Where is the ice in comets

Abstract

JHKL photometry of comets P/Tuttle, Meier 1980q, P/Stephan-Oterma, and Bowell 1980b has yielded J-H and H-K colors, uncontaminated by thermal emission, which are nearly identical for all four comets. The colors are inconsistent with the reflection spectrum from a cloud of icy particles, if the particles are composed primarily of any of the ices (H2O, CO2, CH4, or NH3) commonly assumed to be present in the nuclei of comet. Circular variable filter spectra of comet Stephan-Oterma confirm the absence of any absorption features due to these ices. The reflection spectra of these comets appear most like those of Cand S-type asteroids and the ring of Jupiter. Mie calculations for core-mantle particles suggest that ices could be present as thin mantles on inherently reddish, refractory cores, such as magnetite.