Engineering topics

Drake, Michael J.

Publications and source records attributed to Drake, Michael J..

At least 19 records

NASA NTRS2004

Metal/Silicate Partitioning of P, Ga, and W at High Pressures and Temperatures: Dependence on Silicate Melt Composition

The distinctive pattern of element concentrations in the upper mantle provides essential evidence in our attempts to understand the accretion and differentiation of the Earth (e.g., Drake and Righter, 2002; Jones and Drake, 1986; Righter et al., 1997; Wanke 1981). Core formation is best investigated through use of metal/silicate partition coefficients for siderophile elements. The variables influencing partition coefficients are temperature, pressure, the major element compositions of the silicate and metal phases, and oxygen fugacity. Examples of studies investigating the effects of these variables on partitioning behavior are: composition of the metal phase by Capobianco et al. (1999) and Righter et al. (1997); silicate melt composition by Watson (1976), Walter and Thibault (1995), Hillgren et al. (1996), Jana and Walker (1997), and Jaeger and Drake (2000); and oxygen fugacity by Capobianco et al. (1999), and Walter and Thibault (1995). Here we address the relative influences of silicate melt composition, pressure and temperature.

Bailey, Edward↗

NASA NTRS2003

Vanadium, Cr, Si, and the Mg/Si Ratio of the Earth

Experiments investigating the partitioning of V, Cr, and Si between metal and silicate at various pressures, temperatures, redox state, and composition demonstrate that V and Cr are always more siderophile than Si. The relatively high abundances of V and Cr in the Earth's upper mantle indicate that the high Mg/Si ratio of the Earth's upper mantle cannot be attributed to extraction of Si into the core and must be an intrinsic bulk property of the silicate Earth.

Drake, Michael J.↗

NASA NTRS1999

Mars Sample Handling and Requirements Panel (MSHARP)

In anticipation of the return of samples from Mars toward the end of the first decade of the next century, NASA's Office of Space Sciences chartered a panel to examine how Mars samples should be handled. The panel was to make recommendations in three areas: (1) sample collection and transport back to Earth; (2) certification of the samples as nonhazardous; and (3) sample receiving, curation, and distribution. This report summarizes the findings of that panel. The samples should be treated as hazardous until proven otherwise. They are to be sealed within a canister on Mars, and the canister is not to be opened until within a Biosafety Hazard Level 4 (BSL-4) containment facility here on Earth. This facility must also meet or exceed the cleanliness requirements of the Johnson Space Center (JSC) facility for curation of extraterrestrial materials. A containment facility meeting both these requirements does not yet exist. Hazard assessment and life detection experiments are to be done at the containment facility, while geochemical characterization is being performed on a sterilized subset of the samples released to the science community. When and if the samples are proven harmless, they are to be transferred to a curation facility, such as that at JSC.

Carr, Michael H.↗

NASA NTRS1995

Report of centimeter-sized tektites in Pima County, Arizona, cannot be verified

Glassy objects reportedly found in Pima County, Arizona, have been identified as tektites. A field survey of the area where they were said to occur, however, did not produce any other tektites, nor did it reveal any other geologic features that might indicate a nearby impact crater. The major-, minor-, and trace-element composition of one specimen is similar to those measured in indochinites, which suggests the objects reportedly from Pima County were instead transported to southern Arizona from Indochina by people.

Kring, David A.↗

NASA NTRS1994

Fractionated martian atmosphere in the nakhlites?

Considerable evidence points to a martian origin of the shergottite-nakhlite-chassignite (SNC) meteorites. Noble gas isotopic compositions have been measured in most SNC meteorites. The Xe-129/Xe-132 vs. Kr-84/Xe-132 ratios in Chassigny, most shergottites, and lithology C of EETA 79001 define a linear array. This array is thought to be a mixing line between martian mantle and martian atmosphere. One of the SNC meteorites, Nakhla, contains a leachable component that has an elevated Xe-129/Xe-132 ratio relative to its Kr-84/Xe-132 ratio when compared to this approximately linear array. The leachable component probably consists in part of iddingsite, an alteration product produced by interaction of olivine with aqueous fluid at temperatures lower than 150 C. The elevated Xe isotopic ratio may represent a distinct reservoir in the martian crust or mantle. More plausibly, it is elementally fractionated martian atmosphere. Formation of sediments fractionates the noble gases in the correct direction. The range of sediment/atmosphere fractionation factors is consistent with the elevated Xe-129/Xe-132 component in Nakhla being contained in iddingsite, a low temperature weathering product. The crystallization age of Nakhla is 1.3 Ga. Its low-shock state suggests that it was ejected from near the surface of Mars. As liquid water is required for the formation of iddingsite, these observations provide further evidence for the near surface existence of aqueous fluids on Mars more recently than 1.3 Ga.

