Host-guest prospects of neodymium and gadolinium ultraphosphate frameworks for nuclear waste storage: Multi-temperature topological analysis of nanoporous cages in RP{sub 5}O{sub 14}
Highlights: • The temperature-dependent cage topologies of RP{sub 5}O{sub 14} (R = Nd or Gd) were examined. • A topological analysis revealed similar cage structure for RP{sub 5}O{sub 14} (R = Nd or Gd). • One exception: the 8/4 cage topology of NdP{sub 5}O{sub 14} lacks structural cross-linking. • Volume (UO{sub 2} or PuO{sub 2}) ≫ 8/4 topology in RP{sub 5}O{sub 14} (R = Nd or Gd). • RP{sub 5}O{sub 14} (R = Nd or Gd) are good prospective host media for nuclear waste storage. - Abstract: Rare-earth ultraphosphate (RP{sub 5}O{sub 14}) framework materials are potential host media for nuclear waste storage, since cages within their nanoporous structures have volumes that match well those of prospective guests such as uranium or plutonium ions. Good volume matches of host cages and guest compounds are nonetheless not the only structural requirement for ensuring viable nuclear waste storage. Host structures also need to be stable enough to withstand the typical environmental conditions of long-term storage of spent nuclear fuel. To this end, the nanoporous cage topologies of neodymium and gadolinium ultraphosphate, NdP{sub 5}O{sub 14} and GdP{sub 5}O{sub 14}, are investigated as a function of temperature. Topological analysis shows that, while both compounds are essentially isostructural, thus displaying the same type of cage structures, the cage volumes of NdP{sub 5}O{sub 14} are significantly larger than those of GdP{sub 5}O{sub 14}, with one stark exception. This exception concerns the cage of NdP{sub 5}O{sub 14} whose 8/4 topology lacks structural cross-linking that would otherwise give it much more strength. This 'squashed' cage appears to owe its origins to the specific nature of crystallographic twinning in NdP{sub 5}O{sub 14}, which causes strain that needs alleviating; squashing the 8/4 cage in NdP{sub 5}O{sub 14} would be the most susceptible option towards this end, since its cage manifests the weakest structural construct. GdP{sub 5}O{sub 14} succumbs to a gradual contraction of its 8/4 cage only with increasing temperature above 300 K; this is well below its second-order monoclinic-to-orthorhombic phase transition at 420–430 K; which is 420 K for NdP{sub 5}O{sub 14}. Fortunately, the volumes of heavy metal ions that arise from spent nuclear fuels do not match the size requirements of cages with 8/4 topology in RP{sub 5}O{sub 14} hosts needed for encapsulation; otherwise, radiation leakage of such containment would present a risk. Both NdP{sub 5}O{sub 14} and GdP{sub 5}O{sub 14} would therefore seem to offer good prospects as host media for nuclear waste storage.