Search NASA⌕ Search

SEARCH · Search NASA

Results for “Additive Manufacturing”

Search indexed NASA NTRS and DOE OSTI research on propulsion, heat transfer, battery materials and energy systems. Follow report and document links to the original sources.

Quote a phrase for an exact phrase match. Source license links do not imply unrestricted reuse.

At least 577 records · Page 32

Understanding the Thermal Physics and Metallurgy of Metal Big Area Additive Manufacturing

The research goal of this EPSCoR-DOE partnership is to mitigate defects in parts made using a new type of additive manufacturing (AM) process called metal Big Area Additive Manufacturing (m-BAAM). To realize this goal, the PIs will detect and correct defects in the part as it is being printed by combining fundamental knowledge of the thermal physics and metallurgy of m-BAAM with in-process sensor data. Developed at the DOE-funded Manufacturing Demonstration Facility at Oak Ridge National Laboratory, the m-BAAM process involves one or more robots working together to produce a part by fusing metal wire layer-by-layer using arc welding. The process can print large metal parts such as turbine blades, which is not possible using other AM processes. In addition, m-BAAM production rates are more than ten times faster than other AM processes while requiring one-tenth of the material cost. Despite their potential to become a critical force multiplier in the energy generation industry, m-BAAM parts may fail to print accurately due to retention of heat and uneven cooling. Overheating and anomalous cooling rates in turn can cause inconsistencies in the microstructure, leading to sudden failure when used in safety-critical applications. In other words, flaw formation in m-BAAM parts is governed by the thermal history – intensity and spatial distribution of heat inside the part during printing. The thermal history is a complex function of the part shape and process settings such as welding energy, path taken by the welding torch for deposition (tool path), wire feed rate, among others.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Materials Development and Advanced Process Simulation for Additive Manufacturing with Fiber-Reinforced Thermoplastics (Final Technical Report)

DuPont, Local Motors, and the Composites Manufacturing and Simulation Center (CMSC) at Purdue worked together to advance process simulation capabilities for Additive Manufacturing (AM) and develop printable short fiber reinforced semi-crystalline engineering thermoplastics suitable for vehicle components. DuPont provided one candidate thermoplastic material, which was evaluated against the following three criteria: 1) Printability using extrusion additive manufacturing processes. 2) Suitability for vehicle applications based on mechanical coupon screening tests. 3) Predictive capability of process simulations. Indiana Manufacturing Institute provided modeling and simulation technology and access to Purdue’s lab scale AM printer. Local Motors provided mechanical property requirements and printed demonstration prototype components using their Thermwood Large Scale Additive Manufacturing (LSAM) printer. To meet the performance and cost requirements of the automotive industry, high fiber content semi-crystalline engineering materials are required. Printing experience and property data for a 50% by weight short glass fiber reinforced material were gathered. Further, material properties required for simulating the printing process with the glass-fiber reinforced material were characterized. Knowledge was acquired with regards to the processability and performance of this thermoplastic material. Predictions of part deformation and crystallinity level were verified against experimental observations. Any significant results other than verification of simulation, e.g., novel material identified here would be impactful.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Evolution of carbide precipitates in Haynes® 282 superalloy processed by wire arc additive manufacturing

Precipitation hardening regulated with heat treatments is a critical technique for tuning the mechanical properties of Ni-based superalloys fabricated with additive manufacturing, where mechanical deformation is no longer viable for microstructural refinement. As one of the key precipitates, carbides prevail in the additively manufactured alloys, whose precipitation kinetics remain largely vague. This work studies the influence of heat treatments on the evolution of MC- and M 23 C 6 -type carbides within a Haynes® 282 superalloy prepared by wire arc additive manufacturing (WAAM). SEM-EDS analysis was performed to identify the evolution pathways of the carbides, and TEM and XRD characterizations were carried out to track the crystallographic features. The MC-type carbides are originally present in the as-printed alloy, which distribute uniformly across the whole material and remain largely unchanged in size during the heat treatments. By contrast, the incipiently non-existent M 23 C 6 -type carbides precipitate during an aging treatment at 1010 °C, which majorly extend along the grain boundaries as kinetically feasible sites. Further experimental and computational analysis confirms the enhancing effect of the M 23 C 6 -type carbides on the Vickers hardness. For the first time, this work revealed the evolution pathways of carbides within a Haynes® 282 superalloy prepared by WAAM, providing critical information for tunning the microstructure and mechanical properties. Finally, the carbide evolution kinetics established in this work can be potentially extended to other alloys prepared with WAAM, providing critical information to prevent mechanical failures associated with carbide coarsening.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗

Binder Jet Additive Manufacturing Process and Material Characterization for High Temperature Heat Exchangers Used in Concentrated Solar Power Applications

The U.S. Department of Energy’s (DOE) Sunshot 2030 initiative has a goal of reducing the cost of concentrating solar power (CSP) to 5 cents per kWh for baseload power plants. One of the potential pathways to this goal includes a reduction in the cost of the supercritical CO2 (sCO2) power block to 0.9 cents per kWh. Recuperators—high and low temperatures, used in the sCO2 power cycle, contribute to >50% of the cost of the power cycle. This work studies the feasibility towards a ≥10% cost reduction for High Temperature Recuperators (HTR) used in the sCO2 power cycle. One way to address the cost reduction is by leveraging low-cost additive manufacturing, specifically, Binder Jet Additive Manufacturing (BJAM) to 3D print HTRs at scale. This study focuses on the development of a BJAM process towards 3D printing HTR cores using Stainless Steel alloy 316L (SS316L). To evaluate the suitability of the BJ process towards the HTR, high level specifications of the application are translated to materials capability requirements. Subsequently, at-temperature materials testing is conducted on as-printed and sintered additively manufactured coupons. Data from the coupons are compared against cast and wrought SS316L data obtained from the literature. Results show that the tensile properties from the BJ process compare well against cast properties. Furthermore, a baseline analysis of creep testing data is established for the BJ process, and insights are drawn from the results towards future improvements of the process.

14 SOLAR ENERGY↗

Investigating Marine Environmental Degradation Of Additive Manufacturing Materials For Renewable Energy Applications

Marine renewable energy is a relatively young industry where there is a great need for rapid prototyping in design-build-test campaigns to quickly mature ground-breaking technologies. Additive manufacturing has an important role to play in the industry; however, little information is available to marine energy developers to help inform them on which additive manufacturing materials are appropriate for harsh marine environments. This paper presents an initial study on the mechanical characterization of polymeric additive manufacturing materials and degradation effects due to the marine environment. Ultem 9085, acrylonitrile styrene acrylate (ASA), and chopped carbon-filled Nylon, as well as continuous carbon and glass fiber reinforced Nylon were chosen for this study. Samples were manufactured to perform a variety of tension, shear, and compression mechanical characterization tests on the materials. Half of the samples were conditioned in Pacific Ocean water for approximately 6 months at the Pacific Northwest National Laboratory’s Marine and Coastal Research Laboratory before being returned for mechanical characterization. The mechanical testing results showed that the Ultem 9085 and ASA materials experienced little to no degradation in stiffness or strength after exposure to the marine environment. On the other hand, the Nylon-based materials suffered significant stiffness and strength degradation (over 50% in some cases) after environmental conditioning. Ultimately, these results should serve as starting points to allow marine renewable energy developers to make informed additive manufacturing material choices for their prototype deployments.

Murdy, Paul↗

BAAM Additive Manufacturing of Magnetically Levitated Wind Turbine

ORNL worked with Hover Energy LLC (Hover) on the design of Big Area Additive Manufacturing (BAAM) extrusion components. The objective of this technical collaboration was to identify and evaluate fabrication of components using alternative additive manufacturing techniques. Multiple candidate parts were identified. A design modification to fabricate diverters using additive manufacturing (AM) was performed and the part was analyzed based on anticipated wind loading. Scaled versions of two parts were printed using the BAAM for wind tunnel testing.