Drake, Michael J.↗

NASA NTRS1993

Rubidium and cesium in the earth and the moon

The purpose of the study is to provide an alternative perspective on both the mass balance issue and on the issue of secular change in the Rb-Cs ratio in the earth mantle. In particular, it is argued that the apparent secular change in the Rb/Cs ratio may be simply an artifact of alteration of older rocks through weathering and/or metamorphism subsequent to formation. It is also shown that there is not necessarily a need for a hidden, undepleted reservoir, and the consistency of this result with other mass calculations is explored. New methods for estimating the Rb/Cs ratio of the bulk silicate earth are suggested.

Jones, John H.↗

NASA NTRS1993

Metal-silicate thermochemistry at high temperature - Magma oceans and the 'excess siderophile element' problem of the earth's upper mantle

Low-temperature metal-silicate partition coefficients are extrapolated to magma ocean temperatures. If the low-temperature chemistry data is found to be applicable at high temperatures, an important assumption, then the results indicate that high temperature alone cannot account for the excess siderophile element problem of the upper mantle. For most elements, a rise in temperature will result in a modest increase in siderophile behavior if an iron-wuestite redox buffer is paralleled. However, long-range extrapolation of experimental data is hazardous when the data contains even modest experimental errors. For a given element, extrapolated high-temperature partition coefficients can differ by orders of magnitude, even when data from independent studies is consistent within quoted errors. In order to accurately assess siderophile element behavior in a magma ocean, it will be necessary to obtain direct experimental measurements for at least some of the siderophile elements.

Capobianco, Christopher J.↗

NASA NTRS1993

Noble gas evidence of an aqueous reservoir near the surface of Mars more recently than 1.3 Ga

Considerable evidence points to a Martian origin of the SNC meteorites. One of these meteorites, Nakhla, contains a leachable component which has an elevated Xe-129/Xe-132 ratio relative to its Kr-84/Xe-132 ratio when compared to the approximately linear array defined by Chassigny, most shergottites, and lithology C of EETA 79001. This array is thought to be a mixing line between Martian mantle and Martian atmosphere. The leachable component probably consists in part of iddingsite, an alteration product produced by interaction of olivine with aqueous fluid at temperatures lower than 150 C. The radiogenic Xe component may represent a distinct reservoir in the Martian crust or mantle. More plausibly, it is Martian atmosphere, fractionated by solution in liquid water and by interaction with sediment. The crystallization age of Nakhla is 1.3 Ga. Its low shock state suggests that it was ejected from near the surface of Mars. Liquid water is required for the formation of iddingsite. These observations provide further evidence for the near surface existence of aqueous fluids more recently than 1.3 Ga.

Drake, Michael J.↗

NASA NTRS1992

Mg-perovskite/silicate melt and magnesiowuestite/silicate melt partition coefficients for KLB-1 at 250 Kbars

The partitioning of elements amongst lower mantle phases and silicate melts is of interest in unraveling the early thermal history of the Earth. Because of the technical difficulty in carrying out such measurements, only one direct set of measurements was reported previously, and these results as well as interpretations based on them have generated controversy. Here we report what are to our knowledge only the second set of directly measured trace element partition coefficients for a natural system (KLB-1).

