Mechanistic Understanding of the Interactions and Pseudocapacitance of Multi-Electron Redox Organic Molecules Sandwiched between MXene Layers
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
SEARCH · Search NASA
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
For the last several decades, numerous strategies have been proposed to be able to interconvert electricity and commodity fuels for transportation and other applications. Even as solar and wind energy become more widely available, these renewable energy sources are not always available where the population is most dense or during peak times of energy demand. One plausible solution to the issue of electricity storage and transport is to use electricity to drive the formation of high-energy compounds and chemical fuels. As a result, the electrochemical conversion of CO 2 into chemical fuels has received major attention as a multi-pronged approach for electricity coversion, storage, and transport. Similar strategies are also attractive for conversion of N 2 and NO x into value added compounds such as ammonia. Metalloporphyrin and metallocorrole complexes are comprised of aromatic tetrapyrrole scaffolds and have been extensively studied as homogeneous catalysts for critical catalytic processes like the electrochemical CO 2 reduction reaction (eCO 2 RR) to generate CO as feedstock for the Fischer–Tropsch process to generate a variety of hydrocarbons as chemical fuels. Despite their significance and impact, efficiently driving such catalytic reduction processes is challenging for multiple reasons. Such processes require multiple-electron transfer events, as opposed to single-electron redox chemistry that forms high-energy singly-reduced intermediates. In addition, these electron transfer events must be coupled to proton-transfer steps and avoid application of high overpotentials where proton (H + ) reduction to generate H 2 (as well as other side-reactions) can lower the selectivity and energy efficiency of the eCO 2 RR process. Certain Fe(III) aromatic tetrapyrroles (e.g., porphyrins and corroles) have been reported to overcome these challenges, but are often difficult to synthesize and modify, and have a tendency to support single-electron redox chemistry at the metal as opposed to multielectron redox involving the ligand and metal in concert. Other families of tetrapyrroles in which all four meso-carbons are reduced (i.e., sp 3 -hybridized) are also known in the literature. These non-aromatic tetrapyrroles are known as porphyrinogens and support multi-electron redox chemistry which has been elaborated by several groups, prompting researchers to consider whether these scaffolds may improve the kinetics and efficiencies of multi-electron steps attendant to activation of thermodynamically stable small-molecule substrates such as CO 2 , N 2 , NO 3 − , and NO 2 − . Although porphyrinogens support multi-electron redox properties, the four sp 3 -hybridized meso-carbons inherent to the tetrapyrrole core completely disrupt π-conjugation between pyrrolic units, which compromises the photochemical properties of porphyrinogens in comparison to that of traditional porphyrinoids. Moreover, the highly reducing nature of porphyrinogens predisposes these platforms to extreme air and water sensitivity. Accordingly, such metalated porphyrinogens are often pyrophoric and/or incompatible with many common organic solvents (CH 2 Cl 2 , CHCl 3 , CH 3 CN, EtOAc, etc.). Hence, reports of efficient small-molecule activation or catalysis supported by porphyrinogens have been limited. To overcome the instability of porphyrinogens while retaining the scaffold’s attractive multi-electron redox properties, we have directed attention to establishing less-well studied groups of non-aromatic tetrapyrroles (i.e., phlorins, biladienes, and isocorroles). These non-traditional tetrapyrroles each contain just a single sp 3 -hybridized meso-carbon, which ablates the platforms aromaticity but still provides an extended π-framework. In addition to developing innovative platforms that may be used to sustainably generate value-added chemicals, fuels, and ammonia via either photo- or electrocatalytic approaches our work also has significantly broadened our understanding of how to prepare and modulate the properties of non-aromatic tetrapyrroles for other applications. Our efforts entailed a synergistic partnership and active collaborations with Drs. David C. Grills and Mehmed Z. Ertem (both of Brookhaven National Lab) to better characterize isocorroles (and related non-aromatic tetrapyrroles) using a variety of advanced spectroscopic and theoretical methods. Our combined efforts have shown that the combination of properties that isocorroles (and related tetrapyrroles) provide results in good chemical stability paired with unique redox and photochemical characteristics that are not typically supported by simple and/or unadorned aromatic tetrapyrroles. Beside redox chemistry, the photochemistry of isocorroles and other non-aromatic tetrapyrroles containing one sp 3 -hybridized meso-carbon is also appealing due to their absorption in the long-visible to near-IR regions, which are essential for photocatalysis and related applications that benefit from direct excitation at these wavelengths. The results reported vastly improve our understanding of non-aromatic tetrapyrrole synthesis, properties and utility for activation of small molecule substrates such as O 2 and CO 2 in the presence of weak cationic organic acids.
