Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Larsen, Edward W.

Publications and source records attributed to Larsen, Edward W..

MPACT 4.4 Theory Manual

MPACT is a three-dimensional (3D) full-core neutron transport code capable of calculating subpin power distributions. Calculations are based on the Boltzmann transport equation for neutron fluxes for problems in which the detailed geometrical configuration of fuel components such as the pellet and cladding are explicitly retained. The cross-section data needed for the neutron transport calculation are obtained directly from a multigroup cross section library, which has traditionally been used by lattice physics codes to generate few-group homogenized cross sections for nodal core simulators. Hence, MPACT assumes neither a priori homogenization nor group condensation for the full core spatial solution. The 3D MPACT transport solution can be obtained using the method of characteristics (MOC), which employs discrete ray tracing within each fuel pin. However, for practical reactor applications, the direct application of MOC to 3D core configurations requires an excessive amount of memory and computing time due to the very large number of rays. For practical 3D full-core calculations, MPACT commonly uses an approximate “2D/1D” method that treats the radial (x and y) variables differently from the axial (z) variable. In particular, the radial dependence of the solution is calculated using transport theory, and the axial dependence is calculated using diffusion or P 3 theory. The 2D/1D method requires the core to be divided into a vertical stack of axial slices with a thickness of Δ z ≈ 5–10 cm. Each axial slice is divided radially into coarse spatial cells with boundaries that usually constitute the pin cell boundaries, for which Δ x = Δ y ≈ 1.5 cm. Then, each coarse radial cell (pin cell) is divided into 50–100 fine radial cells, which resolve the angular flux in the fuel, cladding, and moderator regions.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

A Multilevel in Space and Energy Solver for 3-D Multigroup Diffusion and Coarse-Mesh Finite Difference Eigenvalue Problems

The Multilevel in Space and Energy Diffusion (MSED) method accelerates the iterative convergence of multigroup diffusion eigenvalue problems by performing work on lower-order equations with only one group and/or coarser spatial grids. It consists of two primary components: (1) a grey (one-group) diffusion eigenvalue problem that is solved via Wielandt-shifted power iteration (PI) and (2) a multigrid-in-space linear solver. In previous work, the efficiency of MSED was verified using Fourier analysis and numerical results from a one-dimensional multigroup diffusion code. Since that work, MSED has been implemented as a solver for the coarse-mesh finite difference (CMFD) system in the three-dimensional Michigan Parallel Characteristics Transport (MPACT) code. In this paper, the results from the implementation of MSED in MPACT are introduced, and the changes needed to make MSED more suitable for MPACT are described. For problems without feedback, the conclusions in this paper show that MSED can reduce the CMFD run time by an order of magnitude and the overall run time by a factor of 2 to 3 compared to the default CMFD solver in MPACT [PI with the generalized minimal residual (GMRES) method]. For problems with feedback, the convergence of the outer Picard iteration scheme is worsened by the well-converged CMFD solutions produced by the standard MSED method. To overcome this unintuitive deficiency, MSED may be run with looser convergence criteria (a modified version of the MSED method called MSED-L) to circumvent the issue until the multiphysics iteration in MPACT is improved. Results show that MSED-L can reduce the CMFD run time in MPACT by an order of magnitude, without negatively impacting the outer Picard iteration scheme.

3-D↗

Space-Dependent Wielandt Shifts for Multigroup Diffusion Eigenvalue Problems

We present a new concept—the space-dependent Wielandt shift (SDWS)—for accelerating the convergence of the power iteration (PI) scheme for multigroup diffusion k-eigenvalue problems. The SDWS improves on standard Wielandt shift (WS) techniques, which are empirical in nature and are typically effective only when the current estimate of the solution is reasonably converged. By accounting for the physics of the problem through SDWS, we are able to improve the acceleration for the initial iterates when the current estimate of the solution is not close to convergence. Numerical results from one-dimensional problems suggest that, compared to standard WS techniques, the new SDWS techniques can provide upward of a 46% reduction in the number of PIs required for convergence and a 40% reduction in the computational time required. This improvement is sensitive to several problem-dependent factors, such as the geometry and energy-dependence of the problem, the spatial discretization, and the initial guess. The reduction in computational time is also dependent on the linear solver in the PI scheme, as it is well known that WSs can significantly worsen the conditioning of the diffusion linear system. In this paper, we provide a detailed study of the impact of WSs on the performance of several iterative linear solvers. Results from our implementation of SDWS in the three-dimensional (3D) code MPACT show that SDWS can provide similar speedups for 3D multigroup diffusion eigenvalue problems. These results also show that moderate speedups can be obtained by applying SDWS to the coarse mesh finite difference (CMFD) solver in a CMFD-accelerated transport scheme. However, the benefit of doing this may be limited because all but the first few CMFD solves are relatively easy to converge, regardless of the WS used.

