Analysis of the Startup of Watts Bar Nuclear Unit 2 using VERA
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Engineering topics
Publications and source records attributed to Collins, Benjamin.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
The recent interest in molten salt reactor technology by the nuclear industry has sparked significant interest in developing modeling and simulation tools for molten salt reactors. The MPACT whole core transport solver has been adapted to address several unique features of molten salt reactors. This paper discusses implementation of a depletion methodology which simulates the mixing of fuel throughout the core, the continuous removal of fission products, and the continuous addition of new fuel into the system. It also presents the methodology used to treat the transport of delayed neutron precursors. These new methods are demonstrated using models based on Transatomic Power Corporation’s molten salt reactor design.
This paper summarizes improvements in the coarse mesh finite difference (CMFD) performance by focusing on the eigenvalue solution methodology. The current solution technique uses a shifted power iteration with the PETSc solver package. A generalized Davidson methodology has been implemented into MPACT using the Trilinos solver package. The new generalized Davidson solver shows significant improvements in the overall runtime for the CMFD acceleration scheme and the overall MPACT performance. The performance improves between 5 and 27 times for the CMFD runtime. This results in a speedup of between 2.5 to 5 times on the overall solution time for MPACT.
The MPACT code, being developed collaboratively by the University of Michigan and Oak Ridge National Laboratory, is the primary deterministic neutron transport solver being deployed within the Virtual Environment for Reactor Applications (VERA) as part of the Consortium for Advanced Simulation of Light Water Reactors (CASL). In many applications of the MPACT code, transport-corrected scattering has proven to be an obstacle in terms of stability, and considerable effort has been made to try to resolve the convergence issues that arise from it. Most of the convergence problems seem related to the transport-corrected cross sections, particularly when used in the 2D method of characteristics (MOC) solver, which is the focus of this work. Here in this paper, the stability and performance of the 2-D MOC solver in MPACT is evaluated for two iteration schemes: Gauss-Seidel and Jacobi. With the Gauss-Seidel approach, as the MOC solver loops over groups, it uses the flux solution from the previous group to construct the inscatter source for the next group. Alternatively, the Jacobi approach uses only the fluxes from the previous outer iteration to determine the inscatter source for each group. Consequently for the Jacobi iteration, the loop over groups can be moved from the outermost loop$-$as is the case with the Gauss-Seidel sweeper$-$to the innermost loop, allowing for a substantial increase in efficiency by minimizing the overhead of retrieving segment, region, and surface index information from the ray tracing data. Several test problems are assessed: (1) Babcock & Wilcox 1810 Core I, (2) Dimple S01A-Sq, (3) VERA Progression Problem 5a, and (4) VERA Problem 2a. The Jacobi iteration exhibits better stability than Gauss-Seidel, allowing for converged solutions to be obtained over a much wider range of iteration control parameters. Additionally, the MOC solve time with the Jacobi approach is roughly 2.0-2.5× faster per sweep. While the performance and stability of the Jacobi iteration are substantially improved compared to the Gauss-Seidel iteration, it does yield a roughly 8$-$10% increase in the overall memory requirement.
This paper describes the methodology developed and implemented in the Virtual Environment for Reactor Applications Core Simulator (VERA-CS) to perform high-fidelity, pressurized water reactor (PWR), multicycle, core physics calculations. Depletion of the core with pin-resolved power and nuclide detail is a significant advance in the state of the art for reactor analysis, providing the level of detail necessary to address the problems of the U.S. Department of Energy Nuclear Reactor Simulation Hub, the Consortium for Advanced Simulation of Light Water Reactors (CASL). VERA-CS has three main components: the neutronics solver MPACT, the thermal-hydraulic (T-H) solver COBRA-TF (CTF), and the nuclide transmutation solver ORIGEN. This paper focuses on MPACT and provides an overview of the resonance self-shielding methods, macroscopic-cross-section calculation, two-dimensional/one-dimensional (2-D/1-D) transport, nuclide depletion, T-H feedback, and other supporting methods representing a minimal set of the capabilities needed to simulate high-fidelity models of a commercial nuclear reactor. Results are presented from the simulation of a model of the first cycle of Watts Bar Unit 1. The simulation is within 16 parts per million boron (ppmB) reactivity for all state points compared to cycle measurements, with an average reactivity bias of <5 ppmB for the entire cycle. Comparisons to cycle 1 flux map data are also provided, and the average 2-D root-mean-square (rms) error during cycle 1 is 1.07%. To demonstrate the multicycle capability, a state point at beginning of cycle (BOC) 2 was also simulated and compared to plant data. The comparison of the cycle 2 BOC state has a reactivity difference of +3 ppmB from measurement, and the 2-D rms of the comparison in the flux maps is 1.77%. Lastly, these results provide confidence in VERA-CS’s capability to perform high-fidelity calculations for practical PWR reactor problems.
