SEARCH · Search NASA
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
This data set consists of the data used to generate the figures in the paper titled "Wall conditioning effects of boron powder injection in KSTAR with a tungsten divertor" in the journal Nuclear Fusion, 2025.
Boron powder dropped into KSTAR plasmas decreased the radiated power, core electron density, and Z eff , indicating that the ablated and redeposited boron powder helped to condition the plasma-facing surfaces. Visible line emission of oxygen and tungsten were also reduced by 50% (80%) with boron injection into H-mode (L-mode) discharges that used the new KSTAR tungsten monoblock lower divertor. Dynamic particle balance analysis found a negligible difference in the inferred wall pumping rate during the steady portion of the discharges. It is inferred that the observed conditioning effects were principally caused by a reduction in intrinsic impurities as opposed to a reduction in wall recycling. These results are in qualitative agreement with low-Z injected powder experiments across many fusion devices, confirming the utility of low-Z powder injection as a real-time wall conditioning tool.
Not Available
Advanced vacuum technologies, including pumping, fueling and wall conditioning, have been successfully developed or upgraded to efficiently control the fuel and impurity particles to extend the plasma pulse duration in the experimental advanced superconducting tokamak (EAST). To improve the particle exhaust rate cryopumps with a 60% increase in pumping speed and ∼2 times increase in saturation capacity have been developed, and molecular pumps with a ∼30% increase in pumping speed have been upgraded. In order to monitor the molecular pump status while avoiding bearing faults and overload accidents, a fault detection system has been built which can offer an early warning to avoid more losses within the fusion device. A series of fueling technologies have been developed including gas injection system, supersonic molecular beam injector, pellet injector (PI), massive gas injector and shattered pellet injector, installed at the midplane and divertor positions at different ports to improve fueling uniformity and efficiency. Meanwhile, routine wall conditioning such as electric and hot N 2 baking, ion cyclotron wall conditioning and glow discharge cleaning have been successfully developed to remove the impurity particles from the inner component and materials. The low Z material wall coating and real-time powder injection during plasma discharge are also designed and applied to further improve particle control capability. Finally, by using these advanced vacuum related technologies, good vacuum (<2 × 10 −6 Pa) and wall conditions are realized, and the fuel and impurity particles can be effectively and stably controlled, which promotes the achievement of the record plasma of ∼1056 s pulse duration with the line-averaged electron density of 1.8 × 10 19 m −3 on EAST. They provide a very important reference for vacuum system design and operation for future fusion devices.
Long-pulse, high-performance operation with tungsten plasma-facing components is a crucial challenge for achieving steady-state (SS) goals in ITER and future fusion devices. This paper presents a joint international effort between the DIII-D and KSTAR tokamaks aimed at demonstrating the compatibility of the high q 95 ~ 6 hybrid scenario with a tungsten divertor and superconducting coils. A DIII-D hybrid scenario recipe is successfully tailored to KSTAR’s operational constraints, which facilitates cross-device studies. The results show successful 30 s long-pulse operation in KSTAR at a normalized beta (β N = 2.4) with a benign m/n = 4/3 mode and effective mitigation of tungsten accumulation. Despite this success, the KSTAR scenario exhibits a greater than 25% reduction in thermal confinement compared to the DIII-D reference. To investigate this discrepancy, we performed a predictive TGYRO validation study, which suggests that the difference is likely caused by a weaker temperature pedestal in the KSTAR discharge due to a higher and narrower density pedestal. In addition, such lower thermal confinement leads to higher impurity accumulation, possibly due to a change in neoclassical transport with increased inward pinch, which further degrades global confinement. We also report that stationary, long-pulse operation with sustained thermal confinement requires consistent fueling and wall conditioning. These findings highlight the importance of optimized fueling and real-time wall conditioning in achieving a high temperature pedestal and strong global confinement during stable long-pulse operation. We propose potential approaches toward fully SS, long-pulse operation, including real-time wall conditioning using an impurity dropper in KSTAR and future tokamaks.
