Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Pronskikh, Vitaly

Publications and source records attributed to Pronskikh, Vitaly.

At least 19 records

Cultural Shifts in High Energy Physics Collaboration from the Cold War to the Present: A Historical and Philosophical Perspective

Here, this article employs empirical history and the philosophy of science to study cultural convergences and divergences in international collaborations in high energy physics. We examine two cases: (1) E-36, an experiment on small angle proton-proton scattering conducted during the Cold War at the National Accelerator Laboratory (NAL) in the USA by Soviet and US scientists and (2) an ongoing collaborative experiment, NICA, at the Joint Institute for Nuclear Research (JINR, Dubna), which is a project devoted to heavy-ion physics. The JINR, particularly its Laboratory of High Energy Physics (formerly the “Laboratory of High Energies”) is the main mediating actor between these two cases (i.e., E-36 and NICA), as the majority of Soviet participants in E-36 were representatives of the Institute. Using empirical data collected through archival searches, field observations conducted at JINR in 2018–2019, and in-depth interviews, we tell a story of cultural differences in high energy physics by applying the concepts of ‘trading zones’ (P. Galison) and the translation of interests in actor-networks (B. Latour, M. Callon and others). We analyze three types of cultural diversity (specialization, nationality, and generational) in light of the implications of temporal context and the dichotomy between East and West, showing the roles cultural diversity plays in scientific collaboration (which is an integral part of as well as obstacle to scientific research that can nevertheless provide learning opportunities). Our study aims to demonstrate how disunity and diversity may function in scientific research and how high energy physics collaborations can remain productive despite sometimes deep divergences, including those between East and West.

72 PHYSICS OF ELEMENTARY PARTICLES AND FIELDS↗

Pion-Production Target for Mu2e-II: Design and Prototype

The higher beam intensity available for Mu2e-II will require a substantially different target design. This paper discusses our recent advances in conceptual R&D for a Mu2e-II target station. The design is based on energy deposition and radiation damage simulations as well as thermal and mechanical analyses to estimate the survivability of the system. We considered rotated targets, fixed granular targets and a novel conveyor target with tungsten or carbon spherical elements that are circulated through the beam path. The motion of the spheres can be generated either mechanically or both mechanically and by a He-gas flow. The simulations identified the conveyor target as the preferred approach, and that approach has been developed into a prototype. We describe this first prototype for the Mu2e-II target and report on its mechanical tests performed at Fermilab that indicate the feasibility of the design, discuss its challenges as well as suggest directions for further improvement.

Neuffer, David↗

Atomistic simulations of He bubbles in Beryllium

Formation of He bubbles can have a significant effect on the microstructural evolution and properties of irradiated materials. In this report, we use atomistic simulations based on machine learning potentials to investigate the fundamental behavior of He bubbles in Be, with a specific focus on the shape, stability, and diffusivity of bubbles. Stability of He bubbles is quantified in terms of formation energies, which are determined as a function of the ratio of He/V. We find that He bubbles become unstable with respect to plastic deformation through punch-out dislocations around the bubble when the He/V ratio is larger than ~1.25, and the punch-out process induces the change of the regular bubble shape. In general, the bubble shape of He in Be is found to be ellipsoid-like. It is also found that for a fixed He/V ratio, the bubble attracts vacancies to become larger in size. If the bubble size is constant, the bubble attracts additional He atoms until the punch-out reaction occurs. The dominant diffusion mechanism of He bubbles changes from surface diffusion to volume diffusion as the temperature is increased, with a crossover occurring at about 900 K.

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

The Ethical Aspects of Choosing a Nuclear Fuel Cycle

In this paper, we addressed the problem of choosing a nuclear fuel cycle. Ethical problems related to the choice of a nuclear fuel cycle, such as the depletion of natural uranium reserves, the accumulation of nuclear waste, and the connection with the problems of nonidentity and distributive justice are considered. Here, we examined cultural differences in attitudes toward nuclear safety and the associated ambiguities in the choice of a nuclear fuel cycle. We suggested that the reduction in consumption of natural uranium does not seem to be a feasible way of reducing nuclear waste because of the nonidentity problem.

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Second Generation Fermilab Main Injector 8 GeV Beamline Collimation Preliminary Design

The current Fermilab Main Injector 8 GeV beamline transverse collimation system was installed in 2006. Since then, proton beam intensities and rates have increased significantly. With the promise of even greater beam intensities and a faster repetition rate when the PIP-II upgrade completes later this decade, the current collimation system will be insufficient. Over the past 18 months, multiple collimation designs have been investigated, some more traditional and others novel. A preliminary design review was conducted and a design chosen. Work is underway to finalize the chosen design, prototype some of its novel components and procure parts for installation Summer 2023.

