Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “spallation behavior”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 19 records

Lessons Learned in Employing Data Analytics to Predict Oxidation Kinetics and Spallation Behavior of High-Temperature NiCr-Based Alloys

Machine learning (ML) can offer many advantages in predicting material properties over traditional materials development methods based solely on limited experimental investigations or physical-based simulations with the capability to reduce development cost, risk, and time. However, so far, limited efforts have been made to predict alloy oxidation kinetics and spallation behavior via ML due to the lack of consistently measured and sufficient experimental data and the inherent complexity in oxidation behavior of multicomponent high-temperature alloys. A previous study reported the ability of ML to predict oxidation kinetics of NiCr-based alloys as a function of alloy composition and operating conditions. Here, the performance of a ML model in predicting rate constants and spallation probability was evaluated in light of the roles of the data distribution of the experimental dataset (data analytics), the alloy composition, the exposure environment and the chosen oxidation approach to extracting kinetic values from the measured mass changes (but using either a simple parabolic law or a statistical cyclic oxidation model). Potential strategies to improve the predictions and enhance the extrapolative capability of the previously trained model will be discussed.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Atomistic study of silicon alloying in the spallation behavior of nanocrystalline aluminum systems

Here, the effect of concentration of the alloying element silicon (Si) on the shock and spall response of aluminum (Al) is studied using classical molecular dynamics (MD) simulations. Silicon is distributed as individual grains and as grain boundaries and the dynamic response under shock is studied for an impact velocity of 1000 m/s. A general trend observed here is that the spallation is almost exclusively intergranular and limited to Al-Si interfaces. The spall strengths are observed to a) decrease with an increase in alloying of Si as grains and b) show little increase for up to 50% grain boundary segregation. An increase in grain size of the whole system showed negligible differences in spall strength, highlighting the significance of concentration of the alloying species rather than its grain size. These results provide an atomistic understanding of light-weight metallic systems under shock compression and pave the way for designing multiphase metal matrix alloys and composites for defense/armor applications.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Dynamic compression and spallation behavior of NbTaTiVZr high-entropy alloy

High-entropy alloys are a new class of materials with promising properties for aerospace and defense applications. The unique behavior of these materials is driven by the complex interactions between dissimilar atoms in a crystal and requires combined theoretical and experimental efforts to unlock their full potential. Here, we evaluate the relationship between the microstructure and the dynamic response of the equiatomic NbTaTiVZr alloy. Specifically, the shock Hugoniot, or equation of state, was measured up to a particle velocity of 0.5 mm μs −1 using gas gun plate impacts. Shock wave profile and incipient spallation experiments were used to characterize wave propagation and damage formation with post-mortem recovery experiments. Molecular dynamics simulations confirm the experimental findings and extend them up to 2.1 mm μs −1 particle velocity. Computational thermodynamic calculation of phase diagram simulations explain details of the material microstructure, which explains the measured strength and experimental damage patterns. Overall, this work provides detailed high-strain-rate characterization of a refractory high-entropy alloy, and more importantly, a framework and demonstration of the utility and necessity of a combined theoretical and experimental approach, outlining the importance of considering processing and manufacturing conditions when evaluating the performance of new materials.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Isothermal and Cyclic Oxidation of Haynes 282 Processed by Electron Beam Melting (EBM) and Laser Powder Bed Fusion (LPBF) in Dry Air at 800 and 950°C

Here, the isothermal and cyclic oxidation behavior of Haynes 282 (H282) processed by laser powder bed fusion and electron beam melting was compared to its cast counterpart during exposures in air at 800 and 950°C. The specific microstructure of the AM alloys compared to coarse-grain cast 282 resulted in differences in oxidation rates, internal oxidation and spallation behavior. At 800°C, faster Ti diffusion to the surface due to the smaller grain size of the AM alloys led to Ti doping of the Cr 2 O 3 scale and faster oxidation rates. The higher density of grain boundaries also resulted in more pronounced internal oxidation. At 950°C, a duplex Cr 2 O 3 scale was observed with a dense inner layer and porous cracked outer layer with embedded TiO 2 particles. The impact of the external and internal oxide compositions and oxidation-induced elemental depletions on the oxidation lifetime, creep properties and spallation behavior is discussed.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Kinetics of Cyclic Oxidation and Cracking and Finite Element Analysis of MA956 and Sapphire/MA956 Composite System