17 WIND ENERGY↗

Depletion Analysis of Additively Manufactured Control Elements in HFIR

The High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR) at Oak Ridge National Laboratory is a flux-trap type research reactor which provides one of the highest steady-state neutron sources in the world. HFIR neutrons are used for a range of research applications, including scattering experiments, materials irradiation, and isotope production. The HFIR core operates at 85 MW and is light water cooled and moderated. The core consists of several concentric cylindrical regions, as depicted in Fig. 1. At the center of the core is the flux trap, where the thermal flux reaches a maximum on the order of 10{sup 15} neutrons/cm{sup 2}-s. Immediately surrounding the flux trap are two annular fuel elements, an inner fuel element and an outer fuel element, each loaded with hundreds of thin fuel plates curved into an involute shape. Surrounding the outer fuel element are two thin control elements (CEs), an inner CE (ICE) and an outer CE (OCE). The CEs are axially zoned into three regions according to absorption strength: the white regions contain only structural aluminum and do not significantly contribute to absorption; the gray regions contain tantalum (Ta) as the primary absorber with a concentration of 30% by volume; and the black regions contain europium in the form of Eu{sub 2}O{sub 3} with a concentration of 33% by volume. A thick beryllium reflector is the final core component surrounding the CEs. A particular challenge to efficient maintenance and continued operation of HFIR is fabrication of the CEs, the current methods for which are tedious, outdated, and expensive. In an effort to improve the operational economics of HFIR and to demonstrate the application of advanced manufacturing techniques to the production of nuclear reactor components, the ultrasonic additive manufacturing (UAM) process is being investigated for fabrication of the HFIR CEs. This application of UAM involves directly embedding small cylindrical compacts (∼5.6 mm diameter, ∼1.7 mm thick) containing 60% neutron poison by volume into an aluminum matrix, using energy from ultrasonic vibrations to bond the compacts to the aluminum. The CEs contain discrete regions of absorbing material, in contrast to the standard design with homogeneously distributed absorbers. This novel design necessitates an investigation into how the HFIR core neutronic behavior differs from the case with homogeneous CEs so as to ascertain the feasibility of using additively manufactured CEs in HFIR. From an operations perspective, it is desirable for the discrete CEs to match the performance of the homogeneous CEs as closely as possible so as to avoid reconsideration of established safety margins. Earlier analyses of HFIR under beginning of cycle (BOC) conditions have indicated that although absorption properties on a local scale differ significantly between CE designs, the macroscopic behavior (neutron multiplication and flux and power distributions) of the HFIR core is not significantly altered. This study now addresses CE performance throughout depletion of the HFIR core during a reactor cycle. These analyses help to construct a more complete picture of the feasibility of employing additively manufactured CEs in HFIR and will reveal any adjustments which must be made to the design in order to maintain acceptable performance. (authors)

11 NUCLEAR FUEL CYCLE AND FUEL MATERIALS↗

Additive Manufacturing of Cryogenic Austenitic Steel JK2LB via Wire-Fed Directed Energy Deposition (DED) for Fusion Energy Applications

This study explores the feasibility of fabricating cryogenic austenitic steel JK2LB via both laser-based directed energy deposition (laser-DED) and arc-based directed energy deposition (arc-DED) additive manufacturing processes for potential application in fusion reactors. JK2LB, a low-nickel, high-manganese stainless steel developed for ITER, offers excellent cryogenic toughness, radiation resistance, and decay-to-clearance characteristics. Although JK2LB was originally designed to endure cyclic stresses at cryogenic temperatures in tokamaks, its low-temperature mechanical integrity and radiation tolerance also make it a promising candidate for structural components, such as the coil case/support structure in nonplanar high-temperature superconducting magnet assemblies in stellarators. Directed energy deposition (DED) additive manufacturing was selected for this study due to its capability to fabricate large structures with complex geometries. Here, to address the long lead time and high cost associated with acquiring conventional JK2LB solid wire, JK2LB powder-cored wire was developed as the feedstock material. Testing blocks were then fabricated using both wire-fed laser-DED and arc-DED processes. Microstructural and compositional analyses revealed that both DED approaches yield fully austenitic phase and columnar grain structures. Mechanical testing at room temperature revealed that both DED routes achieved yield strength and elongation comparable to those of conventionally processed JK2LB via vacuum melting, electroslag remelting, extrusion, and drawing, though ultimate tensile strength was reduced due to Mn loss and large columnar grains. As a study mainly focusing on the additive manufacturing process, this work demonstrates the potential of additive manufacturing for fusion energy applications and provides a basis for optimization and future cryogenic mechanical evaluation.