43 PARTICLE ACCELERATORS↗

What Composition of High-Energy Physics Collaborations is Epistemically Optimal?

Computer simulations have recently come to the fore as a crucial tool for studying epistemic dynamics of scientific collectives. One pressing issue in big-ticket, long-term, and crowded particle physics research is the optimal organization of collaborations. This research developed a computation model of collaborations in high-energy physics and performed simulations to investigate the epistemic efficiency of groups and its dependence on the size of such groups and their composition: namely, percentages of pure, partially theoretically competent, and fully theoretically competent experimentalists. The present study reveals that in both small (100-member) and large (3000-member) groups, epistemic payoff as the measure of epistemic efficiency of collaborations is, generally, positively correlated with an increase in both the number of theoretically fully competent and pure (incompetent) experimentalists. Here, we are less certain of such conclusion in the case of the small collaborations. Although the subcommunity of experimentalists who are partially expert is not found to be immediately epistemically beneficial for collaborations, nevertheless they also crucially serve as a transitional community between the theorists and the experimentalists. Predicated on the toy model simulations, I suggest that institutions should provide measures to assist members of the latter subgroup in progressing toward developing a full theoretical expertise.

72 PHYSICS OF ELEMENTARY PARTICLES AND FIELDS↗

Climate of the Field: Snowmass 2021

How are formal policies put in place to create an inclusive, equitable, safe environment? How do these differ between different communities of practice (institutions, labs, collaborations, working groups)? What policies towards a more equitable community are working? For those that aren't working, what external support is needed in order to make them more effective? We present a discussion of the current climate of the field in high energy particle physics and astrophysics (HEPA), as well as current efforts toward making the community a more diverse, inclusive, and equitable environment. We also present issues facing both institutions and HEPA collaborations, with a set of interviews with a selection of HEPA collaboration DEI leaders. We encourage the HEPA community and the institutions & agencies that support it to think critically about the prioritization of people in HEPA over the coming decade, and what resources and policies need to be in place in order to protect and elevate minoritized populations within the HEPA community.

Hansen, Erin V.↗

Simulation as a sustainable trading zone: Aiming at intergenerational justice

The paper, drawing on the example of simulation codes used in nuclear physics and high-energy physics, seeks to call attention to the ethical implications of discontinuing support for simulation codes and the loss of knowledge embodied in them. Predicated on the concept of trading zones and actor network models, the paper addresses the problem of extinction of simulation codes and attempts to understand their evolution and development within those frameworks. We show that simulation codes of closed type develop to the level of creoles, becoming local languages and standards of scientific centers and disappearing as their few main developers leave, whereas codes of open types become universal languages, imposing problemsolving patterns on the entire community and crowding out other codes. The paper suggests that because of simulations’ reliance on tacit knowledge, practices entrenched in codes cannot be exhaustively explicated or transmitted through writing alone; on the contrary, the life cycle of a simulation code is determined by the life cycle of its trading zone. We examine the extent to which both of these phenomena pose a risk to the preservation of knowledge. Bearing upon intergenerational ethics, we draw analogies between the pure intergenerational problem (PIP) and the problem of preserving the knowledge implemented in simulation codes and transmitting it to future generations. We argue that for the complete transfer of knowledge, it is necessary to develop and maintain inhabitability and sustainability of simulation trading zones in a controllable way, at least until the demand for these codes is warranted to cease in the future.

73 NUCLEAR PHYSICS AND RADIATION PHYSICS↗

Model uncertainty in accelerator application simulations

Monte-Carlo nuclear reaction and transport codes are widely used to devise accelerator-based nuclear physics experiments; at the same time, many experiments are performed to validate the Monte-Carlo codes, which can be used for the design of full-scale nuclear power applications or the design of new benchmark experiments. Dedicated model benchmark studies investigate a broad range of nuclear reactions and quantities. Examples of these include isotope formation or secondary particle fluxes that result from the interactions of GeV-range hadrons with monoisotopic targets, which can be used to assess the respective systematic uncertainty of models. Such benchmark studies, as well as many nuclear application experiments and simulations carried out by various groups over the last few decades, enable us to draw methodological lessons. In this work, model uncertainty determined based on available experimental data allow us to identify the effects of practitioner expertise as well as the design of codes (user access to micro-scale parameters) on the range of uncertainties. We found that in cases when simulations are performed by code developers or users that are very experienced in performing simulations, the model to experiment quantity ratios generally agree with the limits determined by dedicated benchmark studies. In other cases, the ratios generally tend to be either smaller (underestimation of model error) or larger (overestimation of model error). A plausible explanation of the aforementioned effects is suggested.

