Linking initial microstructure to microstructure evolution and conductivity change in SOFC electrodes: a phase field simulation
Presented by NETL at SOFC-XV, 7/17
SEARCH · Search NASA
Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.
Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.
Presented by NETL at SOFC-XV, 7/17
Work proposed in this project focused on understanding the effect of martensitic transformation in the steel on the potential for cracking during seamless induction hardening (SIH) as a function of process conditions to allow the process to optimally scale up. Large-scale, three-dimensional phase-field simulations of martensitic transformation were performed using MEUMAPPS-SS (Microstructure Evolution Using Massively Parallel Phase-field Simulations – Solid State) code developed at Oak Ridge National Laboratory. The simulations were guided by location-specific thermal history generated by experimental measurements of time-temperature history generated at The Timken Company. The simulations were able to capture the morphological evolution of the martensite variants in an Fe-1.0C-1.5Cr steel based on the Nishiyama-Wasserman (NW) orientation relationship. The simulations were also able to quantify the stress-state at the interface between impinging martensite variants. The simulations indicated that the magnitude of the various stress and strain components were dependent on the sizes of the impinging plates with a reduction in these quantities with reduced plate size in agreement with experimental findings. The results obtained from the simulations will be used to guide the optimization of the alloy thermal conditions to eliminate quench cracking during SIH of bearing steels.
Accounting for the combined effect of multiple sources of stochasticity in material attributes, we develop an approach that computationally predicts the probability of ignition of polymer-bonded explosives (PBXs) under impact loading. The probabilistic nature of the specific ignition processes is assumed to arise from two sources of stochasticity. The first source involves random variations in material microstructural morphology; the second source involves random fluctuations in grain-binder interfacial bonding strength. The effect of the first source of stochasticity is analyzed with multiple sets of statistically similar microstructures and constant interfacial bonding strength. Subsequently, each of the microstructures in the multiple sets is assigned multiple instantiations of randomly varying grain-binder interfacial strengths to analyze the effect of the second source of stochasticity. Critical hotspot size-temperature states reaching the threshold for ignition are calculated through finite element simulations that explicitly account for microstructure and bulk and interfacial dissipation to quantify the time to criticality (t{sub c}) of individual samples, allowing the probability distribution of the time to criticality that results from each source of stochastic variation for a material to be analyzed. Two probability superposition models are considered to combine the effects of the multiple sources of stochasticity. The first is a parallel and series combination model, and the second is a nested probability function model. Results show that the nested Weibull distribution provides an accurate description of the combined ignition probability. The approach developed here represents a general framework for analyzing the stochasticity in the material behavior that arises out of multiple types of uncertainty associated with the structure, design, synthesis and processing of materials.
Progress on modeling the the creep of thick sections welds in Alloy 740H is reported. Climb of dislocations during creep has been added to the model. Creep testing is continuing and stress drop testing has been initiated to determine the threshold stress of this particle-strengthened alloy. Work has also begun on generating synthetic microstructures, representative of experimental microstructures, from data collected with EBSD. This will enable incorporation of experimental microstructures into the modeling and simulation effort.
Alloys corroding in molten salt have been observed to form bicontinuous, nanoporous microstructures via dealloying, which subsequently undergo coarsening due to facile transport in high-temperature conditions. In this work, we describe a methodology to elucidate the underlying transport mechanisms during coarsening of a bicontinuous microstructure via quantitative comparisons between phase-field simulations and four-dimensional in situ experiments, in this case X-ray nanotomography of the coarsening of a dealloyed 80 wt% Ni-20 wt% Cr microwire in molten KCl-MgCl 2 at 800°C. We conduct phase-field simulations initialized from experimental data to model coarsening via three different transport mechanisms: surface diffusion, solid bulk diffusion, and liquid bulk diffusion. These simulations reproduce key features of the experiment, such as the densification of the outer layer of the dealloyed wire and the reduction in radius over time. We quantitatively compare different microstructural characteristics between the simulations and experiment and extract temporal scaling factors that optimally match the time scales of the simulations to that of the experiment. This allows us to evaluate morphological similarity between the simulations and experiment and relate the experimental coarsening kinetics to fundamental material properties. We find that surface diffusion is most likely to be the dominant coarsening mechanism, and its kinetics imply a surface diffusivity of D S = 8.9 x 10 -20 m 3 /s, which is within the range of reported values for Ni-vacuum interfaces at 800°C. However, the difference between the experiment and the surface diffusion simulation increases substantially at late times, suggesting that other mechanisms, such as the dissolution of residual Cr, may be at play.