Nuclear Science & Technology↗

Variationally Derived Discontinuity Factors for the Asymptotic Homogenized Diffusion Equation

Here in this work, we derive and test variational discontinuity factors (DFs) for the asymptotic homogenized diffusion equation. We begin with a functional for optimally estimating the reactor multiplication factor, then introduce asymptotic expressions for the forward and adjoint angular fluxes, and finally require that all first-order error terms vanish. In this way, the reactor multiplication factor can be calculated with second-order error. The analysis leads to (1) an alternate derivation of the asymptotic homogenized diffusion equation, (2) variational boundary conditions for large periodic systems, and (3) variational DFs to be applied between adjacent periodic regions (e.g., fuel assemblies). Numerical tests show that applying the variational DFs to the asymptotic homogenized diffusion equation yields the most accurate estimates of the reactor multiplication factor compared to other DFs for a wide range of problems. However, the resulting assembly powers are less accurate than those obtained using other DFs for many realistic problems.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

Stability and accuracy of 3D neutron transport simulations using the 2D/1D method in MPACT

A consistent “2D/1D” neutron transport method is derived from the 3D Boltzmann transport equation, to calculate fuel-pin-resolved neutron fluxes for realistic full-core Pressurized Water Reactor (PWR) problems. The 2D/1D method employs the Method of Characteristics to discretize the radial variables and a lower order transport solution to discretize the axial variable. This paper describes the theory of the 2D/1D method and its implementation in the MPACT code, which has become the whole-core deterministic neutron transport solver for the Consortium for Advanced Simulations of Light Water Reactors (CASL) core simulator VERA-CS. Several applications have been performed on both leadership-class and industry-class computing clusters. Results are presented for whole-core solutions of the Watts Bar Nuclear Power Station Unit 1 and compared to both continuous-energy Monte Carlo results and plant data.

75 CONDENSED MATTER PHYSICS, SUPERCONDUCTIVITY AND↗

MPACT Standard Input User s Manual, Version 2.2.0

The MPACT (Michigan PArallel Charactistics based Transport) code is designed to perform high-fidelity light water reactor (LWR) analysis using whole-core pin-resolved neutron transport calculations on modern parallel-computing hardware. The code consists of several libraries which provide the functionality necessary to solve steady-state eigenvalue problems. Several transport capabilities are available within MPACT including both 2-D and 3-D Method of Characteristics (MOC). A three-dimensional whole core solution based on the 2D-1D solution method provides the capability for full core depletion calculations.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Space-Dependent Wielandt Shift Methods for Multigroup Diffusion Eigenvalue Problems

In the calculation of neutronic eigenfunctions and eigenvalues, it is often desirable to approximate the neutron transport equation by a diffusion equation that requires significantly less computational resources to solve. Even when a full transport solution is needed, the solution of the diffusion system can be used to accelerate iterative methods for calculating the transport eigenfunction and eigenvalue. The convergence rate of the basic power iteration method for eigenvalue problems is governed by the dominance ratio; realistic reactor core problems often have high dominance ratios and the power iteration method can converge slowly as a result. A common technique for accelerating the convergence of power iteration is the Wielandt shift (WS) method, which reduces the dominance ratio by 'shifting' the eigenvalue spectrum using an estimate of the desired eigenvalue. WS provides a significant speedup over power iteration if the eigenvalue estimate is close to the true eigenvalue, but it can be difficult to obtain such an estimate. In practice, the shift in the WS method can be dynamically updated in the iteration scheme, in a way that depends on the eigenvalue estimates from the most recent iterations. We present a physically-motivated Space-Dependent Wielandt Shift (SDWS) for solving multigroup diffusion eigenvalue problems. The space-dependence of the eigenvalue shift in SDWS enables a more effective acceleration of the power iteration scheme than WS at the beginning of the iteration scheme, when the current estimate of the eigenvalue is not close to the actual eigenvalue. Several variants of SDWS are discussed here, including an SDWS method that combines the strengths of SDWS (in the early iterations) with those of standard WS (in the later iterations). Numerical results from a 1-D multigroup diffusion problem demonstrate an order of magnitude speedup over power iteration and a 41% speedup over a standard WS technique. This speedup is problem-dependent and appears to be greater for 'more difficult' problems. In this summary, the term 'speedup' refers to a reduction in the number of iterations required to converge to the correct eigenvalue and eigenfunction. Because the scattering is treated fully implicitly (i.e., it is part of the left-hand side of the diffusion system and directly inverted), the computational cost of a single iteration does not vary significantly among the methods discussed in this summary. The number of iterations is therefore representative of the total computational cost for a method. We acknowledge that certain iterative solvers for linear systems (e.g., GMRES) require more computational time to converge when the system is nearly singular (i.e., when a very aggressive Wielandt shift is applied). Nonetheless, when using SDWS in the manner described in this summary, we have seen that the reduction in computational time from reducing the number of power iterations generally outweighs the extra computational time required by iterative solvers such as GMRES. (authors)

