Engineering topics

Pint, Bruce A.

Publications and source records attributed to Pint, Bruce A..

At least 19 records

DOE OSTI2024

High-Temperature Oxidation Study in a Multi-Oxidant Environment Using 18 O Tracer

The goal of this study was to use 18 O-enriched water to better understand the role of H 2 O in high-temperature oxidation. Seven model and three commercial M-Cr and M-Cr-Al alloys were studied in air with 10% of H 2 O at 800 °C for 5 h. Oxygen from water vapor was more reactive than oxygen from the air and 18 O enriched at the outermost layers of the formed Cr- and Al-rich oxides. Alloys with Al and/or Ti additions showed signs of internal oxidation but 18 O was not enriched inside the alloy in locations with internal oxidation. In conclusion, depending on the alloy Al content, the oxide went from Al oxidation beneath a chromia scale to external alumina scale formation.

18O-enriched water↗

DOE OSTI2024

Materials Assessment for FLiBe Fusion Blankets

This evaluation was prepared at the request of DOE-FES and expands on an earlier evaluation prepared by Wilson, Wiffen and Keiser in 2015 (attached as Appendices A and B). Additional useful information for materials in fission molten salt reactor systems that use FLiBe can be found in a prior NRC report [Busby 2019]. The purpose of this report is to review the considerations that will determine the fusion blanket structural materials that will be suitable for use in a FLiBe breeder-coolant fusion power plant (FPP). Identifying a fusion-relevant structural material that is sufficiently compatible with FLiBe is a key issue to be addressed. The constraints and trade-offs made in structural materials selection include the usual power generation requirements such as mechanical properties, fabricability and durability, which assumes reasonable compatibility with the working fluid. For an FPP, additional constraints include neutron economy (breeding ratio), resistance to irradiation damage and low activation (i.e. waste disposal) characteristics.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

DOE OSTI2024

Measure the effect of molten halide salt exposure on creep rupture lifetime

Recent resurgence in the research and commercial interests in molten salt reactors (MSRs) as a viable advanced reactor concept to achieve the short- and long-term climate goals has resulted in ongoing efforts to demonstrate their commercial potential. These are relying on a combination of the extensive legacy knowledge from the molten salt reactor experiment (MSRE) and relatively recent data on materials compatibility of structural materials of interest such as 316H in molten salts environments. However, there is a critical lack of data on the mechanical behavior of alloys of interest for MSRS such as 316H, 617 and 709 in molten fluoride (FLiNaK or FLiBe) or chloride (NaCl-MgCl 2 ) salts. Limited legacy data from the molten salt reactor experiment (MSRE) program showed a significant reduction in creep rupture strength of a Ni-base alloy (Ni-15Cr-7Fe wt.%) in the molten fluoride NaF-ZrF4-UF4 (50-46-4 mol.%) salt. With ongoing efforts to commercialize different molten salt reactor concepts, the industry can considerably benefit from quantitative information on the impact of molten halide salts on the engineering properties such as creep and fatigue strength of materials of interest. Creep tests for 316H were conducted with fluoride (FLiNaK) and chloride (NaCl-MgCl 2 ) salts tat 650°C/150 MPa while alloys 709 and 617 were tested with FLiNaK at 700C/158 MPa and 750C.146 MPa respectively. Baseline tests were conducted in air to assess the impact of the molten salts on the creep behavior.

22 GENERAL STUDIES OF NUCLEAR REACTORS↗

DOE OSTI2024

Strength stability at high temperatures for additively manufactured alumina forming austenitic alloy

Several fast-spectrum nuclear reactors designed to generate high power (~450 MWe) rely on forced convection of media such as supercritical CO 2 , sodium, or liquid lead to cool the nuclear core, operating at temperatures up to 600 °C. Cost-effective, high-strength Fe-based alumina forming austenitic (AFA) alloys are a promising candidate for the fabrication of critical nuclear components. This study investigated laser powder bed fusion (LPBF) processing of an AFA alloy composition optimized for improved creep resistance. Electron microscopy revealed an elongated grain structure along the build direction with a fine sub-grain cellular structure decorated with (Cr,Fe,Nb) 23 C 6 carbide precipitates at the intercellular boundaries. Finally, at temperatures of 20–900 °C, the LPBF alloy's superior tensile properties compared to its arc-melted counterpart and other advanced steels (e.g., SS316) were attributed to the distribution of nano-sized carbide precipitates, whereas the high ductility was attributed to the LPBF alloy's elongated grain structure.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

