Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “Alloy Design”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 289 records · Page 16
All sourcesNASA NTRSDOE OSTI
DOE OSTI2025

Temperature-Dependent Mechanical Properties of Ni-Based Concentrated Alloys: Insights from First-Principles Calculations

The present work focuses on predicting temperature-dependent mechanical properties of Ni-based concentrated alloys Ni 18 Cr 10 Co 10 Fe 6 M 4 (abbreviated by X 44 M 4 , with M = Al, V, Mn, Fe, Nb, Mo, and W) using density functional theory (DFT). These predictions are based on shear (plastic) and elastic deformations, utilizing the special quasirandom structure (SQS), the phonon-based quasiharmonic approach (QHA), and the quasistatic approach. The resulting properties include coefficient of thermal expansion via QHA, ideal shear strength (τ IS ), and stable and unstable stacking fault energies (γ SF and γ US ) through pure alias shear deformation, and elastic constants (c ij ), bulk modulus (B 0 ), and shear modules (G 0 ) via elastic deformation. Notably, predicting accurate γ SF is challenging due to uncertainties that can exceed the γ SF values. τ IS and γ US exhibit a strong linear relationship, enabling the accurate prediction of γ US based on the precisely determined τ IS . All mechanical properties of X 44 M 4 decrease with increasing temperature, except for some γ SF cases such as X 44 M 4 with M = V, Mn, Fe, Mo, and W. Among the X 44 M 4 alloys, X 44 Nb 4 exhibits the lowest τ IS , γ US , and G 0 values, and the highest B 0 /G 0 ratio, while X 44 Mn 4 has the lowest B 0 and B 0 /G 0 ratio. We found that volume is a crucial descriptor for understanding and modeling mechanical properties (except B0 and maybe also γ SF ) affected by alloying elements and temperature. Ni-based dilute alloys (e.g., Ni 11 M 1 and Ni 31 M 1 ) and concentrated alloys (e.g., X 44 M 4 ) show similar trends in mechanical properties influenced by alloying elements and temperature, simplifying the analysis and design of Ni-based alloys.

Elastic properties↗
NASA NTRSDate not supplied

Demonstration of How Manufacturing Innovations Challenge Conventional Structural Design

For almost 100 years, commercial aircraft have been fabricated using riveted aluminum alloy structures. Aside from refining aircraft designs for better aerodynamic efficiency, improving alloy compositions, and automating assembly steps, fuselage construction remains largely unchanged today. The intent of the lightweight metallic fuselage prototype undertaken in NASA’s Advanced Air Transport Technology project was to demonstrate innovative forming and joining processes that advance the design paradigm, i.e. achieve high-rate manufacturing and reduce assembly time/costs. Over the past decade, researchers at NASA Langley Research Center have evaluated the potential to modify the flow forming process to produce near-net shaped cylinders, integrally stiffened along the cylinder axis, for space launch vehicles. The production of integral stiffeners in a formed aluminum cylinder, the size of the Space Shuttle external tank, replaced machined thick plate and welding steps to eliminate > 500,000 pounds of machining chips and ~ 0.5 miles of welds. The flow forming method, called the Integrally Stiffened Cylinder (ISC) process, was successfully demonstrated up to the 10-foot diameter scale, which laid the groundwork for the current investigation of metallic fuselage structures. Using the ISC process as the basis for the re-design of a metallic fuselage eliminates hundreds of thousands of holes and rivets, while significantly reducing assembly time and crack initiation sites in the integral structure. However, the ISC process is not currently configured to fabricate circumferential ring frames for carrying fuselage internal pressure loads. Consequently, a trade study was performed to assess existing and advanced manufacturing processes, including additive manufacturing, forming, and welding. The approach with the lowest barriers to success, while simultaneously improving manufacturing time and cost, was to use formed ring frame segments attached to the ISC via Refill Friction Stir Spot Welding (RFSSW). The RFSSW process is five times faster than drilling, reaming, and riveting and provides similar mechanical performance. Finishing the fuselage structure with conventional windows, floor beams, and floor panels can then be accomplished using incumbent assembly methods, thereby maximizing reuse of existing infrastructure for aircraft construction. Structural analyses were performed to assess and optimize the geometric variables of integrated skin and stiffener configurations. A cost benefit and manufacturing rate analysis was also performed to compare against the current state-of-the-art for single aisle transport class aircraft. The resulting structure offers a weight reduction that rivals current graphite-epoxy composite fuselage structures. The projected manufacturing rate is close to double current metallic fuselages and six times faster than current composite manufacturing practices. The damage tolerance properties of a monocoque fuselage structure have yet to be assessed, but past integral airframe structural work has exploited geometric features to blunt or turn cracks. This concept offers promise that integrated structures can meet stringent aircraft durability specifications. An important benefit is that such aluminum fuselage structures may be inspected and repaired using established practices and existing expertise. Finally, pursuit of advanced manufacturing processes for future aluminum fuselages minimizes waste and the structure is 100% recyclable at the end-of-life for maximum sustainability.