Drake, Michael J.↗

NASA NTRS1992

Estimation of high temperature metal-silicate partition coefficients

It has been known for some time that abundances of siderophile elements in the upper mantle of the Earth are far in excess of those expected from equilibrium between metal and silicate at low pressures and temperatures. Murthy (1991) has re-examined this excess of siderophile element problem by estimating liquid metal/liquid silicate partition coefficients reduces from their measured values at a lower temperature, implying that siderophile elements become much less siderophilic at high temperatures. Murthy then draws the important conclusion that metal/silicate equilibrium at high temperatures can account for the abundances of siderophile elements in the Earth's mantle. Of course, his conclusion is critically dependent on the small values of the partition coefficients he calculates. Because the numerical values of most experimentally-determined partition coefficients increase with increasing temperature at both constant oxygen fugacity and at constant redox buffer, we think it is important to try an alternative extrapolation for comparison. We have computed high temperature metal/silicate partition coefficients under a different set of assumptions and show that such long temperature extrapolations yield values which are critically dependent upon the presumed chemical behavior of the siderophile elements in the system.

Jones, John H.↗

NASA NTRS1992

Mg-perovskite/silicate melt partition coefficients in the CMS system at 2430 C and 226 Kbars

The partitioning of elements among lower mantle phases and silicate melts is of interest in unraveling the early thermal history of the Earth. Because of the technical difficulty in carrying out such measurements, only one direct set of measurements has been reported, and these results as well as interpretations based on them have generated controversy. The first set of direct measurements on a synthetic system in the CaO-MgO-SiO2 (CMS) is reported. An experiment was conducted at Stony Brook, using the USSA-2000 split sphere anvil apparatus. An experiment in the CMS system doped with oxides of Al, Ti, Sc, and Sm and run at a nominal temperature of 2380 C and pressure of 226 kbars is reported. Nominal temperatures were measured with a W 3 percent Re/W 25 percent Re thermocouple. The hot spot temperature, where the liquidus is located, is estimated to be at 2430 C. A 10 mm MgO octahedron was used in concert with 4 mm truncation edge lengths on the WC cubes. The sample was contained in a Re capsule which was inserted into a LaCrO3 furnace. Pressure was calibrated at 2000 C. Run duration was approximately 3 minutes. The charge was mounted in epoxy and analyzed using a CAMECA SX-50 electron microprobe. Standard operating conditions were employed, although counting time for the less abundant elements was increased to improved counting statistics. The melt is unquenchable, and forms a dendritic intergrowth of quench crystals and residual melt. It was analyzed using a 30 micron raster. The structural identity of the Mg-perovskite phase was confirmed using x ray microdiffractometry. The results of the investigation are presented.

Mcfarlane, Elisabeth A.↗

NASA NTRS1992

Forsterite/melt partitioning of argon and iodine: Implications for atmosphere formation by outgassing of an early Martian magma ocean

Argon and Xe in the Martian atmosphere are radiogenic relative to the Martian mantle if the SNC meteorites are from Mars. Decay of the short lived isotope I-129 to Xe-129 (t sub 1/2 = 16 m.y.) is the most plausible source of the radiogenic Xe. This short half life constrains any process responsible for the elevated Xe-129/Xe-132 ratio of the Martian atmosphere to occur very early in solar system history. Musselwhite et al. proposed that the differential solubility of I and Xe in liquid water played a key role in producing the radiogenic signature in the Martian atmosphere. Here we explore an alternative hypothesis involving purely igneous processes, and motivated in part by new experimental results on the partitioning of I and Xe between minerals and melt.

Musselwhite, Donald S.↗

NASA NTRS1991

Early outgassing of Mars supported by differential water solubility of iodine and xenon

The Martian atmosphere has a high X-129/Xe-132 ratio compared to the Martian mantle. As Xe-129 is the daughter product of the extinct nuclide I-129, a means of fractionating iodine from xenon early in Martian history appears necessary to account for the X-129/Xe-132 ratios of its known reservoirs. A model is presented here to account for the Marian xenon data which relies on the very different solubilities of xenon and iodine in water to fractionate them after outgassing. Atmospheric xenon is lost by impact erosion during heavy bombardment, followed by release of Xe-129 produced from I-129 decay in the crust.

