Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “saturation temperature”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 19 records
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
DOE OSTI2025

Development of a Flow Stabilization Algorithm Enabling Measurement of Low Oxygen Concentrations in Liquid Sodium

To enhance the automated control of the plugging meter (PM) and thereby enhance detection fidelity in ultralow oxygen environments [≤1 parts per million by weight (wppm)], a novel proportional derivative controller has been implemented with conventional PM hardware. This ramp sign stabilized flow (RSSF) controller manipulates the sign (heating or cooling direction) at a fixed rate, enabling precise temperature adjustment around the saturation temperature of the bulk sodium. This adjustment helps maintain flow stability in a partially formed sodium oxide plug, thus greatly reducing the temperature amplitude in the plugging cycle and promoting simple and accurate oxygen determinations in addition to an increased sampling rate. Rather than relying on the subjective nature of indexing the time when the flow rate changes due to the plugging or unplugging onset to the PM temperature, a running average of the correlated oxygen concentration with time over multiple plugging events can provide oxygen readings ranging from an absolute uncertainty of 500 wppb in real time to less than 50 wppb for a 24-h sampling window. Finally, the RSSF controller was tested at 508 ± 7 wppb with measured oxygen of 542 ± 179 wppb, further reducing the variance between the saturation temperature and the plugging temperature.

46 INSTRUMENTATION RELATED TO NUCLEAR SCIENCE AND ↗
DOE OSTI2022

Preliminary Thermal-Hydraulic Analysis of the UTA–2 Subcritical Linear Accelerator–Driven System

The National Nuclear Security Administration’s mission includes establishing a reliable supply of 99 Mo without highly enriched uranium. Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) supports this objective through collaborative research and development with industrial partners. Niowave Inc., a current partner, is currently designing a subcritical linear accelerator-driven system (ADS) and preparing for the US Nuclear Regulatory Commission’s licensing process. Niowave’s system has the potential to efficiently supply medical radioisotopes. The technology includes a superconducting electron accelerator and a pile of both natural and low-enriched uranium (LEU) targets. The process fissions uranium and many valuable isotopes can then be extracted from the targets. Niowave is currently iterating through conceptual and detailed design processes for several system sizes. This report discusses UTA–2, which is at the demonstration stage. UTA–2 will validate numerical modeling results with experimental measurements before progressing to the detailed design of UTA–3, the commercial-sized ADS. The thermal-hydraulic behavior of the UTA–2 core design was numerically investigated using STAR-CCM+, as described in this report. STAR-CCM+, a state-of-the-art computational fluid dynamics (CFD) software that was commercially developed by Siemens, has an extensive user base and a set of validation studies. It is also compliant with the American Society of Mechanical Engineers’ Nuclear Quality Assurance 1 standard. Three cases are investigated in this report. Case 1 quantified the temperature field within the UTA–2 assembly and water tank using only conduction as the method of thermal energy transport. This simplified approach was overly conservative and yielded wetted cladding temperatures above the coolant saturation temperature. In this case, the maximum temperature of the wetted cladding surface of the highest power rod exceeded the saturation temperature of water by 63.8°C. Because of the overly conservative approach taken in Case 1 and its negative subcooled margin, buoyancy-driven natural circulation flow physics were implemented in Case 2. Adding coolant motion significantly distributed the thermal energy of the system through convective heat transfer. This relatively small amount of convective heat transfer significantly reduced system temperatures and increased the subcooled margin from –63.8 to 61.3°C. This margin confirmed that no boiling was expected during normal operation of UTA–2 at 230 W. Case 3 had no additional physics models but considered an overpower event during which the power of each LEU and natural uranium rod was at its respective peak values. This resulted in a study with the total assembly power equal to 176% of the nominal power of 230 W considered in Cases 1 and 2. The resulting natural circulation flows were slightly enhanced. The subcooled margin decreased slightly to 46.3°C, which is still a significant margin to local boiling of the water within the tank. This margin confirmed that no boiling was expected during an abnormal operation of UTA–2 at 406 W.

