Workshop on Mars Sample Return Science
Martian magnetic history; quarantine issues; surface modifying processes; climate and atmosphere; sampling sites and strategies; and life sciences were among the topics discussed.
Drake, Michael J.↗
Engineering topics
Drake, Michael J.
Publications and source records attributed to Drake, Michael J..
Accretion and primary differentiation of Mars
In collecting samples from Mars to address questions such as whether Mars accreted homogeneously or heterogeneously, how Mars segregated into a metallic core and silicate mantle, and whether Mars outgassed catastrophically coincident with accretion or more serenely on a longer timescale, we must be guided by our experience in addressing these questions for the Earth, Moon, and igneous meteorite parent bodies. A key measurement to be made on any sample returned from Mars is its oxygen isotopic composition. A single measurement will suffice to bind the SNC meteorites to Mars or demonstrate that they cannot be samples of that planet. A positive identification of Mars as the SNC parent planet will permit all that has been learned from the SNC meteorites to be applied to Mars with confidence. A negative result will perhaps be more exciting in forcing us to look for another object that has been geologically active in the recent past. If the oxygen isotopic composition of Earth and Mars are established to be distinct, accretion theory must provide for different compositions for two planets now separated by only 0.5 AU.
Drake, Michael J.↗
Siderophile elements in planetary mantles and the origin of the moon
The collisional ejection and the coaccretion hypotheses of lunar origin are examined in the context of theories of planetary accretion and of siderophile element abundances in planetary mantles. The information concerning the possible dynamical environments within which the terrestrial planets may have grown and the known abundances of siderophile and chalcophile elements in the mantles of the earth, the moon, and the hypothetical shergottite parent body is used to evaluate the existing hypotheses of lunar origin. The analysis indicates that none of the existing theories concerning lunar origin is fully consistent with observed siderophile element abundances in the lunar and terrestrial mantles.
Drake, Michael J.↗
Core formation in the shergottite parent body and comparison with the earth
Abundances of elements in shergottite, nakhlite, and Chassigny meteorites which originated on a single planet, the shergottite parent body (SPB), were examined with the aim of elucidating the chemical conditions of metal separation and core formation in the SPB and of testing present models of planetary core formation. Using partition coefficients and the SPB mantle composition determined in earlier studies, the abundances of Ag, Au, Co, Ga, Mo, Ni, P, Re, S, and W were modeled, with free parameters being oxygen fugacity, proportion of solid metal formed, proportion of metallic liquid formed, and proportion of silicate that is molten. It is shown that the abundances of all elements (except Mo) could be reproduced using models with these four free parameters. In contrast to the SPB, an equivalent model used to predict element abundances in the earth's mantle was shown by Jones and Drake (1986) to be inadequate; there is at present no hypothesis capable of quantitatively reproducing the elemental abundances of the earth's mantle. The contrast suggests that these two terrestrial planets (assuming that the SPB is Mars) may have accreted or differentiated differently.
Treiman, Allan H.↗
The case for planetary sample return missions. I - Origin of the solar system
The scientific aims and proposed scenarios of sample-return missions (SRMs) to Mars, Venus, comets, and asteroids are reviewed. SRMs are currently being evaluated as natural follow-ons to the NASA remote-sensing orbiter missions of the 1990s. The technological advantages of ground laboratory analysis of returned samples are discussed; and it is argued that SRMs to large evolved bodies can provide a record of (1) the composition of the solar system at different heliocentric distances and (2) the nature of the processes that led to the accretion of small objects (preserved as comets and asteroids) into large planetary bodies. Also considered are NASA research and analysis programs needed to support studies of solar-system origin. It is recommended that planning of SRMs be begun immediately, although they may not be feasible before the year 2000.
Drake, Michael J.↗
Geochemical Constraints on Core Formation in the Earth
New experimental data on the partitioning of siderophile and chalcophile elements among metallic and silicate phases may be used to constrain hypotheses of core formation in the Earth. Three current hypotheses can explain gross features of mantle geochemistry, but none predicts siderophile and chalcophile element abundances to within a factor of two of observed values. Either our understanding of metal-silicate interactions and/or our understanding of the early Earth requires revision.
Jones, John H.↗
Is lunar bulk material similar to earth's mantle?
In an attempt to ascertain whether or not lunar bulk material is similar to the earth's mantle, consideration is given to the following parameters of both planetary bodies: oxygen isotopic composition, metal/silicate ratio, siderophile trace element concentrations, refractory lithophile trace element concentrations, volatile element ratios and volatile/refractory element ratios, bulk Mg /(Mg + Fe) ratio, Fe/Mn ratios, and redox state. The values of these parameters are estimated and various hypotheses for lunar origin are examined in their light.
Drake, Michael J.↗