Search NASA⌕ Search

Engineering topics

Wachsman, Eric

Publications and source records attributed to Wachsman, Eric.

3D Printed, Low Tortuosity Garnet Framework For Beyond 500 Wh/kg Batteries

In this project, we developed LLZO garnet ink recipes and processes for 3D-printing highly ordered ionically conductive garnet porous structures on dense garnet separators. Using this technique, we are able to fabricate controlled architecture LLZO garnet solid-state electrolyte (SSE) trilayers for application in solid-state lithium batteries. The trilayer comprises a thin dense center layer sandwiched between a 3D-printed patterned porous layer and a random porous layer. The dense layer functions as the ionic separator between the anode and cathode. The random porous layer hosts the lithium-metal anode and provides the structural support. The 3D-printed SSE patterned porous layer hosts the cathode, providing continuous, low tortuosity pathways for fast 3D Li+ transport through the cell while increasing the electrode/electrolyte interface area to decrease the interfacial resistance. Compared to the random porous structure, this ordered patterned structure possesses more vacant space for higher cathode loading without sacrificing ionically conducting capability, thus potentially greatly increasing the cell energy density. For demonstration purposes, we developed two patterns for the 3D-printed porous layer: grids and columns, for hosting sulfur and NMC cathode, respectively. The corresponding two types of cells were fabricated and tested, and have demonstrated achievement of theoretical discharge capacity without cathode calendaring. In addition, we developed a fundamental solid-state ionic and electronic transport model to optimize the 3D-printed structures for maximum energy and power density. The model was validated by experiment and provides the critical design criteria for achieving the >500 Wh/kg energy goal as function of C-rate.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

Challenges for and Pathways toward Li-Metal-Based All-Solid-State Batteries

Solid-state batteries utilizing Li metal anodes have the potential to enable improved performance (specific energy >500 Wh/kg, energy density >1500 Wh/L), safety, recyclability, and potentially lower cost (<$100/kWh) compared to advanced Li-ion systems.1,2 These improvements are critical for the widespread adoption of electric vehicles (EVs) and trucks and could create a short-haul electric aviation industry.1-3 Expectations for solid-state batteries are high, but there are significant materials and processing challenges to overcome.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

Challenges for and Pathways Toward Solid-State Batteries

Solid-state batteries utilizing lithium metal anodes have the potential to enable batteries with a specific energy of >500 Wh/kg and an energy density of >1,500 Wh/L for thousands of cycles. When optimized they will improve the energy efficiency, operating temperature range, sustainability, and safety at a lower cost compared to projections for advanced Li-ion batteries. This improved performance is critical for the widespread adoption of electric vehicles and may enable future applications such as electric aviation. Expectations for solid-state batteries are high, there are significant materials and processing challenges that need to be overcome. Some of these challenges are well known; others are more subtle and are just becoming known. The challenges and their solutions must be clearly identified to realize high-energy solid-state Li metal batteries. In the United States, the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) funds the majority of energy storage research and development, including solid state battery research. Web of Science publication analysis shows that worldwide DOE is second largest funder. Work on solid state batteries is distributed across different arms of DOE and is coordinated at headquarters to ensure a broad national portfolio for advanced batteries, including lithium batteries and solid-state battery devices. We note that university and national laboratory researchers in the US with a long-standing interest in solid state batteries is a small, integrated community with recognized impact for publications, patents and startup companies. The opportunity for this group to engage for research with international colleagues is growing, fostered by periodic bilateral meetings supported by DOE and by the recent joint US German research program for lithium battery interface studies. These are valuable opportunities to speed solid-state battery development. The ORNL led virtual workshop, overviewed here, confirms the community’s shared vision of the exciting advances, opportunities, and challenges. Further, we are seeing that this workshop has spawned several new informal collaborations and draft proposals. This encourages us to propose future discussion. On May 11, 2020, Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) hosted a 6-hour, on-line national workshop to discuss recent advances and most the prominent obstacles to realizing solid-state Li metal batteries. The workshop included more than 30+ experts from national laboratories, universities, and companies, all of whom have worked on solid-state batteries for multiple years. The participants shared recent advances, many not yet in print, illustrating that the community has gained significant new insights for solid-state Li battery materials over the last 5 years. In this report, the major outcomes of the workshop are organized to identify the gaps in our scientific knowledge for four core materials science areas: (1) Li metal anodes, (2) the solid electrolyte in contact with Li metal, (3) active cathode materials and solid-state composite cathodes, and (4) solid electrolytes. Illustrative examples and discussions are reported with the more comprehensive issues in the report. Discussion of additional challenges related to processing of solid-state battery materials and to the designs and architectures for mechanically robust, long-lived batteries received less attention due to time constraints. These are good themes for deeper discussion at a follow-on workshop, where a complete list of critical research topics can be identified.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