This project targets the conversion of ubiquitous small molecules (e.g. NO, CO, H 2 O) into viable precursors to synthetic fuels. Current state of the art catalyst design has not directly targeted transition metal complexes capable of mediating the multi-electron redox processes necessary to reduce the overpotential (energy loss) required achieve efficient activation of small molecule substrates. In this vein, a new strategy has been developed for the assembly of polynuclear architectures; allowing for the construction of tunable polymetallic centers that assemble easily within a pre-organized template (conferring stability, selectivity and tunability) that can effect multi-electron redox processes for reactions. Catalyst development has commenced with the following target design elements: (1) catalysts featuring multiple transition metal ions in the same reaction space to greatly expand accessible molecular redox capabilities; (2) catalysts are assembled in a polynucleating ligand framework that permits control over the cluster morphology as well as the local steric and electronic environment of the transition metal ions within the cluster. The high-tunability of the catalyst composition (metal content) and geometric flexibility has permitted a rigorous assessment of electronic-structure-to-function relationship to be developed, further guiding synthetic efforts to realize more potent catalysts. The numerous permutations possible showcase the high degree of generality to this approach with many synthetic handles to tune redox and reaction chemistry. Trinuclear complexes have been synthesized featuring homo- and hetero-trinuclear cores featuring a variety of first row transition metal ions (Cr→Ni). The molecular clusters have been shown to successfully mediate multi-electron redox processes in a cooperative fashion without requiring strong chemical reductants or oxidants. The reactive molecular complexes are being utilized to activate and breakdown the robust bonds within typical waste stream small molecules (e.g., greenhouse gases) and convert them into value-added commodity chemicals. Ultimately, the catalysts developed by this approach will be required to convert energy acquired via renewable resources (e.g., solar or wind) into synthetic fuels as an energy storage mechanism.
Aqueous solutions of polyoxometalates (POMs) have been shown to have potential as high-capacity energy storage materials due to their potential for multi-electron redox processes, yet the mechanism of reduction and practical limits are currently unknown. Herein, we explore the mechanism of multi-electron redox processes that allow the highly reduced POM clusters of the form {MO 3 } y to absorb y electrons in aqueous solution, focusing mechanistically on the Wells-Dawson structure X 6 [P 2 W 18 O 62 ], which comprises 18 metal centers and can uptake up to 18 electrons reversibly (y = 18) per cluster in aqueous solution when the countercations are lithium. This unconventional redox activity is rationalized by density functional theory, molecular dynamics simulations, UV-vis, electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy, and small-angle X-ray scattering spectra. These data point to a new phenomenon showing that cluster protonation and aggregation allow the formation of highly electron-rich meta-stable systems in aqueous solution, which produce H 2 when the solution is diluted. Finally, we show that this understanding is transferrable to other salts of [P 5 W 30 O 110 ] 15- and [P 8 W 48 O 184 ] 40- anions, which can be charged to 23 and 27 electrons per cluster, respectively.