07 ISOTOPE AND RADIATION SOURCES↗
DOE OSTI2025

Enhanced pool boiling heat transfer using novel inverted trapezoid microgroove structures

Pool boiling heat transfer improvements with enhanced surfaces have been extensively studied for various hydrofluorocarbon (HFC) refrigerants. However, there is a limited number of studies in the open literature that focus on the pool boiling heat transfer characteristics of hydrofluoroolefin (HFO) refrigerants on enhanced surfaces. This study aims to address this gap by analyzing the pool boiling behavior of HFO refrigerants, specifically R1234yf and R1234ze(E). Experiments were conducted on both plain surfaces and novel inverted trapezoid microgroove structures. Further, the experimental results indicate that the microgroove structures can improve heat transfer coefficients by up to 80% compared to plain surfaces. Additionally, the performance of R1234yf and R1234ze(E) was compared to that of R134. It was observed that R1234yf exhibited comparable performance to R134a, while R1234ze(E) showed slightly lower performance. To assess the influence of saturation temperature on pool boiling heat transfer, tests were conducted at different saturation temperatures of 15℃, 25℃, and 35℃. The findings revealed that the pool boiling heat transfer coefficient increases with rising saturation temperature.

42 ENGINEERING↗
DOE OSTI2021

Simple Heat Pipe Model

This is a simple model designed to run fast but still maintain the key physics and feedback mechanisms of a heat pipe. First, the capillary pressure is a function of the liquid working fluid volume fraction. Second, the boiling and condensation are based on the saturation temperature that is based on the heat pipe pressure. When the pressure goes up, the saturation temperature goes up and the vapor rains on the wick. When the pressure goes down, the saturation temperature goes down and the liquid in the entire wick boils. This is how the heat pipe adjusts to stay robust under different temperatures and heat fluxes.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗
DOE OSTI2024

Reliability of Copper Inverse Opal Surfaces for Extreme-Heat-Flux Micro-Coolers in Low-Global-Warming-Potential Refrigerant R-1233zd Pool Boiling Experiments

This presentation provides a brief snapshot of the InterPACK paper InterPACK2023-113781. The paper explores copper inverse opal (CIO) surface reliability in pool boiling experiments in water and a new, low-global-warming-potential (GWP = 1) hydrofluoroolefin (HFO) refrigerant R-1233zd. The CIO-based structure is intended to develop enhanced two-phase heat transfer surfaces for extreme-heat-flux (approximately 1 kW/cm2) micro-coolers. In this study, a limited number of pool boiling experiments were performed using water and HFO-1233zd fluid, and the reliability of the CIO-based surfaces was evaluated. Critical heat flux (CHF) values in HFO-1233zd at 40 Degrees Celsius to 45 Degrees Celsius saturation temperatures and the corresponding saturation pressures were also measured. The CHF values with the refrigerant are significantly lower compared to those with water, but the refrigerant allows for a wider usable temperature range in the end application of the micro-coolers and is not limited to data centers with controlled ambient conditions. Reliability experiments with CIO surface samples - involving pool boiling with water on the CIO surfaces for approximately 48 hours and with HFO-1233zd for 144 hours - showed no structural degradation of the enhanced surface or any significant performance drop in heat transfer coefficients. The CIO surface samples in water were oxidized, most likely due to the presence of air in water and in the experimental vessel.

critical heat flux↗
DOE OSTI2020

Superconducting phase transitions in disordered NbTiN films

Suppression of superconductivity in disordered systems is a fundamental problem of condensed matter physics. Here we investigate superconducting niobium-titanium-nitride (Nb 1-x Ti x N) thin films grown by the atomic layer deposition (ALD) with slightly different growth process parameters. We observe a smooth crossover from the disorder-driven superconductor-normal metal transition (SMT) to the superconductor-insulator transition (SIT) via the intermediate Bose metal state detected by the low-temperature saturation of the temperature dependence of the sheet resistance. We demonstrate that the SIT via the intervening Bose metal state occurs if the sheet resistance of the film in the maximum, R max prior to the superconducting drop of R(T), exceeds R q = h/4e 2 .