72 PHYSICS OF ELEMENTARY PARTICLES AND FIELDS↗

Doses and fluxes in the proton-irradiated Big Target: A MARS15 analysis

This work is aimed at determination of secondary particle fluxes, prompt and residual doses as well as energy deposition in and around the Big Target, a 20-tonnes cylindrical target made of natural uranium with the lead core and a stainless-steel yoke, which is being considered to be irradiated by a 0.16-μA 600-MeV proton beam of the JINR Phasotron accelerator. The simulations were performed with the use of the MARS15 particle transport code employing the LAQGSM and CEM generators and based on the ENDFB-VIII neutron cross section library. The calculations for 12-hour, 100-hour, and 3-day irradiations with the aforementioned conditions indicate that temperature rise due to the beam does not require target cooling, the target can be safely handled soon after the end of irradiation, and its decommissioning is possible three years past the irradiation. Doses

43 PARTICLE ACCELERATORS↗

Computer Modeling and Simulation: Increasing Reliability by Disentangling Verification and Validation

Verification and validation (V&V) of computer codes and models used in simulations are two aspects of the scientific practice of high importance that recently have been discussed widely by philosophers of science. While verification is predominantly associated with the correctness of the way a model is represented by a computer code or algorithm, validation more often refers to the model’s relation to the real world and its intended use. Because complex simulations are generally opaque to a practitioner, the Duhem problem can arise with verification and validation due to their entanglement; such an entanglement makes it impossible to distinguish whether a coding error or the model’s general inadequacy to its target should be blamed in the case of a failure. I argue that a clear distinction between computer modeling and simulation has to be made to disentangle verification and validation. Drawing on that distinction, I suggest to associate modeling with verification and simulation, which shares common epistemic strategies with experimentation, with validation. To explain the reasons for their entanglement in practice, I propose a Weberian ideal–typical model of modeling and simulation as roles in practice. I examine an approach to mitigate the Duhem problem for verification and validation that is generally applicable in practice and is based on differences in epistemic strategies and scopes. Based on this analysis, I suggest two strategies to increase the reliability of simulation results, namely, avoiding alterations of verified models at the validation stage as well as performing simulations of the same target system using two or more different models. In response to Winsberg’s claim that verification and validation are entangled I argue that deploying the methodology proposed in this work it is possible to mitigate inseparability of V&V in many if not all domains where modeling and simulation are used.

97 MATHEMATICS AND COMPUTING↗

Book Review: What Makes a Good Experiment? Reasons and Roles in Science

Classification is an arduous and sometimes controversial undertaking because of its inherent cultural particularity. One famous literary example is the fictitious nomenclature of animals found in Jorge Luis Borges’s ‘The Analytical Language of John Wilkins’. According to Borges, that taxonomy was discovered by a translator, F. Kuhn, in a Chinese source and divides all animals into fourteen categories, starting with ‘those that belong to the Emperor’ and ending with ‘those that from a long way off look like flies’. Physics of the twentieth century is a ramified full-fledged technical culture, and it should surprise no one that physics experiments can be classified in different ways, allowing certain experiments to belong to more than one category. Allan Franklin’s analysis of experiments is based on his classification, which substantially grasps the essence of the experimental enterprise. Although Franklin does not offer an explicit answer to the question posed in the title, he does include a detailed examination of several important physics and biology experiments in history

Pronskikh, Vitaly↗

Calculating Residual Dose in Mu2e DS Hall

The Mu2e experiment at Fermilab is a project designed to measure the neutrinoless conversion of muons into electrons. In this experiment there will be particle beams accelerated to relativistic energies impinging upon targets, producing fluxes of secondary particles. It’s among these fluxes where there are substantial fractions of high-energy stable particles arising in spallation and fragmentation reactions, leading to nuclear transmutations in the structural materials surrounding those targets. As a result of neutron activation of the walls and other materials, the structures become radioactive even after the beam has been turned off. This leads to the desire of quantifying the severity of this radiation hazard in order to comply with Fermilab radiological standards.

72 PHYSICS OF ELEMENTARY PARTICLES AND FIELDS↗