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

MPACT Theory Manual, Version 2.2.0

This theory manual describes the three-dimensional (3-D) whole-core, pin-resolved transport calculation methodology employed in the MPACT code. To provide sub-pin level power distributions with sufficient accuracy, MPACT employs the method of characteristics (MOC) solutions in the framework of a 3-D coarse mesh finite difference (CMFD) formulation. MPACT provides a 3D MOC solution, but also a 2D/1D solution in which the 2D planar solution is provided by MOC and the axial coupling is resolved by one-dimensional (1-D) lower order (diffusion or P3) solutions. In Chapter 2 of the manual, the MOC methodology is described for calculating the regional angular and scalar fluxes from the Boltzmann transport equation. In Chapter 3, the 2D/1D methodology is described, together with the description of the CMFD iteration process involving dynamic homogenization and solution of the multigroup CMFD linear system. A description of the MPACT depletion algorithm is given in Chapter 4, followed by a discussion of the subgroup and ESSM resonance processing methods in Chapter 5. The final Chapter 6 describes a simplified thermal hydraulics model in MPACT.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

MPACT VERA Input User s Manual, Version 2.2.0

The MPACT (Michigan PArallel Charactistics based Transport) code is designed to perform high-fidelity light water reactor (LWR) analysis using whole-core pin-resolved neutron transport calculations on modern parallel-computing hardware. The code consists of several libraries which provide the functionality necessary to solve steady-state eigenvalue problems. Several transport capabilities are available within MPACT including both 2-D and 3-D Method of Characteristics (MOC). A three-dimensional whole core solution based on the 2D-1D solution method provides the capability for full core depletion calculations.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

Performance Improvements for Coarse Mesh Finite Difference Acceleration L3:RTM.PRT.P13.02

The development of VERA-CS in recent years has focused on developing the capability to simulate multiple cycles of operating commercial nuclear power plants. Now that these capabilities have advanced to the point where it is being deployed to users, the focus is on improving the computational performance of various components in VERA-CS. In this work, the focus is on the Coarse Mesh Finite Difference (CMFD) solution in MPACT. CMFD serves multiple purposes in the 2D/1D solution methodology. First, it is a natural mechanism to tie together the radial MOC transport and the axial SP3 solution. Because the CMFD system solves the multigroup three-dimensional core in one system, it pulls together the global response of the system. In addition, the CMFD solution provides a framework to accelerate the convergence of the eigenvalue problem.

21 SPECIFIC NUCLEAR REACTORS AND ASSOCIATED PLANTS↗

An Implicit Correlation Method for Cross-Correlation Sampling, with MCNPX-PoliMi Validation

Monte Carlo particle transport codes used to model detector response are traditionally run in analog mode. However, analog simulations of cross-correlation measurements are extremely time-consuming because the probability of coincident detection is small, approximately equal to the product of the probabilities of a single detection in each detector. The new “implicit correlation” method described here increases the number of correlated event scores, thereby reducing variance and required computation times. The cost of the implicit correlation method is comparable to the cost of simulating single-event detection for the lowest absolute detector efficiency in the problem. The new method is especially useful in the nuclear nonproliferation and safeguards fields for simulating correlation measurements of shielded special nuclear material. The new method was implemented in MCNPX-PoliMi for neutron-neutron cross-correlations with a Cf-252 spontaneous fission source measured by 14 detectors at various angles. The method demonstrated good agreement with analog simulation and reference measurement results. Small differences between nonanalog and analog cross-correlation distributions are attributed to discretization errors that are often not present in practical applications. Improvement in the figure of merit was greater than a factor of 100 in all tested cases.

Marcath, Matthew J.↗

Asymptotic, multigroup flux reconstruction and consistent discontinuity factors

Recent theoretical work has led to an asymptotically derived expression for reconstructing the neutron flux from lattice functions and multigroup diffusion solutions. The leading-order asymptotic term is the standard expression for flux reconstruction, i.e., it is the product of a shape function, obtained through a lattice calculation, and the multigroup diffusion solution. The first-order asymptotic correction term is significant only where the gradient of the diffusion solution is not small. Inclusion of this first-order correction term can significantly improve the accuracy of the reconstructed flux. One may define discontinuity factors (DFs) to make certain angular moments of the reconstructed flux continuous across interfaces between assemblies in 1-D. Indeed, the standard assembly discontinuity factors make the zeroth moment (scalar flux) of the reconstructed flux continuous. The inclusion of the correction term in the flux reconstruction provides an additional degree of freedom that can be used to make two angular moments of the reconstructed flux continuous across interfaces by using current DFs in addition to flux DFs. Thus, numerical results demonstrate that using flux and current DFs together can be more accurate than using only flux DFs, and that making the second angular moment continuous can be more accurate than making the zeroth moment continuous.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

MPACT User's Manual (Version 2.0.0)

The MPACT (Michigan PArallel Charactistics based Transport) code is designed to perform high-fidelity light water reactor (LWR) analysis using whole-core pin-resolved neutron transport calculations on modern parallel-computing hardware. The code consists of several libraries which provide the functionality necessary to solve steady-state eigenvalue problems. Several transport capabilities are available within MPACT including both 2-D and 3-D Method of Characteristics (MOC). A three-dimensional whole core solution based on the 2D-1D solution method provides the capability for full core depletion calculations.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