Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Cao, Yan

Publications and source records attributed to Cao, Yan.

At least 19 records

Transient Modeling and Simulation of a Generic Stable Salt Reactor

A SAM system-level model of a generic stable salt reactor has been developed to investigate thermal-hydraulic behavior and safety performance under steady and transient conditions. The model integrates information generated from a reactor physics analysis using PROTEUS and PERSENT, and a computation fluid dynamics (CFD) analysis using STAR-CCM+. A loose, iterative coupling scheme between PROTEUS and SAM is implemented to calculate the equilibrium power and temperature distributions in the steady-state critical core condition. The converged steady-state model is then used in PERSENT to calculate the four reactivity feedback temperature coefficients (Doppler, fuel density, coolant density, and core radial expansion) and kinetic parameters that are needed in SAM to model the temperature feedback effects in transient simulations. Within the fully enclosed liquid fuel pins, natural convection is the dominant heat transfer mechanism. The STAR-CCM+ model of the fuel pin considers conjugate heat transfer from the liquid fuel salt to the pin cladding and external reactor coolant. The CFD results of the axial and radial temperature profiles are used to empirically determine an effective fuel salt thermal conductivity in the SAM fuel pin model so that the temperatures predicted by the SAM model match as closely as possible the CFD results. In the central region of the fuel pin, the effective thermal conductivity is as high as similar to 60 times the physical fuel salt thermal conductivity. The whole-plant SAM model is then used to simulate an unprotected station blackout transient. The results of this simulation showed that the large negative fuel axial expansion reactivity feedback reduces fission power to similar to 2.4% nominal power. The core is cooled by natural circulation, which removes heat in the core to the emergency heat removal system, and ultimately, to the ambient. However, peak fuel salt and cladding temperatures can potentially reach as high as 1500 K, albeit briefly, if the shutdown mechanism fails to operate.

stable salt reactor; transient simulations; system↗

Stochastic Optimization to Find Optimum Beginning-of-Life Core Configuration of Stable Salt Reactor with Online Refueling

A stochastic optimization method has been developed to find an optimum equilibrium cycle core configuration of the waste-burning stable salt reactor, which is a fast-spectrum molten salt reactor with frequent online refueling. An optimum core configuration was determined with the goal of minimizing radial power peaking. Because of the vast number of potential candidate core configurations, stochastic optimization was applied based on simulated annealing and an additional acceleration method, which screened out unpromising core configurations. It has been demonstrated that the developed stochastic optimization method successfully finds the optimal core configuration regardless of the initial guess and outperforms the gradient descent approach. In addition, it has been observed that the use of a so-called out-in core configuration as the initial guess speeds up convergence of the iterative solution more than five times. Based on the searched optimum equilibrium cycle core configuration, new beginning-of-life (BOL) core configurations have been developed. In conclusion, the new BOL core configurations will be used in developing optimum refueling strategies.

Moltex static salt reactor↗

High-Fidelity Multiphysics Modeling of a Heat Pipe Microreactor Using BlueCrab

Researchers who are actively developing nuclear microreactors are planning to employ innovative designs and features using traditional commercial modeling tools that may be inadequate for their design and licensing activities. The codes developed under the U.S. Department of Energy Office of Nuclear Energy Advanced Modeling and Simulation (NEAMS) program provide flexibility in terms of geometry modeling and multiphysics coupling and are particularly well suited for modeling novel microreactor concepts. To test the maturity of these codes, this paper introduces a conceptual heat pipe microreactor (HP-MR) designed to gather various technologies of interest to microreactor developers such as control drums, heat pipes, and hydride moderators. Here, the objective of this effort is to demonstrate NEAMS tools capability to perform high-fidelity multiphysics simulations, using coupled neutronics (via the Griffin code), heat conduction (via the BISON code), heat pipe modeling (via the Sockeye code), and hydrogen redistribution in hydride metal moderator (via the SWIFT code). Codes are coupled in-memory through the Multiphysics Object-Oriented Simulation Environment (MOOSE) framework, which permits flexible multiphysics data transfer schemes. The analysis confirmed two key aspects of the HP-MR concept: (1) its ability to follow the power load requested from the heat pipe and (2) its ability to avoid heat pipe cascading failure unless designed with high power close to operating failure limits of its heat pipes. The developed computational model was distributed publicly on the Virtual Test Bed for training purposes to accelerate adoption by industry and to provide a high-fidelity multiphysics solution for benchmarking against other tools. Additional multiphysics analyses including other transients and coupled physics were identified as necessary future work, together with a focus on validating multiphysics behavior against experiments.