Safe, Low-Cost, High Energy-Density, Solid-State Li-Ion Batteries

We developed intrinsically safe, robust, low-cost, high-energy-density solid-state Li-ion batteries, by integrating high conductivity garnet-type solid Li ion electrolytes and several different cathodes in tailored microstructures, fabricated by low-cost supported thin-film ceramic techniques, to overcome the primary technological barriers to next generation battery technology. In this ARPA-E project we employed Li-garnet solid-state electrolytes pioneered by one of the co-investigators (Thangadurai) which has room temperature (RT) conductivity of ~10 -3 S cm -1 . The highly stable garnet SSE allowed the use of S, NMC, and other cathodes with Li metal anodes without stability or flammability concerns. We studied the garnet’s stability when exposed to CO 2 and humidity (with or without an ALD coating) and showed that the material can be processed in ambient air for most steps prior to battery assembly, significantly reducing production costs. We extensively studied and scaled up the synthesis of the powder and explored external suppliers of garnet to determine the best pathway for commercial success. We used low-cost and scalable tapecasting fabrication methods to create porous-dense-porous “trilayer” solid electrolyte microstructures with a ~20 μm separating dense layer, and >70% porosity porous layers to host the electrodes. These scalable multilayer ceramic fabrication techniques, without need for dry rooms or vacuum equipment, also provide for dramatically reduced manufacturing costs. The tailored microstructured electrode supports (scaffold) increased interfacial area ~50x, overcoming the high impedance typical of planar geometry SSLiBs, resulting in record-setting 10 mA/cm 2 lithium cycling in a symmetric cell. We expanded our tapecasting ability and showed tapes >25m in length by the end of the project. We demonstrated the ability to sinter garnet without the use of a garnet powderbed, which could have been a major obstacle and waste of material at scale. At the same time, we expanded the size of our trilayers from coin cells (0.7 cm 2 ) to the full format design (30 cm 2 ). To develop full cells, we demonstrated 250 Wh/kg at room temperature with commercial NMC electrode films in a bilayer configuration. Similarly, we demonstrated 280 Wh/kg trilayer Li-S cells at room temperature with >90% capacity retention over 300 cycles. At 90°C we demonstrated 350 Wh/kg with a Li-S trilayer. The high thermal stability of the garnet electrolyte also enabled extended cycling (400 cycles) of a Li-TiS 2 cell at 150 °C, showcasing the exceptional safety and nonflammability of the solid-state trilayer batteries. Ion Storage Systems has taken this technology and knowledge to produce trilayer garnet electrolytes and is building out facilities to commercialize high performance solid state batteries. ISS has hired a strong staff, identified and communicated with a large number of potential partners, and successfully secured follow-on funding.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

Towards Mixed Ionic and Electronic Conducting Li-Stuffed Garnets

Li-stuffed garnet-type Li 7 La 2.75 Ca 0.25 Zr 1.75 Nb 0.25 O 12 (LLCZNO) and Li 7+y La 2.75 Ca 0.25 Zr 1.75-y Nb 0.25 MyO 12 (M = Mn, Fe, Co, Ni; y = 0.1, 0.2, referred to as yM-LLCZNO) were synthesized in air by ceramic synthesis at different sintering temperatures. The resulting compositions were characterized for their phase formation and microstructure, and their ionic and electronic conductivities in air and 7% H 2 /N 2 . Powder X-ray diffraction showed that transition metal-doped LLCZNO garnets contain several impurity phases. The transition metal-substituted samples have lower conductivities than that of the parent LLCZNO. The electronic conductivities of selected transition metal-doped LLCZNO samples were found to be about 4 to 5 orders of magnitude lower than their corresponding ionic conductivity, highlighting the challenge to design single-phase mixed electronic and ionic conducting Li-stuffed garnets in both oxidizing and reducing atmospheres. The research area of single-phase mixed conducting Li-garnet is relatively unexplored at the moment, and a theoretical study will help to elucidate the underlying challenge in doping transition metal in Li-based garnets structure and its effect on transport properties.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