Sapphire fiber-reinforced MA956 composites hold promise for significant weight savings and increased high-temperature structural capability, as compared to unreinforced MA956. As part of an overall assessment of the high-temperature characteristics of this material system, cyclic oxidation behavior was studied at 1093 C and 1204 C. Initially, both sets of coupons exhibited parabolic oxidation kinetics. Later, monolithic MA956 exhibited spallation and a linear weight loss, whereas the composite showed a linear weight gain without spallation. Weight loss of the monolithic MA956 resulted from the linking of a multiplicity of randomly oriented and closely spaced surface cracks that facilitated ready spallation. By contrast, cracking of the composite's oxide layer was nonintersecting and aligned nominally parallel with the orientation of the subsurface reinforcing fibers. Oxidative lifetime of monolithic MA956 was projected from the observed oxidation kinetics. Linear elastic, finite element continuum, and micromechanics analyses were performed on coupons of the monolithic and composite materials. Results of the analyses qualitatively agreed well with the observed oxide cracking and spallation behavior of both the MA956 and the Sapphire/MA956 composite coupons.

Lee, Kang N.↗

High temperature air oxidation behavior of Hastelloy X processed by Electron Beam Melting (EBM) and Selective Laser Melting (SLM)

The microstructure and oxidation behavior of Laser Beam Melted, Electron Beam Melted and wrought Hastelloy X were studied at 950 °C in dry air, 50 h cycles, up to 1000 h. The variability of processing parameters and powder compositions strongly impacted the oxidation and spallation behavior. Finally, the alloys with high Mn and Si were associated with higher oxidation rates, finer Cr 2 O 3 grain microstructure and increased spallation was observed for the alloys with large elongated grain microstructures (aspect ratio of 10 ± 3).

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Shock-induced twinning/detwinning and spall failure in Cu–Ta nanolaminates at atomic scales

Here, this study provides new insights into the role of interfaces on the deformation and failure mechanisms in shock-loaded Cu–Ta–Cu trilayer system. The thickness of the Ta layer, piston velocities, and shock pulse durations were varied to explore the impact of impedance mismatch and loading conditions on spallation behavior and twin formation. It was found that the interfaces play a crucial role in the dynamic response of these multilayered systems since secondary reflection waves generated at the interfaces significantly affected the peak stress and pressure profiles, influencing void nucleation and failure modes. In the trilayer systems, failure predominantly occurred at interfaces and within the Ta layer, with void nucleation sites and twinning behavior being markedly different compared to single-crystal Cu and Ta. Increasing the Ta layer thickness modified the wave interactions, leading to different failure locations. Higher piston velocities were associated with increased spall strength by enhancing wave interactions and void formation, particularly at the interfaces and within the Ta layer, under specific configurations. Additionally, shorter shock pulse durations facilitated earlier initiation of the release fan, reducing twin formation and altering the failure dynamics by accelerating twin annihilation and pressure release.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Cyclic oxidation behavior of selected commercial NiCr-alloys for engine exhaust valves in wet air environment between 800 and 950 °C

In this work, the impact of water vapor on the cyclic oxidation behavior of four commercial Ni-based superalloys (N80A, N90, R41 and H282) was investigated between 800 and 950°C. Oxidation- and volatilization-induced Cr loss accelerated the transition from protective and adherent oxide formation (Cr 2 O 3 ) to mixed oxides that significantly spalled at 950°C for H282 and R41. The accelerated oxidation, Cr depletion, and spallation susceptibility for R41 and to a lesser extent for H282 compared to N80A and N90 was related to the higher fraction of γ’, which led to increased Ti incorporation into the Cr 2 O 3 scale in the presence of water vapor.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Oxidative Recession, Sulfur Release, and Al203 Spallation for Y-Doped Alloys

Second-order spallation phenomena have been noted for Y-doped Rene'N5 after long term oxidation at 1150 degrees C. The reason for this behavior has not been conclusively identified. A mass equivalence analysis has shown that the surface recession resulting from oxidation has the potential of releasing about 0.15 monolayer of sulfur for every 1 mg/sq cm of oxygen reacted for an alloy containing 5 ppmw of sulfur. This amount is significant in comparison to levels that have been shown to result in first-order spallation behavior for undoped alloys. Oxidative recession is therefore speculated to be a contributing source of sulfur and second-order spallation for Y-doped alloys.