A consistent “2D/1D” neutron transport method is derived from the 3D Boltzmann transport equation, to calculate fuel-pin-resolved neutron fluxes for realistic full-core Pressurized Water Reactor (PWR) problems. The 2D/1D method employs the Method of Characteristics to discretize the radial variables and a lower order transport solution to discretize the axial variable. This paper describes the theory of the 2D/1D method and its implementation in the MPACT code, which has become the whole-core deterministic neutron transport solver for the Consortium for Advanced Simulations of Light Water Reactors (CASL) core simulator VERA-CS. Several applications have been performed on both leadership-class and industry-class computing clusters. Results are presented for whole-core solutions of the Watts Bar Nuclear Power Station Unit 1 and compared to both continuous-energy Monte Carlo results and plant data.
VERA, the Virtual Environment for Reactor Applications, is the system of physics capabilities being developed and deployed by the Consortium for Advanced Simulation of Light Water Reactors (CASL). CASL was established for the modeling and simulation of commercial nuclear reactors. VERA consists of integrating and interfacing software together with a suite of physics components adapted and/or refactored to simulate relevant physical phenomena in a coupled manner. VERA also includes the software development environment and computational infrastructure needed for these components to be effectively used. We describe the architecture of VERA from both software and numerical perspectives, along with the goals and constraints that drove major design decisions, and their implications. We explain why VERA is an environment rather than a framework or toolkit, why these distinctions are relevant (particularly for coupled physics applications), and provide an overview of results that demonstrate the use of VERA tools for a variety of challenging applications within the nuclear industry.
The MPACT code provides the capability to calculate the steady-state and transient reactor core neutron distribution for operating nuclear power plant (PWR) conditions across multiple fuel cycles. As required in the CASL SQA plan, it is the responsibility of UM and ORNL as joint owners of MPACT to ensure that verification and validation activities are performed and documented in a V&V manual with supporting publications and CASL technical reports which can be distributed for reference and distribution within VERA. This document provides the first revision of the MPACT verification and validation (V&V) manual and describes the current state of MPACT V&V and updates the framework for future MPACT V&V activities. During FY16, MPACT V&V activities in the areas of code verification have continued to mature and work has progressed on code error evaluation using the Method of Manufactured Solutions (MMS). Several specific tasks have also been completed to improve MPACT code verification to include tasks to improve the unit and regression test coverage. A joint UM/ORNL task was completed to develop standardize coding standards and workflow for the continued collaborative development of MPACT. During the past year, MPACT validation work has continued in both the areas of measured data from critical experiments as well as measured data from operating nuclear power plants. Preliminary work was also performed in FY16 on the use of post-irradiation examinations for evaluation and validation of the isotopic depletion capability in MPACT. Based on the results of V&V efforts this past year, the confidence level has increased in the ability of MPACT to model an operational Pressurized Water Reactor. Areas were identified which require increased emphasis during FY17 to include updating all the V&V problems with the new 51-group library, the completion of cycle 2 of the BEAVRS benchmark, initial validation for BWR applications, the addition of Uncertainty Quantification results into the benchmark results, and the completion of specific validation tasks for the CASL Challenge problems.
In recent weeks, attention has been given to resolving the convergence issues encountered with TCP 0 by trying a Jacobi (J) inscatter approach when group sweeping, where the inscatter source is constructed using the previous iteration flux. This is in contrast to a Gauss-Seidel (GS) approach, which has been the default to-date, where the scattering source uses the most up-to-date flux values. The former is consistent with CASMO, which has no issues with TCP 0 convergence. Testing this out on a variety of problems has demonstrated that the Jacobi approach does indeed provide substantially more stability, though can take more outer iterations to converge. While this is not surprising, there are improvements that can be made to the MOC sweeper to capitalize on the Jacobi approximation and provide substantial speedup. For example, the loop over groups, which has traditionally been the outermost loop in MPACT, can be moved to the interior, avoiding duplicate modular ray trace and coarse ray trace setup (mapping coarse mesh surface indexes), which needs to be performed repeatedly when group is outermost.
This report describes the performance improvements made to the VERA Core Simulator (VERA CS) during FY2016. At the beginning of the year, a timing study was performed to identify areas of the code where the run-times could be improved. This study identified six broad areas for improvement: • Cross section lookup and CMFD stabilization, • CTF parallel partitioning, • MOC methodology, • Subgroup methodology, • MOC parallel partitioning, and • CMFD Krylov solution techniques. The goal of this work was to reduce the VERA-CS run-times so a complete cycle depletion could be run with 1,000 cores overnight (i.e., the “1,000 core depletion” criterion). This goal was set by our industry partners so they could achieve reasonable turnaround on medium-sized computer clusters. The results presented in this report show a code speed-up by a factor of 5, which successfully satisfies the goal set by industry.