DOE OSTI2024

Evaluation of liquid metal embrittlement of F82H and 4340 steels in liquid lithium

Here, to evaluate the liquid metal embrittlement (LME) susceptibility of F82H, a reduced activation ferritic-martensitic (RAFM) steel, a testing procedure using hollow cylindrical tensile specimens was used. Tensile tests are compared between specimens filled with argon and lithium at 200 °C. To validate the procedure, initial testing was performed on type 4340 steel, which is well-known to exhibit LME. Compared to 4340 steel, F82H only showed minor effects of Li exposure, including pre-testing exposures with Li at 400 °C for 1 h and 500 °C for 500 h. Furthermore, changing the strain rate or tensile test temperature also did not show significant embrittlement.

70 PLASMA PHYSICS AND FUSION TECHNOLOGY↗

DOE OSTI2024

Finite Element Modeling of the Phase Change in Thermally-Grown SiO 2 in SiC Systems for Gas Turbines

The operating lifetimes of SiC-based components in combustion environments are directly linked to the adhesion of the protective environmental barrier coating (EBC) layer. One of the major known failure modes for EBCs is the formation of a thick SiO 2 thermally grown oxide (TGO), which decreases coating adhesion and encourages eventual coating spallation. The effect of the TGO thickness under Yb 2 Si 2 O 7 EBCs on silicon carbide was investigated using finite element models (FEMs) with various interfacial architectures and SiO 2 TGO thicknesses. Further, the FEMs incorporated a user-defined material to simulate the volume contraction of the TGO during the silica phase transformation from β-cristobalite to α-cristobalite upon cooling from the stress-free state at 1350°C to room temperature. Systems with and without a silicon bond coating intermediary layer were assessed. It was shown that the TGO phase transformation stress (1.6–1.7 GPa) dominated the increase in stress in the TGO and EBC layers. Furthermore, it was found that stress increase in the TGO was independent of TGO thickness and interface geometry. These results indicate that stabilization of the TGO to mitigate the phase transformation could dramatically improve the performance of SiC-base components with EBCs.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

DOE OSTI2024

Effect of Impurities on the Compatibility of Steels in Supercritical CO 2 at 450°–650°C

Direct-fired supercritical CO 2 (sCO 2 ) power cycles are a pathway to low-CO 2 fossil energy but contain O 2 and H 2 O in the sCO 2 from combustion. The effect of impurities on structural steels was investigated at 450°-650 °C in 30 MPa sCO 2 . The test matrix included 9 and 12%Cr ferritic-martensitic (FM) steels and conventional and advanced austenitic steels exposed for 1000-2000 h with and without additions of 1%O 2 and 0.1%H 2 O to simulate the cycle after water removal. For FM steels, the mass gains and scale thicknesses were similar with and without impurities with the formation of thick, duplex Fe-rich scales in all cases including the observation that Fe 2 O 3 only formed with 1%O 2 . For the austenitic steels, higher mass gains were observed at all temperatures with increased formation of Fe-rich oxides when impurities were added. Carbon ingress was assessed by bulk combustion analysis, glow discharge optical emission spectroscopy (GDOES) and measuring postexposure room temperature tensile properties. In conclusion, bulk C content was strongly increased at 650 °C but not at 450° or 550 °C.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