Stabilizing the Garnet Solid-Electrolyte/Polysulfide Interface in Li–S Batteries

Chemical and physical short circuits are the main challenges faced by lithium batteries which compromise battery performance and safety. At the cathode, solvation of active cathode materials and shuttling of unwanted chemical species in the liquid electrolyte result in “chemical short circuits”, which deteriorate the Li metal electrode and limit the deployment of new cathode materials, such as high voltage cathodes, sulfur, and air/O 2 . In Li–S batteries, the repeated shuttling of polysulfides between electrodes constantly corrodes the Li metal anode and the loss of active material will result in low Coulombic efficiency. At the anode, Li dendrite penetration through the separator causes internal electronic, or “physical”, short circuits. Finally, several strategies have been reported to prevent chemical and physical short circuits by using a cathode host, small sulfur molecules, modified separators, or electrolyte additives to alleviate sulfur materials diffusion and shuttling, and finding ways to delay, confine, or block Li dendrites to extend the cycling lifetime and avoid thermal runaway in lithium metal batteries.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

Toward garnet electrolyte–based Li metal batteries: An ultrathin, highly effective, artificial solid-state electrolyte/metallic Li interface

Solid-state batteries are a promising option toward high energy and power densities due to the use of lithium (Li) metal as an anode. Among all solid electrolyte materials ranging from sulfides to oxides and oxynitrides, cubic garnet–type Li 7 La 3 Zr 2 O 12 (LLZO) ceramic electrolytes are superior candidates because of their high ionic conductivity (10 -3 to 10 -4 S/cm) and good stability against Li metal. However, garnet solid electrolytes generally have poor contact with Li metal, which causes high resistance and uneven current distribution at the interface. To address this challenge, we demonstrate a strategy to engineer the garnet solid electrolyte and the Li metal interface by forming an intermediary Li-metal alloy, which changes the wettability of the garnet surface (lithiophobic to lithiophilic) and reduces the interface resistance by more than an order of magnitude: 950 ohm·cm2 for the pristine garnet/Li and 75 ohm·cm 2 for the surface-engineered garnet/Li. Li 7 La 2.75 Ca 0.25 Zr 1.75 Nb 0.25 O 12 (LLCZN) was selected as the solid-state electrolyte (SSE) in this work because of its low sintering temperature, stabilized cubic garnet phase, and high ionic conductivity. This low area-specific resistance enables a solid-state garnet SSE/Li metal configuration and promotes the development of a hybrid electrolyte system. The hybrid system uses the improved solid-state garnet SSE Li metal anode and a thin liquid electrolyte cathode interfacial layer. This work provides new ways to address the garnet SSE wetting issue against Li and get more stable cell performances based on the hybrid electrolyte system for Li-ion, Li-sulfur, and Li-oxygen batteries toward the next generation of Li metal batteries.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

Mechanistic Enhancement of SOFC Cathode Durability

Durability of solid oxide fuel cells (SOFC) under “real world” conditions is an issue for commercial deployment. In particular cathode exposure to moisture, CO2, Cr vapor (from interconnects and BOP), and particulates results in long-term performance degradation issues. Here, we have conducted a multi-faceted fundamental investigation of the effect of these contaminants on cathode performance degradation mechanisms in order to establish cathode composition/structures and operational conditions to enhance cathode durability.

25 ENERGY STORAGE↗

Oxygen Generation from Carbon Dioxide for Advanced Life Support

The partial electrochemical reduction of carbon dioxide (CO2) using ceramic oxygen generators (COGs) is well known and widely studied. However, complete reduction of metabolically produced CO2 (into carbon and oxygen) has the potential of reducing oxygen storage weight for life support if the oxygen can be recovered. Recently, the University of Florida devel- oped novel ceramic oxygen generators employing a bilayer elec- trolyte of gadolinia-doped ceria and erbia-stabilized bismuth ox- ide (ESB) for NASA's future exploration of Mars. The results showed that oxygen could be reliably produced from CO2 at temperatures as low as 400 C. The strategy discussed here for advanced life support systems employs a catalytic layer com- bined with a COG cell so that CO2 is reduced all the way to solid carbon and oxygen without carbon buildup on the COG cell and subsequent deactivation.

Bishop, Sean↗