Fuel retention remains a critical challenge for magnetic confinement fusion devices. As a low-Z material, lithium plays a key role in tokamak wall conditioning and impurity control. In this study, the fuel retention behaviors associated with two lithium forms—powder and granule—are systematically examined using the gas balance method. Both forms of lithium injection significantly enhance fuel retention, shifting the wall behavior from net outgassing to net absorption. For lithium powder injection, compared with the reference discharge, a suppression efficiency exceeding 40% is achieved relative to the number of injected lithium atoms. Moreover, discharges with different injection rates show a monotonic increase in retained fuel with the injected lithium quantity. In contrast, repeated granule injections exhibit a pronounced cumulative effect, with the retention ratio varying from 0.16 to 0.65 over successive discharges, indicating progressive enhancement of wall absorption and deuterium retention. These results advance the understanding of wall behavior modification induced by solid material injection and provide insights for developing effective wall-conditioning strategies using low-Z materials in ITER and future fusion reactors, while the expected high retention may ultimately exclude the use of Li wall conditioning in future fusion devices.
Boron (B), as a low-Z material, is widely employed for wall conditioning to enhance plasma performance in fusion devices. In the Experimental Advanced Superconducting Tokamak, a series of experiments involving real-time B powder injection has been conducted to investigate fuel particle behavior. It was observed that fuel particle recycling decreased with an increase in the amount of B powder injected, resulting in an increase in short-term fuel retention. The fuel recycling decreased by up to 80%, as indicated by divertor neutral pressure and D α line emission. Furthermore, each B atom exhibited a trapping capacity of 0.3 D particles during B powder injection at a typical flow rate. The real-time B injection had no wall hysteresis effect on D retention, implying that cumulative B injection and deposited film did not affect long-term D retention. The possible mechanism for D retention is the formation of B-C-O-D compounds and co-deposition between B and D particles during discharges. This investigation would be valuable for evaluating T retention when B is used as wall conditioning material in future fusion reactor devices.
Boron (B), a low-Z (atomic number) material, has been widely utilized in wall conditioning to improve plasma performance in fusion devices. In 2023, boronization was successfully conducted on EAST featuring an ITER-like tungsten divertor and fully metallic first wall. The process employed predischarge coating with carborane (C 2 B 10 H 12 ) as the working material, assisted by ion cyclotron wall conditioning (ICWC). After one time 12 g boronization, it was found the thickness of B film was approximately 120 nm. Post-boronization observations indicated that substantial hydrogen (H) release during initial plasma discharges compared with the consumed W/B wall, attributed to H co-deposition during the ICWC-boronization processing, which led to uncontrollable divertor neutral pressure and plasma density. The H/(H + D) ratio demonstrated a gradual reduction from ∼85% to 30% over more than 1850 s of deuterium plasma, with a cumulative injected energy of 2325 MJ. The B coating significantly enhanced the stored energy in plasma and improved confinement performance. The stored energy in plasma showed an increase of about 20%, primarily due to a reduction in impurity radiation, including oxygen (O) and heavy impurities such as tungsten (W), iron (Fe), and copper (Cu). The effective ion charge (Z eff ) decreased from 2.3 to 2.0. Following ICWC-boronization, the line-integrated radiation profile decreased by nearly 35% in the plasma core, plasma density and electron temperature exhibited an increase of ∼7% and 12% due to enhanced wall fueling and reduced impurity radiation. The lifetime of boronization, as evaluated by the line emissions from boron and other impurity radiation, was about 1700 s of deuterium plasma, with a cumulative injected energy of 2125 MJ on EAST. These findings provide significant insights for evaluating ICWC-boronization applicability in ITER with full W wall structure.
In Large Helical Device (LHD), diborane (B 2 H 6 ) is used as a standard boron source for boronization, which is assisted by helium glow discharges. In 2019, a new Impurity Powder Dropper (IPD) system has been installed and is under evaluation as a real-time wall conditioning technique. In LHD), which is a large size heliotron device, an additional helium (He) glow discharge cleaning (GDC) after boronization has been operated for a reduction of hydrogen recycling from coated boron layers, and this operational time of 3 h was determined by spectroscopic data during glow discharges. A flat hydrogen profile is obtained on the top surface of coated boron on the specimen exposed to boronization, the result suggests a reduction of hydrogen at the top surface by He-GDC. Trapped oxygen in coated boron was obtained by boronization, and the coated boron, which has boron-oxide, on the first wall by B-IPD was also shown. Finally, considering the difference in coating areas between B 2 H 6 boronization and B-IPD operation, it would be most effective to use the IPD and B 2 H 6 boronization coating together for optimized wall conditioning.
