GOES-R Spacecraft Verification and Validation Compared with Flight Results

Chapel, Jim; Bevacqua, Tim; Stancliffe, Devin; Ramsey, Graeme; Rood, Tim; Freesland, Doug; Fiorello, John; Krimchansky, Alexander

NASA NTRS · 20190002516

GOES-R Spacecraft Verification and Validation Compared with Flight Results

Chapel, Jim·Bevacqua, Tim·Stancliffe, Devin·Ramsey, Graeme·Rood, Tim·Freesland, Doug·Fiorello, John·Krimchansky, Alexander

View original source ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

The Geostationary Operational Environmental Satellite, R-Series (GOES-R) represents a dramatic improvement in GEO (Geostationary Earth Orbit) weather observation capabilities over the previous generation. To provide these new capabilities, GOES-R incorporates a number of new technologies flying for the first time. As with any new spacecraft design, extensive ground testing was performed to validate the vehicle performance. In this paper, we present several successes and several lessons-learned from the GOES-R verification and validation (V&V) efforts. Included are the Dynamic Interaction Test (DIT) results for jitter assessment, and comparison to flight results. Also included are the effects of thermally-induced alignment perturbations, along with post-launch mitigations. Finally, we discuss unexpected GOES-17 gyro performance, which caused a Safe Mode entry shortly after launch. V&V mitigations are presented, which will be used for the next two GOES-R vehicles.

Explore related subjects

GOES-17 Jitter GOES-R GPS Receiver Dynamic Interaction Test GOES-16

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeX RIS

Chapel, Jim, Bevacqua, Tim, Stancliffe, Devin, Ramsey, Graeme, Rood, Tim, Freesland, Doug, Fiorello, John, Krimchansky, Alexander. 2019-02-01. GOES-R Spacecraft Verification and Validation Compared with Flight Results. https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20190002516

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related reports

NASA NTRS2019

GOES-16 and GOES-17 ABI INR Assessment

The Image navigation and registration (INR) Performance Assessment Tool Set (IPATS) measurement accuracy, within 0.06 pixels, is sufficient for INR assessment. IPATS is not a static system. Additional filters and/or sub-procedures were developed when the demand emerged, e.g. the development of Short Term AbNormal Dectection (STAND) and View Zenith Angle (VZA) filters in post-launch test (PLT) of GOES-16 and GOES-17 respectively. NAV INR accuracy improved with updates and tuning in PLT. Currently, NAV errors are about 1-2 urad for all assessed channels of both ABIs. IPATS NAV assessments will continue to provide feedback for tuning the navigation algorithms and parameters in future updates and future GOES-R series ABIs.

GOES-17↗

NASA NTRS2019

GOES-16 and GOES-17 ABI INR Assessment

The first two satellites of the US Geostationary Operational Environmental Satellite R-Series (GOES-R) were launched on November 19, 2016 and March 1, 2018 respectively. GOES-16 officially became GOES East on December 18, 2017, and the designation of GOES-17 as GOES West occurred on February 12 2019. The Advanced Baseline Imager (ABI) is the primary instrument on GOES-16 and GOES-17 for imaging Earth’s surface and atmosphere to significantly improve the detection and observation of severe environmental phenomena. The Image Navigation and Registration (INR) Performance Assessment Tool Set (IPATS) was developed to assess INR performance of GOES-R series ABI images. In this paper, we first describe the assessment of IPATS algorithm accuracy. Next, we present the relationship between view zenith angle (VZA) and the quality of the IPATS measurements. Lastly, we present GOES-16 and GOES-17 navigation (NAV) assessments results from flight data spanning from the start of INR assessment to June 2019. The results show a) IPATS “stair step” measurement error is less or equal to 0.06 ABI pixel with IPATS baseline configuration; b) VZA is an effective filter to exclude outliers of the measurements; and c) ABI INR for both satellites has improved over time as post-launch tests (PLT) were performed and corrections applied. This paper also shows that the post-launch INR tuning of GOES-17 was much shorter than GOES-16.

GOES-17↗

NASA NTRS2019

GOES-17 Magnetometer On-Orbit Calibration Design and Results

The Geostationary Operational Environmental Satellite-R (GOES-R) is a series of four NOAA weather satellites. Each spacecraft flies a Magnetometer instrument which includes two boom mounted fluxgate sensors located 6.3 and 8.5 meters from the spacecraft. Sensor readings are corrupted by both internal (bias and scale factor) and external (spacecraft emitted fields and misalignments) error sources. In order to estimate the bias, an on-orbit calibration is performed, slewing the spacecraft about multiple axes and then performing a fit of the data to determine zero offset and misalignment terms. The first satellite in the series, GOES-16 was launched in November 2016. Its magnetometer calibration maneuver was found to be inadequate providing insufficient rotation about orthogonal axes. The uncertainty in the estimated biases was found to be in the 3-5 nanotesla range, exceeding the magnetometer accuracy requirement of 1.0 nanotesla. Based on lessons learned, the maneuver was redesigned to provide multiple 360 degree rotations about two orthogonal axes, providing optimal visibility into bias and misalignment. Varying ambient fields over the duration of the calibration maneuvers, corrupts the ability to accurately determine parameters of interest. To address this issue, rather than assuming a constant field for the duration of the maneuver, a non-linear least squares filter was employed that uses a series of spline functions to better fit the ambient field. The number of splines can be varied to minimize the least squares filter residuals. Simulations were performed using 360 days of GOES-16 data to bound the uncertainty in the biases for given residuals of the fit to the ambient field. Following the launch of the second satellite in the series, GOES-17 in March 2018, the new calibration maneuver and enhanced bias estimation algorithm were exercised twice. Based on the residuals of the fit, the uncertainty of the estimated zero offset was reduced by an order of magnitude from 3-5 nanotesla to approximately 0.4 nanotesla per axis. This paper provides details of the maneuver design and the innovative algorithm used to estimate the GOES-17 biases and misalignments.

GOES-17↗