Microreactor↗

Modeling Radionuclide Inventories in MSR Off-Gas Systems with Radiochemical Transport Analysis

Molten salt reactors (MSR) contain unique characteristics that may require enhancements to modeling tools to accurately predict phenomena. One characteristic that may be advantageous to leverage during normal operation is on-line processing of the circulating fuel salt, such as an off-gas system (OGS) to remove volatile fission products. Therefore, new modeling tools must be developed to integrate spatial resolution and chemistry effects into fuel depletion tools to be able to account for these non-core sources of radioactivity. Such types of radiochemical transport analysis tools were used to estimate the removal rates for 12 elements within a flow model of the Molten Salt Reactor Experiment (MSRE) by optimizing against legacy experimental data of the gas-borne (GB) percentages of 12 nuclides. The removal rates were used in a depletion model to calculate the FP inventory that enters the MSRE OGS. Calculations are in good agreement with the empirical GB percentages reported for the 12 nuclides, which validates the approach and verifies each tool’s treatment of the radiochemical flow effects. The OGS inventory is discussed in terms of the largest nuclide contributors to activity, dose consequence, decay heat, and elemental composition. Finally, insights from the study allow recommendations to be made for future code development activities.

Shahbazi, Shayan↗

The importance of delayed neutron precursors in gamma dose calculations for activated primary heat exchanger components in the Molten Salt Breeder Reactor

The Molten Salt Reactor (MSR) Multiphysics Applications technical area in the Nuclear Energy Advanced Modeling and Simulation program has supported the development of 3D Monte Carlo models of the Molten Salt Breeder Reactor (MSBR) over the last couple of years. This MSBR model was previously run with the Shift Monte Carlo code to perform radiation shielding calculations in the reactor cell area. The MSBR is a 2250 MWth (1000 MWe) liquid-fueled molten salt reactor design developed at Oak Ridge National Laboratory in the 1970s. Determining the source terms from activated primary heat exchanger (HX) components is important because delayed and prompt neutron fluxes incident on these components affect the dose rate in the primary HX maintenance areas. This information can be used in the development of remote handling procedures required during shutdown for maintenance. A methodology has been developed and is proposed in this paper to quantify the activated source term from the primary HX components as a result of the movement of the delayed neutron precursors in flowing primary fuel salt through the primary HXs in the MSBR. The goal of this research is to evaluate the gamma dose rates in the maintenance hatches above the primary HX using the activated HX source terms. The study showed that the gamma dose rates are approximately two orders of magnitudes higher when accounting for the neutron activation from the movement of delayed neutron precursors through the HXs than when flowing fuel is not considered. Thus, the movement of delayed neutron precursors must be taken into account for accurately predicting the neutron activation of primary loop components.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Molten Salt Reactor Experiment Simulation using Shift/Griffin