DOE OSTI2024

Evaluation of coated steels in supercritical CO 2

The carburizing supercritical CO 2 (sCO 2 ) environment limits the use of lower cost steels in the lower temperature (450–650°C) portions of the sCO 2 Brayton cycle because of concerns about internal carburization and embrittlement. Results on a ferritic–martensitic steel and conventional and advanced austenitic steels at 450–650°C in 30 MPa sCO 2 with and without 1% O 2 and 0.1% H 2 O additions have indicated that sCO 2 environments will have lower maximum operating temperatures compared to steam plants. Pack Al and Cr coatings were evaluated at 650°C on T91 and 316H substrates and showed some benefit for up to 2000 h at 650°C, especially without impurities. However, characterization indicated Al 2 O 3 was not formed and Cr-rich carbides formed in the Cr coatings. With the addition of impurities in the sCO 2 , the coatings were less protective at 650°C. Subsequent exposures at 600°C in sCO 2 showed similar behavior. Postexposure evaluations included measuring the bulk C content and room temperature tensile properties. Finally, improvements were indicated but the tensile results were complicated by the high temperature pack coating process affecting the substrate properties.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

DOE OSTI2023

FWP FEAA149: “Next Generation Environmental Barrier Coatings”

Environmental barrier coatings (EBCs) are required coatings for utilization of SiC/SiC ceramic matrix composite (CMC) components in gas turbines, where the EBC represents the life-limiting factor for such components. EBC/CMC systems have shown success in aero-engine applications with increased turbine inlet temperatures and improved efficiencies, which are achieved through higher temperature stability, lower density, and decreased reliance on cooling air compared to traditional superalloys. While industrial gas turbines (IGTs) do not currently utilize SiC/SiC CMCs, the current shift towards low-carbon or carbon-free fuel sources for power generation could result in a need for EBC/CMC components with higher temperature capabilities. In this work, three tasks were outlined to improve understanding of EBC lifetimes to encourage use in IGTs with carbon-free fuel such as hydrogen: 1. Define the bond coating oxidation kinetics and EBC failure criteria, 2. Measure thermal expansion coefficients of each layered material, and 3. Perform advanced characterization and modeling to assess EBC lifetimes. Cyclic steam oxidation tests were conducted on various EBC/Si/SiC chemistries and EBC/SiC architectures to define substrate oxidation kinetics and EBC failure modes. An open-source code was developed to quantify the undulating thermally grown oxide thickness with thousands of measurements from specimen cross-section images. Bond coating oxidation kinetics were determined and used to develop a kinetic and thermodynamic model for predicting EBC lifetimes. High-temperature Raman spectroscopy was utilized for determining the SiO 2 thermally grown oxide phase transformation as the life-limiting feature for EBCs. Model efforts supported the claim that the SiO 2 phase transformation causes elevated stress during thermal cycling with associated cracking that decreases the adhesion strength of the EBC, eventually resulting in coating spallation. The finite element model subroutine will be made publicly available upon internal review. Further development of an EBC lifetime model for IGTs involves definition of a critical SiO 2 thickness for EBC spallation and must also consider both environmental (gas velocity, pressure, etc.) and specimen (EBC dopants, layer architectures, etc.) effects into predicted bond coating oxidation kinetics for long-lifetime components.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

DOE OSTI2023

The Impact of Oxidation-Induced Degradation On Materials Used in Hydrogen-Fired Microturbines

Hydrogen-fueled microturbines are being considered as part of the future green microgrid. However, the use of hydrogen as a fuel presents new challenges for selection and development of suitable high temperature materials for hydrogen combustion. The burning of hydrogen is expected to result in higher operating temperatures and higher than typically observed water vapor contents in exhaust gases versus burning natural gas. In the present work, foil specimens of various Fe- and Ni-based alloys were oxidized in air + 10 % H 2 O and air + 60% H 2 O for up to 5,000 h at 700 °C to simulate the exhaust atmosphere of natural gas and hydrogen-fueled microturbines. Here, the impact of alloy composition and water vapor content on the oxidation/ volatilization induced loss of wall thickness was experimentally evaluated. Enhanced external oxidation and volatilization of Cr 2 O 3 and Ti-doped Cr 2 O 3 scales was observed in air + 60% H 2 O compared to air + 10% H 2 O. No significant impact of the higher water vapor content was observed on Al 2 O 3 scales formed on Fe-based alumina forming alloys. Lifetime modeling was employed to predict the combined effects of water vapor content, gas flow rates, temperature and alloy composition on the oxidation-induced lifetime of the investigated materials.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