final report
Redox-active polymers (RAPs) are promising organic electrode materials for affordable and sustainable batteries due to their flexible chemical structures and negligible solubility in the electrolyte. Developing high-dimensional RAPs with porous structures and crosslinkers can further improve their stability and redox capability by reducing the solubility and enhancing reaction kinetics. Further, this work reports two three-dimensional (3D) RAPs as stable organic cathodes in Na-ion batteries (NIBs) and K-ion batteries (KIBs). Carbonyl functional groups are incorporated into the repeating units of the RAPs by the polycondensation of Tetrakis(4-aminophenyl)methane and two different dianhydrides. The RAPs with interconnected 3D extended conjugation structures undergo multi-electron redox reactions and exhibit high performance in both NIBs and KIBs in terms of long cycle life (up to 8000 cycles) and fast charging capability (up to 2 A g -1 ). The results demonstrate that developing 3D RAPs is an effective strategy to achieve high-performance, affordable, and sustainable NIBs and KIBs.
Redox-active porous polymers are becoming promising organic electrode materials for alkali-ion batteries because of their tunable pore size, flexible chemical structure, and high thermal stability. This work presents various porous bipolar polymers as cathodes in Na-ion batteries (NIBs) and K-ion batteries (KIBs). Two structural units containing carbonyl and amine active centers, respectively, were introduced into the repeating units of the polymers by the polycondensation of N,N,N',N'-tetrakis(4-aminophenyl)-1,4-phenylenediamine (TAP) and various dianhydrides. Here, the resulting bipolar polymers undergo multi-electron redox reactions involving both cations and anions during battery charge and discharge. The impacts of extended conjugation structures and porosity on the electrochemical performances were investigated by tuning the conjugation structures in the dianhydride monomers. The bipolar polymers with extended conjugation structures and small pore size exhibit superior electrochemical performance in NIBs and KIBs in terms of high redox potentials, long cycle life, and fast-charging capability, demonstrating great promise as organic cathode materials for alkali-ion batteries.
The Structural Molecular Biology (SMB) macromolecular crystallography (MC) group at the Stanford Synchrotron Radiation Lightsource (SSRL) have developed state-of-the-art capabilities tailored for metalloenzyme structural analysis. Metalloproteins sit at the center of biology’s most audacious chemistry. From multi-electron redox catalysis to radical rearrangements and light-driven transformations, metal sites give proteins access to reaction landscapes that would otherwise be inaccessible under ambient conditions. Yet their study presents a fundamental paradox for MC studies: the very X-rays we use to reveal atomic structure can alter the electronic states we seek to understand. As the field moves beyond static snapshots toward mechanistic insight, success increasingly depends on our ability to maintain metal centers in their native state throughout the experiment. The SSRL SMB-MC beamlines integrate a suite of capabilities specifically designed to address these challenges. By combining in situ spectroscopic verification, intelligent dose management, controlled reaction initiation, optimized anomalous diffraction, and real-time crystallographic diffraction analysis, these tools enable researchers to interrogate metalloproteins with unprecedented rigor. This article explores how these complementary approaches are reshaping our ability to capture metalloprotein chemistry, and what this means for mechanistic studies at synchrotron beamlines.
