Jet Noise Predictions with Wall-Modeled Large-Eddy Simulations
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Engineering topics
Publications and source records attributed to Gerrit-Daniel Stich.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
A new immersed boundary Wall-Modelled Large Eddy Simulation (WMLES) formulation is developed to study high-lift aerodynamics on the NASA High-Lift Common Research Model (HL-CRM). A sequence of Cartesian Octree grids with sizes ranging from 100 Million through 2.02 Billion grid points is utilized to systematically assess grid-sensitivity and convergence for the in-tunnel (QinetiQ) configuration of the model, and remarkable agreement between the immersed boundary and the curvilinear body-aligned WMLES formulations is reported on grids with comparable resolutions. In the free-air configuration of the model, consistent predictions between the Curvilinear Overset and the Cartesian Octree formulations are reported for angles of attack up to C(L,max) at a=19.57. However, some differences in the onset of stall are seen between the two methods for a>20°: while the curvilinear WMLES experiences wing-root separation with increasing angle of attack (Topology A), the Cartesian Octree formulation shows a different flow topology characterized by boundary layer weakness on the main element, emanating from the pylon-wing attachment (Topology B). In order to obtain further insight into the two-distinct topologies, carefully designed numerical experiments to isolate effects of the model standoff and the tunnel wall-boundary layers are conducted using the immersed boundary WMLES formulation. The increased incidence angle-of-attack on the inboard portion of the wing due to the standoff is shown to be sufficient for triggering a switch from Topology B to Topology A in Cartesian WMLES. The role of the floor boundary layer is further examined in detail by identification of additional corner-flow vorticity generated by the viscous juncture flow interactions between the floor boundary layer and the standoff leading to formation of a strong coherent and persistent vortex on the belly-side of the fuselage. The intensity of this vortex is shown to increase with the thickness of the floor boundary layer. A further increase in the incidence angle of attack near the leading-edge strake caused by the presence of this belly-side vortex is quantified for two-distinct floor boundary layers. Both of the floor boundary layers considered result in the onset of large scale wing-root separation at a=21.47in non-confined (free-air) configurations.
Note: Presentation is accompanied by an mp4 video of the given talk with a run time of 9 mins 47 secs.
A campaign of wall-modeled large-eddy simulations (WMLES) using structured curvilinear overlapping grids has been performed with the Launch Ascent and Vehicle Aerodynamics (LAVA) computational fluid dynamics (CFD) software to predict jet noise for single-stream axisymmetric round jets. The simulations address the new Prediction Uncertainty Reduction (PUR) technical challenge within the context of NASA’s Commercial Supersonic Technology (CST) project. The focus of this effort is to generate a simulation database for single-stream axisymmetric round nozzles at several operating points both for static (no ambient co-flow), and in-flight (M ͚ =0.3 co-flow) conditions. The operating conditions range in jet exit Mach number from 0.38 to 1.1 with nozzle temperature ratios (NTR) from 0.84 to 2.7. The effect of the flight-stream on far-field noise sound spectra is assessed. Comparison of LES predictions to microphone array measurements demonstrate good agreement within the resolved frequency range. A dip in the predicted low frequency noise spectra for observers between 120° and 145° is observed. This dip is smaller for lower Mach numbers and seems to be correlated to the Mach wave radiation angle. The Mach 1.1 jet shows broadband-shock associated noise. While the onset of BBSN appears to be captured correctly in WMLES, some differences in its magnitude and the prominent frequency at which it occurs persist between the experiment and the simulations. The effect of the outer nozzle boundary layer state created by the co-flow is assessed and shows to be important for accurate comparisons with experiments. A change of 2.5dB between a slip-wall condition and a artificially thickened turbulent boundary layer was observed. In addition, simulations were performed with an alternative nozzle geometry that includes a internal plug and has twice the nozzle exit diameter. These two configurations resulted in very comparable spectra which is consistent with experimental observations. A generally stronger deviation from experimental results is observed for in-flight cases compared to static conditions. The applicability and correct usage of acoustic analogies used for far-field propagation with strong turbulent co-flows needs to be investigated more systematically using canonical problems to improve comparisons between experiments and WMLES. This is especially true for coherent noise sources seen in BBSN.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
