Constraints on triple oxygen isotope kinetics
Triple oxygen isotope measurements have been used as tracers for classifying meteorites, as indicators of atmospheric chemistry and as a proxy for primary productivity among other uses. These utilities rely on the mass dependency of most chemical reactions: δ17O is proportional to δ18O by roughly a factor of 0.5. However,in detail it is known that mass-dependency factorsvary. Constraints on mass dependency are well established for equilibrium isotope effects, but similar constraints for kinetic isotope effects are lacking.Here, we provide constraints for isotope effects generated by unidirectional chemical reactions (i.e. kinetic isotope effects, KIEs). A simplified Monte Carlo model is used to estimatethe range of kinetic isotope effects. It is found that the range of KIEs exceeds the range of equilibrium isotope effects such that some mass dependent kinetic isotope effects could be mistaken for being mass-independent. For the16O-17O-18O system,Δ′17Ovariations as large 0.8‰ can be generated from a single reaction step. Two case studies from published literature, on the thermal decomposition of calcite (CaCO3) and brucite (Mg(OH)2), are used to test the extreme limits of the modeled results. Isotope fractionationsgenerated fromdensity functional theory models of the surface reaction steps are shownto match the published data. The fractionation models are strictly mass dependent thus this result suggests thermal decomposition of calcite is also mass dependent. Although oxygen is the focus here, our approach applies to any system with more than two isotopes.