Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Collins, Benjamin

Publications and source records attributed to Collins, Benjamin.

At least 73 records · Page 4

Development of Preliminary VERA-CS Crud Induced Localized Corrosion Modeling Capability

The objective of this milestone was to develop a crud-induced localized corrosion (CILC) screening capability in VERA-CS using existing codes and capabilities that had been developed in the Consortium for Advanced Simulation of Light Water Reactors (CASL) as part of the efforts to resolve the crud challenge problem. The milestone work focused on improving existing CASL software and implementing clad corrosion modeling into VERA-CS. Clad corrosion modeling was implemented by creating an application interface (API) in the Cicada software so that its clad heat transfer and corrosion models could be used in VERA-CS. Cicada was coupled to the subchannel code CTF for solving crud and corrosion growth. Additionally, a clad corrosion model was added directly to CTF to serve as an alternate approach. The rod thermal hydraulic reconstruction (ROTHCON) process, which is used for capturing computational fluid dynamics (CFD)-predicted rod-surface heat and turbulence behavior that can impact crud-induced power shift (CIPS) and CILC prediction, was also implemented into VERA-CS. Usability improvements were made to this feature, which was developed over several previous milestones, so that the VERA-CS user can link spacer grids in a VERA-CS model to an applicable pregenerated spacer grid data file if available. Several assessments were performed to demonstrate the proper functioning of the new capability. Sensitivity studies were performed to demonstrate the effect of crud lithium content, oxide thermal conductivity, Cicada mesh refinement, and ROTHCON coupling mesh refinement on predicted amounts of crud and oxide growth. A full-scale demonstration was performed by running Seabrook Cycle 5 with the CILC capability. Some general observations were made from the assessments. It was observed that predicted corrosion thickness is less than anticipated for CILC cases, so further work is needed to better understand and improve the corrosion modeling. Refining the coupling mesh in the ROTHCON process leads to increased corrosion and crud thickness, which can affect where crud and corrosion grow, how thick it gets, and how many rods experience crud and corrosion growth. Results indicate that applying the ROTHCON process and refining the coupling mesh leads to only a slight increase in total core maximum crud and corrosion thickness, but it leads to a significant increase in the number of rods with a maximum thickness that surpasses a set threshold value (i.e., more rods grow thicker corrosion and crud). Computational performance of the simulation is degraded by a factor of 5{6 with high coupling mesh refinement. The impact of the ROTHCON coupling mesh refinement on total core crud mass is less significant; however, using the ROTHCON process with CFD-generated data over the Yao{Hochreiter{Leech (YHL) model in CTF leads to significantly different amounts of total core crud mass. Future work on the CILC screening capability will include model improvement and validation, development and testing of a CILC-risk screening criteria, and performance improvements.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

A Full-Height Axial P 3 Solver for the 2D/1D Method in MPACT

This report encompasses the efforts to complete L3:RTM.PRT.P15.04, which relates to improvements to the axial solvers in MPACT. Over the past few years, a number of convergence issues have been encountered throughout the 2D/1D calculation. While many of these were related to transport-corrected stability, which has been much improved through the development of multigroup MOC kernels, there are still some instabilities that are more directly related to the 1D axial nodal solvers. The primary focus of this milestone is on the development of a full-height P 3 solver, which solves for a single linear system for the entire rod, compared to the one- and two-node solvers previously available in MPACT. To provide an efficient full-height solver, the SuperLU direct linear solver was leveraged and an alternative rod decomposition scheme is used in favor over the typically employed axial decomposition. In addition to the full-height solver, a number of stability observations are discussed pertaining to (1) cases with thin planes in the axial reflectors, (2) quadratic radial leakage interpolation, (3) the reset sol capability, which reinitializes the solution before continuing the calculation, and (4) the flux threshold used in the radial transverse leakage splitting logic. The last of these was improved by identifying an acceptable threshold, which greatly help provide stability to the default one-node P 3 solver approach. Results demonstrating the full-height solver are presented for (1) a single assembly case from the AP1000 reactor design, (2) VERA Progression Problem 5a, and (3) a Watts Bar Unit 1, Cycle 1 case that demonstrated convergence issues due to thin planes in the axial reflector. In total, the full-height solver appears to be 3–5× slower for the nodal solve time, yield a roughly 10–20% increase in total problem run time, and requires ~5% more memory. However, these increases may be justifiable if the solver is proven to be more stable than the current default. Additionally, the VERA Progression Problem 4a case with the 252-group library is shown for the one-node P 3 solver with the updated threshold for radial transverse leakage splitting. This case also previous failed very early in the calculation, but is now able to run to completion. Brief details are also included related to the refactoring the nodal sweeper design. Previously, all nodal sweeper options were available in one large module, which was cumbersome and difficult to extend. Before the work here began, the design was refactored to include a number of abstract and extended types, which will help make future extensions easier. All-in-all, this milestone successfully implemented a new axial solver and improved the stability of the current default axial solver. However, additional testing will be necessary on new cases that demonstrate convergence issues before a decision can be made to change the current default in MPACT.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