Smialek, James L.↗

Characterization of mechanical properties and deformation behavior of highly irradiated 316L stainless steel from target modules at the Spallation Neutron Source using digital image correlation analysis

Tensile specimens with irradiation doses ranging from approximately 0.7 to 7.6 displacements per atom (dpa) were fabricated from 316L samples removed from Spallation Neutron Source (SNS) target vessels after service. Tensile tests were performed in conjunction with digital image correlation (DIC) characterization, which permitted detailed analysis of the strain distribution and deformation behavior of the specimen gauge sections during testing. The results show, while considerable hardening (500–700 MPa increase in yield strength) occurred in the 316L SNS target material with increasing dose, appreciable ductility (19–23% total elongation) remained in the material after irradiation to 7.6 dpa in the mixed neutron/proton environment of the SNS target region. The DIC data showed the strain distribution and deformation behavior of all irradiated specimens were nonuniform during testing. Strain localization in the form of deformation bands or “hotspots” was observed during testing, and in some specimens, the bands propagated as deformation waves along the gauge section. The “traveling wave” deformation behavior affected the amount of elongation each specimen achieved, and the scatter in the elongation data was attributed to the large variation in deformation behavior observed among different specimens. Bands of localized strain, or deformation bands, oriented at specific angles were observed in two-dimensional plots of the strain distribution in the gauge sections of some specimens. Overall, this paper describes the experimental procedures, results, and deformation behavior of tensile specimens from SNS targets after service and illustrates the value of DIC characterization during tensile testing of irradiated materials.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Role of α → ε → α phase transformation on the spall behavior of iron at atomic scales

Shock compression of iron microstructures above a threshold stress results in a α (BCC) → ε (HCP) transformation and the propagation of the release wave brings the metal back to the α phase following the ε→α transformation. Predicting failure behavior under shock loading conditions (spallation) relies on understanding the evolution of defects in the microstructure as it undergoes the α→ε→α phase transformation. This study uses molecular dynamics (MD) simulations to investigate the role of defect evolution during α→ε→α phase transformation on the spall strength values of single-crystal (sc) Fe microstructures. The MD simulations aim to characterize the ε phase fraction formed during shock compression and the defects during shock release for variations in loading orientations and shock stresses. The simulations are carried out for loading along the [100], [110], [111], and [112] orientations and for impact velocities ranging from 600 m/s to 1 km/s. The ε phase fractions during compression and defects (dislocations, twins) characterized during spall failure show an orientation dependence that affects the spall strength values. Here, the lowest value for spall strength is observed for the <110> loading orientation that shows a high density of twinning at the spall plane, whereas the highest value is observed for the <100> orientation and is associated with a α (BCC) → γ (FCC) transformation at the spall plane. The correlations of the spall strength values with the strain rates and with the ε phase fractions are discussed.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

On the role of geometrically necessary dislocations in void formation and growth in response to shock loading conditions in wrought and additively manufactured Ta