aluminum↗
DOE OSTI2025

High-Entropy Alloys for Accelerator Beam Window Applications

Development of novel high-entropy alloys (HEAs) is currently underway for potential use as beam windows in future multi-megawatt target systems at Fermilab. HEAs encompass a new class of materials with a vast design space allowing for material properties to be tailored for particular applications and to potentially offer improved resistance to beam-induced radiation damage and thermal shock effects. The alloy systems being studied consist of several compositions of AlCoCrMnTiV with 4 6 component elements. These alloys are all predicted by CALPHAD simulation to have a single-phase BCC crystal structure and low density, with some compositions displaying ordered, nanoscale precipitates. This presentation will briefly discuss alloy design and synthesis before giving a detailed description of the characterization studies of these HEAs in both the pristine state and post-irradiation by low-energy heavy ions to high damage levels. Electron microscopy techniques to quantify elemental homogeneity and composition, determine grain size, shape, and orientation, and quantify lattice parameters, defect structures and precipitate phases are all being used to study alloy microstructures. Mechanical properties of the alloys at the microscale will be reported. The evolution of these properties as a function of radiation damage will also be described. Bulk thermal characteristics of these HEAs have been tested to measure specific heat capacity and coefficient of thermal expansion as a function of temperature. To determine bulk tensile properties a miniature tensile testing apparatus is under development; it s commissioning will be covered briefly. The talk will conclude with our plans for alloy down-selection.

Burleigh, A. [Fermilab]↗
DOE OSTI2025

Fabrication and Testing of Solid-Solution Strengthened Corrosion Resistant Alloys For Service in Molten Fluoride Environments

The demand for higher system thermal efficiencies requires the operation of power generation cycles and heat conversion systems at progressively higher temperatures. As the system operating temperature increases, existing materials may not provide adequate mechanical properties or environmental compatibility or both. There is an increasing commercial interest in the development and deployment of liquid-fueled Molten Salt Reactors (MSRs). Hastelloy®N, the highest performing candidate MSR structural alloy, is not capable of operations at temperatures above 700°C, thus limiting the performance of these systems. Using an Integrated Computational Materials Engineering (ICME)-approach and small laboratory scale heats, ORNL developed a class of patented alloys covered by U.S. Patent 9, 435, 011 B2, “Creep-resistant, Cobalt-free alloys for high temperature, liquid-salt heat exchanger systems,” similar to Hastelloy®N in that they are primarily solid solution strengthened. In contrast to precipitation strengthened alloys, the microstructure of solid solution alloys and hence the high temperature mechanical properties are stable for extended periods of time allowing long reactor operating life. The new alloys have shown to possess good resistance to liquid fluorides at temperatures up to 850°C and have significantly improved creep properties when compared to Hastelloy®N. The purpose of the CRADA project was for ORNL to collaborate with Haynes International- a materials producer, MetalTek International- a foundry, and Kairos Power – an advanced reactor developer – to scale-up selected alloys, evaluate their properties, and identify one solid solution strengthened alloy that can meet the property requirements for the reactor being developed by Kairos Power and other similar liquid fluoride-salt cooled reactors. As part of the project, eight alloys were down-selected and fabricated in larger industrial scale heats by Haynes International. Resistance to molten salt was evaluated in flowing FLiNaK and FLiBe by Kairos Power using their Rotating Cage Loop (RCL) system. Accounting for iron deposition during these tests, the new alloys displayed very low net mass change showing excellent corrosion performance in molten salt. Creep properties evaluated at ORNL were found to be better than that of Hastelloy®N and 316 stainless steel. Long-term stabilities of the alloys evaluated by Haynes International showed that these alloys have excellent thermal stability in the temperature range 704.4-815.6°C, with the change in strength and ductility being less than 10-15% after a 4000-hour exposure at 815.6°C. Autogenously Gas Tungsten Arc Welding (GTAW) welded samples showed less than 10% change in yield strength / ultimate tensile strength / total elongation compared to the basemetal, indicating that the alloys have excellent weldability. Three parts were successfully investment-cast using one alloy with very little voiding showing feasibility of fabricating parts using the casting process. This project enabled extensive interaction between the material producer Haynes International, casting supplier MetalTek, and reactor developer Kairos Power. This facilitated testing of materials and components produced using the newly developed alloys by the end-user. This allowed the generation of critical dataset required for down-selection of a few promising alloys for further development. This data is also currently being shared with other reactor designers for them to evaluate the suitability of this alloy for their reactor design. The availability of this alloy will ultimately enable the design and development and deployment of MSRs with increased temperature of operation and thus, improved efficiencies.