In this study the implementation of actuator-disk, actuator-line and sliding-mesh methodologies in the Launch Ascent and Vehicle Aerodynamics (LAVA) solver is described and validated against several test-cases. The different models are validated against available numerical as well as experimental data. Both steady and unsteady Reynolds-Averaged Navier-Stokes (RANS) simulations using the Spallart Allmaras (SA) turbulence model are performed for several different configurations representative of aeroscience applications. The first part of the paper is focused on the verification and validation of the implemented propulsor models. The first validation case is a theoretical rotor in hover, compared with the 1D analytical solution derived from momentum theory. The second validation is the Rotor-Airframe Interaction Model of Georgia Institute of Technology (GIT), representing the application of actuator disks to top-mounted rotorcraft vehicles or unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs). The third case is a representative configuration for tip-mounted rotor-craft vehicles such as NASA’s X57 airplane. The second part of the paper shows the implemented models applied to realistic engineering configurations such as NASA’s X57 airplane and the R4 Advanced Ducted Propellor (ADT). A modification to the actuator line method in order to represent the blade geometry more closely is proposed and comparisons with simulations modeling the blade utilizing a sliding-mesh approach are made.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
- An emerging potential market has generated renewed interest in civil supersonic aircraft - Evidenced by the appearance of several commercial programs despite lack of standards for en route noise or landing and takeoff noise - Overland Flight Restrictions based on unacceptable sonic boom noise are viewed as the main barrier to this vision - National Research and Policy agencies play a central role in developing the data needed for the regulation change that is essential to enabling this new market - The vision of the Supersonics Community is a future where fast air travel is available for a broad spectrum of the traveling public - Future supersonic aircraft will not only be able to fly overland without creating an “unacceptable situation” but compared to Concorde and SST will be efficient, affordable, and environmentally responsible
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
This paper presents results from ongoing research on jet noise prediction using wall-modeled large eddy simulations (WMLES) conducted within the Launch Ascent and Vehicle Aerodynamics (LAVA) computational framework. The study primarily focuses on the aeroacoustic implications of multi-stream nozzle configurations with internal mixing and both internal and external plugs, at a Reynolds number of 1×10 6 based on the nozzle exit diameter. While internal mixing nozzles have long been considered for jet noise reduction, the complexities of their impact on overall noise levels remain insufficiently understood. This research applies established best practices for WMLES to these complex nozzle configurations, aiming to assess their efficacy and identify limitations in accurately predicting noise behaviors. Through detailed comparisons with experimental data obtained from NASA’s Glenn Research Center, initial findings underscore the challenges inherent in current simulation practices when confronted with intricate geometric and operational conditions. Responding to these challenges, the study explores innovative computational approaches to rectify discrepancies noted between experimental outcomes and CFD predictions. Once example is the introduction of a resonating sound source in the simulation environment to mimic potential unobserved acoustic phenomena.A second example is the strategic modifications to the geometry of external plugs to account for real-world deformations caused by heating and gravity. These novel strategies aim to enhance the accuracy and reliability of noise predictions from supersonic jets, advancing our understanding and capability to effectively reduce jet noise in commercial supersonic aircraft
The NASA Source Diagnostic Test (SDT) campaign experimental data is used for validation of a sliding mesh technique recently implemented within the Launch, Ascent, and Vehicle Aerodynamics computational framework for time-accurate simulation of rotating fans. The far-field acoustics are analyzed in this work, building upon the aerodynamic validation studies previously published in Part I. Two modeling approaches are explored: the unsteady Reynolds-averaged Navier Stokes (uRANS) with the negative Spalart-Allmaras (SA-neg) turbulence model closure, and a hybrid Reynolds-averaged Navier Stokes/large-eddy simulation (RANS/LES) paradigm employing a zonal detached-eddy simulation (ZDES) closure with enhanced shielding protection. Two convective flux scheme approaches with different dissipation properties are also explored with ZDES. The Ffowcs-Williams and Hawkings (FW-H) permeable surface approach is used for propagation of the near-field acoustics to the far-field microphone locations. This work analyzes the low-speed (approach) condition, characterized by a fan rotation speed of 7808 rotations-per-minute (RPM). Three different grid levels ranging between 200 million and 1.1 billion grid points are considered. Results show good prediction of the broadband noise levels at sideline angles ranging between 70° and 110°. The forward arc observers show an under-prediction of the overall sound pressure levels (OASPL) even at the fine grid level. A breakdown of the inlet and exhaust contributions reveals a steep drop-off in the broadband noise levels past a blade-passing frequency (BPF) of 1.5, potentially caused by a lack of resolved small-scale turbulent fluctuations in the interstage region. Past 110° the OASPL are over-predicted by up to 10 dB due to an over-prediction of the low-frequency broadband noise levels in the aft arc. The detuning of BPF2 caused by small deviations in the blade stagger angle around the wheel is captured, and a corresponding decrease in the sound power level for this cut-on tone is observed.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.