This study investigates the role of geometrically necessary dislocations (GNDs) and microstructure on void nucleation and growth in wrought and additively manufactured (AM) tantalum subjected to high-strain rate loading. Multi-modal 3D data was collected using TriBeam tomography to calculate GND densities and their spatial relationship to voids. A microstructural comparison between the wrought and AM samples identified distinct void shapes and locations, with intragranular voids and more spherical voids frequently observed in the AM dataset. Results indicate that voids preferentially form at both high-angle grain boundaries and low-angle subgrain boundaries, the latter of which are frequently observed in the AM material. Through a radial distribution analysis of all voids in the datasets, significant GND localization to near-void-surface regions was observed in both samples. 3D crystal plasticity simulations were employed to extend the experimental observations, revealing higher void growth rates in [111] oriented grains when compared to [001] grains. The simulations also suggest that GNDs can be generated as part of the void growth process, with more GND accumulation for growth in a [111] grain than a [001] grain. These findings provide valuable insights into the links between nanoscale void nucleation, mesoscale void growth, and microstructural effects in dynamically loaded tantalum.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Multimodal 3D characterization of voids in shock-loaded tantalum: Implications for ductile spallation mechanisms

Predicting the failure of crystalline materials at high strain rates requires knowledge of the underlying failure mechanisms and their dependence on microstructure. However, little experimental consensus exists on the underlying micromechanics of spallation. In this study, a 3D-EBSD characterization experiment is performed on tantalum prior to and after partial spallation by plate impact, which allowed for the statistical assessment of the microstructural neighborhoods surrounding incipient voids. In analyzing the resulting dataset containing 5884 grains and 467 voids, it is observed that the voids were roughly spherical and consistent in size throughout the spalled material. The voids mostly resided at quadruple points, at triple junctions, at grain boundaries, and within grains, in decreasing order of prevalence. Moreover, voids tended to form at grain boundaries with high degrees of plastic incompatibility, growing into the plastically soft grain but orienting primarily with or perpendicular to the loading direction. Here, the statistics from these analyses of 3D microstructural data support dynamic cavitation models for ductile spallation.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Cyclic Oxidation Modeling Program Rewritten for MS Windows

Turbine superalloy components are subject to high-temperature oxidation during operation. Protection is often conferred by coatings designed to form slow-growing, adherent oxide scales. Degradation by oxidation is exacerbated by the thermal cycling encountered during normal aircraft operations. Cooling has been identified as the major contributor to stresses in the oxidation scales, and it may often cause some oxide scale spallation with a proportional loss of protective behavior. Overall oxidation resistance is, thus, studied by the weight change behavior of alloy coupons during high-temperature cyclic oxidation in furnace or burner rig tests. The various characteristics of this behavior are crucial in understanding the performance of alloys at high temperatures. This new modeling effort helps in the understanding of the major factors involved in the cyclic oxidation process. Weight change behavior in cyclic oxidation is typified by an initial parabolic weight gain response curve that eventually exhibits a maximum, then transitions into a linear rate of weight loss due to spalling. The overall shape and magnitude of the curve are determined by the parabolic growth rate, kp, the cycle duration, the type of oxide scale, and the regular, repetitive spalling process. This entire process was modeled by a computer program called the Cyclic Oxidation Spalling Program (COSP) previously developed at the NASA Glenn Research Center. Thus, by supplying appropriate oxidation input parameters, one can determine the best fit to the actual data. These parameters describe real behavior and can be used to compare alloys and project cyclic oxidation behavior for longer times or under different cycle frequencies.

Smialek, James L.↗

Cyclic Oxidation Testing and Modelling: A NASA Lewis Perspective

The Materials Division of the NASA Lewis Research Center has been heavily involved in the cyclic oxidation of high temperature materials for 30 years. Cyclic furnace and burner rig apparati have been developed, refined, and replicated to provide a large scale facility capable of evaluating many materials by a standard technique. Material behavior is characterized by weight change data obtained throughout the test, which has been modelled in a step-wise process of scale growth and spallation. This model and a coupled diffusion model have successfully described cyclic behavior for a number of systems and have provided insights regarding life prediction and variations in the spalling process. Performance ranking and mechanistic studies are discussed primarily for superalloys and coating alloys. Similar cyclic oxidation studies have been performed on steels, intermetallic compounds, thermal barrier coatings, ceramics, and ceramic composites. The most common oxidation test was performed in air at temperatures ranging from 800 deg. to 1600 C, for times up to 10000 h, and for cycle durations of 0.1 to 1000 h. Less controlled, but important, test parameters are the cooling temperature and humidity level. Heating and cooling rates are not likely to affect scale spallation. Broad experience has usually allowed for considerable focus and simplification of these test parameters, while still revealing the principal aspects of material behavior and performance. Extensive testing has been performed to statistically model the compositional effects of experimental alloys and to construct a comprehensive database of complex commercial alloys.