More than a third of all known proteins to date are either oxidoreductases or metalloproteins. The diversity of metal cofactors and redox centers in these proteins make them attractive candidates for engineering protein-based biocatalysts, biosensors, and biofuel cells, among other necessary tools for the bioeconomy. Many of these enzymes function as large multi-subunit complexes arranged as symmetric or asymmetric assemblies, and the purpose of this architecture is unclear. The goal of the project was to address this fundamental question by investigating the mechanism of action of two oxidoreductases: Nitrogenase and DPOR (Dark-Operative Protochlorophyllide Oxidoreductase, a nitrogenase-like oxidoreductase). Nitrogenase and DPOR play key roles in nitrogen fixation and photosynthesis, processes essential to sustaining life. Both proteins are arranged as two symmetrical halves with each half capable of substrate reduction. For more than half a century, substrate reduction by nitrogenase has been presumed to occur independently within the two identical halves. Funded by this DOE grant we have now shown that both nitrogenase and DPOR function asymmetrically. Electron transfer in one half suppresses activity in the other. Thus, we have demonstrated that the two halves do not function in an independent manner; rather, catalytic events in one-half allosterically suppress activity and electron transfer (ET) in the other. This alternating-site mechanism has significant implications on our current understanding of substrate reduction by these enzymes and offers a new mechanistic paradigm for the reactions they catalyze. Our work now provides a mechanistic map of the how the two symmetric catalytic halves work together to establish and maintain the sequential-site mechanism through multiple ET cycles to achieve substrate reduction. There is substantive need for bio-inspired tools that enable reduction of nitrogen and other substrates, as well as photosynthesis, for energy and food production. Understanding the workings of enzymes like nitrogenase and DPOR that mediate multi-electron redox chemistry is vital for designing such synthetic tools. The timing of our research coincides with the biotechnological breakthrough of light-driven artificial N2 reduction by nitrogenase, achieved using the native enzyme with both halves arranged in a mirror-like architecture as catalyst. Together with such discoveries, our research now reveal unknown facets of the reaction mechanism and hold promise for designing more effective catalysts.
Methyl-coenzyme M reductase (MCR) is the key enzyme in the biological formation and anaerobic oxidation of methane (AOM). Methane is a potent greenhouse gas and the major component of natural gas. Given the abundance of natural gas reserves in remote areas, there is great current interest in a scalable bio-based process for the conversion of methane to liquid fuel or other high-value commodity chemicals. MCR holds much promise for use in such a methane bioconversion strategy. However, MCR cannot currently be produced in an active form in a heterologous host, due in large part to the lack of genetic and biochemical information about the production of holo MCR. In an effort to overcome this deficiency, our laboratory elucidated the biosynthetic pathway of the unique nickel-containing coenzyme of MCR, F430. The key step in coenzyme F430 biosynthesis (Cfb) was found to involve an unprecedented reductive cyclization reaction that converts Ni-sirohydrochlorin a , c -diamide to 15,17 3 -seco-F430-17 3 -acid. This remarkable transformation, which involves a 6-electron reduction of the isobacteriochlorin ring system, cyclization of the c -acetamide side chain to form a γ-lactam ring, and the formation of 7 stereocenters, is catalyzed by a primitive homolog of nitrogenase (CfbCD). Nitrogenase is a two-component metalloenzyme that catalyzes the ATP-dependent reduction of dinitrogen to ammonia (nitrogen fixation). Homologs of nitrogenase are also involved in the biosynthesis of the photosynthetic pigments chlorophyll and bacteriochlorophyll. Phylogenetic analysis of the CfbCD complex suggests that it is representative of a more ancient lineage of the nitrogenase superfamily, and a thorough investigation of its structure and function is likely to shed light on the mechanisms and evolution of these important metalloenzymes that catalyze multi-electron redox reactions. Moreover, a detailed understanding of the mechanism of the CfbCD complex may aid in the development of specific inhibitors to help reduce natural greenhouse gas emissions and can be exploited for the heterologous production of MCR for methane bioconversion. Towards these goals, the following Specific Aims will be pursued to determine the: 1) Identity of the CfbCD reaction product. The exact reaction catalyzed by CfbCD, including the number of electrons transferred and whether it involves enzymatic cyclization, is unclear. Several approaches, including reaction stoichiometry measurements, spectroelectrochemistry, and magnetic resonance spectroscopy will be applied to elucidate the structure of the reaction product and establish whether CfbCD is a reductase or reductive cyclase. 2) Structure, conformational dynamics, and oligomerization state changes of CfbCD. Significant insight into the mechanism and allosteric regulation of CfbCD can be obtained by assessing changes in the structure and dynamics of the complex during the catalytic cycle. To accomplish this, a combination of size-exclusion chromatography, hydrogen-deuterium exchange mass spectrometry, molecular dynamics simulations, and high-resolution structural methods will be employed. 3) Source, order, and stereochemistry of proton additions during CfbCD catalysis. Details regarding the order and stereochemistry of proton additions during the CfbCD reaction will be uncovered using a combined spectroscopic and computational approach. Complementary mechanistic studies employing site-directed mutagenesis and substrate analogs will establish the identity of active site acid residues and the possible involvement of substrate-assisted catalysis during the CfbCD reaction.