99 GENERAL AND MISCELLANEOUS↗
NASA NTRS1994

Simplex turbopump design

Turbomachinery used in liquid rocket engines typically are composed of complex geometries made from high strength-to-weight super alloys and have long design and fabrication cycle times (3 to 5 years). A simple, low-cost turbopump is being designed in-house to demonstrate the ability to reduce the overall cost to $500K and compress life cycle time to 18 months. The simplex turbopump was designed to provide a discharge pressure of 1500 psia of liquid oxygen at 90 lbm/s. The turbine will be powered by gaseous oxygen. This eliminates the need for an inter-propellant seal typically required to separate the fuel-rich turbine gases from the liquid oxygen pump components. Materials used in the turbine flow paths will utilize existing characterized metals at 800 deg R that are compatible with a warm oxygen environment. This turbopump design would be suitable for integration with a 40 K pound thrust hybrid motor that provides warm oxygen from a tapped-off location to power the turbine. The preliminary and detailed analysis was completed in a year by a multiple discipline, concurrent engineering team. Manpower, schedule, and cost data were tracked during the process for a comparison to the initial goal. The Simplex hardware is the procurement cycle with the expectation of the first test to occur approximately 1.5 months behind the original schedule goal.

Marsh, Matt↗
NASA NTRS1981

Advanced oxide dispersion strengthened sheet alloys for improved combustor durability

Burner design modifications that will take advantage of the improved creep and cyclic oxidation resistance of oxide dispersion strengthened (ODS) alloys while accommodating the reduced fatigue properties of these materials were evaluated based on preliminary analysis and life predictions, on construction and repair feasibility, and on maintenance and direct operating costs. Two designs - the film cooled, segmented louver and the transpiration cooled, segmented twin Wall - were selected for low cycle fatigue (LCF) component testing. Detailed thermal and structural analysis of these designs established the strain range and temprature at critical locations resulting in predicted lives of 10,000 cycles for MA 956 alloy. The ODs alloys, MA 956 and HDA 8077, demonstrated a 167 C (300 F) temperature advantage over Hastelloy X alloy in creep strength and oxidation resistance. The MA 956 alloy was selected for mechanical property and component test evaluations. The MA 956 alloy was superior to Hastelloy X in LCF component testing of the film cooled, segmented louver design.

Henricks, R. J.↗
DOE OSTI2025

Fabrication and Testing of Solid-Solution Strengthened Corrosion Resistant Alloys For Service in Molten Fluoride Environments