Irradiation creep is known to be an important process for structural materials in nuclear environments, potentially leading to creep failure at temperatures where thermal creep is generally negligible. While there is a great deal of data for irradiation creep in steels and zirconium alloys in light water reactor conditions, much less is known for first wall materials under fusion energy conditions. Lacking suitable fusion neutron sources for detailed experimentation, modeling, and simulation can help bridge the dose-rate and spectral-effects gap and produce quantifiable expectations for creep deformation of first wall materials under standard fusion conditions. In this paper, we develop a comprehensive model for irradiation creep created from merging a crystal plasticity representation of the dislocation microstructure and a defect evolution simulator that accounts for the entire cluster dimensionality space. Both approaches are linked by way of a climb velocity that captures dislocation-biased defect absorption and a dislocation strengthening term that reflects the accumulation of defect clusters in the system. Here, we carry out our study in Fe under first wall fusion reactor conditions, characterized by a fusion neutron spectrum with average recoil energies of 20 keV and a damage dose rate of ≈3×10 –7 dpa/s at temperatures between 300 and 800 K.
Irradiation creep is known to be an important process for structural materials in nuclear environments, potentially leading to creep failure at temperatures where thermal creep is generally negligible. While there is a great deal of data for irradiation creep in steels and zirconium alloys in light water reactor conditions, much less is known for first wall materials under fusion energy conditions. Lacking suitable fusion neutron sources for detailed experimentation, modeling, and simulation can help bridge the dose-rate and spectral-effects gap and produce quantifiable expectations for creep deformation of first wall materials under standard fusion conditions. In this work, we present a comprehensive model for irradiation creep created from merging a crystal plasticity representation of the dislocation microstructure and a defect evolution simulator that accounts for the entire cluster dimensionality space. Both approaches are linked by way of a climb velocity that captures dislocation-biased defect absorption and a dislocation strengthening term that reflects the accumulation of defect clusters in the system. We carry out our study in Fe under first wall fusion reactor conditions, characterized by a fusion neutron spectrum at temperatures between 300 and 800°K.
The mechanical behavior of submicron body-centered cubic (BCC) micro-pillars is investigated by three-dimensional dislocation dynamics (DD) simulations to better understand the governing mechanisms for size dependent plasticity under uniaxial tension and pure torsion. A formula is developed to compute the incremental plastic twist due to dislocation motion in DD simulations. The DD simulations show that different dislocation microstructures are created depending on the loading conditions, which leads to different size dependent mechanical behavior. While in tension plasticity is mainly governed by the kinetics of dislocation motion controlled partly by the surface dislocation sources, plastic flow in torsion is controlled by dislocation pile-ups associated with strain gradients. The simulation results also reveal a Bauschinger effect and plastic recovery under cyclic twist, which have been observed in recent experiments.
A novel method to systematically vary temperature and thus study the resulting microstructure of a material is presented. This new method has the potential to be used in a combinatorial fashion, allowing the rapid study of thermal holds on microstructures to be conducted. This is demonstrated on a beta titanium alloy, where the thermal history has a strong effect on microstructure. It is informed by simulation and executed using the resistive heating capabilities of a Gleeble 3800 thermomechanical simulator. Spatially varying isothermal holds of 4 h were affected, where the temperature range of the multiple isothermal holds varied by ~175 °C.
In this work, we apply a phase-field model to gain insights into the corrosion behavior of Mg alloys. Specifically, we study the effect of electrochemical properties of the materials and their environment and the spatial distribution of second phases in a magnesium alloy. To this end, we perform sensitivity analyses in which we separately vary the exchange current density and corrosion potential of the second phase, as well as the electrolyte conductivity. We describe the effects of these parameters on the corrosion current and the resulting corrosion-front morphology. We also confirm that the ratio between the Wagner length, calculated for the anodic phase, and the initial width of the anodic domain is a good predictor of the morphological characteristic of the corroding surface. In addition, we examine the effect of the microstructure on the corrosion behavior in both 2D and 3D systems by varying the shape, size, and distribution of the second-phase regions. Our findings provide insights into the influence of the two-phase microstructure on the corrosion behavior in a magnesium alloy.
Mg-6Gd-2Zn-0.4Zr (wt.%, GZ62K) alloy was processed by solution treatment under different temperatures. The microstructure, hardness, corrosion and wear behaviors in simulated body fluid (SBF) have been studied. The results indicate that the (Mg, Zn){sub 3}Gd phase decreases, the precipitated phases gradually increase, and the long-period stacking ordered structure disappears with the increase of solution temperature. The alloy has better corrosion resistance after solution treatment, and that solution treated at 490 °C for 12 h shows the best corrosion resistance. The friction coefficient of the alloy under dry sliding condition decreases slightly, but the mass loss increases with increasing the solution temperature. The alloy solution treated at 460 °C for 12 h exhibits the lowest friction coefficient and mass loss in SBF, and it also has the best wear resistance under dry sliding condition.
