Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Siddhartha Krishnamurthy

Publications and source records attributed to Siddhartha Krishnamurthy.

At least 19 records
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
NASA NTRS2026

Helicopter and Urban Air Mobility (UAM) Laboratory Comparison (HULC) Psychoacoustic Test

The Helicopter and Urban Air Mobility (UAM) Laboratory Comparison (HULC) psychoacoustic test was conducted in July 2025 to compare human annoyance responses to noise from UAM vehicles and helicopters. This document provides a literature review, describes the HULC test methodology including stimuli selection and test administration procedures, and presents results from an initial analysis using multilevel statistical modeling. The test utilized 123 sound stimuli from four helicopters and six UAM vehicles across three flight phases (departure, cruise, and approach), presented to 40 subjects in the Exterior Effects Room (EER) at NASA's Langley Research Center. Subjects rated their annoyance on a 0 to 10 scale while imagining hearing these sounds multiple times daily near their homes. Key findings revealed that, at the same A-weighted sound exposure levels, UAM vehicles and helicopters produced similar annoyance responses across all flight phases, with mean differences of only approximately 1 dB and overlapping confidence intervals. However, at equivalent observer distances, UAM vehicles had inherently quieter operations and lower mean annoyance ratings. These results suggest that UAM vehicles and helicopters may be assessed in a similar manner for community noise impact. The quieter noise characteristics of UAM vehicles may provide advantages for operating in communities and integrating into urban environments.

psychoacoustics↗
NASA NTRS2024

An Annoyance Model for Urban Air Mobility Vehicle Noise in the Presence of a Masker

Proposed Urban Air Mobility (UAM) operations offer an alternative to road and rail traffic for local and regional movement of people and goods. To allow for large-scale adoption of UAM vertical takeoff and landing (VTOL) aircraft, it is critical to predict human annoyance response to the acoustic noise generated by these vehicles. We propose a model that predicts an individual’s perceived level of annoyance when presented with UAM VTOL aircraft noise in the context of a representative masking noise. The annoyance model is based on the psychoacoustic annoyance model of Fastl and Zwicker (Zwicker and Fastl, 1999), with an additional tonality term based on subjective testing of UAM sound quality (Boucher, et al., 2023). The model also predicts changes in annoyance when UAM noise is masked by a background sound, based on subjective evaluation of detection, noticeability, and annoyance of noise in the presence of a masker.

Noise↗
NASA NTRS2024

Toward a Psychoacoustic Annoyance Model for Urban Air Mobility Vehicle Noise

A psychoacoustic test was performed to obtain annoyance responses to noise from a quadrotor Urban Air Mobility (UAM) vehicle to aid in the development of a model of annoyance to UAM vehicle noise. Previous analysis of that test concluded that a psychoacoustic annoyance (PA) model, including the effects of loudness, sharpness, fluctuation strength and roughness, correlated well with the collected annoyance responses. This motivated the assessment of other PA models available in the literature, as well as the development of a new PA model based on the previously collected annoyance responses to UAM noise. To build the PA model for UAM noise, annoyance ratings to individual sounds and annoyance comparisons between pairs of sounds are first combined into a latent annoyance scale that has a correlation coefficient of 0.98 with the raw responses and that is based on just-noticeable-differences (JNDs) in annoyance. Examples for two sounds that differ in annoyance by 1 JND show when there is 75% agreement about which sound is more annoying. This latent annoyance (JND) scale also gives insight into the interplay of various perceptual components, such as overall loudness, temporal effects and spectral effects. The proposed PA model for UAM noise is fit to the latent annoyance scale, includes the sound quality effects mentioned above, as well as a term for tonality, and offers a step forward in the prediction of annoyance to UAM vehicle noise.

Urban Air Mobility↗
NASA NTRS2024

Perceptual Evaluation of Sound Exposure Level in Annoyance Ratings to Helicopter Noise

A psychoacoustic test was performed to assess the effectiveness of Sound Exposure Level (SEL) for indicating changes in annoyance to helicopter noise. SEL was evaluated for flyover auralizations of optimized rotor designs and for flyover recordings of different helicopters and maneuvers. The test used paired comparisons of flyovers within 10 dB of the maximum A-weighted sound pressure level. For stimuli of equal SEL, annoyance responses showed whether or not SEL is a good indicator of annoyance. While this work does not seek to determine specific attributes contributing to annoyance that are not included in SEL, the magnitude of this offset is of primary interest. Specifically, annoyance responses to relative differences in SEL allowed the calculation of an Equal Annoyance Point. Reductions in SEL lead to reductions in annoyance as expected, but for certain cases, SEL can fail to capture perceptually significant features such as audible differences due to changes in tail rotor design or unsteadiness in the sound of the helicopter.