Application and Assessment of Fully-coupled Fuel Performance in VERA

This report documents demonstrations of the fully coupled multiphysics capability developed in VERA and assesses the agreement between different approaches for integrating fuel performance calculations into VERA. It corresponds to CASL milestone L3:AMA.RX.P15.11 and fulfills the objectives and execution plan set out in that milestone.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

VERA-CS User Support Activities for PoR 15

The purpose of this milestone is to document the user support activities that took place between 4/1/2017 and 9/29/2017 (PoR 15). In the normal PHI workflow, that also extends to several activities within RTM, a Kanban process is followed. This involves creating tickets for specific work items and track the progress to complete these specific work items.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

FY17 MPACT Development Activities

Over the course of FY17, several improvements have been made to MPACT which effect the capability and performance of MPACT in several key areas. This report serves to document the capabilities developed at ORNL. There are four key areas of development that are highlighted here: • Externally driven source calculations to analyze reactor startup and the impact of secondary neutron sources. • Extensions to the Rhodium detector model to improve analysis of fixed core Rh detectors which are used in several cores. • Improved performance of PN scattering MOC sweeper to provide quicker reference solutions. • Implementation of an MOC kernel implemented on graphics processing units (GPU) to take advantage of advanced hardware. The next four sections discuss each of these features in detail. The final section discusses continuing work that is needed to improve these features.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Flexible Spatial Partitions in MPACT Through Module-Based Data Passing

As part of the Consortium for Advanced Simulation of Light Water Reactors (CASL), the Virtual Environment for Reactor Applications (VERA) is being developed to provide high-fidelity multiphysics simulations of nuclear reactor cores. The MPACT code being developed collaboratively by Oak Ridge National Laboratory and the University of Michigan is the primary deterministic neutron transport solver available within VERA. MPACT employs the 2D/1D method to solve 3D problems using 2D method of characteristics (MOC) radial transport solvers with 1D nodal expansion method-based P3 (NEM-P3) axial transport solvers, which are coupled using axial and radial transverse leakages. A 3D coarse mesh finite difference (CMFD) solver is used to provide accelerated convergence and stability. Quarter-core problems in MPACT are typically run on moderately sized clusters ({approx}500-10,000 cores). As such, it relies heavily on spatial decomposition, both radially and axially, using MPI data communication along spatial domain boundaries to pass angular flux boundary condition and neighboring data. The initial spatial decomposition strategy implemented into MPACT overlaid a Cartesian grid over the core to form the domain boundaries. With this approach, a single buffer spanning across the entire boundary between two spatial domains is passed to a domain's neighbor. Additionally, only one neighboring domain index was allowed in each direction. For example, the entire eastern boundary of a domain must be the entire western boundary of the corresponding neighbour's domain. This implementation helped to execute cases on several thousand cores, where substantial radial decomposition was used. The default for several years was to use assembly decomposition, which yielded 73 radial partitions in the Watts Bar Unit 1 (WBN1) models being analyzed. However, as CASL formed stronger connections with industry partners, there was a strong push to allow MPACT to run on fewer cores, preferably in the 500-1,000 core range. Such cases require much less radial decomposition, typically with 8-16 radial domains on each plane. Unfortunately, the previous decomposition strategy is very limited in its ability to yield well-balanced domains, and it does not permit partitions with an arbitrary number of domains, particularly with small numbers of radial domains (3, 5, 7, 11, 13, etc.). With these limitations, a more flexible approach that provided more even-load balancing was needed. The details of this new strategy are outlined here, along with insights to its advantages. The examples provided are for the WBN1 core, which has been the focus of several initial CASL analyses. It is worth noting that spatial decomposition strategies have been employed in many codes with focus on a number of different transport methodologies. The references cited are not exhaustive as this has been very important research topic across many areas.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Verification of a Multiphysics Code with Method of Manufactured Solutions