Musselwhite, Donald S.↗

NASA NTRS1991

Sm-Nd and Rb-Sr isotopic systematics of ureilites

The present evaluation of Sm-Nd and Rb-Sr isotopic data for seven ureilites establishes their divisions into three groups on the bases of Sm-Nd isotopic systematics. The first group of ureilites is made up of whole-rock samples whose highly depleted assemblages indicate Sm-Nd model ages consistent with 4.55 Ga. The second group of whole-rock samples of Kenna, Novo Urei, and ALHA77257 are heterogeneous mixtures of an unidentified light REE-enriched component and a light REE-depleted olivine-pyroxene assemblage. In the third group, LEW85440 neither has a model Sm-Nd age of 4.55 Ga nor plots of the 3.74 Ga isochron of the Kenna group; it might have had an evolution similar to the Kenna group, but involving different times and/or isotopic compositions.

Goodrich, Cyrena Anne↗

NASA NTRS1990

Solubility and partitioning of Ar in anorthite, diopside, forsterite, spinel, and synthetic basaltic liquids

The solubility and partitioning of Ar in natural anorthite, diopside, forsterite, spinel, and synthetic iron-free basaltic melts was investigated using a new technique that obviates the postquenching phase separation. It was found that the solubility of Ar in the minerals was surprisingly high. Moreover, the solubility of Ar in different samples of a particular mineral run in the same experiment varied more than the solubility in the same sample run in different experiments, suggesting that noble gases are held in lattice vacancy defects. Moreover, the results of TEM imaging revealed no anomalous microstructures, while EXAFS studies of some samples showed that Kr has no preferred site in the lattices, supporting the defect siting conclusion.

Broadhurst, C. Leigh↗

NASA NTRS1990

Constraints on the Formation of the Terrestrial Planets from Experimental Geochemistry

The abundances of V, Cr, and Mn in the mantles of the Earth and Moon are very similar, and are distinct from all other sampled solar system bodies. This similarity has led to the suggestion that there is a genetic relationship between the Earth and Moon, more specifically, that the Moon was derived from the mantle of the Earth after formation of the core. This proposal is at odds with the Giant Impact paradigm of lunar origin and our current understanding of the formation of the terrestrial planets. During the award period, some of the necessary experimental procedures were developed. Specifically, an assembly design has been developed to permit heating of metal by insulating it from highly conducting diamond. A Nd-YAG laser was assembled, aligned and tested. The technique for preparation of the run products for electron microprobe analysis was developed, and an alternative approach has been identified. A scheme to carry out polybaric experiments on a single charge was developed. The experiments carried out did not lead to conclusive results, and the arguments advanced by Drake et aL (1989) and Drake (1990) remain the best summary of the status of the problem.

Drake, Michael J.↗

NASA NTRS1989

V, Cr, and Mn in the earth, moon, EPB, and SPB and the origin of the moon - Experimental studies

The abundances of V, Cr, and Mn inferred for the mantles of the earth and moon decrease in that order and are similar in both mantles (but distinct from those in the mantles of the Eucrite Parent Body and Shergottite Parent Body), suggesting a common origin for the mantles of the earth and the moon. This hypothesis was investigated on the basis of a comparison between the depletions of V, Cr, and Mn in the mantles of the earth and the moon, and the metal/silicate partition coefficients of these elements at 1260 C and 1 bar pressure among a S-bearing metallic liquid, a silicate melt, and a FeNi alloy. It was found that the earth and the moon depletions of V, Cr, and Mn are not correlated with metal/silicate partition coefficients; the V and Cr partitioned into S-rich metallic liquids under reducing conditions more strongly than Mn, consistent with the relative volatilities of these elements. This indicates that the depletion patterns of these elements in the mantles of the earth and moon cannot be attributed primarily to terrestrial core formation.

Drake, Michael J.↗

NASA NTRS1988

Partitioning of rare earth elements between hibonite and melt and implications for nebular condensation of the rare earth elements

The effect of oxygen fugacity on the partitioning of REEs between hibonite and silicate melt is investigated in hibonite-growth experiments at 1470 C. The experimental procedures and apparatus are described, and the results are presented in extensive tables and graphs and characterized in detail. The absolute activity coefficients in hibonite are estimated as 330 for La, 1200 for Eu(3+), and 24,000 for Yb. It is inferred that ideal solution behavior cannot be assumed when calculating REE condensation temperatures for (Ca, Al)-rich inclusions in carbonaceous chondrites.

Drake, Michael J.↗