Sound Exposure Level↗
NASA NTRS2023

A Hybrid Transfer Function Procedure for Broadband Auralization Within Small Flight Vehicle Interiors

Auralization of the sound fields within flight vehicle interiors is of interest to aircraft designers considering crew and passenger ride quality. Computer models can be used to predict the filtering effects that the fuselage structure and interior volume have on the exterior sound field in order to simulate the resulting cabin interior noise. However, this can become expensive when a wide frequency range of analysis suitable for passenger auralization is desired. This is particularly the case when using deterministic modeling methods such as finite element analysis (FEA) wherein prohibitively high levels of detail and finite element discretizations are required to resolve the wavelengths at high frequencies. On the contrary, Statistical Energy Analysis (SEA), while not capturing important modal behaviors at low frequencies, is better suited for higher frequency analyses where structural and interior dynamics exhibit high modal overlap and spatially averaged physical quantities suffice. For this reason, a hybrid procedure is considered here that utilizes FE modal solutions at lower frequencies and SEA results at higher frequencies. A transfer function dataset containing the exterior to interior vibroacoustic filtering effect is calculated accordingly and subsequently stored to be used for a variety of exterior dynamic load cases. At low frequencies, the transfer function dataset detail is related to the level of FE model refinement whereas at high frequencies it functions as an equalizer array with a level of detail corresponding to the SEA subsystem partitioning scheme. The above procedure is described herein and demonstrated on a six passenger flight vehicle with eight propulsors in a hover flight condition.

auralization↗
NASA NTRS2023

A Hybrid Transfer Function Procedure for Broadband Auralization Within Small Flight Vehicle Interiors

Auralization of the sound fields within flight vehicle interiors is of interest to aircraft designers considering crew and passenger ride quality. Computer models can be used to predict the filtering effects that the fuselage structure and interior volume have on the exterior sound field in order to simulate the resulting cabin interior noise. However, this can become expensive when a wide frequency range of analysis suitable for passenger auralization is desired. This is particularly the case when using deterministic modeling methods such as finite element analysis (FEA) wherein prohibitively high levels of detail and finite element discretizations are required to resolve the wavelengths at high frequencies. On the contrary, Statistical Energy Analysis (SEA), while not capturing important modal behaviors at low frequencies, is better suited for higher frequency analyses where structural and interior dynamics exhibit high modal overlap and spatially averaged physical quantities suffice. For this reason, a hybrid procedure is considered here that utilizes FE modal solutions at lower frequencies and SEA results at higher frequencies. A transfer function dataset containing the exterior to interior vibroacoustic filtering effect is calculated accordingly and subsequently stored to be used for a variety of exterior dynamic load cases. At low frequencies, the transfer function dataset detail is related to the level of FE model refinement whereas at high frequencies it functions as an equalizer array with a level of detail corresponding to the SEA subsystem partitioning scheme. The above procedure is described herein and demonstrated on a six passenger flight vehicle with eight propulsors in a hover flight condition.

auralization↗
NASA NTRS2023

Acoustics Technical Working Group and UAM Noise Working Group Proceedings

The NASA Acoustics Technical Working Group Meeting originally started as a program planning meeting in 1992 and has grown through the years. The purpose of these biannual meetings is to foster communication and collaboration among NASA researchers and their university, industry, and government colleagues on activities and work of current and future mutual interest. The NASA-led Urban Air Mobility (UAM) Noise Working Group (UNWG) Meeting began in 2018 as a one-day meeting immediately following the Acoustics Technical Working Group Meeting. The UNWG utilizes four subgroups that conduct regular meetings throughout the year to focus on challenges facing UAM vehicles for community noise and acceptance. The four subgroups coordinate research for development of noise prediction tools/noise reduction technologies, ground and flight test methods, human response and metrics, and regulations and policy (led by the FAA). This work is a compilation of the presentations given at ATWG/UNWG Fall 2022 held in person and via Teams at NASA Glenn Research Center. All NASA content was previously submitted through STRIVES for public presentation. This is merely a compilation. Non-NASA content has permission to distribute. Slide 208 video is included in the Available Downloads as Medial.MOV.

Advanced Air Mobility↗
NASA NTRS2021

Rotorcraft Sound Quality Metric Test 1: Stimuli Generation and Supplemental Analyses

A psychoacoustic test was conducted at the NASA Langley Research Center Exterior Effects Room (EER) to assess annoyance to simulated helicopter sounds over a range of sound quality (SQ) metric values. Initial findings identified important SQ metrics as sharpness, tonality, and fluctuation strength. This document is a supplement to the initial findings in which the following are discussed: (i) a detailed treatment of the sound generation process, (ii) the impact of analyzing results with stimuli measured in the EER instead of the intended synthesized stimuli, (iii) an evaluation of annoyance responses with certification metrics, and (iv) adjunct analyses related to the test methodology.