The Department of Energy (DOE)’s NEAMS focuses its efforts on the development of advanced modeling and simulation (M&S) tools for light-water reactors (LWRs) and non–LWRs (i.e., molten salt reactors, high-temperature gas reactors, microreactors, and fast reactors). In the previous fiscal year, the Multiphysics Applications Driver Technical Area funded molten salt reactor (MSR) M&S at Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) to generate multigroup macroscopic cross sections with Shift for a MSRE 2D lattice model in Griffin. In addition, Shift’s capability to calculate gamma dose rates from activated components in the primary exchangers in a molten salt breeder reactor was also demonstrated. In fiscal year 2023, ORNL generated multigroup macroscopic cross sections using Shift for a 3D MSRE core model. MSRE depletion calculations using Griffin were also demonstrated in this fiscal year. For the depletion calculation, one-group microscopic cross sections for the 3D MSRE core were generated using Shift, and the decay transmutation library from ORIGEN was converted to an ISOXML file, which is required as input in Griffin. Several Monte Carlo codes, such as OpenMC and Serpent, were also used to benchmark and supplement multigroup cross sections generated by Shift. Multigroup libraries were generated with 8 and 20 group structures, and the study found the 8-group structure to be more accurate when comparing Griffin results to continuous energy (CE) Monte Carlo results. The average flux from CE Shift calculations is up to ~6% higher than the CE Serpent calculations because of different values applied for the energy released per fission (κ values). The average flux in the fuel salt calculated by Griffin using cross sections generated with Shift agrees well with the reference CE Shift solution; the same is valid for the corresponding Serpent results. The maximum relative error is ~6% and ~2% compared to the CE Shift and Serpent reference solutions, respectively. Meanwhile, the average flux calculated by Griffin in the graphite moderator shows a higher difference in the thermal range when compared to both reference Monte Carlo solutions; this result suggests a need for improvement in cross section generation for the graphite moderator in the thermal range in both Monte Carlo codes. Griffin depletion calculations using cross sections from Shift and Serpent were performed and compared against ORIGEN calculations, and the nuclide densities calculated by Griffin were found to be generally in agreement with those of ORIGEN. Because a different approach was taken to calculate the energy released per fission ( κ values) in Shift and Serpent, a difference in nuclide densities from differences in the average flux was observed between Griffin using Serpent and Shift cross sections. Griffin calculations with Shift cross sections produced higher average flux in the salt than with Serpent cross sections, leading to higher consumption of 235 U and higher production of 135 Xe. For time-dependent depletion calculations, cross sections were generated with Serpent, and Griffin’s results using these cross sections were compared to CE Serpent depletion results, demonstrating good agreement. The average difference in keff between Serpent and Griffin as a function of burnup is about 155 pcm. Similarly, good agreement with small differences up to ~0.5% was also noticed in the nuclide density of 235 U and 135 Xe. More details regarding the methodologies invoked to generate the cross section to make code-to-code comparisons are discussed further in this report. User feedback on Griffin and Shift capabilities that will enhance these calculations is provided in this report for future consideration. The work performed this fiscal year can be extended further for multiphysics coupling of Griffin-Pronghorn/SAM with Mole to study precursor flow and salt chemistry.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Numerical Studies of the On-Line Reactivity Monitoring Techniques in Subcritical Systems: Revisit of the Area-Ratio Method, the Neutron Source-Modulation Method, and the Flux-to-Current Ratio Method

In the subcritical systems, the subcriticality level must be monitored continuously to ensure the safe operation of the systems. Techniques such as the neutron source-modulation method and the flux-to-current ratio method have been proposed for on-line reactivity measurements of the subcritical systems. However, the accuracy of these methods is unknown in the actual applications. In this report, the fundamental concepts of these techniques are visited, with numerical simulation techniques developed to validate these on-line reactivity monitoring methodologies. Specifically, the Monte Carlo numerical simulation results show that the neutron source-modulation method is not accurate in determining the reactivity of the subcritical systems. The flux-to-current ratio method can provide on-line reactivity measurements, and its spatial effects have been studied and well understood through the numerical simulations of the fuel loading of the neutron source facility of Ukraine. In addition, a modified version of the area-ratio method is proposed for the on-line measurements of the absolute reactivity of the subcritical systems. Monte Carlo numerical simulations showed that this method can provide the absolute reactivity of the subcritical systems within ~5% error, if the neutron detectors are placed close to the fuel assembly interface with the reflector zone or in the reflector zones away from the neutron source.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Multiphysics simulations of Self-Regulating performance of an optimized molten metal fuel microreactor design