Cryogenic steel↗

Signatures of the unique microstructure of additively manufactured steel observed via diffraction

A series of measurements were designed to gain confidence in the interpretation of the peak breadth in diffraction patterns collected from additively manufactured material, which has a novel microstructure in comparison to the well understood microstructure of wrought materials. Stainless steels made with two additive manufacturing techniques were compared to wrought material. Similar patterns observed in the scattering vector dependence for additively manufactured and deformed wrought materials suggested that the broadening in both materials was related to dislocations. Finally, this was confirmed by heat-treatment, during which both materials exhibited recovery due to the annealing of dislocations at the same temperature.

304L stainless-steel↗

Additive manufacturing of sandwich panels with continuous fiber reinforced high modulus composite facings

Abstract An improved approach consisting of a combination of fiber placement and fused filament fabrication is introduced for the additive manufacture (AM) of structural grade sandwich beams. Here, sandwich beams are additively manufactured using in‐situ deposition and consolidation of continuous fiber unidirectional facings made from a commingled yarn system of e‐glass fiber (~50% vol.) and amorphous PET, and a hexagonal honeycomb core structure made from PETG. Both facings and the sandwich core are manufactured on a single machine, in one sequence (skin‐core‐skin), employing the benefit of matrix compatibility to create autohesion at the interfaces. Flexural and transverse shear rigidity are determined experimentally and compared with analytical predictions and show correlation to within 3%. Flexural strength and core shear strength are also measured. Post‐mortem examinations show that core fracture and core facing debond were the dominant failure mode in flexure. Single cantilever beam tests were performed to evaluate core facing debond toughness. Subsequently, surface preheat using infrared heaters was utilized to increase autohesion between core and facing. The results show debond toughness was increased 4 times using infrared heating. This research effort presents a manufacturing approach that has the potential for the AM of stiff, well bonded, structural grade sandwich beams, in an integrated sequence, employing in‐situ consolidation to the facings, without the need for the use of intermediate adhesives for skin‐to‐core bonding. Highlights An improved additive manufacturing technique for making sandwich panels is developed. Sandwich panel facings have fiber volume fractions of approximately 50%. Surface preheat improves core‐to‐facing debond toughness by a factor of 4. Top and bottom facings are consolidated during manufacture leading to better properties. Experimental results are compared to analytical predictions and show good correlation.

17 WIND ENERGY↗

Composites and additive manufacturing for high-field coil supports for stellarators

The utilization of composites layered on an additive manufactured substrate, for the production of coil supports for modular coils in small or middle size experimental stellarators is assessed. The focus of the study is a monolithic coil support comprising the coils of a half-period of a stellarator, somewhat similar to the ones in UST_2 and ARIES-CS stellarators. However, the concept may be applicable to quasi-monolithic coil supports (coil forms of NCSX type) or individual coil casings (W7-X type).Coil supports for stellarators require high precision, stiffness and strength for large contorted parts. Traditionally, monolithic coil supports are produced by steel casting/forging and final machining. This production method and material gives accurate, stiff and strong coil supports, but the method may be expensive for monolithic supports due to the geometrical complexity and required accuracy of the structure. In relation to those matters, this work investigates whether a monolithic coil support comprising an additive manufactured resin substrate, which is externally (outward from the coils) surrounded with a thick layer of fibre-reinforced resin, may achieve enough strength and stiffness under middle/high magnetic fields. Finite element calculations are produced to obtain the direction of the principal stresses and their values in compression and tension at different areas of the monolithic support, which is relevant for anisotropic materials. The feasibility of directional application of (carbon) fibres on the winding surface of the stellarator outward from the coils is experimentally tested on a scaled-down additively manufactured prototype of a monolithic support. The strength and stiffness of the composite structure appears sufficient for common magnetic fields in experimental stellarators, and the 3D-composite design and manufacturing was technically feasible.

