Topological perturbation to a standard dehydrogenation catalyst, Pt 3 Sn
Topological materials, which exhibit protected topological surface states (TSS) near the Fermi level, have been proposed to be good catalysts. Topological catalysis may be more prevalent than we suspect, and not limited to exotic new materials. Here we study a known dehydrogenation catalyst, Pt 3 Sn alloy, which happens to be a topological semimetal, and probe the participation of TSSs in catalytic dehydrogenation of methane catalyzed by this material. Through first principle modeling and detailed analysis of the electronic structure for topological and non-topological surfaces of Pt 3 Sn, we find that TSS get significantly altered by the binding of reaction intermediates, particularly H. However, this effect of TSS on the binding of the reagents is merely perturbative, as the majority of the adsorbate binding is achieved by not-surface-focused electronic states, located much deeper below the Fermi level. Therefore, the reaction energetics and selectivity are predominantly determined by electronic states other than TSS. The fact that TSS are available for the reagent binding does not alone guarantee that the catalysis is strongly driven by TSS. However, TSS are not to be ignored, as small changes in the energetics along the reaction profile can translate into substantial differences in the reaction rate. Hence, in our view, Pt 3 Sn – a topological material – is first and foremost a standard catalyst, with added topological features, and not purely a topological catalyst. Our results point at the need to carefully consider all the bonding effects at the topological material interface.