We report the basic behaviors of fuel recycling and impurity accumulation during >100 s long-pulse H-mode plasma under full metal wall conditions on EAST. Significant fuel recycling and impurity rising, particularly from heavy impurities, have been observed when operating with a bare metal wall or a deteriorate real-time coated wall, which severely limits the duration of H-mode discharges. To address this issue, a novel dynamic wall coating technique combining feedforward and feedback controls has been successfully developed. The feedforward control presets the Li powder injection rate based on prior experimental observations, whereas the feedback control dynamically modulates the Li injection rate in response to real-time Li-II line emission measurements. Using this approach, a 605 s H-mode plasma has been achieved with fuel recycling and impurity level maintained stable. This result extends the previous record of a 403 s long-pulse H-mode plasma Gong et al (2024 Nucl. Fusion 64 112013) by over 200 s. It demonstrates the effectiveness of the dynamic powder injection technique in controlling fuel recycling and impurities accumulation, while prolonging plasma duration. These findings offer valuable insights into potential applications of other low-Z powder, such as boron, in ITER.
The Impurity Powder Dropper (IPD) is a device capable of injecting controlled amounts of sub-millimetre powder into the plasma under the action of gravity. In 2019 the IPD was first installed on the Large Helical Device (LHD) in Japan, with the aim of improving the plasma performances through real time boronization and assessing the compatibility of this technique with steady state operation. Extensive series of experiments have been performed using the IPD, focused on the improvement of the plasma performance via low-Z powder injection and the understanding of the underlying physical phenomena. In this article, we review the experiments that took place in the period 2019-2024. The main results include the demonstration of the improvement of the wall conditions (reduction of intrinsic impurity content, wall recycling) both on a shot-to-shot basis and in real time. Furthermore, a reduced-turbulence improved confinement regime has been observed coincident with powder injection, resulting in an increase of the plasma temperature of the order of 25%, with enhancements that can reach up to 50% for ion temperature.
Here, this article presents the design and performance characterization of a MINi Powder INjector (MINPIN) developed for boron wall conditioning (boronization) in the SMall Aspect Ratio Tokamak (SMART) at the University of Seville, Spain. SMART studies positive and negative triangularity plasmas within the low aspect ratio range of 1.4 < R/a < 3, with a major radius (R) of 0.40–0.60 m and a minor radius (a) of 0.20–0.33 m. MINPIN, in design, will gravitationally deliver boron (B) powder into the plasma, which ablates and transports the injected material. Mounted on the top of the vessel, the MINPIN will drop controlled amounts of powder using a piezoelectric blade driven by a signal generator that vibrates at a set frequency. The B will then be deposited in a layer on SMART’s stainless steel vacuum vessel walls, and this boronization process reduces the influx of intrinsic wall impurities, such as oxygen, carbon, nitrogen, and iron, which radiate power and cool the plasma. In the laboratory, we calibrated the drop rate for 1–10 mg/s, which will enable controlled boronization coating while achieving efficient powder ablation. We propose MINPIN’s operational scenarios based on the calibrated drop rate and estimated drop duration, assuming the distance from MINPIN to SMART’s plasmas.
Abstract Boron (B) powder injection is a potential alternative to glow discharge boronization as a wall conditioning method for tokamaks. This technique is currently being studied in WEST experiments, during which B powder is injected by an Impurity Powder Dropper developed by PPPL. In order to interpret and analyse experimental trends, and to help develop future experiments, a modelling workflow using a boundary plasma simulation (SOLEDGE-EIRENE) and powder ablation simulation (Dust Injection Simulator) was developed and tested. The effect of adding a B neutral source to simulated deuterium + oxygen (D + O) plasmas was compared to experimental data from the WEST C5 campaign, where B powder was injected in a dedicated experiment. While the impact of B injection on radiated power P rad measurements at the upper divertor was similar, there were significant differences in measurements of P rad , outer strike point electron temperature T e OSP and O-II line intensity at the lower divertor between experiment and simulation. This discrepancy suggests that those parameters were affected by phenomena not present in the simulations, with the most likely candidates being reduced D recycling and a reduced O sourcing from the divertor.