Non-aqueous redox flow batteries based on total organic electrolytes, consisting of earth-abundant elements, i.e., C, H, N, O, are regarded as a promising technology for sustainable and large-scale energy storage. In particular, bipolar redox-active organic materials (BROMs) are distinctly fascinating as electroactive species because they have multiple oxidation states and can undergo multiple redox processes. By virtue of this unique characteristic, BROMs can be utilized as both anolyte and catholyte in symmetric flow batteries, consequently, helping alleviate cross-contamination issues. Here, in this paper, we report an all-organic symmetric redox flow battery based on diimide molecule as a bipolar electroactive material. The potential interval between the cathodic peak and the inner and outer anodic peaks led to a promising cell voltage of 2.22 V. The symmetric battery can be operated at a current density of 20 mA cm -2 , with a coulombic efficiency of 90% for over 100 cycles. This work proposes an alternative approach to designing multi-electron organic redox active materials to facilitate the advancement of high-density symmetric flow batteries.
Sn is a promising metal anode for aqueous batteries, with up to four-electron redox available per atom (903 mAh g −1 Sn ). However, practically harnessing the four-electron Sn(OH) 6 2− /Sn reversibility remains challenging due to limited mechanistic understanding. Here, in this study, we reveal a kinetically asymmetric redox pathway involving a successive four-electron plating and a stepwise 2 + 2 electron stripping through a Sn(OH) 3 − intermediate. The crossover of Sn(OH) 3 − induces a reversible self-discharge that reduces Coulombic efficiency but does not impact cyclability, demonstrated by four-electron Sn-Ni full cells that sustain >800 h of stable cycling. By tuning the ion selectivity of the separator to suppress Sn(OH) 3 − crossover while allowing OH − transport, we further demonstrate high Sn utilization (67%) and high energy density (143.1 Wh L −1 cell). The results provide key understandings of the tradeoffs in engineering reversible multi-electron metal anodes and define a new benchmark for practical energy density that exceeds any Sn-based aqueous batteries to date.
The theoretical capacity of a given electrode material is ultimately determined by the number of electrons transferred in each redox center. The design of multi-electron transfer processes could break through the limitation of one–electron transfer and multiply the total capacity, but is difficult to achieve because multiple electron transfer processes are generally thermodynamically and kinetically more complex. In this work, we report the discovery of two-electron transfer in monolayer Ni(OH) 2 nanosheets, which contrasts with the traditional one-electron transfer found in multilayer materials. The first-principles calculations predict that the first oxidation process from Ni 2+ →Ni 3+ occurs easily, whereas the second electron transfer from Ni 3+ →Ni 4+ is strongly hindered in multilayer materials by both the interlayer hydrogen bonds and the domain H structure induced by the Jahn-Teller distortion of the Ni 3+ (t 2g 6 e g 1 ) centered octahedra. In contrast, the second electron transfer can easily occur in monolayers because all H’s are fully exposed. Experimentally, the as-prepared monolayer is found to deliver an exceptional redox capacity of ~ 576 mAh/g, nearly two times the theoretical capacity of one-electron processes. In-situ experiments demonstrate that monolayer Ni(OH) 2 can transfer two electrons and mostly transform to Ni 4+ in the charging process, while bulk Ni(OH) 2 can be partially transformed . Our work reveals a new redox reaction mechanism in atomically thin Ni(OH) 2 nanosheets, and suggests a promising path towards tuning the electron transfer numbers to multiply the capacity of the relevant energy storage materials.