75 CONDENSED MATTER PHYSICS, SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND↗
DOE OSTI2024

Thermal-hydraulic Performance of Emerging Low GWP Refrigerant Mixture under Flow Boiling in Brazed Plate Heat Exchangers

The hydrofluorocarbon (HFC) refrigerants used in the current refrigeration systems are facing a phase-down due to their higher greenhouse effect resulting in global warming, and thus HVAC&R industry has undergone a transition to low Global Warming Potential (GWP) refrigerants. Refrigerant mixtures are attractive alternatives since their composition can be tailored to comply with environmental regulations while preserving favorable thermophysical properties. However, the new low-GWP zeotropic mixture refrigerants have two or more components with different saturation temperatures at the same pressure level, known as temperature glide, which can cause the degradation of the overall heat transfer performance. The brazed plate heat exchangers (BPHX) provide excellent heat transfer performance due to a compact design and are used in several air-conditioning and refrigeration applications. In this study, flow boiling heat transfer and the associated pressure drop of the refrigerant mixture in a vertical BPHX were experimentally investigated. The single-phase water-to-water experiments were conducted in the tested heat exchanger with a counter-flow configuration. The flow boiling experiments charged with R-134a and R-454C were then performed in a pumped refrigerant loop to evaluate its thermal-hydraulic performance. Furthermore, parametric studies of various heat fluxes, mass fluxes, vapor qualities, and saturation temperatures were also conducted.

Yang, Cheng-Min↗
DOE OSTI2026

Computational Thermal Hydraulics of a High-Performance Low-Enriched-Uranium Annular Target for HFIR Irradiation

Molybdenum-99 has historically been generated via isolation from fissioned highly enriched uranium (HEU) targets. Here, this isotope is in high demand due to its daily use across the world in radiopharmaceutical medical procedures. The primary objective of this work was to design and analyze an experimental target assembly containing one low-enriched-uranium (LEU) annular target for irradiation at the High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR). Efforts included incorporating spatially dependent energy sources from neutron and gamma interactions, quantifying thermal contact conductance at material interfaces, performing grid-independent studies, comparing turbulence models, and simulating various steady-state and transient scenarios relevant for irradiation qualification and eventual insertion. These models provide velocity, pressure, and temperature distributions in both space and time. Such results enable the selection of an appropriate irradiation location, fission rate density, and flow-limiting orifice size and demonstrate compliance with HFIR safety requirements such that insertion into the reactor can be approved. This analysis shows that across all scenarios, wetted surface temperatures remain below the coolant saturation temperature with no net vapor formation in the coolant. In every scenario, all components stay below 30% of the aluminum 6061 melting temperature. Computational fluid dynamics and system-level models predict peak target temperatures that agree within 4%, though the predicted axial location of the peak differs by about 10% of the heated length due to differences in flow development length. These results de-risk the irradiation of LEU (annular targets) and strengthen a domestic, HEU-independent 99 Mo supply by providing important fuel performance data to form the foundation for a robust licensing basis.

Molybdenum-99↗
DOE OSTI2025

Tetragonal structure and uniaxial magnetic anisotropy in the arc-melted (Ce,Zr) 2 (Fe,M) 17 (M = Mo, W, Co) alloys

The tetragonal ThMn 12 -type structure is stabilized in (Ce 1-x Zr x ) 2 T 16 M (x = 0.2 – 0.3; T = Fe or Fe/Co, M = Mo or W) arc-melted alloys. Approximately 5 at% of Mo or W admixture is sufficient to transform the hexagonal Th 2 Ni 17 -type structure of (Ce 1-x Zr x ) 2 Fe 17 into the tetragonal ThMn 12 -type structure of nearly single-phase (Ce 1-x Zr x ) 2 Fe 16 M and/or (Ce 1-x Zr x ) 2 Fe 15 CoM bulk alloys. X-ray Rietveld refinements reveal that Zr and Mo (W) substitute different sites in the tetragonal crystal structure. Zirconium preferentially replaces Ce, whereas Mo (W) substitutes Fe. At room temperature, the tetragonal phases exhibit strong ferromagnetism and a uniaxial magneto-crystalline anisotropy with anisotropy fields of 15 – 17 kOe. These materials possess room-temperature saturation magnetizations of 95 – 105 emu/g and Curie temperature of 420 – 505 K. At some concentrations, concurrent Zr and Mo (W) site occupancy facilitates 1:12 structure formation in bulk alloys with minimal presence of non-magnetic element in the Fe sublattice, thus securing the highest known magnetic moment per Fe atom (∼ 1.37 µ B ) in this type of materials. The intrinsic magnetic characteristics, as well as the absence of critical rare earths (RE), make these compounds interesting for development as low-cost permanent magnets. In conclusion, small Co additions improve the Curie temperature, especially if combined with W.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2021