DOE OSTI2023

The Dissolution of Cr and Fe at 850°C in FLiNaK and FLiBe

Understanding the solubility of common alloying elements, such as Cr and Fe, in fluoride salts, can provide valuable insights into the degradation process of alloys in these salts and assist in modeling the attack observed in static and flowing conditions. Previous isothermal dissolution experiments at 550°-750°C in FLiNaK showed little effect of time or temperature on the amount of dissolution, which was not expected. Therefore, the purpose of this milestone was to extend those observations to 850°C where Ni-based alloys have been developed with 100+X better creep strength than the historic Hastelloy N alloy developed for molten salt reactors more than 50 years ago. Exposures were conducted in the same commercial FLiNaK and FLiBe salts used in the lower temperature exposures.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

DOE OSTI2023

Measuring the Dissolution of Cr and Fe at 550°-750°C in FLiNaK and FLiBe

Assessing the compatibility of 316H stainless steel with molten fluoride salts has been identified as a key research topic for molten salt reactor development. Current developers are interested in 316H stainless steel due to its ready availability and ASME code qualification. Previous studies of 316H stainless steel compatibility in molten fluoride salts have shown general agreement that Cr is selectively removed from the alloy during the exposures in molten salts. However, the extent of Cr dissolution depends on the initial purity of the salt and Fe also readily dissolves in the salt. In order to model dissolution, it is necessary to understand how time and temperature affect the dissolution rates of the alloying elements which may lead to saturation of these elements in the salt. To study the dissolution of 316H, Cr and Fe specimens were exposed in FLiNaK and LiFBeF2 (FLiBe) salt at three different temperatures (550°-750°C) and three different durations (100-2000 h) in isothermal capsule experiments.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

DOE OSTI2023

Predicting the creep-rupture lifetime of a cast austenitic stainless steel using Larson-Miller and Wilshire parametric approaches

An experimental dataset of just over 100 creep tests of a cast austenitic stainless steel, CF8C-Plus, was analyzed by two temperature-compensated parametric models (Larson-Miller, Wilshire et al.) to predict long-term lifetimes as functions of temperature and stress. The dataset and associated regression analyses showed greater scatter than typically found in recent similar studies of wrought Ni-based alloys by the same two models and was attributed to the microstructural inhomogeneity of the cast stainless steel. Qualitatively, the Larson-Miller formalism showed greater lifetime prediction accuracy than the Wilshire approach, with the latter model's predictive ability being particularly degraded by the presence of two very significant outlier results. This observation suggests that the Larson-Miller approach is more robust when treating rupture-time datasets that show particularly wide experimental scatter. Despite the differences in the overall predictive ability, both models yielded similar predictions of the applied stress at which CF8C-Plus would have a creep-limited lifetime of 100,000 h when loaded below the yield point.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

DOE OSTI2023

Internal carburization and scale formation on austenitic steels in supercritical carbon dioxide

Direct-fired supercritical CO 2 (sCO 2 ) power cycles are being commercialised to revolutionise fossil energy as a low-emission power source. In order to lower the cost of this technology, less expensive steels are needed in the lower temperature segments of the cycle. However, there are concerns about internal carburisation of steels in sCO 2 . A consistent observation is that thin, Cr-rich oxides appear to reduce C ingress compared to thick Fe-rich oxides formed on 9–12% Cr ferritic-martensitic steels. Advanced austenitic stainless steels (SS) like alloy 709 (20Cr-25Ni) are able to continue to form Cr-rich oxides at 650°C, while a conventional type 316 H SS formed a Fe-rich scale. The C diffusion profiles in SS specimens were quantified at 550°C–650°C using glow discharge optical emission spectroscopy and electron probe microanalysis. Analytical transmission electron microscopy was used to compare the thin protective Cr-rich oxide formed on alloy 709 in sCO 2 at 650°C to that formed in ambient air.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