Metal additive manufacturing (AM) allows for the freeform creation of complex parts. However, AM microstructures are highly sensitive to the process parameters used. Resulting microstructures vary significantly from typical metal alloys in grain morphology distributions, defect populations and crystallographic texture. AM microstructures are often anisotropic and possess three-dimensional features. These microstructural features determine the mechanical properties of AM parts. Here, we reproduce three “canonical” AM microstructures from the literature and investigate their mechanical responses. Stochastic volume elements are generated with a kinetic Monte Carlo process simulation. A crystal plasticity-finite element model is then used to simulate plastic deformation of the AM microstructures and a reference equiaxed microstructure. Results demonstrate that AM microstructures possess significant variability in strength and plastic anisotropy compared with conventional equiaxed microstructures.
A phase-field model is proposed to simulate coherency loss coupled with microstructure evolution. A special field variable is employed to describe the degree of coherency loss of each particle and its evolution is governed by a Ginzburg-Landau type kinetic equation. For the sake of computational efficiency, a flood-fill algorithm is introduced that can drastically reduce the required number of field variables, which allows the model to efficiently simulate a large number of particles sufficient for characterizing their statistical features during Ostwald ripening. The model can incorporate size dependence of coherency loss, metastability of coherent particles, and effectively incorporate the underlying mechanisms of coherency loss by introducing a so-called differential energy criterion. The model is applied to simulate coarsening of Al 3 Sc precipitates in aluminum alloy and comprehensively compared with experiments. Our results clearly show how the particle size distribution is changed during coherency loss and affects the coarsening rate.
Austempered ductile iron (ADI) is frequently obtained by means of a three-step austempering heat treatment. The parameters of this process play a crucial role on the microstructure of the final product. This paper considers the influence of some process parameters (i.e., the initial microstructure of ductile iron and the thermal cycle) on key features of the heat treatment (such as minimum required time for austenitization and austempering and microstructure of the final product). A computational simulation of the austempering heat treatment is reported in this work, which accounts for a coupled thermo-metallurgical behavior in terms of the evolution of temperature at the scale of the part being investigated (the macroscale) and the evolution of phases at the scale of microconstituents (the microscale). The paper focuses on the sensitivity of the process by looking at a sensitivity index and scatter plots. The sensitivity indices are determined by using a technique based on the variance of the output. The results of this study indicate that both the initial microstructure and the thermal cycle parameters play a key role in the production of ADI. This work also provides a guideline to help selecting values of the appropriate process parameters to obtain parts with a required microstructural characteristic.
Within the LDRD on 'Critical Issues on Materials for Gen-IV Reactors' basic thermodynamics of the Fe-Cr alloy and accurate atomistic modeling were used to help develop the capability to predict hardening, swelling and embrittlement using the paradigm of Multiscale Materials Modeling. Approaches at atomistic and mesoscale levels were linked to build-up the first steps in an integrated modeling platform that seeks to relate in a near-term effort dislocation dynamics to polycrystal plasticity. The requirements originated in the reactor systems under consideration today for future sources of nuclear energy. These requirements are beyond the present day performance of nuclear materials and calls for the development of new, high temperature, radiation resistant materials. Fe-Cr alloys with 9-12% Cr content are the base matrix of advanced ferritic/martensitic (FM) steels envisaged as fuel cladding and structural components of Gen-IV reactors. Predictive tools are needed to calculate structural and mechanical properties of these steels. This project represents a contribution in that direction. The synergy between the continuous progress of parallel computing and the spectacular advances in the theoretical framework that describes materials have lead to a significant advance in our comprehension of materials properties and their mechanical behavior. We took this progress to our advantage and within this LDRD were able to provide a detailed physical understanding of iron-chromium alloys microstructural behavior. By combining ab-initio simulations, many-body interatomic potential development, and mesoscale dislocation dynamics we were able to describe their microstructure evolution. For the first time in the case of Fe-Cr alloys, atomistic and mesoscale were merged and the first steps taken towards incorporating ordering and precipitation effects into dislocation dynamics (DD) simulations. Molecular dynamics (MD) studies of the transport of self-interstitial, vacancy and point defect clusters in concentrated Fe-Cr alloys were performed for future diffusion data calculations. A recently developed parallel MC code with displacement allowed us to predict the evolution of the defect microstructures, local chemistry changes, grain boundary segregation and precipitation resulting from radiation enhanced diffusion. We showed that grain boundaries, dislocations and free surfaces are not preferential for alpha-prime precipitation, and explained experimental observations of short-range order (SRO) in Fe-rich FeCr alloys. Our atomistic studies of dislocation hardening allowed us to obtain dislocation mobility functions for BCC pure iron and Fe-Cr and determine for FCC metals the dislocation interaction with precipitates with a description to be used in Dislocation Dynamic (DD) codes. A Synchronous parallel Kinetic Monte Carlo code was developed and tested which promises to expand the range of applicability of kMC simulations. This LDRD furthered the limits of the available science on the thermodynamic and mechanic behavior of metallic alloys and extended the application of physically-based multiscale materials modeling to cases of severe temperature and neutron fluence conditions in advanced future nuclear reactors. The report is organized as follows: after a brief introduction, we present the research activities, and results obtained. We give recommendations on future LLNL activities that may contribute to the progress in this area, together with examples of possible research lines to be supported.