A phase-field method for boiling heat transfer

Here we present a phase field method for heat transfer in two-phase flow with boiling. The vapor/liquid interface evolution is modeled by the Cahn-Hilliard equation. The phase change rate is determined by accounting for the heat conduction balance on either vapor or liquid side of the interfacial area, depending on which side the temperature is assumed to be maintained at the saturation temperature during boiling. The velocity correction scheme proposed by Dong & Shen [27] is extended to solve the Navier-Stokes equations for a non-solenoidal velocity field, and the entropy viscosity method is employed for stabilization. The phase change model is verified by two-dimensional simulations of a vapor bubble growing in super-heated liquid and in film boiling. In both cases, mesh independence of the results is systematically performed. Subsequently, the method is applied to predict the growth of three-dimensional vapor bubble in a rectangular microchannel with boiling flow, achieving good agreement with experimental measurements and available simulation results using the level-set method. The numerical experiments demonstrate that the required mesh resolution for the phase field method is comparable with that of volume of fluid (VoF) and level-set methods.

71 CLASSICAL AND QUANTUM MECHANICS, GENERAL PHYSIC↗
DOE OSTI2020

Influence of non-magnetic Cu on enhancing the low temperature magnetic properties and Curie temperature of FeCoNiCrCu(x) high entropy alloys

The microstructure and magnetic properties of three face-centered cubic (FCC) FeCoNiCrCu(x) high entropy alloys (HEAs) (x=0, 0.5, 1) are investigated. Interestingly, addition of the nonmagnetic element Cu to FeCoNiCr HEA is found to enhance exchange interactions and low temperature saturation magnetization. The paramagnetic to ferromagnetic Curie transition temperature increases from 85 K for FeCoNiCr to 118 K for FeCoNiCrCu. This is counterintuitive since Cu is nonmagnetic; however, atom probe tomography revealed Cu rich clusters containing 5 at% Ni and 1 at% each of Fe, Co, Cr, within FCC matrix, these clusters altered the matrix composition and consequently its magnetic properties.

Chaudhary, Varun↗
DOE OSTI2025

Operation of helium sub-atmospheric multistage cryogenic centrifugal compressor trains: Part 1 – Steady state modeling and speed ratio selection

Helium cryogenic systems which can provide cooling below the normal boiling point of helium (approximately 4.2 K) are often required by superconducting radio-frequency niobium resonators utilized in modern high-energy particle accelerators. Achieving temperatures below 4.2 K generally involves operating a cryogenic vessel with liquid helium under sub-atmospheric conditions, thereby lowering the saturation pressure and corresponding saturation temperature. Over the last several decades, multi-stage cryogenic centrifugal compressor trains (CC’s) have been operated efficiently and reliably within large-scale cryogenic systems to continuously evacuate helium vapor generated by a device within the vessel, maintaining sub-atmospheric conditions in the vessel while pressurizing the return vapor to above atmospheric conditions. Traditionally, these CC systems have been operated using empirically derived control philosophies and insight gathered from previous operational experience. Recent efforts at the Facility for Rare Isotope Beams (FRIB) have been aimed at the development of a theoretical basis to characterize the operation of multi-stage cryogenic centrifugal compressor train and utilizing predictive model results to generate control parameters. The objective of this research was identifying operational points which adequately balance cryogenic system efficiency, stability, and overall ease of operation. Furthermore, this manuscript provides an overview of the predictive model development, characterization of the FRIB cryogenic centrifugal compressors and implementation of the predicted performance results during steady-state system operation.

Compressor train control↗
DOE OSTI2024

Evaluation of Mechanical and Thermomechanical Water Vapor Compression Techniques for Enabling High Temperature Lift Hydration-Based Chemical Heat Pumps

Achieving high temperature lifts (>200 K) via a chemical heat pump based on salt hydration/dehydration reactions requires the transport of water vapor from low to high pressure. Alternative compression approaches require condensing of low-pressure water vapor, pumping of liquid water, and subsequent evaporation when the low-side pressure corresponds to sub-ambient water saturation temperatures. Thus, this study compares four steam compression methods for use within a chemical heat pump system based on a reversible calcium oxide hydration/dehydration reaction with a temperature lift from 350 °C heat to >600 °C. Purely mechanical and thermochemical/mechanical compression technologies are considered. A parametric study of maximum allowable temperature, the isentropic efficiency of mechanical compressors, the effectiveness of heat exchangers, and the assumed allowable heat exchanger pressure drop is conducted to determine the mechanical and thermal energy consumed per kilogram of compressed steam. The system complexity in terms of the number of main system components, maximum pressure ratio, and maximum allowable temperature is estimated. Model results show an absorption-based steam compressor has the highest exergetic efficiency for the required chemical heat pump required conditions. As a result, this system configuration was then experimentally demonstrated to illustrate the impact of system performance on component effectiveness.