Smialek, J. L.↗

Diffusion bonding of tungsten-vanadium-zirconium using vacuum hot pressing for the development of a low decay heat cladding solution for tungsten spallation targets

Tantalum has been used as cladding material for water-cooled solid tungsten targets at many leading spallation neutron production facilities thanks to its high neutron yield, manageable radiation damage behavior, and excellent corrosion/erosion resistance in radiation environments. However, from a safety hazard perspective, thermal neutron capture of tantalum in spallation environments causes a high specific decay heat in the target volume, which often becomes a limiting factor in increasing the beam power on the target. In this paper, we studied vacuum hot pressing (VHP) parameters to diffusion bond zirconium to tungsten to explore the feasibility of using zirconium alloys as an alternative cladding material to tantalum. Zirconium alloys have long been used as cladding material for early generation solid spallation targets, and nuclear fuel rods. In spallation environments zirconium has significantly lower decay heat with shorter decay time compared to tantalum. The hot isostatic pressing (HIP) of zirconium and tungsten is known to produce limited bonding quality due to the formation of the brittle ZrW2 intermetallic layer. To overcome this problem, placing a vanadium interlayer between tungsten and zirconium has been proposed by exploring parameter space in binary alloy phase diagrams. Under the VHP conditions, 860 ◦C at 70 MPa for 4 hours, Zr-V and V-W showed good diffusion bonding, which demonstrates the feasibility of a single step HIP process to make the zirconium alloy clad tungsten spallation volumes.

Lee, Yong Joong↗

Constrained model calibration of grain structure dependent spall dynamics in shock-loaded tantalum

Here, we perform a gas gun experiment by shock loading tantalum samples of varying grain structures to assess the suitability of a numerical model for simulating spall behavior. The observed differences in spall strength, as well spallation and re-compression history, are not captured in uncalibrated hydrodynamic simulations. An optimization is performed on the Johnson spall model to determine the best parameters that fit the observed trends. Linear stability analysis is employed to motivate bounds on those parameters. Herein, optimized simulations agree well with the experimental results, reproducing pullback depth and recompression timescales across the different samples tested. Further, the observed pullback time of the single crystal sample was found to imply, via the stability analysis, a percolation threshold in good agreement with the theoretical value for a body centered cubic lattice. Therefore, the combined linear stability and percolation analysis shows promise and may be applied to other materials with diverse microstructures. Collectively, the findings demonstrate that the model is suitable for reproducing spall-induced free surface behavior across various microstructures, but also points to caution in using model coefficients for uncalibrated microstructures.

58 GEOSCIENCES↗

COSP for Windows: Strategies for Rapid Analyses of Cyclic Oxidation Behavior

COSP is a publicly available computer program that models the cyclic oxidation weight gain and spallation process. Inputs to the model include the selection of an oxidation growth law and a spalling geometry, plus oxide phase, growth rate, spall constant, and cycle duration parameters. Output includes weight change, the amounts of retained and spalled oxide, the total oxygen and metal consumed, and the terminal rates of weight loss and metal consumption. The present version is Windows based and can accordingly be operated conveniently while other applications remain open for importing experimental weight change data, storing model output data, or plotting model curves. Point-and-click operating features include multiple drop-down menus for input parameters, data importing, and quick, on-screen plots showing one selection of the six output parameters for up to 10 models. A run summary text lists various characteristic parameters that are helpful in describing cyclic behavior, such as the maximum weight change, the number of cycles to reach the maximum weight gain or zero weight change, the ratio of these, and the final rate of weight loss. The program includes save and print options as well as a help file. Families of model curves readily show the sensitivity to various input parameters. The cyclic behaviors of nickel aluminide (NiAl) and a complex superalloy are shown to be properly fitted by model curves. However, caution is always advised regarding the uniqueness claimed for any specific set of input parameters,

Smialek, James L.↗