HF Vapor Etching for Stardust Particle Extraction: A Progress Report

Kaitlyn Anne Mccain; Timothy Michael Hahn; Rosalind May Armytage; Wayne Patrick Buckley; Christopher Jorge Snead; Lan Anh Ngoc Nguyen

NASA NTRS · 20230008311

HF Vapor Etching for Stardust Particle Extraction: A Progress Report

Kaitlyn Anne Mccain·Timothy Michael Hahn·Rosalind May Armytage·Wayne Patrick Buckley·Christopher Jorge Snead·Lan Anh Ngoc Nguyen

View original source ↗Export metadata ↓

Abstract

The Stardust mission captured thousands of particles from Jupiter-family comet 81P/Wild 2 using aluminum foil and silica aerogel collection media [1]. Most studies of Wild 2 material examine refractory terminal particles >1 μm in diameter which are extracted individually from the ends of tracks produced by the particle’s impact into the aerogel medium. A substantial (>65 %) mass fraction of the impactors is present as fine-grained (i.e. <1 μm) material in the ‘bulb’ and walls of the tracks, which may contain preserved organic material and presolar grains [2]. Few presolar grains have been identified in Stardust samples, which has been interpreted as owing to destruction upon impact into the foils and preferential sampling of terminal particles rather than a lack of presolar grains in Wild 2 samples [3-5]. By isolating the fine-grained material from these bulbs and performing microbeam and isotopic analyses (i.e., scanning electron microscopy and NanoSIMS), organic matter and presolar grains can be identified and constraints can be placed on the constituents of primitive outer solar system materials.

Explore related subjects

Stardust

Keep this discovery

Explore connections, maps & timelines

BibTeX RIS

Kaitlyn Anne Mccain, Timothy Michael Hahn, Rosalind May Armytage, Wayne Patrick Buckley, Christopher Jorge Snead, Lan Anh Ngoc Nguyen. HF Vapor Etching for Stardust Particle Extraction: A Progress Report. https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20230008311

Cite the original work for its findings. Save a collection to share your selection of sources.

KEEP EXPLORING

Related reports

NASA NTRS2023

An Improved Hf Vapor Etching Apparatus for Stardust Particle Extraction

Introduction: The NASA Stardust mission captured thousands of particles from the Jupiter-family comet 81P/Wild 2 in a collector composed of aluminum foil and blocks of silica aerogel [1]. To date, most Wild 2 particles available for study are relatively large and coherent particles extracted individually from the ends of hollow, carrot-shaped impact tracks produced during impact into aerogel. However, >65% of the impacting mass can be found in the ‘bulb’ of the track, including nearly all of the <1 μm size fraction [2]. This fraction contains organic-rich material and is likely to include presolar grains, representing a critical opportunity to constrain the organic and presolar inventory of primitive outer solar system materials. However, the small size and susceptibility of this fraction to melting or alteration during capture poses significant analytical challenges. Previous attempts to extract and concentrate fine-grained material from the bulb of Stardust tracks have attempted to develop techniques that efficiently destroy aerogel and leave impactor particles relatively unharmed. The low density and high porosity of silica aerogel makes it more susceptible to attack by etching with hydrofluoric acid (HF) [3] or CF4 plasma ashing [4] than collected cometary silicates. Previous studies of HF vapor etching used HF solutions varying between 5 to 49% and noted that at high concentrations and etch rates, a liquid droplet was produced according to the etching reaction 4HF + SiO2 → SiF4 (g) + 2H2O [3]. SiF4 readily decomposes into HF and silicic acid in water, which has the potential to alter the freed cometary silicates. The plasma ashing technique avoids production of a liquid droplet and minimizes damage to embedded silicates but requires specialized equipment [4]. In this abstract, we present recent improvements to the HF etching procedure with the aim of constructing an etching chamber capable of slowly etching silica aerogel using small quantities of dilute HF. The etching chamber can be assembled using readily available materials.

Stardust↗

NASA NTRS2014

Stardust Interstellar Preliminary Examination V: XRF Analyses of Interstellar Dust Candidates at ESRF ID13

Here, we report analyses by synchrotron X-ray fluorescence microscopy of the elemental composition of eight candidate impact features extracted from the Stardust Interstellar Dust Collector (SIDC). Six of the features were unambiguous tracks, and two were crater-like features. Five of the tracks are so-called midnight tracks that is, they had trajectories consistent with an origin either in the interstellar dust stream or as secondaries from impacts on the Sample Return Capsule (SRC). In a companion paper reporting synchrotron X-ray diffraction analyses of ISPE candidates, we show that two of these particles contain natural crystalline materials: the terminal particle of track 30contains olivine and spinel, and the terminal particle of track 34 contains olivine. Here, we show that the terminal particle of track 30, Orion, shows elemental abundances, normalized to Fe, that are close to CI values, and a complex, fine-grained structure. The terminal particle of track 34, Hylabrook, shows abundances that deviate strongly from CI, but shows little fine structure and is nearly homogenous. The terminal particles of other midnight tracks, 29 and 37, had heavy element abundances below detection threshold. A third, track28, showed a composition inconsistent with an extraterrestrial origin, but also inconsistent with known spacecraft materials. A sixth track, with a trajectory consistent with secondary ejecta from an impact on one of the spacecraft solar panels, contains abundant Ce and Zn. This is consistent with the known composition of the glass covering the solar panel. Neither crater-like feature is likely to be associated with extraterrestrial materials. We also analyzed blank aerogel samples to characterize background and variability between aerogel tiles. We found significant differences in contamination levels and compositions, emphasizing the need for local background subtraction for accurate quantification.

Stardust↗

NASA NTRS2014

Stardust Interstellar Preliminary Examination IX: High-Speed Interstellar Dust Analog Capture in Stardust Flight-Spare Aerogel

The NASA Stardust mission used silica aerogel slabs to slowly decelerate and capture impinging cosmic dust particles for return to Earth. During this process, impact tracks are generated along the trajectory of the particle into the aerogel. It is believed that the morphology and dimensions of these tracks, together with the state of captured grains at track termini, may be linked to the size, velocity, and density of the impacting cosmic dust grain. Here, we present the results of laboratory hypervelocity impact experiments, during which cosmic dust analog particles (diameters of between 0.2 and 0.4 lm), composed of olivine, orthopyroxene, or an organic polymer, were accelerated onto Stardust flight spare low-density (approximately 0.01 g/cu cm) silica aerogel. The impact velocities (3-21 km/s) were chosen to simulate the range of velocities expected during Stardust's interstellar dust (ISD) collection phases. Track lengths and widths, together with the success of particle capture, are analyzed as functions of impact velocity and particle composition, density, and size. Captured terminal particles from low-density organic projectiles become undetectable at lower velocities than those from similarly sized, denser mineral particles, which are still detectable (although substantially altered by the impact process) at 15 km/s. The survival of these terminal particles, together with the track dimensions obtained during low impact speed capture of small grains in the laboratory, indicates that two of the three best Stardust candidate extraterrestrial grains were actually captured at speeds much lower than predicted. Track length and diameters are, in general, more sensitive to impact velocities than previously expected, which makes tracks of particles with diameters of 0.4 lm and below hard to identify at low capture speeds (<10 km/s). Therefore, although captured intact, the majority of the interstellar dust grains returned to Earth by Stardust remain to be found.

Stardust↗