DOE OSTI2023

Rapid Quenching of Molten Salts as an Approach for the Coordination Characterization of Corrosion Products

A new apparatus was built to rapidly cool molten salts in liquid argon to prevent contamination during quenching and enable new insight into the structure in the liquid state. To test the applicability of the apparatus, several industrially relevant chloride salt compositions were first melted, rapidly solidified, and then characterized. The design proved applicable for the rapid quenching of molten salt. Furthermore, the structure of the apparatus prevented exposure of the rapidly quenched salt to impurities (humidity, oxygen, etc.). X-ray diffraction of salt specimens cooled with and without liquid argon showed differences including a structure further from the expected stoichiometric equilibrium with rapid cooling. Of particular interest is the chemical state of metallic impurities, and this may be probed using electron paramagnetic resonance.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

DOE OSTI2023

Raman spectroscopic characterization of SiO 2 phase transformation and Si substrate stress relevant to EBC performance

To accurately model the long-term durability of environmental barrier coatings (EBCs), a more complete understanding of the phase composition and transformations of the thermally grown oxide SiO 2 (TGO) is desired. For the TGO formed during thermal cycling in steam, cristobalite formation and the subsequent β- to α-cristobalite transformation has been identified as a potentially life-limiting mechanism. In this study, Raman micro-spectroscopy was used to quantify the cristobalite transformation on a polycrystalline Si coupon that was exposed to steam at 1350°C for 100 h. The phase transformation was mapped at 200–260°C on the TGO surface at different ramp rates using a heating stage and a micro-positioning stage. The stress in the Si substrate was also determined using Raman spectroscopy by measuring the stress induced peak shift. The α→β phase transformation produced a 300–500 MPa tensile stress in the Si substrate, which compared well to the stress predicted from the volumetric expansion of the cristobalite. In conclusion, quantifying the phase transformation and residual stress are critical tools in developing the next generation of high performance EBCs.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

DOE OSTI2023

Characterization of Fe and Cr Dissolution and Reaction Product Formation in Molten Chloride Salts With and Without Impurities

There is considerable interest in molten chloride salts for several applications including thermal storage and next-generation molten salt reactors (MSRs). Several studies have concluded that Cl salts are highly corrosive to structural materials. Using Oak Ridge National Laboratory’s established methodology, Cl salt compatibility was assessed for candidate Ni-based alloys 230, 600 and 740 H at 600°–800°C in static welded capsules and in flowing thermal convection loop (TCL) salt experiments. Simply drying commercial Cl salt at 550°–650°C and adding~0.05 wt.%Mg was able to produce small specimen mass changes and limited surface attack after 100–1000 h exposures. Intentional additions of H 2 O, NiCl 2 and undried salt were used to better understand the role of impurities and achieve the>50 µm levels of attack reported in other studies. Further, characterisation of Cr depletion and oxide formation in conjunction with pre- and post-test salt chemistry measurements are being used to understand salt compatibility of structural materials.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

DOE OSTI2023

ULTIMATE FY22 Creep Test Facility Report (FY23 ARPA-E Milestone Report)

In the 18-month Phase 1 of this project, a facility was assembled for creep testing of refractory metals at 1300°C. This report focuses on the four creep frames that are operational and using an inert gas system (argon) to limit oxidation of the refractory metal specimens being tested. This report details the operations for the first period of operation including the results and lessons learned for Nb- and Mo-based alloy specimens tested by the ORNL team. For an alloy development program, a particularly unique feature of the ORNL facility is more than 40 years of experience conducting mechanical properties testing on sub-sized test specimens (25 mm long dogbones). Due to proprietary constraints, only one representative set of team data are provided. The primary concern for testing Nb-based alloys is oxygen ingress. Despite several strategies to reliably limit O ingress, including getters and Ar gas purity, the experimentally informed strategy currently being developed is a new load train design intended to better seal the system. Hardware for the new design is currently being fabricated.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