Advanced microreactors are expected to play an indispensable role in reliable energy solutions for civilian/ military applications in off-grid regions and space applications such as power supplies for Lunar and Mars bases. An innovative fast neutron spectrum heat pipe microreactor (HP-MR) concept was recently proposed with two unique features: molten U-Mn fuel and heat pipes as the heat removal mechanism. The microreactor was designed to be self-regulated, solely relying on reactivity feedbacks from fuel temperature. The reactor design has been further optimized to provide sufficient engineering safety margin and effective heat removal. In this study, the self-regulating performance of the optimized molten metal fuel microreactor was investigated by multi-physics simulations (neutronics, heat-transfer and heat pipe modeling) based on the MOOSE MultiApps system. In conclusion, the responses of the reactor to a series of transient scenarios were simulated to demonstrate the exceptional and inherent safety features of the novel microreactor concept.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Practical Multi-Cycle Refueling Simulation of Stable Salt Reactors Based on REBUS Depletion Calculation

A Python software tool ReloadPy has been developed to assistant in formulating online refueling strategies for a family of stable salt reactors. ReloadPy wraps over the legacy fast reactor analysis codes REBUS, DIF3D, and PERSENT. These codes are used to perform single cycle depletion analysis and calculate reactivity worth and power density. ReloadPy determines a refueling assembly position to achieve the user-specified primary objective while satisfying constraints on various performance parameters such as the maximum power density, the maximum reactivity worth of reloaded assembly, and the minimum cycle length. Various capabilities of prescribing refueling sequence or a range of candidate refueling positions and restarting a previous simulation with altered options are implemented to reduce the required user’s efforts to investigate different refueling strategies. This report presents the computational models and methods and also serves as a user guide. Long-term simulation capabilities with different refueling strategies are demonstrated by a series of sample SSR refueling calculations with two-dimensional surrogate core models.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Neutron Source Facility of the National Science Center “Kharkiv Institute of Physics and Technology” at Kharkiv, Ukraine

Argonne National Laboratory developed, designed, and supported the construction of a state-of-the-art Neutron Source Facility (NSF) at the Kharkov Institute of Physics and Technology (KIPT) in Kharkov Ukraine, under the U.S. DOE NNSA Russian Research Reactor Fuel Return (RRRFR) program. Ukraine approved the return of all highly enriched uranium in the country to Russia prior to the 2012 Nuclear Security Summit in return for the RRRFR program to fund the development, the design, and the construction of the NSF. The facility is designed to produce medical isotopes, train nuclear professionals, support the Ukrainian nuclear industry, and provide experimental capabilities for performing reactor physics, materials, and basic science research. The NSF was successfully started and operated in August 2021. The NSF is the first facility of this type in the world, and it will be used to understand the physics of driven systems for energy production and the disposal of spent nuclear fuels. The NSF consists of a subcritical assembly using low enriched uranium (LEU) fuel driven with an electron accelerator. The NSF target design utilizes tungsten or natural uranium for producing neutrons through photonuclear reactions using 100-MeV electrons. The accelerator power is 100 KW, which produces 3x10 14 neutrons per second from the uranium target. The subcritical assembly is designed to obtain the highest possible neutron flux intensity with an effective neutron multiplication factor of less than 0.98. Passive safety, reliability, and environmental considerations were included in the NSF design. The NSF utilization study shows that this neutron source has the capability of producing different medical isotopes. Several horizontal neutron channels are incorporated for performing applied and basic research. The NSF is configured to accommodate future design upgrades and new missions. The facility design was approved by the Ukraine Academy of Sciences before starting the NSF construction. The construction, the equipment installation, and the operation of the different systems of the NSF were completed and approved by the Ukrainian regulators. In July 2020, the State Nuclear Regulatory Inspectorate of Ukraine (SNRIU) issued a license for the physical startup of the NSF. The construction of facility was completed in early 2021.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Multiphysics Analysis of Load Following and Safety Transients for MicroReactors