The demand for higher system thermal efficiencies requires the operation of power generation cycles and heat conversion systems at progressively higher temperatures. As the system operating temperature increases, existing materials may not provide adequate mechanical properties or environmental compatibility or both. There is an increasing commercial interest in the development and deployment of liquid-fueled Molten Salt Reactors (MSRs). Hastelloy®N, the highest performing candidate MSR structural alloy, is not capable of operations at temperatures above 700°C, thus limiting the performance of these systems. Using an Integrated Computational Materials Engineering (ICME)-approach and small laboratory scale heats, ORNL developed a class of patented alloys covered by U.S. Patent 9,435,011 B2, “Creep-resistant, Cobalt-free alloys for high temperature, liquid-salt heat exchanger systems,” similar to Hastelloy®N in that they are primarily solid solution strengthened. In contrast to precipitation strengthened alloys, the microstructure of solid solution alloys and hence the high temperature mechanical properties are stable for extended periods of time allowing long reactor operating life. The new alloys have shown to possess good resistance to liquid fluorides at temperatures up to 850°C and have significantly improved creep properties when compared to Hastelloy®N. The purpose of the CRADA project was for ORNL to collaborate with Haynes International- a materials producer, MetalTek International- a foundry, and Kairos Power – an advanced reactor developer – to scale-up selected alloys, evaluate their properties, and identify one solid solution strengthened alloy that can meet the property requirements for the reactor being developed by Kairos Power and other similar liquid fluoride-salt cooled reactors. As part of the project, eight alloys were down-selected and fabricated in larger industrial scale heats by Haynes International. Resistance to molten salt was evaluated in flowing FLiNaK and FLiBe by Kairos Power using their Rotating Cage Loop (RCL) system. Accounting for iron deposition during these tests, the new alloys displayed very low net mass change showing excellent corrosion performance in molten salt. Creep properties evaluated at ORNL were found to be better than that of Hastelloy®N and 316 stainless steel. Long-term stabilities of the alloys evaluated by Haynes International showed that these alloys have excellent thermal stability in the temperature range 704.4-815.6°C, with the change in strength and ductility being less than 10-15% after a 4000-hour exposure at 815.6°C. Autogenously Gas Tungsten Arc Welding (GTAW) welded samples showed less than 10% change in yield strength / ultimate tensile strength / total elongation compared to the basemetal, indicating that the alloys have excellent weldability. Three parts were successfully investment-cast using one alloy with very little voiding showing feasibility of fabricating parts using the casting process. This project enabled extensive interaction between the material producer Haynes International, casting supplier MetalTek, and reactor developer Kairos Power. This facilitated testing of materials and components produced using the newly developed alloys by the end-user. This allowed the generation of critical dataset required for down-selection of a few promising alloys for further development. This data is also currently being shared with other reactor designers for them to evaluate the suitability of this alloy for their reactor design. The availability of this alloy will ultimately enable the design and development and deployment of MSRs with increased temperature of operation and thus, improved efficiencies.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2025

Advancements in the modification of TiFe alloys for enhanced hydrogen Storage: Strategies and future Directions

Hydrogen is considered a promising clean energy source, and a potential alternative to conventional fossil fuels. TiFe alloy has been particularly interesting due to its ability to reversibly absorb and desorb hydrogen at room temperature and low pressure. The initial hydrogen absorption stage of TiFe alloy requires activation under high-temperature and high-pressure conditions, which hinders its practical application. Here, this paper primarily examines the impact of elemental substitution methods on the hydrogen storage capabilities of TiFe alloys, with a particular emphasis on elucidating the mechanisms associated with various substituent elements. Commonly utilized elements, such as Mn, V, and Zr, significantly improve the activation performance of TiFe alloys. Additionally, the incorporation of elements such as Ni, Cr, Ce, and Y contributes to the modulation of phase composition, as well as the enhancement of activation and kinetic properties. However, there exists a notable deficiency in systematic investigations concerning alternative elements, coupled with a frequent oversight of the preparation process's influence on the hydrogen storage characteristics of these alloys. Consequently, the mechanisms by which different elements affect the hydrogen storage process in TiFe alloys remain inadequately understood among current research, thereby complicating the establishment of experiment-based design guidelines for TiFe alloys. Furthermore, the plasma treatment and high-entropy alloying present new approaches for optimizing the hydrogen storage properties of TiFe alloys. This paper aims to present novel research perspectives and insights to scholars in the field by introducing methods for the modification of TiFe alloys.