Queral, Vicente↗

Printability and Overall Cooling Performance of Additively Manufactured Holes With Inlet and Exit Rounding

Abstract To improve cooling effectiveness of gas turbine hardware, various film cooling hole shapes have previously been researched. Unique design modifications have recently been made possible through the design freedom allotted by additive manufacturing (AM). As one example, creating a rounded inlet for a film-cooling hole can mitigate separation at the inlet. This study explores various geometric features by exploiting the uses of additive manufacturing for shaped film cooling holes at engine scale. Both printability and cooling performance were evaluated. Resulting from this study, additively manufactured holes with hole inlet and exit rounding were printed with some variations from the design intent (DI). The largest deviations from the design intent occurred from dross roughness features located on the leeward side of the hole inlet. The measured overall effectiveness indicated that an as-built inlet fillet decreased in-hole convection as well as decreased jet mixing compared to the as-built sharp inlet. Including an exit fillet, which prevented an overbuilt diffuser exit, was also found to decrease jet mixing. A particular insight gained from this study is the importance of the convective cooling within the hole to the overall cooling performance. In-hole roughness, which is a result of additive manufacturing, increased convective cooling within the holes but also increased jet mixing as the coolant exited the hole. The increased jet mixing caused low overall effectiveness downstream of injection.

Engineering↗

Additive Manufacturing Integrated Energy Demonstration

Meet AMIE - the Additive Manufacturing Integrated Energy demonstration project. Led by Oak Ridge National Laboratory and many industry partners, the AMIE project changes the way we think about generating, storing, and using electrical power. AMIE uses an integrated energy system that shares energy between a building and a vehicle. And, utilizing advanced manufacturing and rapid innovation, it only took one year from concept to launch.

3-D PRINTING↗

Volumetric Additive Manufacturing of Dormant Catalytic Chemistries to Generate Silicone Micro‐ and Millifluidic Devices and Instant Molds

Tomographic volumetric additive manufacturing (T‐VAM) rapidly prints solid objects within minutes, accessing photochemistries that are traditionally challenging for layer‐based additive manufacturing methods. This includes high‐viscosity materials, air‐free chemistries, and solid‐state systems. Catalytic chemistries are appealing as a pathway to engineering advanced materials, including tough thermosets, silicone elastomers, and complex block copolymers. However, photoactivated dormant catalytic chemistries, where the catalyst irreversibly activates upon exposure to light, are incompatible with typical tomographic VAM approaches. To address this limitation, a zero‐dose optimization strategy is devised to preserve dormant catalysts in desired regions by keeping them unexposed to light. VAM printed micro‐ and millifluidic devices and instant molds are successfully produced within minutes in silicones polymerized using photoactivated dormant platinum photohydrosilylation catalysts. The printed channels are programmed to be 500 and 2500 µm for the micro‐ and millifluidic devices, and print fidelity is assessed by X‐ray computed tomography. This work demonstrates the potential of zero‐dose optimization to expand the range of chemistries accessible for VAM, enabling the rapid fabrication of complex devices.

Additive Manufacturing↗

Investigation of the irradiation effects in additively manufactured 316L steel resulting in decreased irradiation assisted stress corrosion cracking susceptibility

While additive manufacturing (AM) is an area of increasing interest to the nuclear industry, there are significant research and development needs prior to successful implementation of additively manufactured components into reactors. AM steel behaves differently than traditional wrought material, as has been observed in numerous mechanical testing studies. The nuclear industry must also understand the material response to irradiation. This work examines the irradiation damage and the irradiation assisted stress corrosion cracking behavior (IASCC) of both proton irradiated AM and wrought 316L steel. For IASCC testing, specimens were strained to 4% plastic strain in a simulated boiling water reactor environment (288°C, 0.2 µS/cm). Transmission and scanning electron microscopy, confocal microscopy, and X-ray computed tomography were used to examine coupons of the material as well as tensile bars used in the IASCC testing. This work found that the wrought 316L was more susceptible to IASCC than the AM steel, however, some IASCC was observed in the AM steel when tested with the tensile axis parallel to the build direction. Electron microscopy has shown significantly fewer radiation induced voids formed in the AM steel. While the pre-existing pore network in the AM steel may act as a sink to point defects, this is not expected to be the major factor in the reduced swelling observed in the AM steel. The lower density of radiation induced voids was expected to contribute to the IASCC resistance by decreasing the localization of deformation in the irradiated specimens, however, severity of localized deformation in AM steel, measured in dislocation channel spacing and height, was similar or more severe to that found in wrought. In conclusion, the presence of severe cracking in the wrought specimens did not allow for a direct comparison of localized deformation severities between the AM and wrought steel.