Advanced reactors↗
DOE OSTI2020

Characterization of Transition Edge Sensors for the Simons Observatory

The Simons Observatory is building both large (6 m) and small (0.5 m) aperture telescopes in the Atacama Desert in Chile to observe the cosmic microwave background CMB radiation with unprecedented sensitivity. Simons Observatory telescopes in total will use over 60,000 transition edge sensor (TES) detectors spanning center frequencies between 27 and 285 GHz and operating near 100 mK. TES devices have been fabricated for the Simons Observatory by NIST, Berkeley, and HYPRES/SeeQC corporation. Iterations of these devices have been tested cryogenically in order to inform the fabrication of further devices, which will culminate in the final TES designs to be deployed in the field. The detailed design specifications have been independently iterated at each fabrication facility for particular detector frequencies. We present test results for prototype devices, with emphasis on NIST high frequency detectors. A dilution refrigerator was used to achieve the required temperatures. Measurements were taken both with 4-lead resistance measurements and with a time-domain Superconducting Quantum Interference Device (SQUID) multiplexer system. The SQUID readout measurements include analysis of current versus voltage (IV) curves at various temperatures, square wave bias step measurements, and detector noise measurements. Lastly, normal resistance, superconducting critical temperature, saturation power, thermal and natural time constants, and thermal properties of the devices are extracted from these measurements.

47 OTHER INSTRUMENTATION↗
DOE OSTI2024

Universal correlation for falling film evaporation heat transfer coefficients of water and seawater

Horizontal falling film evaporators are widely utilized in desalination industries to increase fresh water supply. However, universal correlations for seawater falling film evaporation under varied operational and geometrical conditions are simply unavailable in open literature. Thus, this study aims to develop such a universal correlation for both plain and enhanced tubes. The detailed heat transfer mechanisms are reviewed, and rational parameters are incorporated to develop the universal correlation. A dataset of 994 data points from 9 sources covering a wide range of conditions was compiled. These conditions include Reynolds numbers from 10 to 7235, heat fluxes from 7.7 to 208 kW/m -2 , saturation temperatures from 278 to 401 K, salinities from 0 to 60 gsalt kg -1 water, tube diameters from 15.8 to 50.8 mm, and liquid feeder height to diameter ratios from 1 to 2.25. Upon analysis, it was found that most of the recommended existing correlations exhibited poor predictive accuracy, as evidenced by larger MADs. The developed correlation in this study demonstrated the best predictive accuracy for the entire dataset, yielding a MAD of 16.8 % and an R 2 of 0.82. Furthermore, the performance of the new correlation was individually assessed across a broader spectrum of operational and design conditions, reflecting the individual conditions’ influences with an overall MAD of 20 %.

42 ENGINEERING↗
DOE OSTI2026

Enhanced pool boiling heat transfer with metal foam tubes in inline tube bundle configuration

Flooded evaporators, commonly known as shell-and-tube heat exchangers, are widely used in large-scale industrial refrigeration and air-conditioning systems due to their high pool boiling heat transfer efficiency. However, their bulky configuration requires a large refrigerant inventory, which poses safety challenges—particularly when employing next-generation A2L refrigerants that are mildly flammable. Here, to address this issue, the development of compact heat exchangers with enhanced heat transfer performance is essential. In this study, a novel metal foam tube design is proposed to augment pool boiling heat transfer. Experiments were conducted at a saturation temperature of 20 °C and across a heat flux range of 7–60 kW m −2 . The tests were conducted for both smooth and metal foam tubes with an inline tube bundle configuration and for a pitch–to–diameter (P/D) ratios of 1.3 and 1.5. Pool boiling performance was evaluated for next-generation hydrofluoroolefin (HFO) refrigerants, R1234yf and R1234ze(E), with R134a serving as the baseline fluid. The results indicate that the heat transfer coefficient (HTC) of R1234yf is comparable to R134a, while R1234ze(E) shows slightly lower performance. Importantly, the metal foam tubes achieved up to a 217% enhancement in HTC compared to smooth tubes.

