for molten salt systems. In FY25, significant developments were made to the code package, enhancing its capabilities for modeling all relevant phenomena within operating moltens salt reactors (MSRs). The developments and activities in FY25 included: 1. Implementation of Level-Set methods to enable modeling of single-bubble behavior in molten salts. In FY25, the Level-Set two-phase flow modeling implementation was improved to simulate single bubble behavior with molten salt media. The large density and viscosity ratios between typical gases and molten salt liquids present challenges for these types of numerical solvers. With enhancements to the pressure projection method, MOSCATO’s Level-Set solver was able to be successfully validated to experiments related to helium bubble rise in stagnant molten salt. The simulated bubble rising velocity showed reasonable good agreement with experimental measurements. The bubble shape and dynamics were also visually compared with experimental snapshots, demonstrating a good qualitative match. 2. Generation of mass transfer correlations for multiphase flow systems. To enable calculations of the tritium transport across the interface between gas bubbles and salt, we modeled high- Schmidt-number mass transfer around a sphere across a broad range of Reynolds numbers. The mesh near the sphere surface was highly refined to resolve steep concentration gradients caused by the low diffusion coefficient. Literature-based mass transfer correlations were compared with the numerical results, and modifications were proposed to improve agreement, particularly at higher Schmidt numbers. These mass transfer correlations were subsequently provided to other national laboratories to help enable high quality mass transfer simulations using lower-order solvers under development within the NEAMS program. 3. Preliminary implementation of a bubbly flow solver. To model bubbly flow in molten salt, we implemented a bubbly flow solver for void fractions less than 5%. To do so, an algebraic relative velocity model that assumes small bubbles with rapid momentum equilibration was added to MOSCATO to compute bubble velocities. Preliminary comparisons with experimental data showed reasonable agreement, and further improvements are underway. 4. Generation of mass transfer correlations for MSRE subchannel The Molten-Salt Reactor Experiment (MSRE) was a landmark historical project that demonstrated the feasibility of molten-salt reactor technology. The MSRE campaign also generated a significant body of experimental data and reports that continue to support molten-salt–related research. In this report, the MSRE core subchannel was used as the reference geometry for a mass transfer study performed with MOSCATO. The geometry and computational mesh were adapted from a previous study, providing adequate resolution for the relatively low Reynolds number in this case. Additional mesh refinement was applied to reach higher Schmidt numbers, enabling the derivation of a reliable mass-transfer correlation for the present scenario. 5. Simulations of oxygen ingressions into molten salt. In the previous fiscal year, we initiated a study to simulate oxygen ingression in stagnant salt. As oxygen enters the salt through its surface, it reacts with Ce 3+ to form solid CeO 2 and other reaction products. To more fully capture the complex diffusion-convection-reaction mechanisms, capabilities for modeling natural convection in the salt vessel were added. These were needed as the flow of the ingressed gas induced flow in the salt caused by surface shear and non-isothermal effects. With these updated physics in place, we were able to successfully reproduce the experimental results for the rate of change of CeCl 3 concentrations versus time. 6. Flow corrosion model validation. In FY24, MOSCATO’s corrosion model was validated against static corrosion experiments. In FY25, this work was extended to a flow corrosion experiment, where FLiNaK salt was driven by natural convection, with initial salt impurities to initiate corrosion. Despite uncertainties in parameters such as elemental diffusion coefficients in the alloy and unknown H + concentrations, the simulations achieved good agreement with experimental results, especially in predicting sample mass losses.
During FY21, we conducted ongoing development work for the MOSCATO (Molten Salt Chemistry and Transport) solver. The code development work primarily consisted of transitioning capabilities from the original version of the solver, which was written in OpenFOAM, into Nek5000. In doing so, a fast, highly parallelizable solver was created that is capable of complex chemistry and corrosion simulations for engineering-scale molten salt systems. The Nek5000 version of MOSCATO is now fully featured and capable of higher-fidelity simulations than were previously possible. Demonstration cases including a thermal convection loop have been simulated to test these new capabilities. Although capable of large-scale simulations, MOSCATO is not well-suited to parametric studies of complete reactor geometries. These types of simulations are instead better handled by reduced-order modeling codes such as ORNL’s Mole code. Reduced-order simulation tools like Mole, however, are dependent on high fidelity correlations to account for complex, coupled three-dimensional phenomena that they do not directly simulate. Tools such as MOSCATO must therefore be used to create these correlations, as suitable empirical relationships are not available for most molten salt systems. Toward that end, we used the Nek-derived version of MOSCATO to create new mass transfer correlations for three relevant cases including tubular, tube bank, and subchannel geometries. These new correlations are more accurate than any existing ones and can be readily integrated into any reduced-order modeling tools that are targeting full-scale MSR simulations.