Additive manufacturing↗

Additive Manufacturing of Advanced High Temperature Masking Fixtures for EBPVD TBC Coating

The purpose of this Manufacturing Demonstration Facility (MDF) technical collaboration project between Praxair Surface Technologies, Inc. (PST) and Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) was to develop an additive manufacturing process to fabricate next generation high temperature masking fixtures for coating of turbine airfoils with ceramic Thermal Barrier Coatings (TBC) by the Electron Beam Physical Vapor Deposition (EBPVD) process. Typical masking fixtures are sophisticated designs and require complex part manipulation in order to achieve the desired coating distribution. Fixtures are typically fabricated from high temperature nickel (Ni) based superalloys. The fixtures are fabricated from conventional processes by welding of thin sheet material into a complex geometry, to decrease the weight load for the manipulator and to reduce the thermal mass of the fixture. Recent attempts have been made in order to fabricate the fixtures through casting, but thin walled sections are difficult to cast and have high scrap rates. This project focused on understanding the potential for fabricating high temperature Ni based superalloy fixtures through additive manufacturing. Two different deposition processes; electron beam melting (EBM) and laser powder bed fusion were evaluated to determine the ideal processing route of these materials. Two different high temperature materials were evaluated. The high temperature materials evaluated were Inconel 718 and another Ni base alloy, designated throughout the remainder of this document as Alloy X, as the alloy composition is sensitive. Inconel 718 is a more widely utilized material for additive manufacturing although it is not currently the material utilized for current fixtures. Alloy X is the alloy currently used for the fixtures, but is not a commercially available alloy for additive manufacturing. Praxair determined it was possible to build the fixture using laser powder bed technology from Inconel 718. ORNL fabricated the fixture geometry using the EBM technology in order to compare deposition features such as surface roughness, geometric accuracy, deposition rate, surface and subsurface porosity, and material quality. It was determined that the laser powder bed technology was ideal for the geometry and requirements of the fixture set by Praxair, and Praxair moved forward with the purchase of a laser powder bed system. The subsequent portion of the project focused on determining the ideal processing parameters for alloy X for the laser powder bed system using ORNL’s Renishaw laser powder bed system. Praxair supplied gas atomized powders of alloy X material with properties specified by ORNL. ORNL printed text cube arrays in order to determine the ideal combination of laser powder and laser travel speed in order to maximize material density, improve surface quality, and maintain geometric accuracy. Additional powder supplied by Praxair was used to fabricate a full-scale fixture component.

42 ENGINEERING↗

Utility of Big Area Additive Manufacturing for Part Production for Low-Head Hydropower

ORNL worked with Cadens, LLC to explore the use of additive manufacturing (AM) for the production of low-cost parts for low-head hydropower systems. Cadens develops design optimization software that leverages the flexible, low-cost, high-strength benefits of AM and composite materials, and operates a micro-hydro lab to test AM components in controlled environments. Until now Cadens’ tests have been limited in size to components that they can cost-effectively manufacture using local commercial systems. This project provided an opportunity for Cadens to scale up their modular AM hydropower parts using the capabilities of Big Area Additive Manufacturing (BAAM). This project was a success and resulted in the design and fabrication of several end use parts of a hydropower system using a Big Area Additive Manufacturing (BAAM) system. The fabricated parts include draft tube, thimble, runner housing mold, PVC end fitting and two PVC pipe supports. The components have been in use for more than three years without a 3D printed component failing.

13 HYDRO ENERGY↗

Load balancing for multi-beam additive manufacturing systems

As powder bed fusion (PBF) additive manufacturing (AM) becomes a more mature field, system configurations are gradually moving away from the classic single heat source, layer-by-layer system configurations towards unconventional system configurations that offer higher throughput. Higher throughput systems allow PBF systems to be considered for a larger variety of industrial applications. However, the inclusion of multiple heat sources, or beams, also increases the complexity of the control schemes needed. For multi-beam systems with overlapping fields of view, the distribution of workload, or load balancing, across these beams directly affects the total print time for a build. Additionally, the probability of any beam failing in a multi-beam system increases with the number of beams. While manual methods of load balancing and dealing with beam failures are reasonable for current generation multi-beam systems, as system configurations become more complex, manual methods will become prohibitively inefficient. Here, this paper introduces two different ways to load balance multi-beam systems of various configuration types, regardless of their complexity, which are highly performant. A consequence of this performance is the enablement of on-the-fly load balancing in the event a beam fails, thus improving system robustness.

36 MATERIALS SCIENCE↗