The main objective of this research program is to design, manufacture, and demonstrate a miniaturized, multi-process, monitoring system (mMPMS) for boiler condition management and easy system deployment to obtain a higher spatial resolution of wall conditions in utility boilers. This system will facilitate a Condition-Based Maintenance (CBM) philosophy that actively monitors the health of assets to predict and prevent failures and maximize availability and generating capacity at a reduced cost. CBM systems can provide boiler data that the advanced process control (APC) system can utilize for plant performance optimization, which is increasingly relevant as coal power plants shift from predominantly base-load operation to predominantly transient operation involving large load swings. The mMPMS is based on an electrochemical sensor that provides a real-time indication of the risk of damage to key locations in the radiant or convective section of a coal-fired boiler such as metal loss rates, heat flux, metal surface temperature, and deposit thickness. These indications can be utilized to optimize boiler performance as well as improve boiler availability in conjunction with corresponding operating conditions. This monitoring system was developed and tested in the high-temperature regions of a coal-fired utility boiler in this project but can be applied to many other industries and applications as well. The new sensor design, leveraging the existing electrochemical noise-based monitoring system, is small enough to be installed through the webbing of the waterwalls without the need for long shut-downs to bend tubes and to make it feasible to obtain high spatial resolution in the boiler. Data can be transferred to the plant distributed control system (DCS) and any other control system. The sensor body that houses the sensor assembly was designed to ensure good conductive contact with boiler tubes to ensure the sensor is held at an identical temperature to the tube surface temperature. The data acquisition and signal conditioning modules were redesigned into a small footprint with optimized cooling of the module. System software was developed specifically for the new signal conditioning module and is compatible with plant PLCs. After the preliminary testing at a pilot-scale facility, five mMPMS were installed at a full-scale pulverized coal-fired plant, Basin Electric Power Cooperative’s Leland Olds Unit 1. The systems were demonstrated over a 6-week period during typical operation. Sensor measurements of deposit thickness were validated during the demonstration and subsequently leveraged to determine sensor-based boiler cleaning strategies. These strategies have the benefit of reduced thermal stresses on boiler tubes from over-cleaning and improved boiler water management. At the end of the project, continued development of the sensor technology was carried out at PacifiCorp’s Hunter Station. REI leveraged the permanent installation of the mMPMS in Unit 3 made possible by DOE funding on a separate program. The work at Hunter Plant focused on application of machine learning and artificial intelligence-based models for integration of sensor signals into control and optimization of Hunter Unit 3 processes.
The ADITYA upgrade (ADITYA-U), a medium-sized (R 0 = 75 cm, a = 25 cm) conventional tokamak facility in India, has been consistently producing experiments findings by usingcircular and shaped-plasmas. Recognizing the plasma parameters aligning closely with the design parameters of circular limited plasmas, ADITYA-U shifted its focus toward exploring the operational regime for experimentation on saw-tooth and MHD phenomena. Moreover, ADITYA-U has made consistent advancements toward conducting preliminary plasma shaping experiments through the activation of top and bottom divertor coils utilizing hydrogen as well as deuterium fuels. Confinement is improved by a factor of ~1.5 in D 2 plasmas when compared to H 2 plasmas of ADITYA-U. Further, ADITYA-U operations emphasize preventing disruptions and runaway electrons (REs) to ensure safe operations for future fusion devices. Significant suppression of REs has been achieved in ADITYA-U with the application of pulsed localized vertical magnetic field (LVF) perturbation, thereby establishing the technique's independence from the tokamak device. The successful RE mitigation requires a critical threshold of LVF pulse magnitude, which is approximately 1% of the toroidal magnetic field, and a minimum duration of ~5 ms. Apart from this, several novel findings have been achieved in the ADITYA-U experiments, including the modification of sawtooth duration through gas-puff, the emergence of MHD-induced geodesic acoustic mode-like oscillations, the propagation of fast heat pulses induced by MHD activity, the control of RE dynamics through Gas-puffs, the propagation of pinch-driven cold-pulses, the transport and core accumulations of argon impurities, the mass dependency of plasma toroidal rotation and the detection of 'RICE' scaling, as well as the characterization of edge plasma using wall conditioning methods, such as glow discharge cleaning using a combination of Ar-H 2 mixture, localized wall cleaning by electron cyclotron resonant plasma, and the development of machine learning-based disruption predictions, will be discussed in this paper.