To push the modeling and simulation to a new level in simulating realistic problems, a common practice is to couple different single-physics codes together to simulate problems involving multiple physics. Although the method of manufactured solutions (MMS) has been shown to be a powerful tool in code verification, there has been little work on applying MMS to a multi-physics code system. Additionally, due to the scarcity of multi-physics validation data, the significance of code verification becomes more prominent as an important part in software quality assurance. With this, the application of MMS to a coupled code system, e.g. VERA-CS, has become a crucial step, which helps identify bugs affecting the order of accuracy, thus increasing the credibility and reliability of the code. In this work, we investigate the application of MMS to verify a multi-physics code system and establish a framework for this application, and we demonstrate this with a neutronics code coupled with a thermal hydraulics (TH) code. The convection module is not yet added to this work, so by TH, only conduction is considered.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Molten Salt Reactor Simulations using MPACT-CTF

The US Department of Energy and industry have shown significant interest in advanced reactors, as evidenced by over 1.3 billion dollars of private investments in companies to develop advanced reactor concepts. More than seven of these advanced reactor concepts use molten salt reactor (MSR) technology. Based on this interest in MSR technology, ORNL has invested in the development of the MSR simulation capability, extending some capabilities in VERA to model this high-profile reactor concept. In this paper, the MPACT deterministic neutron transport capability and the COBRA Two-Fluid (CTF) subchannel capability are adapted to handle liquid fuel MSRs. Specifically, this work focuses on modifications to the depletion algorithms to account for isotopic mixing, continuous feed, and continuous removal. Models will be added to account for drift of precursors and decay heat emitters as the liquid fuel flows through the reactor coolant system. Modifications to CTF, including the addition of molten salt properties, are also addressed. Finally, the coupled MPACT-CTF capability is used to simulate the 30-year operation of an MSR.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Demonstration of Coupled Tiamat Single Assembly Calculations

This report corresponds to milestone L3:PHI.PCI.P15.03, which was originally intended to investigate the time discretization approaches with the newly developed fully coupled Tiamat capability, targeting single assembly problems. At the time, it was thought that various time discretization approaches would need to be assessed. However, it was decided that this was not necessary as what is currently implemented in the code is adequate to provide consistent and full coupling between MPACT, CTF, ORIGEN, and Bison. As such, the milestone has effectively been repurposed as a stepping stone to the quarter core demonstration milestone slated for completion in August by describing and demonstrating the new fully coupled Tiamat capability on a single assembly case based on VERA Progression Problem 6, but with the addition of depletion throughout a representative cycle. Additionally, several other contributions that have been critical to this demonstration are also described. These include (1) the 1.5D capability developed by the Bison team, (2) improvements to the burnup representation in Bison through Tiamat, and (3) the additions to MOOSE to allow Bison to resolve the same timestep are also discussed. Initial simulations have been performed for the Watts Bar Unit 1 Cycle 1 with fully coupled Tiamat. While there are a few things to be improved for the final simulations, the initial results look very promising. The current status and results from this will be presented here, as well as the path forward to resolve the issues observed.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Mongoose Methods and Theory

The Consortium for Advanced Simulation of Light Water Reactors (CASL) has developed a suite of high-fidelity software and methods that is capable of simulating the full operating history of a commercial pressurized water reactor (PWR), including the loading, depletion, shuffling, and discharge of all nuclear fuel assemblies. These tools, collectively known as the Virtual Environment for Reactor Applications, or VERA, include advanced solvers and multi-physics coupling algorithms that provide the most rigorous solutions available today for steady-state nuclear reactor analysis. To demonstrate this capability, VERA has recently been used to simulate over 18 years of operation of Watts Bar Nuclear Unit 1 (WBN1), and the results of these calculations are used to quantify its performance in an industry-grade benchmarking activity.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