Hydrogen storage↗
DOE OSTI2024

Alloying Effects on the Transport Properties of Refractory High-entropy Alloys

Additive Manufacturing (AM) has opened new frontiers for the design of refractory high-entropy alloys (HEAs) for high-temperature applications. The thermal conductivity of the AM feedstock is among the most important thermo-physical properties that control the melting and solidification process. Despite its significance, there remains a notable gap in both computational and experimental research concerning the thermal conductivity of HEAs. Here, we use density functional theory (DFT) to systematically investigate the alloying effects on the transport properties of Ti-Cr-Mo-W-V-Nb-Ta RHEAs, including electrical and thermal conductivities and Seebeck coefficient. The relaxation time of charge carriers is a key underlying parameter determining thermal conductivity that is exceedingly challenging to predict from first principles alone, and we thus follow the approach by Mukherjee, Satsangi, and Singh [Chem Mater 32, 6507 (2022)] to optimize the relaxation time for RHEAs. Here we validated thermal conductivity predictions on elemental solids, binary and ternary alloys, and RHEAs and compared them against thermodynamic (CALPHAD) predictions and our experiments with good correlations. To understand observed trends in thermal conductivity, we assessed the phase stability, electronic structure, phonon, and intrinsic- and tensile strength of down-selected RHEAs. Our electronic structure and phonon results connect well with the observed compositional trends for thermal transport in RHEAs. Our DFT assessment and CALPHAD predictions provide a unique design guide for RHEAs with tailored thermal conductivity, a critical consideration for AM and thermal-management applications.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2025

Design of lightweight BCC multi-principal element alloys with enhanced hydrogen storage using a machine learning-driven genetic algorithm

Body-centered cubic (BCC) based multi-principal element alloy (MPEA) hydrides have demonstrated significant potential for compact and efficient hydrogen storage. In this work, we first leverage machine learning (ML) models to predict the hydrogen affinity, storage capacity and phase stability of BCC MPEAs, creating a unique hydrogen-to-metal (H/M) predictor for materials with unprecedented performance. We developed a metaheuristic optimizer high-throughput framework by interfacing ML models with a genetic algorithm for the accelerated search of {Mg, Al, Ti, V, Cr, Mn, Fe, Co, Ni, Cu, Nb, Mo} based lightweight BCC MPEAs with improved hydrogen storage characteristics. We report five new MPEAs with a predicted gravimetric hydrogen storage capacity of around 3.5 wt% or more, including Cr 0.09 Mg 0.73 Ti 0.18 (4.25 wt% H) and Cr 0.21 Nb 0.11 Ti 0.35 V 0.33 (3.5 wt% H). The electronic structure of the top-performing composition, Cr 0.09 Mg 0.73 Ti 0.18 , was analyzed using density functional theory (DFT) to understand the reasons for its improved hydrogen storage properties compared to TiFe (1.90 wt% H), LaNi 5 (1.37 wt% H) or BCC MPEAs like TiVNbCr (3.70 wt% H). Temperature-dependent molecular dynamics (MD) studies were further performed on optimized BCC MPEAs to qualitatively study hydrogen mobility and analyze the effect of different elemental composition on bulk hydrogen diffusion. Our findings demonstrate how a ML assisted genetic algorithm framework can be used for efficient search of stable, lightweight and cost-effective MPEAs while minimizing the need for expensive ab initio calculations.

DFT↗
DOE OSTI2025

Designing for cooperative grain boundary segregation in multicomponent alloys

Tailoring the nanoscale distribution of chemical species at grain boundaries is a powerful method to dramatically influence the properties of polycrystalline materials. However, classical approaches to the problem have tacitly assumed that only competition is possible between solute species. In this paper, we show that solute elements can cooperate in the way they segregate to grain boundaries: In properly targeted alloys, the different chemical species cooperate to each fill complementary grain boundary sites disfavored by the other. By developing a theoretical “spectral” approach to this problem based on quantum-accurate grain boundary site distributions, we show how grain boundaries can be cooperatively alloyed, whether by depletion or enrichment. We provide machine-learned cosegregation information for over 700 ternary aluminum-based alloys and experimentally validate the concept in one ternary alloy where cosegregation is not expected by prior models but is expected based on the cooperative model.

grain boundaries↗
DOE OSTI2024

Development Results on Replacement Materials for Current Scarce or High Supply Chain Risk Materials