Redox flow battery is a highly promising stationary energy storage method but the limited energy density and high chemical cost are among the main barriers for commercialization. Multi-electron organic redoxmers represent a family of structurally tailorable candidates that can achieve multiplied energy density with decreased materials consumption, potentially resulting in a viable solution to address these challenges. In this work, the recent development of organic molecules with reversible multi-redox activities in both aqueous and nonaqueous electrolytes is reviewed. The major focus is on the fundamental correlation between the chemical structures and the functional properties of reported multi-electron organic molecules. Valuable insights are offered on rational structural design strategies for improving the relevant physico- and electro-chemical properties. Finally, the current challenges are discussed to suggest future research needs along the avenue of using the multi-electron approach to achieve energy-dense, stable, cost-effective redox flow batteries.
The absolute band-edge potentials of semiconductors, i.e., the conduction-band minimum, valence-band maximum, and their relative positions to solution redox potentials, are often invoked as design principles for photoelectrochemical (PEC) devices, especially for particulate photocatalysts. Here we show that reliance on these criteria is not necessary and limits the exploration of materials that will advance the fields of photoelectrochemistry, photochemistry, and photocatalysis. We discuss how i) band-edge energies are not singular parameters and instead shift with pH, electrolyte type, and surface chemistry; ii) the free energy of electrons and holes in comparison to that of solution redox couples dictates overall reaction spontaneity and thus reactivity; and iii) favorable charge-transfer kinetics can occur even when the relevant electrolyte redox potential(s) appear ‘outside’ the bandgap, enabled by the inversion or accumulation of electronic charge at the semiconductor surface. As a result, this discussion informs design principles for photocatalyst systems engineering for both one-electron redox reactions as well as for more complex multi-electron transfer reactions (e.g, H 2 evolution, H 2 O oxidation, CO 2 reduction).
Many important redox-active metalloenzymes consist of 3d transition metals in their active sites. They catalyze multi-electron reactions in aqueous solution, under ambient temperature and pressure. To understand the functionality of the catalytic sites of these enzymes, X-ray spectroscopy methods provide important information of the electronic structure of the metal of interest and its local structural information, as well as their changes during the catalysis. Studying model compounds, that mimic enzyme catalytic site structures or their functional mimics, is as critical as studying enzymes themselves, in order to interpret X-ray spectroscopic data. In this chapter, various X-ray spectroscopic methods that are useful for structural and electronic structural studies of enzymes and model compounds are described.
Fundamental insight into multi-electron, multi-proton redox reactions with organometallic catalysts is greatly facilitated by knowledge of the formal oxidation state of the metal center in each of the elementary reaction steps that comprise the catalytic cycle. X-ray absorption near edge structure (XANES) is utilized herein to quantify the oxidation states and coordination environment of the organometallic resting state and intermediates in a newly proposed catalytic reduction of carbon monoxide to methanol.
Redox transformations at metal oxide (MO x )/solution interfaces are broadly important, and oxygen atom transfer (OAT) is one of the simplest and most fundamental examples of such reactivity. OAT is a two-electron transfer process, well-known in gas/solid reactions and catalysis. However, OAT is rarely directly observed at oxide/water interfaces, whose redox reactions are typically proposed to occur in one-electron steps. Reported here are stoichiometric OAT reactions of organic molecules with aqueous colloidal titanium dioxide and iridium oxide nanoparticles (TiO 2 and IrO x NPs). Me 2 SO (DMSO) oxidizes reduced TiO 2 NPs with the formation of Me 2 S, and IrO x NPs transfer O atoms to a water-soluble phosphine and a thioether. The reaction stoichiometries were established and the chemical mechanisms were probed using typical solution spectroscopic techniques, exploiting the high surface areas and transparency of the colloids. Furthermore, these OAT reactions, including a catalytic example, utilize the ability of the individual NPs to accumulate many electrons and/or holes. Observing OAT reactions of two different materials, in opposite directions, is a step toward harnessing oxide nanoparticles for valuable multi-electron and multi-hole transformations.