Psychoacoustic test, psychoacoustics, sound qualit↗
NASA NTRS2019

Sound Quality Metric Indicators of Rotorcraft Noise Annoyance Using Multilevel Regression Analysis

Although every helicopter in operation has to go through a noise certification process, annoyance due to helicopters still persists within various communities. This implies that certification metrics do not capture the full range of human response and that predicted reactions could be supplemented with other information, which could be acoustic or non-acoustic in nature. The rotorcraft sound quality metric (RoQM) psychoacoustic experiment was designed to determine the relative importance of sound quality metrics (SQMs), such as sharpness, tonality, loudness, fluctuation strength and impulsiveness, on human annoyance to rotorcraft sounds. Starting from a baseline helicopter recording, SQMs were varied synthetically and presented to subjects who responded with an annoyance rating. The RoQM test took place in 2017 at the NASA Langley Research Center in the Exterior Effects Room. A total of 105 sounds were played to 40 subjects. The relationship between helicopter noise sound quality and annoyance is modeled using multilevel regression in this work, which takes into account the variability of responses across subjects. Previous analyses did not consider such a grouping of the data.

Matthew Boucher↗
NASA NTRSDate not supplied

A Synthesis Plug-in for Steady and Unsteady Loading and Thickness Noise Auralization

This paper describes the development and architecture of a plugin for the NASA Auralization Framework that synthesizes rotor sound pressures sample by sample for simulated propagation to auralize rotorcraft flyovers. The main component of the plugin is a preprocessor that synthesizes sound pressures before propagation methods are called. Rotor blade loadings, motion, and geometry data from various tools serve as input to the plugin. Farassat formulation 1A, a solution to the Ffowcs Williams-Hawkings equation, is used for the sound pressure calculations. Use of the plugin is demonstrated with two examples of steady periodic sound synthesis, but the synthesis method and preprocessor architecture described in this paper are also applicable to unsteady periodic and aperiodic sound syntheses.

Siddhartha Krishnamurthy↗
NASA NTRSDate not supplied

A perceptual evaluation of the efficacy of Sound Exposure Level in the rating of annoyance to helicopter noise

A psychoacoustic test was performed that aimed to test how well Sound Exposure Level (SEL) is at indicating changes in annoyance to helicopter noise for simple changes in design as well as for realistic changes found from flight tests. In particular, SEL was evaluated for auralizations of optimized designs of rotor geometries when compared to a baseline design and for recordings that compare different helicopters and maneuvers. Paired comparisons consisted of the 10dB-down portion of flyovers, which is the same portion used to calculate SEL. When played at the same SEL, annoyance responses showed in which cases SEL is a good indicator as well as when other aspects not included in the calculation of SEL may be important. Annoyance responses for relative differences in SEL allowed the calculation of an Equal Annoyance Point, giving further insight to the performance of SEL. Confidence intervals calculated with Monte Carlo simulations showed when responses are statistically different from the equal SEL comparison and also gave an indication of the necessary reduction for designers to be confident that a low noise design is impactful or that a difference in rotorcraft or maneuver is perceptually favorable.

psychoacoustics↗
NASA NTRSDate not supplied

A Perceptual Evaluation of the Efficacy of Sound Exposure Level in the Rating of Annoyance to Helicopter Noise

A psychoacoustic test was performed that aimed to test how well Sound Exposure Level (LAE) is at indicating changes in annoyance to helicopter noise for simple changes in design as well as for realistic changes found from flight tests. In particular, LAE was evaluated for auralizations of optimized designs of rotor geometries when compared to a baseline design and for recordings that compare different helicopters and maneuvers. Paired comparisons consisted of the 10dBA-down portion of flyovers, which is the same portion used to calculate LAE. When played at the same LAE, annoyance responses showed in which cases LAE is a good indicator as well as when other aspects not included in the calculation of LAE may be important. Annoyance responses for relative differences in LAE allowed the calculation of an Equal Annoyance Point, giving further insight to the performance of LAE. Confidence intervals calculated with Monte Carlo simulations showed when responses are statistically different from the equal LAE comparison and also gave an indication of the necessary reduction for designers to be confident that a low noise design is impactful or that a difference in rotorcraft or maneuver is perceptually favorable.

Matthew Alban Boucher↗
NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Prediction-Based Auralization of a Multirotor Urban Air Mobility Vehicle

Recent advances in auralization methods applicable to rotary wing vehicles have made it possible to undertake a prediction-based auralization of a representative multirotor urban air mobility vehicle. These advances include a new capability for synthesizing loading and thickness noise directly from the prediction method and a new capability for predicting and synthesizing modulating broadband self noise within a unified system noise prediction-auralization framework. These capabilities are demonstrated for a six passenger quadrotor reference vehicle design using collective-pitch control. Propagation of the source noise to a ground observer completes the auralization process. The demonstrated capability serves as the basis for future work directed at perception-influenced design of low noise urban air mobility vehicles.

Auralization↗