Additively manufactured immiscible Cu–Fe alloys can exhibit a distribution of nanoscale interfaces due to the distribution of nanoscale clusters in the equilibrium and metastable phases. Molecular dynamics simulations investigate the role of such interfaces on the phase stability and transformation behavior during shock compression, as well as the mechanisms of damage nucleation during spall failure. The model multiphase Cu–Fe systems studied here comprise a distribution of Fe clusters in an FCC Cu matrix, as well as Cu clusters in a BCC Fe matrix. The length scales of the nanoscale clusters determine the energetics of the interfaces that can result in FCC/BCC (equilibrium) or FCC/FCC (metastable) interfaces in the Cu system matrix, and BCC/FCC (equilibrium) or BCC/BCC (metastable) interfaces in the Fe matrix. The MD simulations demonstrate that nanoscale metastable interface microstructures can induce plastic deformation and also stabilize phases or suppress phase transformations in metastable phase clusters. In contrast, equilibrium interfaces can influence phase transformation thresholds and serve as additional void nucleation sites during failure.
Bottlebrush polymers are complex macromolecules with tunable physical properties dependent on the chemistry and architecture of both the side chains and the backbone. Prior work has demonstrated that bottlebrush polymer additives can be used to control the interfacial properties of blends with linear polymers but has not specifically addressed the effects of bottlebrush side chain microstructures. Here, using a combination of experiments and self-consistent field theory (SCFT) simulations, we investigated the effects of side chain microstructures by comparing the segregation of bottlebrush additives having random copolymer side chains with bottlebrush additives having a mixture of two different homopolymer side chain chemistries. Specifically, we synthesized bottlebrush polymers with either poly(styrene-ran-methyl methacrylate) side chains or with a mixture of polystyrene (PS) and poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA) side chains. Furthermore, the bottlebrush additives were matched in terms of PS and PMMA compositions, and they were blended with linear PS or PMMA chains that ranged in length from shorter to longer than the bottlebrush side chains. Experiments revealed similar behaviors of the two types of bottlebrushes, with a slight preference for mixed side-chain bottlebrushes at the film surface. SCFT simulations were qualitatively consistent with experimental observations, predicting only slight differences in the segregation of bottlebrush additives driven by side chain microstructures. Specifically, these slight differences were driven by the chemistries of the bottlebrush polymer joints and side chain end-groups, which were entropically repelled and attracted to interfaces, respectively. Using SCFT, we also demonstrated that the interfacial behaviors were dominated by entropic effects with high molecular weight linear polymers, leading to enrichment of bottlebrush near interfaces. Surprisingly, the SCFT simulations showed that the chemistry of the joints connecting the bottlebrush backbones and side chains played a more significant role compared with the side chain end groups in affecting differences in surface excess of bottlebrushes with random and mixed side chains. This work provides new insights into the effects of side chain microstructure on segregation of bottlebrush polymer additives.
The resistance of polycrystalline materials to intergranular fracture depends on the toughness of the interfaces between neighboring grains. Using finite element simulations on model, two-dimensional microstructures, we demonstrate that the steady-state crack growth resistance of a polycrystal that contains exclusively high toughness interfaces is suboptimal: its crack growth resistance may be increased by introducing a minority fraction of weak interfaces at random locations within the interface network. Furthermore, the weaker are these interfaces, the greater is their toughening effect. These weak interfaces toughen the material through crack deflection and branching, nucleation of secondary cracks, and inelastic dissipation within intact interfaces. Furthermore, our findings suggest that fracture resistance-oriented material development should not aim to eliminate all weak interfaces, but rather judiciously incorporate a low fraction of them.