The tools developed within the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) Office of Nuclear Energy’s Nuclear Energy Advanced Modeling and Simulation (NEAMS) program aim at providing high fidelity multiphysics modeling capabilities to support design and licensing of various types of advanced nuclear reactors, including the technologies being developed by U.S. microreactor vendors relying on heat pipe and gas-cooled technologies. In FY-2022, the NEAMS Multiphysics Applications team made significant progress both in demonstrating capabilities applied to microreactor problems, and in supporting NEAMS developers.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Application of Monte Carlo code SHIFT for MSBR dose rate calculations

This paper presents a study that applied the Monte Carlo code SHIFT to calculate the radiological environment within a detailed Molten Salt Breeder Reactor (MSBR) model. It represents one of the first applications of the SHIFT code in stand-alone simulations for non-light water reactors to help demonstrate the code's potential uses in the design, licensing, and operation of advanced reactors. The radiological conditions of the MSBR were modeled when the reactor is at two different operation modes: normal full power and a drained state. The Forward Weighted-Consistent Adjoint Driven Importance Sampling (FW-CADIS) hybrid method in SHIFT was applied successfully to calculate the ex-core neutron and gamma dose rates for the MSBR at full power. Neutron and gamma dose rates within the drain cell were also calculated for the MSBR at the drained state by integrating the source terms obtained from an ORIGEN-S depletion calculation into the SHIFT simulation. The results indicate that in the drained state, the delayed gammas from the depleted fuel salt are the main contributors to the dose rates. (authors)

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Versatile Heat Transfer Module

Development of micro-reactors that can be easily transported to remote areas for civilian or military applications is an immediate focus of U.S. nuclear industry and therefore is being pursued by multiple reactor vendors (e.g. HolosGen LLC, Westinghouse, Ultra Safe Nuclear Corporation, URENCO, etc.) and actively supported by DOE-NE, DOE-ARPA-E and by the Department Of Defense (DoD). Very-high-temperature gas-cooled (VHTR) and heat pipe cooled reactor technologies are regarded as promising concepts for microreactors applications since they enable compact power conversion systems and display beneficial inherent safety features. Development of microreactors with enhanced performance must be supported by innovations in nuclear technologies. Several technologies being developed by the microreactor industry are being revisited with material technologies developed at the Argonne National Laboratory (ANL). Innovative high-temperature compatible solutions are developed to enable advanced thermal-spectrum microreactor designs featuring improved neutronics performance at high-temperature operating conditions to enable high thermal efficiency and economic competitiveness. This report focuses on the Versatile Heat Transfer Module (VHTM) technology that is developed at ANL for heat-transfer in thermal-spectrum microreactors. This technology is built on a liquid alkali metal heat pipe concept while leveraging advanced nuclear material technologies for high-temperature applications at reduced neutronic penalty with potential improvement in inherent safety behavior. The VHTM can be applied to design high-temperature thermal-spectrum microreactor systems with reduced size, weight, uranium enrichment, or increased lifetime. The INFINIT technology deriving from the VHTM enables design of a highly compact long-life microreactor concept for fission surface power (FSP). Demonstration of multiphysics modeling capability was also completed to showcase the added inherent safety benefits obtained with this concept. The VHTM technology remain at an early development stage with low Technology Readiness Level and Manufacturing Readiness Level. The current demonstration of these technologies has focused on manufacturing capability, on performance of the hydrogen diffusion barrier under thermal cycling, while radiation tolerance demonstration is planned. The next step of the demonstration plan will be the assembly of miniature VHTM for high-temperature testing, which can be used as a prototype for future pilot scale demonstration. Such research is critical to pursue development of these technologies that have the clear potential to significantly improve the performance of currently investigated micro-reactors systems.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Monte Carlo Simulations of the Water Draining Experiment of Giacint Critical Assembly

The MCNP6 computer program has been successfully extended to simulate reactor dynamics problems with moving parts of the geometries. Different from the dynamic method developed in other Monte Carlo codes, a movement scheme has been developed to account for the geometrical parts motion during the particle random walk. The MCNP6 computer program has been used to simulate two transient experiments of the Giacint critical assembly. The MCNP6 calculated total neutron flux was compared with that from the Serpent simulation. An excellent agreement was obtained between the results of the two Monte Caro computer programs. The MCNP6 calculated total neutron flux was also compared with the two measured transients. The MCNP6 results predicted a faster transient than the experimental data. The MCNP6 transient simulation was improved with an adjusted geometrical model which shifts the fuel rods slightly to match the measured reactivity worth due to the drained water. (c) 2021 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