During FY21, we conducted ongoing development work for the MOSCATO (Molten Salt Chemistry and Transport) solver. The code development work primarily consisted of transitioning capabilities from the original version of the solver, which was written in OpenFOAM, into Nek5000. In doing so, a fast, highly parallelizable solver was created that is capable of complex chemistry and corrosion simulations for engineering-scale molten salt systems. The Nek5000 version of MOSCATO is now fully featured and capable of higher-fidelity simulations than were previously possible. Demonstration cases including a thermal convection loop have been simulated to test these new capabilities. We built upon the work for FY22 and improved the code from several different perspectives. First, we improved the user interface by adding a new component to the official Nek5000 input file (.par). This new part contains documents parameters like, salt properties (density, viscosity, Cp, thermal conductivity), diffusion coefficients, standard potential, etc. Second, we built a conversion script to extract salt properties from the MSTDB-TP salt database and write to MOSCATO input file. Third, we migrated the code to NekRS, which is the GPU branch of Nek5000 and suitable for next generation supercomputers. Verification and Validation (V&V) work was also continued in FY22. Two tasks were performed. The first V&V task involved the validation of the Poisson-Nernst-Planck equation solver and Butler-Volmer electrode kinetics, by comparing with numerical and experimental data about thermoelectric cells. The second task involved the comparisons to corrosion results from a thermal convection loop run during the MSRE era. Satisfactory agreement was obtained from both tasks.
The principal objective of this project was to synthesize core-shell heterostructures for solid oxide fuel cell cathodes using a molten salt solvent. In doing so, the main goals were split into a) to elucidate and understand the influence of molten salt chemistries to expeditiously synthesize perovskite type oxides for solid oxide fuel cells, b) provide a chemical framework for future molten salt syntheses of energy relevant ceramic materials, c) demonstrate and investigate the required parameters for the optimal core-shell synthesis and yield of La 0.6 Sr 0.4 Co 0.2 Fe 0.8 O 3 (LSCF) – La 0.8 Sr 0.2 MnO 3 (shell), and d) demonstrate improved cathode performance of core-shell LSCF-LSM compared to an LSCF cathode on symmetric cells. The results clearly show that a) the influence of the molten salt cation outweighs the anion in regards to product stoichiometry, b) molten salts should be tailored to balance cationic and anionic acidity for high product yield, c) high yield of core-shell nanoparticles can be achieved by optimal mass ratio between core to shell, dwell time in the salt, size ratio between core to shell, and mass ratio between overall powder to salt, and d) the core-shell LSCF-LSM cathodes have lower polarization resistances than LSCF at higher temperatures. More work is required to optimize core-shell cathode performance at lower temperatures. However, this work thus provided justification for using the molten salt synthesis for SOFC cathodes and provided insights into future material modifications for improved performance.
Deploying commercial molten salt reactors (MSRs) requires closing technological gaps associated with supplying fuel salt, maintaining fuel salt, and dispositioning used fuel salt at the end of a reactor campaign and operation. A workshop was held to identify the technological gaps in synthesizing, purifying, and supplying fuel salts and recovering and recycling resource materials from used fuel.
Idaho National Laboratory (INL) recently conducted a workshop endorsed by the National Nuclear Security Administration (NNSA) under the auspices of the Defense Nuclear Nonproliferation R&D (DNN R&D) Office's Safeguards Portfolio. The workshop's primary objective was to foster an engaging dialogue among researchers, with a specialized emphasis on the safeguards pertaining to molten salt reactors. At INL, the installation of the state-of-the-art Molten Salt Thermophysical Examination Capability (MSTEC) is underway. This shielded argon glovebox facility, designed for both irradiated and non-irradiated actinide materials, represents the cutting edge of research infrastructure. MSTEC is poised to serve as a pivotal research platform in the realm of molten salt technology, with significant implications for safeguards applications. Participants of the workshop had the opportunity to tour the facilities, including the site where MSTEC is being installed, as well as to observe the INL's molten salt and pyroprocessing research hot cells. The event featured insightful presentations delving into molten salt chemistry and the MSTEC project. Each participating laboratory contributed to the discourse with presentations on their respective research efforts addressing safeguards in relation to molten salt reactors. The workshop culminated with a generative brainstorming session, where participants shared their thoughts on strategic integration with partner agencies, aiming to synergize efforts in advancing the field of nuclear safeguards.
For both coolant and fueled variants of molten salt reactors (MSRs), the corrosion of structural materials is a significant challenge. The corrosion stems from chemical and electrochemical reactions initiated by fissile material, fission products, and impurities in the salt. Lower-fidelity models rely on empirical correlations for mass transfer, simplified lumped temperature profiles, and similar assumptions. They do not capture detailed spatial variations in complex geometries, creating the need for high-fidelity modeling to bridge this gap.As we approach the demonstration and possible deployment of MSRs in this decade, the development of a high-fidelity, high-performance simulator becomes imperative. To simulate the complex electrochemical environment and corrosion within molten salt systems, we have developed the Molten Salt Chemistry And TranspOrt (MOSCATO) code. This endeavor is comprised of three essential components. First, mass transfer equations are coupled with the Navier-Stokes equations in order to account for the transport of species in the salt. Second, the diffusion of alloy constituents, such as Cr, Fe, Ni, etc. is simulated within the structural metals. Third, the alloy and salt domains are coupled to account for the heterogeneous chemical and electrochemical reactions that occur at the salt-alloy interface.MOSCATO manages all three components within the framework of the highly scalable, open-source spectral element method computational fluid dynamics code Nek5000/NekRS. This integration enables MOSCATO to harness the immense computational power of modern high-performance computing resources, ensuring both high fidelity and computational speed.In addition to code development, we have initiated a comprehensive verification and validation campaign, utilizing data from diverse sources. First, MOSCATO's electrochemical solver was verified with reference numerical data. Then validation occurred against experiments: one of a thermal galvanic cell and the other for corrosion in flowing molten salt of FLiNaK (LiF-NaF-KF). This campaign verified and validated MOSCATO as a reliable tool for simulating electrochemical environments and corrosion in molten salt systems.