The MPACT code is the primary deterministic neutron transport solver available in the Virtual Environment for Reactor Applications (VERA) as part of the Consortium for Advanced Simulation of Light Water Reactors (CASL). In contrast to the conventional two-step method using homogenization techniques, MPACT employs a direct transport methodology, where the transport calculation is performed with the explicit reactor core geometry, material compositions, and temperature distribution. As the direct whole-core transport calculation requires significant computational resources, performance improvements have been recently conducted in various components of MPACT. The initial MPACT profiling was performed on the EOS cluster at the Oak Ridge Leadership Computing Facility. Table I shows that the cross section processing accounted for 74% and 33% of the total runtime for VERA Progression Problems 5 and 7. Starting with a problem-independent multigroup (MG) library, two primary functionalities are performed in MPACT to obtain the problem-dependent MG cross sections: (1) the resonance self-shielding calculation, which currently MPACT is approaching with the subgroup method; (2) use of equivalence cross section from resonance calculation to compute the microscopic cross sections, and thus, the macroscopic cross sections of material regions. As shown in Table I, the time distribution in cross section processing varies from case to case. For Problem 5, a 2-D quarter core depletion case, the macroscopic XS dominates due to the increased number of isotopes in the depleted fuel. For Problem 7, a 3-D quarter core PWR at HFP and BOL, more subgroup calculations are performed to obtain updated self-shielded cross sections during the iteration. In this summary, the approaches to reduce the computing time in cross section processing are presented. (authors)
As part of the Consortium for Advanced Simulation of Light Water Reactors (CASL), the Virtual Environment for Reactor Applications (VERA) is being developed to provide high-fidelity multi-physics simulations of nuclear reactor cores. The MPACT code being developed collaboratively by Oak Ridge National Laboratory and the University of Michigan includes the primary deterministic neutron transport solver available within VERA. MPACT employs the 2D/1D method to solve three-dimensional problems, using 2D method of characteristics (MOC) radial transport solvers with 1D NEM-SP3 axial transport solvers, which are coupled using axial and radial transverse leakages. A 3D coarse mesh finite difference (CMFD) solver is used to provide accelerated convergence that is more stable. The Portable, Extensible Tool kit for Scientific Computation (PETSc) generalized minimal residual (GMRES) iterative solver with a block Jacobi preconditioner has been used to solve the CMFD linear systems. This work focused on the addition of a red-black successive over-relaxation (RBSOR) solver to reduce overall runtime by reducing time spent solving the CMFD linear systems. (authors)
The report summarizes the initial profile of MPACT representative of the version that was distributed with VERA 3.4. It then describes several activities recently performed to increase the overall performance of the code. For the various improvements described in this report, several have been well known to the development team and reactor physics methods community for some time; while others proved novel in their combination of other existing ideas. Still, other improvements were the result of unanticipated breakthroughs in numerical methods research. These performance improvement activities focused on the following components of MPACT. Method of Characteristics Transport Kernel Iterative Methods for Coarse Mesh Finite Difference Linear System Macroscopic Cross Section and Effective Fission Spectrum Calculation Resonance self-shielding (Subgroup) calculation A summary of the overall improvement from this work as tested on a few representative problems is provided in the table below. The incremental improvements for various changes are shown in the figure below.
As the MPACT code has matured, the regression and validation base has grown significantly. However, the code is still undergoing advancements to the underlying methods, and improvements to the code have the possibility to change the solution. These types of methodological or data improvements should be encouraged but the requirement to rebaseline the entire regression and validation suite has recently become a daunting task which has made it more difficult to make improvements to the code. One of the objectives of this work is to streamline this process but also to provide diagnostics on the significance of the modification and the impact on several quantities of interest.
As the MPACT code has matured, the regression and validation base has grown significantly. However, the code is still undergoing advancements to the underlying methods, and improvements to the code have the possibility to change the solution. These types of methodological or data improvements should be encouraged but the requirement to rebaseline the entire regression and validation suite has recently become a daunting task which has made it more difficult to make improvements to the code. One of the objectives of this work is to streamline this process but also to provide diagnostics on the significance of the modification and the impact on several quantities of interest.
Not Available
Among the most important accomplishments during Phase 1 of the Consortium for Advanced Simulation of Light Water Reactors (CASL) is the development and deployment of what is known as VERA-CS, the steady-state nuclear reactor core simulation capability of the Virtual Environment for Reactor Applications, VERA. With this product CASL now has the ability to perform and support analyses relating to common evolutions of operating commercial pressurized water reactors (PWRs), including startup testing, power escalation, fuel cycle depletion, and fuel assembly discharge, reinsert, and shuffling. VERA-CS is a high-fidelity, multi-physics engineering tool that utilizes modest high-performance computing (HPC) systems and engineering-scale clusters to simultaneously simulate the local fuel rod neutronics and coolant channel thermal-hydraulics over the life of the reactor. Though it is still under development, the results demonstrated in this report provide encouraging evidence that VERA-CS will become highly acclaimed for industrial, scientific, and educational applications alike.
One of the challenge problems in CASL is to better understand the effects of CRUD on PWRs. One of the primary focuses of the CRUD work this year is the ability to simulate CRUD Induced Power Shift (CIPS). In order to meet this requirement, VERA-CS is being modified in order to model the space and time dependent deposition of CRUD onto the fuel and capture the effects it has on the local power and thermal hydraulic conditions in the core.