MCNP, Moving Geometries, Monte Carlo Reactor Trans↗

Integration of a Wigner effect-based energy storage system with an advanced nuclear reactor

In this work, an innovative energy storage concept based on the purposeful creation of defects in crystalline material by neutron irradiation is presented. Lattice defects are generated when heavy particles collide with the atoms in a crystal structure, i.e., if the incoming particles have enough energy, recoil atoms are displaced from their initial lattice sites. Most of the displaced atoms will eventually combine with nearby vacancies, but some of them will come to rest in non-ideal locations. The energy held by displaced atoms is called Wigner energy. Lattice defects can migrate and form clusters, and the Wigner energy can be released from these groupings if sufficient activation energy is provided. In the nuclear industry, this effect is well-known since it represented an issue for graphite-moderated reactors. This work presents the conceptual design of an engineering system that exploits this physical process to store the energy of neutrons in advanced reactor concepts. In the first part of the paper, the theoretical performance of an energy storage system based on the Wigner effect is described. Given the lattice properties and the compatibility with the harsh reactor environment, graphite was selected as the candidate material for the irradiation targets. Both experimental data and molecular dynamics simulations confirmed that this system can achieve performance comparable with state-of-the-art batteries in terms of stored energy density. In the second part of the paper, the engineering challenges of this innovative technology and the proposed solutions are described. After defining the optimal irradiation conditions, the different steps of the operation of the proposed energy system (from energy storing to energy harvesting) were defined. Finally, the integration of this concept with advanced reactor designs, i.e., a Sodium-cooled Fast Reactor and a Molten Salt-cooled Reactor, was investigated and the corresponding performance was evaluated.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Application of Shift Ex-Core Calculations to a Detailed MSR Model

This report documents the collaborative research conducted between Argonne National Laboratory (ANL) and Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) on applying the Monte Carlo neutronics code Shift to calculate the radiation dose rates for a detailed molten salt reactor (MSR) model based on the Molten Salt Breeder Reactor (MSBR). In this work scope, the ANL and ORNL teams worked together and applied Shift to calculate the radiological environments of this detailed MSR facility modeled with explicit geometries. The radiological conditions within the MSR facility were modeled for when the reactor is at two different operation modes: normal full power and drained state. The FW-CADIS hybrid method in Shift was applied successfully to calculate the ex-core neutron and gamma dose rates for the MSBR at full power. Dose rate maps showed that in the current MSBR numerical model, potential pathways exist for neutrons and gammas to stream through the 8-foot concrete shield to reach the top of the MSBR reactor cell. Neutron and gamma dose rates within the drain cell were also calculated for the MSBR at the drained state by integrating the source terms obtained from an ORIGEN-S depletion calculation into the Shift simulation. The results indicate that in the drained state, the delayed gammas from the depleted fuel salt are the main contributors to the dose rates, which suggests that a steel liner in the tank model must be added for calculating the dose rates in the drain cell.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Assessment of Tools for Molten Salt Reactor Dose Rate Calculations

This report discusses a preliminary assessment of the capabilities of current state-of-the-art stochastic codes Shift and MCNP6 to calculate the ex-core radiation dose rates for a simplified Molten Salt Reactor (MSR) model. The Monte Carlo code Shift has been under significant development in recent years at ORNL as part of the CASL program and is now supported by NEAMS. Originally, Shift was developed for LWR ex-core calculations but with dose rate and shielding calculations specifically requested by the NEAMS program’s MSR industry partners, the MSR Application Drivers team was tasked with assessing Shift for non-LWR applications. This was the first application of the Shift code for non-LWRs and the findings can be considered preliminary due to the activities occurring only over a 5-month period. Attractive features of Shift include massive parallelization and advanced automated variance reduction techniques such as CADIS and FW-CADIS.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