In September 2020, the U.S. government issued an executive order to address the threat to the domestic supply chain from its reliance on critical minerals (CMs) from foreign competitors and to support the domestic mining and processing industry. The Advanced Materials and Manufacturing Technology (AMMT) program is addressing this executive order by evaluating advanced manufacturing (AM) and its impact on the demands of CMs for energy production in general and how the deployment of AM in nuclear energy will support the projected goals of the Paris Accord and further a net-zero carbon economy (NZE) by 2050. Three strategic reports were previously prepared by the AMMT program to date and identified two areas for more detailed exploration: (1) the replacement of high-risk CMs such as cobalt and niobium by more abundant minerals and (2) the minimization and utilization of CM waste streams. The design of nuclear materials without critical elements as alloying elements, is a part of the nuclear materials strategy to overcome the critical minerals scarcity. In this report, two approaches are evaluated namely (1) replacement of critical elements as alloying elements in nuclear materials, and (2) the design of a new alloys that does not contain critical minerals as an alloying element.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
DOE OSTI2025

Discovery, Design, Synthesis and Testing of High Performance Structural Alloys (Final Technical Report)

The overarching goal of this project is to understand the phase stability and mechanical behavior of non-stoichiometric multi-principal element alloy (MPEA) materials. In order to identify suitable alloys, we plan to use a combinatorial thin film screening approach, in collaboration with scientists at Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory who are performing computational work as well as complementary experimental work. Specific tasks within the scope of this project include the fabrication, using thin film deposition from six sputtering targets, of combinatorial samples with multi-dimensional gradients in composition and microstructure. These samples are studied to screen MPEA systems for promising candidate alloys with specific composition(s), based on characterization of composition, structure and mechanical behavior across the thin film. We want to produce single-phase MPEAs with chemical homogeneity in a given thin film region, simple grain structures, and no intermetallic phases present. Gradient films facilitate first-pass screening for desirable characteristics and inform the next stage of work that involves fabrication of bulk MPEA specimens for (tensile) mechanical testing and characterization. To make the bulk alloys, metal (elemental) pieces are melted to form MPEAs, followed by heat treatment to homogenize the composition and microstructure. A subset of alloys is also cast, using vacuum arc melting, to yield larger samples (diameter ~1 cm and length ~5-10 cm) and these allow us to assess viability of scale-up for the alloys in structural applications. Further processing plans include rolling and heat treatment to recrystallize selected bulk MPEAs and grow grains to different extents, in order to investigate size effects in the mechanical behavior of MPEAs. Microspecimen testing will be performed (primarily in tension) to assess the mechanical behavior over a range of temperatures. The deformation microstructure of mechanically tested alloys will be characterized using transmission electron microscopy (TEM) to provide a scientific basis for understanding the structure-property relationships in MPEA mechanical behavior.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗
NASA NTRS1972

Determination of design allowable properties. Fracture of 2219-T87 aluminum alloy

A literature survey was conducted to provide a comprehensive report of available valid data on tensile properties, fracture toughness, fatigue crack propagation, and sustained load behavior of 2219-T87 aluminum alloy base metal and weldments, as applicable to manned spacecraft tankage. Most of the data found were from tests conducted at room temperature, -320 F and -423 F. Data are presented in graphical and tabular form, and areas in which data are lacking are established.

Engstrom, W. L.↗
NASA NTRS1977

The design of an Fe-12Mn-O.2Ti alloy steel for low temperature use

An investigation was made to improve the low temperature mechanical properties of Fe-8 approximately 12% Mn-O 2Ti alloy steels. A two-phase(alpha + gamma) tempering in combination with cold working or hot working was identified as an effective treatment. A potential application as a Ni-free cryogenic steel was shown for this alloy. It was also shown that an Fe-8Mn steel could be grain-refined by a purely thermal treatment because of its dislocated martensitic structure and absence of epsilon phase. A significant reduction of the ductile-brittle transition temperature was obtained in this alloy. The nature and origin of brittle fracture in Fe-Mn alloys were also investigated. Two embrittling regions were found in a cooling curve of an Fe-12Mn-O 2Ti steel which was shown to be responsible for intergranular fracture. Auger electron spectroscopy identified no segregation during solution-annealing treatment. Avoiding the embrittling zones by controlled cooling led to a high cryogenic toughness in a solution-annealed condition.

Hwang, S. K.↗