This study presents the first model intercomparison of aerosol‐cloud‐turbulence interactions in a controlled cloudy Rayleigh‐Bénard Convection chamber environment, utilizing the Pi Chamber at Michigan Technological University. We analyzed simulated cloud chamber‐averaged statistics of microphysics and thermodynamics in a warm‐phase, cloudy environment under steady‐state conditions at varying aerosol injection rates. Simulation results from seven distinct models (DNS, LES, and a 1D turbulence model) were compared. Our findings demonstrate that while all models qualitatively capture observed trends in droplet number concentration, mean radius, and droplet size distributions at both high and low aerosol injection rates, significant quantitative differences were observed. Notably, droplet number concentrations varied by over two orders of magnitude between models for the same injection rates, indicating sensitivities to the model treatments in droplet activation and removal and wall fluxes. Furthermore, inconsistencies in vertical relative humidity profiles and in achieving steady‐state liquid water content suggest the need for further investigation into the mechanisms driving these variations. Despite these discrepancies, the models generally reproduced consistent power‐law relationships between the microphysical variables. This model intercomparison underscores the importance of controlled cloud chamber experiments for validating and improving cloud microphysical parameterizations. Recommendations for future modeling studies are also highlighted, including constraining wall conditions and processes, investigating droplet/aerosol removal (including sidewall losses), and conducting simplified experiments to isolate specific processes contributing to model divergence and reduce model uncertainties.
In the Large Helical Device (LHD), boronization is utilized for wall conditioning, employing two distinct methods: glow discharge using diborane gas and the injection of boron powder into the plasma via an impurity powder dropper (IPD). Glow discharge boronization is conducted after maintenance when the vacuum vessel is exposed to air and just before the start of an experimental campaign. In contrast, real-time boronization using the IPD is performed during discharges. The distribution of boron on plasma-facing components was assessed through long-term material probes in the case of glow discharge and through numerical simulations for the IPD method. Results indicated non-uniform boron distributions in both cases. The impact of these boronization techniques on impurity levels and the lifetime of their effects were also examined. Both methods effectively reduced oxygen and iron in the plasma, with the iron impurities originating from the first wall. For glow discharge boronization, the reduction in oxygen levels persisted until the end of the experimental campaign, whereas the reduction in iron levels only lasted a few days. In the case of boron injection during long pulse discharges exceeding 200 s, the suppression of oxygen and iron was observed. The effect on iron quickly diminished within several seconds after the injection ended, whereas the effect on oxygen lasted more than 100 s. The difference in the lifetimes of the boronization effects is further discussed.
Boronization is a commonly used method of wall conditioning in fusion reactors. The application of boron films to the plasma-facing materials results in enhanced plasma performance due to the reduction of intrinsic impurities. This is primarily driven by a reduction in oxygen content that is chemically trapped in the boron film. The reactive nature of these boron films also raises questions concerning interactions with hydrogen isotopes. In this work, boron-deuterium interactions were studied using molecular dynamics (MD). Reactive force field potentials were used to model the chemical interactions between B and D. An amorphous boron substrate was irradiated by D atoms at varying incident energies, 10 eV < E i < 150 eV and angles, 0° < α < 85°. The reflection probability was calculated and compared to results from the commonly-used binary collision approximation (BCA) method. This comparison found that the BCA underestimated the reflection probability at E i < 35 eV and α > 45 ∘ . The source of this discrepancy was found to be the surface binding energy model. The BCA calculation with an isotropic surface binding energy model was more closely aligned to the MD result. This, in combination with a correction function based on the MD results allows for corrections to the reflection probability of deuterium impinging on boron surfaces. The sputtering of the substrate material was also studied. While this study did not contain sufficient events to quantitatively describe the sputtering behavior, some qualitative results emerged: namely, chemical sputtering of B and D-containing molecules (BD, BD 2 , BD 3 ) at low ( < 20 eV) incident deuterium energies. This result suggests that chemical sputtering could be a significant factor in limiting boron coating lifetime when exposed to lower ion energies, such as those in detached plasmas. The results show that chemical interactions should be taken into account when modeling the interactions between D ions and B surfaces.