Metal foam tubes↗
DOE OSTI2024

Capillary-Enhanced Two-Phase Micro-Cooler Using Copper-Inverse-Opal Wick with Silicon Microchannel Manifold for High-Heat-Flux Cooling Application

In this work, we demonstrate a two-phase capillary-fed boiling micro-cooler that consists of a ~ 25-..mu..m-thick copper inverse opal (CIO) porous wicking structure for high-heat-flux boiling and a silicon 3D-manifold for distributed liquid delivery and vapor extraction across a 0.5 cm x 0.5 cm heated area. At low inlet water mass flow rates of 1.5 to 1.9 g(min)-1, the micro-cooler displays nearly two-phase boiling with exit vapor quality ~ 1 and a high critical heat flux (CHF) of 253 to 320 W cm-2 with low superheat of ~ 10 degrees C resulting in a thermal resistance of boiling ~ 0.025 cm2 degrees C W-1 or heat transfer coefficient of 0.4 MW m-2 degrees C-1. For higher flow rates of 5, 10, and 15 g(min)-1, the micro-cooler exhibits a hybrid single-phase and two-phase cooling regime where the contribution of the sensible heat (single-phase) cooling is linearly added to that of the two-phase cooling. For the highest flow rate of 15 g(min)-1, the CHF is increased to ~ 500 W cm-2 resulting in an overall thermal resistance of ~ 0.18 cm2 degrees C W-1. However, the two-phase heat transfer effectiveness, which estimates the utilization level of the inlet mass flow rate for two-phase boiling, is reduced to ~ 0.11. To achieve the best cooling system performances, the micro-cooler must operate entirely within the two-phase boiling regime (exit vapor quality or two-phase heat transfer effectiveness ~ 1). Ideally, the "coolant" should be delivered near its saturation temperature (~ 100 degrees C for water), which provides significant advantages for the energy-efficient operation of data centers and power electronics. We present detailed analysis with Infrared and high speed camera images at various inlet flow rates and heat fluxes to understand complex heat transfer in the micro-cooler. Furthermore, a conjugate thermofluidic simulation model, which incorporates the physics of capillary-fed boiling in a porous copper layer, agrees well with the experimental data.

capillary-enhanced boiling↗
DOE OSTI2021

Flow condensation heat transfer performance of natural and emerging synthetic refrigerants

There is great interest in predicting flow condensation heat transfer for lower global warming potential (GWP) fluids. This paper analyzes the efficacy of common flow condensation correlations developed for particular fluids in order to identify their suitability to predict heat transfer performance of low GWP fluids. Condensation heat transfer data were extracted from the literature, including 19 papers and 1,473 data points for natural refrigerants [i.e., ammonia (R717), CO 2 (R744), propane (R290), isobutane (R600a)] and 35 papers and 5,030 data points for synthetic refrigerants [i.e., R12, R1234yf, R1234ze(E), R1234ze(Z), R22, R32, R41, R123, R125, R134a, R142b, R152a, R161, R404A, R410A, R448A, R449A, R450A, R452B, R454C, R455A, R513A] encompassing tube diameters of 0.1–11.5 mm, mass fluxes of 55–1200 kg/m2s, and saturation temperatures of -25°C–65°C. Correlations analyzed included Akers et al. (1959), Cavallini et al. (2006, 2011), Kim and Mudawar (2013), Macdonald and Garimella (2016), Shah (1979, 2009, 2013, 2016) and Traviss et al. (1973) for smooth tubes and Chamra et al. (2005) and Kedzierski and Goncalves (1999) for enhanced tubes. Since most studies did not report wall temperature, correlations which relied on wall temperature directly or indirectly were excluded from the analysis. For synthetic refrigerants, mean average error (MAE) ranged from 6%–257%, and Cavallini et al. (2011) and Kim and Mudawar (2013) were the best predictors for emerging synthetic refrigerants. Furthermore, the Kim and Mudawar (2013) correlation was found to best predict the heat transfer performance for propane and R600a data, but most correlations did not accurately predict ammonia and CO 2 flow condensation.

32 ENERGY CONSERVATION, CONSUMPTION, AND UTILIZATI↗