The aerodynamic performance of a swept wing derived from the Common Research Model wing with high-fidelity and smooth leading-edge ice shapes is evaluated using wall-modeled large-eddy simulations. Two mesh paradigms are considered within the Launch, Ascent, and Vehicle Aerodynamics framework: structured hybrid curvilinear body-fitted/immersed-boundary and unstructured Voronoi. The curvilinear approach models the effect of the ice on the flow through penalty terms and the Voronoi strategy includes the ice representation directly in the mesh.Aerodynamic loads, surface pressure profiles, and skin-friction streamlines are compared against experimental results collected at the Wichita State University wind tunnel at a Mach number of 0.18 and a Reynolds number per mean aerodynamic chord of 1.6 million. For the curvilinear simulations with high-fidelity ice, results are sensitive to spanwise mesh resolution near the leading edge, where insufficient spanwise resolution leads to a spanwise running vortexaft of the high-fidelity ice, which is partially removed with increasing spanwise resolution. For the Voronoi simulations with high-fidelity ice, refining the mesh led to good convergence towards the experimental results with the best case demonstrating a maximum discrepancy of three lift counts relative to the experiment across a range of angles of attack from about 5 to 24 degrees, validating the shrink-wrapping procedure used for the ice. For the smooth ice, the curvilinear approach consistently under-predicted the upper surface suction leading to an under-prediction in lift, but did not demonstrate the pronounced over-prediction in upper surface suction near the leading edge observed in the Voronoi simulations.
A series of scale-resolving simulations of flow over the ONERA OAT15A airfoil have been performed at an angle of attack of 3.5◦, just past the onset of buffet. The focus of this study is to document the sensitivity of the wall-modeled large eddy simulation (WMLES) methodology for curvilinear structured overset grids within the Launch, Ascent, and Vehicle Aerodynamics (LAVA) framework to mesh spacing, mesh distribution, and domain size. A secondary purpose of the study is to compare the results from WMLES to unsteady Reynolds-averaged Navier Stokes (URANS) simulations and hybrid RANS-LES (HRLES) within the same LAVA solver framework. The study provides a unique perspective regarding comparisons between different turbulence modeling approaches, time-integration methods, and computational performance since many of the same numerical routines are used for all three types of simulations. The results are compared with experiments and previous numerical studies of the same geometry and flow conditions.
The unstructured Voronoi mesher currently being developed within the Launch, Ascent, and Vehicle Aerodynamics (LAVA) software framework at NASA Ames Research Center is described in detail. The discussions include, but are not limited to, the strategies used in the seeding and smoothing phases to ensure a high-quality mesh for Wall-Modeled Large-Eddy Simulations (WMLES), the methods behind the cell clipping algorithm responsible for conforming the mesh to a complex geometry, and the approach to create a global mesh from the distinct Voronoi cells. Applications and benefits of the Voronoi meshing approach are also presented. The automated meshing paradigm introduced was able to significantly reduce the time necessary to create a high-quality mesh around a complex geometry when compared against the current LAVA curvilinear overset meshing standard. For example, the task of generating a single mesh around the high-lift common research model requires the full dedication of a mesh generation expert for a period between one and two months. A family of meshes with different refinement levels up to six hundred million cells can be generated by a single engineer in a day or two. This technology has the potential for decreasing the turnaround time for conducting WMLES around complex geometries, as well as facilitating comprehensive mesh refinement studies.
Explore the source record for details and available documents.